Challenging historical novae: AT Cnc (1645), Te-11 (483), and M22 (BC 48) revisited

Abstract

Connections between novae with shells and historical observations are crucial for astrophysical understanding of long-term evolution of shells and cataclysmic variables. Three of five previously considered links are revisited here: extended features in M22 in BC48, Te-11 in 483, and AT Cnc in 1645. We aim to develop a procedure to check whether these links are credible. Literal translations of the Chinese texts, historically based arguments, and close readings are combined with astrophysics, (peak brightness, decay time estimate, shell age expansion model calculation, etc.). (a) Nandou's second star, near which the BC48 `guest star' was reported, is identified as tau Sgr, not lambda Sgr, far from the M22 location. A nova in M22 would peak at only m=6.4 \pm 1.4 mag, and thus a description as a `blue-white' `melon' does not fit; it was likely a comet. (b) The imprecise position (`Shen['s] east') of the `guest star' in 483, its extended (dipper-like) radiance, and the context speak for a bolide. Considering the new (larger) Gaia distance and small extinction towards Te-11 (outside a cloud), its bi-polar morphology and current expansion velocity point to a planetary nebula; as a nova, the shell expansion age is 1100-2000 yr from detailed supersonic expansion calculations. (c) Most certainly, Mars was meant when the source for 1645 reported `a large star entered Yugui'; the verb implies motion. AT Cnc lies neither in Yugui's asterism box nor in the eponymous lunar mansion range. The fluid drag expansion age of AT Cancri's ejecta is 128-631 yr. All three exact ages are unsubstantiated. True novae or nova shells can be connected to historical records only if the position and object type are plausible. Duration, brightness (light curve), and color (evolution) should fit and could provide more astrophysical insight ...

13 pages with 2 tables and 7 figures (appeared in A&A)

References in corpus (18)

• Estimating distances from parallaxes. V: Geometric and photogeometric distances to 1.47 billion stars in Gaia Early Data Release 3
• Herschel-Planck dust optical-depth and column-density maps: I. Method description and results for Orion
• Binarity and the abundance discrepancy problem in planetary nebulae
• Observations of Galactic and Extragalactic Novae
• The gas density around SN 1006
• A planetary nebula around nova V458 Vul undergoing flash ionization
• Catalogue of central stars of planetary nebulae: Expanded edition
• When does an old nova become a dwarf nova? Kinematics and age of the nova shell of the dwarf nova AT Cnc
• Galactic Model Parameters and Space Density of Cataclysmic Variables in Gaia Era: New Constraints to Population Models
• Angular Expansion of Nova Shells
• The luminosity evolution of nova shells -- I. A new analysis of old data
• HIP 3678: a hierarchical triple stellar system in the centre of the planetary nebula NGC 246
• Discovery of an old nova remnant in the Galactic globular cluster M 22
• Which information can we derive from historical Far Eastern guest stars for modern research on novae and cataclysmic variables?
• Orbit determination just from historical observations? Test case: The comet of AD 760 is identified as 1P/Halley
• Orbital Period Changes for Fourteen Novae and the Critical Failures of the Predictions of Standard Theories, the Hibernation Model, and the Magnetic Braking Model
• Introducing the Condor Array Telescope: III. The expansion and age of the shell of the dwarf nova Z Camelopardalis, and detection of a second, larger shell
• Confirmation of the planetary nebula nature of HaTr 5. Not the remnant of Nova Sco 1437