Binarity and the abundance discrepancy problem in planetary nebulae

Abstract

The discrepancy between abundances computed using optical recombination lines (ORLs) and collisionally excited lines (CELs) is a major unresolved problem in nebular astrophysics. We show here that the largest abundance discrepancies are reached in planetary nebulae with close binary central stars. This is illustrated by deep spectroscopy of three nebulae with a post common-envelope (CE) binary star. Abell 46 and Ou5 have O++/H+ abundance discrepancy factors larger than 50, and as high as 300 in the inner regions of Abell 46. Abell 63 has a smaller discrepancy factor around 10, but still above the typical values in ionized nebulae. Our spectroscopic analysis supports previous conclusions that, in addition to "standard" hot (Te~10000 K) gas, a colder (Te~1000 K) ionized component that is highly enriched in heavy elements also exists. These nebulae have low ionized masses, between 0.001 and 0.1 solar masses depending on the adopted electron densities and temperatures. Since the much more massive red-giant envelope is expected to be entirely ejected in the CE phase, the currently observed nebulae would be produced much later, in post-CE mass loss episodes when the envelope has already dispersed. These observations add constraints to the abundance discrepancy problem. Possible explanations are revised. Some are naturally linked to binarity, such as for instance high-metallicity nova ejecta, but it is difficult at this stage to depict an evolutionary scenario consistent with all the observed properties. The hypothesis that these nebulae are the result of tidal destruction, accretion and ejection of Jupiter-like planets is also introduced.

arXiv comment24 pages, 5 figures, 8 tables. Accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal

References in corpus (54)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• PyNeb: a new tool for analyzing emission lines. I. Code description and validation of results
• An Extended Grid of Nova Models: II. The Parameter Space of Nova Outbursts
• A Circumbinary Disk in the Final Stages of Common Envelope and the Core-Degenerate Scenario for Type Ia Supernovae
• An AMR Study of the Common Envelope Phase of Binary Evolution
• Simulating the Common Envelope Phase of a Red Giant Using SPH and Uniform Grid Codes
• On the alpha formalism for the common envelope interaction
• Binary Planetary Nebulae Nuclei towards the Galactic Bulge. I. Sample Discovery, Period Distribution and Binary Fraction
• The Second Data Release of the INT Photometric H-Alpha Survey of the Northern Galactic Plane (IPHAS DR2)
• On the abundance discrepancy problem in HII regions
• Double Core Evolution X. Through the Envelope Ejection Phase
• Heavy elements in Galactic and Magellanic Cloud HII regions: recombination-line versus forbidden-line abundances
• Ionization Correction Factors for Planetary Nebulae: I- Using optical spectra
• Evolution on the AGB and beyond: On the formation of H-deficient post-AGB stars
• Electron impact excitation of OII fine-structure levels
• Do most planetary nebulae derive from binaries? I Population synthesis model of the galactic planetary nebula population produced by singlestars and binaries
• Collision Strengths for [O III] Optical and Infrared Lines
• Carbon and oxygen abundances from recombination lines in low-metallicity star-forming galaxies. Implications for chemical evolution
• A deep survey of heavy element lines in planetary nebulae -- II. Recombination line abundances and evidence for ultra-cold plasma
• Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae: confronting models with observations
• Origin of apparent period variations in eclipsing post-common-envelope binaries
• Improved He I Emissivities in the Case B Approximation
• Corrigendum: Improved He~I Emissivities in the Case B Approximation
• Chemical abundances for Hf 2-2, a planetary nebula with the strongest known heavy element recombination lines
• The Necklace: equatorial and polar outflows from the binary central star of the new planetary nebula IPHASXJ194359.5+170901
• Chemical Composition of Two H II Regions in NGC 6822 Based on VLT Spectroscopy
• Physical conditions in the planetary nebula Abell 30
• The binary fraction of planetary nebula central stars I. A high-precision, I-band excess search
• First versus second generation planet formation in post common envelope binary (PCEB) planetary systems
• VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry of the Planetary Nebula NGC 5307 and Temperature Variations
• The hydrogen-deficient knot of the `born again' planetary nebula Abell 58 (V605 Aql)
• Helium recombination spectra as temperature diagnostics for planetary nebulae
• Integral field spectroscopy of planetary nebulae: mapping the line diagnostics and hydrogen-poor zones with VLT FLAMES
• Discovery of close binary central stars in the planetary nebulae NGC 6326 and NGC 6778
• The Dusty Aftermath of the V1309 Sco Binary Merger
• A radial velocity survey for post-common-envelope Wolf-Rayet central stars of planetary nebulae: First results and discovery of the close binary nucleus of NGC 5189
• A tidally destructed massive planet as the progenitor of the two light planets around the sdB star KIC 05807616
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. II. Chemical abundances and the abundance discrepancy factor
• Observations and 3D photoionisation modelling of the Wolf-Rayet planetary nebula NGC 1501
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. I. Line intensities and physical conditions
• Timing variations in the secondary eclipse of NN Ser
• Two-colour photometry of the binary planetary nebula nuclei UU Sagitte and V477 Lyrae: oversized secondaries in post-common-envelope binaries
• New effective recombination coefficients for nebular N II lines
• Observed Planetary Nebulae as Descendants of Interacting Binary Systems
• The planetary nebula IPHASXJ211420.0+434136 (Ou5): insights into common-envelope dynamical and chemical evolution
• ALMA and Herschel Observations of the Prototype Dusty and Polluted White Dwarf G29-38
• V605 Aquilae: a born again star, a nova or both?
• Chemical abundances in the protoplanetary disk LV2 (Orion): clues to the causes of the abundance anomaly in HII regions
• Ionized gas diagnostics from protoplanetary discs in the Orion Nebula and the abundance discrepancy problem
• Very Late Thermal Pulses Influenced by Accretion in Planetary Nebulae
• Can solid body destruction explain abundance discrepancies in planetary nebulae?
• Chemical abundances in Orion protoplanetary discs: integral field spectroscopy and photoevaporation models of HST 10
• Physical conditions derived from OII recombination lines in planetary nebulae and their implications
• When a couple's squabbling leads to cosmic bubbles

Cited by in corpus (71)

• Binary stars as the key to understanding planetary nebulae
• Nebular spectroscopy: A guide on H II regions and planetary nebulae
• Observational Confirmation of a Link Between Common Envelope Binary Interaction and Planetary Nebula Shaping
• Planetary systems and real planetary nebulae from planet destruction near white dwarfs
• Confirmation of the link between central star binarity and extreme abundance discrepancy factors in planetary nebulae
• Planetary Nebulae: Sources of Enlightenment
• NGC 6778: Strengthening the link between extreme abundance discrepancy factors and central star binarity in planetary nebulae
• The post-common envelope central stars of the planetary nebulae Henize 2-155 and Henize 2-161
• Temperature inhomogeneities cause the abundance discrepancy in H II regions
• The Effect of Tides on the Population of PN from Interacting Binaries
• Density biases and temperature relations for DESIRED HII regions
• Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae - I: physical, kinematic and excitation properties
• S-process enrichment in the planetary nebula NGC 3918. Results from deep echelle spectrophotometry
• Imaging the elusive H-poor gas in the high ADF planetary nebula NGC 6778
• Binary Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae Discovered Through Photometric Variability V: The Central Stars of HaTr 7 and ESO 330-9
• Binary Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae Identified With Kepler/K2
• Discovery of an eclipsing dwarf nova in the ancient nova shell Te 11
• The short orbital period binary star at the heart of the planetary nebula M 3-1
• The planetary nebula IC 4776 and its post-common-envelope binary central star
• Forming H-shaped and barrel-shaped nebulae with interacting jets
• The MUSE view of the planetary nebula NGC 3132
• Abell 30 -- A Binary Central Star Among the Born-Again Planetary Nebulae
• The PNe and H II regions in NGC 6822 revisited. Clues to AGB nucleosynthesis
• Observational Constraints on the Common Envelope Phase
• An in-depth reanalysis of the alleged type Ia supernova progenitor Henize 2-428
• High velocity string of knots in the outburst of the Planetary Nebula Hb4
• Very Large Telescope deep echelle spectroscopy of Galactic planetary nebulae NGC 6153, M 1-42 and Hf 2-2
• The post-common-envelope binary central star of the planetary nebula ETHOS 1
• IFU spectroscopy of Southern PNe: VII Photo-ionization modelling of intermediate excitation class objects
• Shaping planetary nebulae with jets in inclined triple stellar systems
• Discovery of an old nova remnant in the Galactic globular cluster M 22
• The binary fraction of planetary nebula central stars: the promise of VPHAS+
• The Kinematics of the Permitted C II $\lambda$ 6578 Line in a Large Sample of Planetary Nebulae
• The post-common-envelope binary central star of the planetary nebula Ou 5: a doubly-eclipsing post-red-giant-branch system
• An outburst powered by the merging of two stars inside the envelope of a giant
• Discovery of an old nova shell surrounding the cataclysmic variable V1315 Aql
• Characterisation of the Planetary Nebula Tc 1 Based on VLT X-Shooter Observations
• The post-common-envelope binary nucleus of the planetary nebula IC~4776: Neither an anomalously long orbital period nor a Wolf-Rayet binary
• The kinematical behaviour of ORLs and CELs in Galactic PNe
• The ionised and molecular mass of post-common-envelope planetary nebulae. The missing mass problem
• The impact of strong recombination on temperature determination in planetary nebulae
• NGC 6153: Reality is complicated
• MUSE spectroscopy of the high abundance discrepancy planetary nebula NGC 6153
• Physical and chemical properties of Wolf-Rayet planetary nebulae
• Planetary nebulae hosting accreting white dwarfs: A possible solution for the mysterious cut-off of Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function?
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in PN M 2-36. Results from deep echelle observations
• Variable jets at the termination of the common envelope evolution
• Bi-abundance ionization structure of the Wolf-Rayet planetary nebula PB 8
• The common envelope origins of the fast jet in the planetary nebula M 3-38
• The physical association of planetary nebula NGC 2818 with open cluster NGC 2818A
• Resonant Temperature Fluctuations in Nebulae Ionized by Short-Period Binary Stars
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in photoionized nebulae from optical spectra
• When the Stars Align: A 5 σ Concordance of Planetary Nebulae Major Axes in the Centre of our Galaxy
• The variability and radial velocity of planetary nebulae central stars
• 3D hydrodynamical models of point-symmetric planetary nebulae: the special case of H1-67
• Surveying Planetary Nebulae Central Stars for Close Binaries: Constraining Evolution of Central Stars Based on Binary Parameters
• Planetary Nebulae: What can they tell us about close binary evolution?
• Introducing PyCross: PyCloudy Rendering Of Shape Software for pseudo 3D ionisation modelling of nebulae
• Imaging the elusive H-poor gas in planetary nebulae with large abundance discrepancy factors
• Detailed studies of IPHAS sources -- I. The disrupted late bipolar IPHASX J193718.6+202102
• The missing mass conundrum of post-common-envelope planetary nebulae
• Challenges faced by current Galactic planetary nebula surveys
• Kinematical analysis of PNe with high ADF: Hf 2-2 and M 1-42
• Physical Conditions and Chemical Abundances of the Variable Planetary Nebula IC 4997
• Appraising the Necklace: A post-common-envelope carbon dwarf inside an apparently carbon-poor planetary nebula
• Close binary central stars and the abundance discrepancy - new extreme objects
• Challenging historical novae: AT Cnc (1645), Te-11 (483), and M22 (BC 48) revisited
• Gaseous abundances in planetary nebulae: What have we learned in the past five years?
• SDSS-V LVM: A spatially resolved study of the physical conditions and the chemical abundance discrepancy in the Lagoon Nebula (M 8)
• Evidence for cold plasma in planetary nebulae from radio observations with the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR)
• A comparative study of O, Ne, Cl, and Ar in Hii regions and PNe of the Galactic disk: Temporal evolution of radial gradients?