Recombination Line vs. Forbidden Line Abundances in Planetary Nebulae

Abstract

Recombination lines (RLs) of C II, N II, and O II in planetary nebulae (PNs) have been found to give abundances that are much larger in some cases than abundances from collisionally-excited forbidden lines (CELs). The origins of this abundance discrepancy are highly debated. We present new spectroscopic observations of O II and C II recombination lines for six planetary nebulae. With these data we compare the abundances derived from the optical recombination lines with those determined from collisionally-excited lines. Combining our new data with published results on RLs in other PNs, we examine the discrepancy in abundances derived from RLs and CELs. We find that there is a wide range in the measured abundance discrepancy Delta(O+2) = log O+2(RL) - log O+2(CEL), ranging from approximately 0.1 dex up to 1.4 dex. Most RLs yield similar abundances, with the notable exception of O II multiplet V15, known to arise primarily from dielectronic recombination, which gives abundances averaging 0.6 dex higher than other O II RLs. We compare Delta(O+2) against a variety of physical properties of the PNs to look for clues as to the mechanism responsible for the abundance discrepancy. The strongest correlations are found with the nebula diameter and the Balmer surface brightness. An inverse correlation of Delta(O+2) with nebular density is also seen. Similar results are found for carbon in comparing C II RL abundances with ultraviolet measurements of C III].

arXiv comment48 pages, 14 figures, accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal Supplement

References in corpus (12)

• Improving Predictions for Helium Emission Lines
• Line temperatures and elemental abundances in HII galaxies
• A deep survey of heavy element lines in planetary nebulae - I. Observations and forbidden-line densities, temperatures and abundances
• A deep survey of heavy element lines in planetary nebulae -- II. Recombination line abundances and evidence for ultra-cold plasma
• An estimate of the time variation of the O/H radial gradient from planetary nebulae
• The Correlations between Planetary Nebula Morphology and Central Star Evolution. Analysis of the Northern Galactic Sample
• Angular dimensions of planetary nebulae
• Spatially-Resolved O II Recombination Line Observations of the Ring Nebula, NGC 6720
• The Distance Scale of Planetary Nebulae
• A New Look At Carbon Abundances In Planetary Nebulae. III. DDDM1, IC 3568, IC4593, NGC 6210, NGC 6720, NGC 6826, & NGC 7009
• The temperature structure of dusty planetary nebulae
• Identification and Characterization of Faint Emission Lines in the Spectrum of the Planetary Nebula IC 418

Cited by in corpus (17)

• On the abundance discrepancy problem in HII regions
• s-Process Abundances in Planetary Nebulae
• Confirmation of the link between central star binarity and extreme abundance discrepancy factors in planetary nebulae
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. II. Chemical abundances and the abundance discrepancy factor
• The Origin and Evolution of the Halo PN BoBn 1: From a Viewpoint of Chemical Abundances Based on Multiwavelength Spectra
• Plasma Diagnostics for Planetary Nebulae and H II Regions Using the N II and O II Optical Recombination Lines
• Recombination coefficients for O II lines in nebular conditions
• Very deep spectroscopy of the bright Saturn Nebula NGC 7009 - II. Analysis of the rich optical recombination spectrum
• Independent Emission and Absorption Abundances for Planetary Nebulae
• The Discrepant Kinematics of ORLs and CELs in NGC 7009 as a Function of Ionization Structure
• Very Large Telescope deep echelle spectroscopy of Galactic planetary nebulae NGC 6153, M 1-42 and Hf 2-2
• The Kinematics of the Permitted C II $\lambda$ 6578 Line in a Large Sample of Planetary Nebulae
• Can solid body destruction explain abundance discrepancies in planetary nebulae?
• Studies of NGC 6720 with Calibrated HST WFC3 Emission-Line Filter Images--II:Physical Conditions
• Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae -- II. Densities, temperatures, abundances and excitation of 6 PNe
• Morpho-kinematic and photoionization models of the multipolar structures in planetary nebula NGC 6572
• Abundances and ADFs in PNe with WC central stars