Can X-rays provide a solution to the abundance discrepancy problem in photoionised nebulae?
arXiv:0905.1952 · doi:10.1111/j.1745-3933.2009.00686.x
Abstract
We re-examine the well-known discrepancy between ionic abundances determined via the analysis of recombination lines (RLs) and collisionally excited lines (CELs). We show that abundance variations can be mimicked in a {\it chemically homogeneous} medium by the presence of dense X-ray irradiated regions which present different ionisation and temperature structures from those of the more diffuse medium they are embedded in, which is predominantly ionised by extreme-ultraviolet radiation. The presence of X-ray ionised dense clumps or filaments also naturally explains the lower temperatures often measured from O {\sc ii} recombination lines and from the Balmer jump when compared to temperatures determined by CELs. We discuss the implications for abundances determined via the analysis of CELs and RLs and provide a simple analytical procedure to obtain upwards corrections for CEL-determined abundance. While we show that the abundance discrepancy factor (ADF) and the Balmer Jump temperature determined from observations of the Orion Nebula can simultaneously be reproduced by this model (implying upward corrections for CELs by a factor of 1.15), we find that the required X-ray fluxes exceed the known Orion's stellar and diffuse X-ray budget, if we assume that the clumps are located at the edge of the blister. We propose, however, that spatially resolved observations may be used to empirically test the model, and we outline how the framework developed in this letter may be applied in the future to objects with better constrained geometries (e.g. planetary nebulae).
arXiv comment5 pages, accepted for publication by MNRAS Letters
References in corpus (28)
- The 'Forbidden' Abundance of Oxygen in the Sun
- A Reappraisal of the Solar Photospheric C/O Ratio
- Diagnostics of irradiated gas in galaxy nuclei. I: A Far-ultraviolet and X-ray dominated region code
- Mocassin: A fully three-dimensional Monte Carlo photoionization code
- Global X-ray properties of the Orion Nebula region
- The dusty MOCASSIN: fully self-consistent 3D photoionisation and dust radiative transfer models
- On the abundance discrepancy problem in HII regions
- Biases in abundance derivations for metal-rich nebulae
- Photospheric Abundances: Problems, Updates, Implications
- Heavy elements in Galactic and Magellanic Cloud HII regions: recombination-line versus forbidden-line abundances
- Million-Degree Plasma Pervading the Extended Orion Nebula
- X-ray enabled MOCASSIN: a 3D code for photoionized media
- A deep survey of heavy element lines in planetary nebulae -- II. Recombination line abundances and evidence for ultra-cold plasma
- Chemical abundances for Hf 2-2, a planetary nebula with the strongest known heavy element recombination lines
- Physical conditions in the planetary nebula Abell 30
- Elemental abundances of Galactic bulge planetary nebulae from optical recombination lines
- Unraveling the Helix Nebula: Its Structure and Knots
- The hydrogen-deficient knot of the `born again' planetary nebula Abell 58 (V605 Aql)
- Integral field spectroscopy of planetary nebulae: mapping the line diagnostics and hydrogen-poor zones with VLT FLAMES
- Enrichment of the ISM by metal-rich droplets and the abundance bias in HII regions
- Observations and 3D photoionisation modelling of the Wolf-Rayet planetary nebula NGC 1501
- Faint recombination lines in Galactic PNe with [WC] nucleus
- Three-dimensional photoionisation modelling of the hydrogen-deficient knots in the planetary nebula Abell 30
- The effects of spatially distributed ionisation sources on the temperature structure of HII region
- XMM-Newton Detection of Hot Gas in the Eskimo Nebula: Shocked Stellar Wind or Collimated Outflows?
- Small scale behavior of the physical conditions and the abundance discrepancy in the Orion nebula
- Charge Transfer Between Neutral Atoms and Highly Ionized Species: Implications for ISO Observations
- Serendipitous XMM-Newton Detection of X-ray Emission from the Bipolar Planetary Nebula Hb 5
Cited by in corpus (14)
- Optical Spectroscopy and Nebular Oxygen Abundances of the Spitzer/SINGS Galaxies
- The Chandra X-ray Survey of Planetary Nebulae (ChanPlaNS): Probing Binarity, Magnetic Fields, and Wind Collisions
- The chemical composition of the Orion star-forming region: II. Stars, gas, and dust: the abundance discrepancy conundrum
- Confirmation of the link between central star binarity and extreme abundance discrepancy factors in planetary nebulae
- Three-dimensional chemically homogeneous and bi-abundance photoionization models of the "super-metal-rich" planetary nebula NGC 6153
- Chemical abundances in the protoplanetary disk LV2 (Orion): clues to the causes of the abundance anomaly in HII regions
- Testing the existence of non-Maxwellian electron distributions in H II regions after assessing atomic data accuracy
- Temperature Structure and Metallicity in H II Regions
- Small-spatial scale variations of nebular properties and the abundance discrepancy in three Galactic HII regions
- Can solid body destruction explain abundance discrepancies in planetary nebulae?
- Chemical abundances in the protoplanetary disk LV2 (Orion) - II: High dispersion VLT observations and microjet properties
- Variable Hard X-ray Emission From the Central Star of the Eskimo Nebula
- Multiple ionisation sources in HII regions and their effect on derived nebular abundances
- Close binary central stars and the abundance discrepancy - new extreme objects