On the abundance discrepancy problem in HII regions

Abstract

The origin of the abundance discrepancy is one of the key problems in the physics of photoionized nebula. In this work, we analize and discuss data for a sample of Galactic and extragalactic HII regions where this abundance discrepancy has been determined. We find that the abundance discrepancy factor (ADF) is fairly constant and of the order of 2 in all the available sample of HII regions. This is a rather different behaviour than that observed in planetary nebulae, where the ADF shows a much wider range of values. We do not find correlations between the ADF and the O/H, O++/H+ ratios, the ionization degree, Te(High), Te(Low)/ Te(High), FWHM, and the effective temperature of the main ionizing stars within the observational uncertainties. These results indicate that whatever mechanism is producing the abundance discrepancy in HII regions it does not substantially depend on those nebular parameters. On the contrary, the ADF seems to be slightly dependent on the excitation energy, a fact that is consistent with the predictions of the classical temperature fluctuations paradigm. Finally, we obtain that Te values obtained from OII recombination lines in HII regions are in agreement with those obtained from collisionally excited line ratios, a behaviour that is again different from that observed in planetary nebulae. These similar temperature determinations are in contradiction with the predictions of the model based on the presence of chemically inhomogeneous clumps but are consistent with the temperature fluctuations paradigm. We conclude that all the indications suggest that the physical mechanism responsible of the abundance discrepancy in HII regions and planetary nebulae are different.

14 pages, 8 figures, 9 tables. Accepted for publication in the ApJ

References in corpus (28)

• A reappraisal of the chemical composition of the Orion nebula based on VLT echelle spectrophotometry
• A Galactic O-Star Catalog
• Heavy elements in Galactic and Magellanic Cloud HII regions: recombination-line versus forbidden-line abundances
• The localized chemical pollution in NGC 5253 revisited: Results from deep echelle spectrophotometry
• The Chemical Composition of the 30 Doradus Nebula Derived from VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry
• Carbon in Spiral Galaxies from Hubble Space Telescope Spectroscopy
• Optical Recombination Lines of Heavy-elements in Giant Extragalactic HII Regions
• A deep survey of heavy element lines in planetary nebulae -- II. Recombination line abundances and evidence for ultra-cold plasma
• Faint emission lines in the Galactic H II regions M16, M20 and NGC 3603
• The temperature and ionization structure of the emitting gas in HII galaxies: Implications for the accuracy of abundance determinations
• Chemical abundances for Hf 2-2, a planetary nebula with the strongest known heavy element recombination lines
• Chemical abundances of the Galactic H II region NGC 3576 derived from VLT echelle spectrophotometry
• Chemical Composition of Two H II Regions in NGC 6822 Based on VLT Spectroscopy
• The [Fe IV] Discrepancy: Constraining the Iron Abundances in Nebulae
• Physical conditions in the planetary nebula Abell 30
• A photoionization modeling study of 30 Doradus: the case for small-scale chemical inhomogeneity
• Deep Echelle Spectrophotometry of S 311, a galactic H II Region Outside the Solar Circle
• Fine Scale Temperature Fluctuations in the the Orion Nebula and the t^2 Problem
• Balmer and Paschen jump temperature determinations in low-metallicity emission-line galaxies
• VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry of the Planetary Nebula NGC 5307 and Temperature Variations
• Spatially-Resolved O II Recombination Line Observations of the Ring Nebula, NGC 6720
• Balmer jump temperature determination in a large sample of low-metallicity H II regions
• Enrichment of the ISM by metal-rich droplets and the abundance bias in HII regions
• Temperature Variations from HST Spectroscopy of the Orion Nebula
• Temperature Variations from HST Imagery and Spectroscopy of NGC 7009
• The temperature structure of dusty planetary nebulae
• Optical recombination lines as probes of conditions in planetary nebulae
• Recombination Line vs. Forbidden Line Abundances in Planetary Nebulae

Cited by in corpus (142)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• De Re Metallica: The cosmic chemical evolution of galaxies
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation with the Direct Method on Stacked Spectra of SDSS Galaxies
• Optical Spectroscopy and Nebular Oxygen Abundances of the Spitzer/SINGS Galaxies
• Understanding Galaxy Evolution through Emission Lines
• New calibrations for abundance determinations in HII regions
• New fully empirical calibrations of strong-line metallicity indicators in star forming galaxies
• New Strong Line Abundance Diagnostics for \HII Regions: Effects of $\kappa$-Distributed Electron Energies and New Atomic Data
• Extragalactic chemical abundances: do HII regions and young stars tell the same story? The case of the spiral galaxy NGC 300
• HII Region Metallicity Distribution in the Milky Way Disk
• Keck HIRES Spectroscopy of Extragalactic HII Regions: C and O Abundances from Recombination Lines
• Eliminating Error in the Chemical Abundance Scale for Extragalactic HII Regions
• The MOSDEF Survey: Direct-Method Metallicities and ISM Conditions at $z\sim 1.5-3.5$
• Carbon and Oxygen Abundances in Low Metallicity Dwarf Galaxies
• Binary stars as the key to understanding planetary nebulae
• The Chemical Evolution of Carbon, Nitrogen, and Oxygen in Metal-Poor Dwarf Galaxies
• IZI: Inferring the Gas Phase Metallicity (Z) and Ionization Parameter (q) of Ionized Nebulae using Bayesian Statistics
• A Window On The Earliest Star Formation: Extreme Photoionization Conditions of a High-Ionization, Low-Metallicity Lensed Galaxy at z~2
• Massive star formation in Wolf-Rayet galaxies. IV: Colours, chemical composition analysis and metallicity-luminosity relations
• "Counterpart" method for abundance determinations in HII regions
• Carbon and oxygen abundances from recombination lines in low-metallicity star-forming galaxies. Implications for chemical evolution
• Measuring nebular temperatures: the effect of new collision strengths with equilibrium and kappa-distributed electron energies
• Properties of the ionized gas in HH202. II: Results from echelle spectrophotometry with UVES
• Binarity and the abundance discrepancy problem in planetary nebulae
• Young stars and ionized nebulae in M83: comparing chemical abundances at high metallicity
• Extreme N-emitters at high-redshift: signatures of supermassive stars and globular cluster or black hole formation in action?
• Carbon and oxygen in HII regions of the Magellanic Clouds: abundance discrepancy and chemical evolution
• The chemical composition of the Orion star forming region: I. Homogeneity of O and Si abundances in B-type stars
• The chemical composition of the Orion star-forming region: II. Stars, gas, and dust: the abundance discrepancy conundrum
• Confirmation of the link between central star binarity and extreme abundance discrepancy factors in planetary nebulae
• Coevolution of metallicity and star formation in galaxies to z=3.7: I. A fundamental plane
• BOND: Bayesian Oxygen and Nitrogen abundance Determinations in giant H II regions using strong and semi-strong lines
• VLT spectroscopy of low-metallicity emission-line galaxies: abundance patterns and abundance discrepancies
• Revisiting the radial abundance gradients of nitrogen and oxygen of the Milky Way
• Carbon and oxygen abundance gradients in NGC300 and M33 from optical recombination lines
• NGC 2579 and the carbon and oxygen abundance gradients beyond the solar circle
• Discovery of Strongly Inverted Metallicity Gradients in Dwarf Galaxies at $z$$\sim$2
• Massive star formation in Wolf-Rayet galaxies. V: Star formation rates, masses and the importance of galaxy interactions
• The radial abundance gradient of oxygen towards the Galactic anticentre
• NGC 6778: Strengthening the link between extreme abundance discrepancy factors and central star binarity in planetary nebulae
• Gradients of chemical abundances in the Milky Way from HII regions: distances derived from Gaia EDR3 parallaxes and temperature inhomogeneities
• A Characteristic Mass Scale in the Mass-Metallicity Relation of Galaxies
• Understanding and reducing statistical uncertainties in nebular abundance determinations
• The post-common envelope central stars of the planetary nebulae Henize 2-155 and Henize 2-161
• Temperature inhomogeneities cause the abundance discrepancy in H II regions
• A Recalibration of Strong Line Oxygen Abundance Diagnostics via the Direct Method and Implications for the High Redshift Universe
• Early Results from GLASS-JWST. XXI: Rapid assembly of a galaxy at z=6.23 revealed by its C/O abundance
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. II. Chemical abundances and the abundance discrepancy factor
• Metallicity gradients in Local Universe galaxies: time evolution and effects of radial migration
• History of the solar-type protostar IRAS16293-2422 as told by the cyanopolyynes
• Ultraviolet spectra of extreme nearby star-forming regions: evidence for an overabundance of very massive stars
• On the radial abundance gradients of nitrogen and oxygen in the inner Galactic disc
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. I. Line intensities and physical conditions
• Extreme Emission-Line Galaxies in SDSS. I. Empirical and model-based calibrations of chemical abundances
• JADES: The star-formation and chemical enrichment history of a luminous galaxy at z~9.43 probed by ultra-deep JWST/NIRSpec spectroscopy
• Faint recombination lines in Galactic PNe with [WC] nucleus
• CHAOS VII: A Large-Scale Direct Abundance Study in M33
• S-process enrichment in the planetary nebula NGC 3918. Results from deep echelle spectrophotometry
• Chemical abundances of Seyfert 2 AGNs I. Comparing oxygen abundances from distinct methods using SDSS
• Towards A Removal of Temperature Dependencies from Abundance Determinations
• Chemical abundances in 7 metal-poor HII regions and a determination of the primordial helium abundance
• Imaging the elusive H-poor gas in the high ADF planetary nebula NGC 6778
• The mass-metallicity relation at z~1-2 and its dependence on star formation rate
• A novel approach to correcting $T_e$-based mass-metallicity relations
• Small scale behavior of the physical conditions and the abundance discrepancy in the Orion nebula
• Analysis of two SMC HII Regions Considering Thermal Inhomogeneities: Implications for the Determinations of Extragalactic Chemical Abundances
• The radial abundance gradient of chlorine in the Milky Way
• About Metallicity Variations in the Local Galactic Interstellar Medium
• Semi-empirical metallicity calibrations based on ultraviolet emission lines of type-2 AGNs
• The chemical composition of Galactic ring nebulae around massive stars
• C/O ratios in planetary nebulae with dual-dust chemistry from faint optical recombination lines
• A Machine Learning Artificial Neural Network Calibration of the Strong-Line Oxygen Abundance
• Direct Constraints on the Extremely Metal-Poor Massive Stars Underlying Nebular C IV Emission from Ultra-Deep HST/COS Ultraviolet Spectroscopy
• The planetary nebula IPHASXJ211420.0+434136 (Ou5): insights into common-envelope dynamical and chemical evolution
• The Cocoon Nebula and its ionizing star: do stellar and nebular abundances agree?
• Dynamics and Morphology of the Milky Way Spiral Arms from the Metallicity Distribution and Radial Mixing
• A global study of the HII region M43 and its ionizing star (I. Stellar parameters and nebular empirical analysis)
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy I: HH529II and III
• Ionizing stellar population in the disk of NGC 3310 $-$ I. The impact of a minor merger on galaxy evolution
• The metallicity and distance of NGC 2403 from blue supergiants
• Ionized gas diagnostics from protoplanetary discs in the Orion Nebula and the abundance discrepancy problem
• Abundances of CNO elements in z ~ 0.3-0.4 LyC leaking galaxies
• The Solar Flare Chlorine Abundance from RESIK X-ray Spectra
• Integral field spectroscopy of selected areas of the Bright Bar and Orion-S cloud in the Orion Nebula
• IFU spectroscopy of Southern Planetary Nebulae IV: A Physical Model for IC 418
• Searches for HCl and HF in comets 103P/Hartley 2 and C/2009 P1 (Garradd) with the Herschel space observatory
• Electron Temperatures and Free-Electron Energy Distributions of Nebulae from C II Dielectronic Recombination Lines
• Excitation of emission lines by fluorescence and recombination in IC418
• The PNe and H II regions in NGC 6822 revisited. Clues to AGB nucleosynthesis
• Carbon Abundances in Starburst Galaxies of the Local Universe
• GAME: GAlaxy Machine learning for Emission lines
• Independent Emission and Absorption Abundances for Planetary Nebulae
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy II: HH204
• Neutron-capture element abundances in the planetary nebula NGC 5315 from deep optical and near-infrared spectrophotometry
• HST/COS Detection of Deuterated Molecular Hydrogen in a DLA at z = 0.18
• The Discrepant Kinematics of ORLs and CELs in NGC 7009 as a Function of Ionization Structure
• Properties of the ionized gas in HH202. I: Results from integral field spectroscopy with PMAS
• Very Large Telescope deep echelle spectroscopy of Galactic planetary nebulae NGC 6153, M 1-42 and Hf 2-2
• Gas-phase Fe/O and Fe/N abundances in Star-Forming Regions. Relations between nucleosynthesis, metallicity and dust
• Sub-damped Lyman alpha systems in the XQ-100 survey II -- Chemical evolution at 2.4<z<4.3
• The Kinematics of the Permitted C II $\lambda$ 6578 Line in a Large Sample of Planetary Nebulae
• Can X-rays provide a solution to the abundance discrepancy problem in photoionised nebulae?
• Metallicities in the Outer Regions of Spiral Galaxies
• Can solid body destruction explain abundance discrepancies in planetary nebulae?
• Chlorine Abundances in Cool Stars
• Small-spatial scale variations of nebular properties and the abundance discrepancy in three Galactic HII regions
• Chemical abundances in Orion protoplanetary discs: integral field spectroscopy and photoevaporation models of HST 10
• No temperature fluctuations in the giant HII region H 1013
• CHAOS V: Recombination Line Carbon Abundances in M101
• The impact of carbon and oxygen abundances on the metal-poor initial mass function
• The kinematical behaviour of ORLs and CELs in Galactic PNe
• A modern guide to quantitative spectroscopy of massive OB stars
• Electron temperature fluctuations in NGC 346
• The Trace of the CNO Cycle in the Ring Nebula NGC6888
• Electron temperature fluctuations in Seyfert galaxies
• On the non-thermal kappa-distributed electrons in planetary nebulae and HII regions: the kappa index and its correlations with other nebular properties
• No evidence for feedback: Unexceptional Low-ionization winds in Host galaxies of Low Luminosity Active Galactic Nuclei at Redshift z ~1
• Chemical abundances in the protoplanetary disk LV2 (Orion) - II: High dispersion VLT observations and microjet properties
• Nitrogen Enrichment in Atmospheres of A- and F- Type Supergiants
• MUSE spectroscopy of the high abundance discrepancy planetary nebula NGC 6153
• Metallicity dependence of the CO-to-H${}_2$ and the [CI]-to-H${}_2$ conversion factors in galaxies
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in PN M 2-36. Results from deep echelle observations
• Deciphering the 3-D Orion Nebula-II: A low-ionization region of multiple velocity components southwest of Theta1OriC confounds interpretation of low velocity resolution studies of temperature, density, and abundance
• Thermal Pressure in Diffuse H2 Gas Measured by Herschel [C II] Emission and FUSE UV H2 Absorption
• Resonant Temperature Fluctuations in Nebulae Ionized by Short-Period Binary Stars
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in photoionized nebulae from optical spectra
• Deep high spectral resolution spectroscopy and chemical composition of ionized nebulae
• On the treatment of $\ell$-changing proton-hydrogen Rydberg atom collisions
• Testing atomic collision theory with the two-photon continuum of astrophysical nebulae
• Revisiting the Local Star-Forming Galaxies Observed in the HETDEX Pilot Survey
• Imaging the elusive H-poor gas in planetary nebulae with large abundance discrepancy factors
• Optical spectroscopy of star-forming regions in dwarf Wolf-Rayet galaxies
• Realistic Models for Filling and Abundance Discrepancy Factors in Photoionised Nebulae
• Temperature based radial metallicity gradients in nearby galaxies
• Testing Evolutionary Models with Red Supergiant and Wolf-Rayet Populations
• SDSS-V LVM: A spatially resolved study of the physical conditions and the chemical abundance discrepancy in the Lagoon Nebula (M 8)
• The Integral Field View of the Orion Nebula
• The kinematical behavior of ORLs and CELs in PNe with [WC] central star
• Massive stars in the nuclei and arms of spirals
• A comparative study of O, Ne, Cl, and Ar in Hii regions and PNe of the Galactic disk: Temporal evolution of radial gradients?
• Observing and Reducing IFUs: INTEGRAL and PMAS -- Properties of the Ionized Gas in HH 202
• Infrared view of the multiphase ISM in NGC 253 II. Modelling the ionised and neutral atomic gas