The Distances to Novae As Seen By Gaia
arXiv:1809.00180 · doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2388
Abstract
The Gaia spacecraft has just released a large set of parallaxes, including 41 novae for which the fractional error is <30%. I have used these to evaluate the accuracy and bias of the many prior methods for getting nova-distances. The best of the prior methods is the geometrical parallaxes from HST for just four novae, although the real error bars are 3X larger than stated. The canonical method for prior nova-distances has been the expansion parallaxes from the nova shells, but this method is found to have real 1-sigma uncertainty of 0.95 mag in the distance modulus, and the prior quoted error bars are on average 3.6X worse than advertised. The many variations on the maximum-magnitude-rate-of-decline (MMRD) relation are all found to be poor, too poor to be useable, and even to be non-applicable for 5-out-of-7 samples of nova, so the MMRD should no longer be used. The prior method of using various measures of the extinction from the interstellar medium have been notoriously bad, but now a new version by Ozdonmez and coworkers has improved this to an unbiased method with 1-sigma uncertainty of 1.14 mag in the distance modulus. For the future, I recommend in order (1) using the Gaia parallax, (2) using the catalog of Ozdonmez, (3) using M_max = -7.0 +- 1.4 mag as an empirical method of poor accuracy, and (4) if none of these methods is available, then to not use the nova for purposes where a distance is needed.
arXiv commentMNRAS in press
References in corpus (43)
- Gaia Data Release 2: The astrometric solution
- Gaia Data Release 2: using Gaia parallaxes
- An Extended Grid of Nova Models: II. The Parameter Space of Nova Outbursts
- Estimating distances from parallaxes
- Comprehensive Photometric Histories of All Known Galactic Recurrent Novae
- Catalog of 93 Nova Light Curves: Classification and Properties
- Optical Imaging of Nova Shells and the Maximum Magnitude-Rate of Decline Relationship
- A Problem with the Clustering of Recent Measures of the Distance to the Large Magellanic Cloud
- A Theoretical Light-Curve Model for the 1999 Outburst of U Scorpii
- Parallax and Distance Estimates for Fourteen Cataclysmic Variable Stars
- Tidal Tail Ejection as a Signature of Type~Ia Supernovae from White Dwarf Mergers
- Discovery of a new photometric sub-class of faint and fast classical novae
- HST Fine Guidance Sensor Astrometric Parallaxes for Three Dwarf Novae: SS Aurigae, SS Cygni, and U Geminorum
- BK Lyncis: The Oldest Old Nova?... And a Bellwether for Cataclysmic-Variable Evolution
- Identifying and Quantifying Recurrent Novae Masquerading as Classical Novae
- Orbital Periods for Three Recurrent Novae
- A Model for the Quiescent Phase of the Recurrent Nova U Scorpii
- AT Cnc: A Second Dwarf Nova with a Classical Nova Shell
- An accurate geometric distance to the compact binary SS Cygni vindicates accretion disc theory
- The Behavior of Novae Light Curves Before Eruption
- Astrometry with Hubble Space Telescope Fine Guidance Sensors - A Review
- Light Curve Analysis of Neon Novae
- The secrets of T Pyxidis II. A recurrent nova that will not become a SN Ia
- Novae With Long-Lasting Supersoft Emission That Drive a High Accretion Rate
- A New Catalogue of Galactic Novae: Investigation of the MMRD relation & Spatial Distribution
- Parallax and Distance Estimates for Twelve Cataclysmic Variable Stars
- When does an old nova become a dwarf nova? Kinematics and age of the nova shell of the dwarf nova AT Cnc
- A Light Curve Analysis of Recurrent and Very Fast Novae in our Galaxy, Magellanic Clouds, and M31
- HST Fine Guidance Sensor Parallaxes for Four Classical Novae
- A Hubble Space Telescope Survey for Novae in M87. II. Snuffing out the Maximum Magnitude - Rate of Decline Relation for Novae as a Non-Standard Candle, and a Prediction of the Existence of Ultrafast Novae
- The dwarf nova SS Cygni: what is wrong?
- GK Per (Nova Persei 1901): HST Imagery and Spectroscopy of the Ejecta, and First Spectrum of the Jet-Like Feature
- The Recurrent Nova T Pyx: Distance and Remnant Geometry from Light Echoes
- Photometric and Spectroscopic Properties of Novae in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- The UBV Color Evolution of Classical Novae. II. Color-Magnitude Diagram
- Accurate Pre-Eruption and Post-Eruption Orbital Periods for the Dwarf/Classical Nova V1017 Sgr
- Biases in Expansion Distances of Novae Arising from the Prolate Geometry of Nova Shells
- The Distances of the Galactic Novae
- A Theoretical Light-Curve Model for the Recurrent Nova V394 Coronae Austrinae
- Distances of CVs and related objects derived from Gaia Data Release 1
- On the Hubble Space Telescope Trigonometric Parallax of the Dwarf Nova SS Cygni
- Phase-Resolved Infrared Spectroscopy and Photometry of V1500 Cygni, and a Search for Similar Old Classical Novae
- A Hubble Space Telescope survey for novae in M87. III. Are novae good standard candles 15 days after maximum brightness?
Cited by in corpus (65)
- New Insights into Classical Novae
- Observations of Galactic and Extragalactic Novae
- Comprehensive Catalogue of the Overall Best Distances and Properties of 402 Galactic Novae
- A UV and optical study of 18 old novae with Gaia DR2 distances: mass accretion rates, physical parameters, and MMRD
- A population of heavily reddened, optically missed novae from Palomar Gattini-IR: Constraints on the Galactic nova rate
- Fermi-LAT Gamma-ray Detection of the Recurrent Nova RS Ophiuchi during its 2021 Outburst
- A Light Curve Analysis of 32 Recent Galactic Novae --- Distances and White Dwarf Masses
- Surveying the X-ray Behavior of Novae as They Emit -rays
- The 2021 outburst of the recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi observed in X-rays by the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory: a comparative study
- On a century of extragalactic novae and the rise of the rapid recurrent novae
- A comparative study of the strength of flickering in cataclysmic variables
- Classical Novae at Radio Wavelengths
- Comprehensive Listing of 156 Reliable Orbital Periods for Novae, Including 49 New Periods
- The first nova eruption in a novalike variable: YZ Ret as seen in X-rays and gamma-rays
- Nothing to see here: Failed supernovae are faint or rare
- The 2019 eruption of recurrent nova V3890 Sgr: observations by Swift, NICER and SMARTS
- A strong shock during a nova outburst: an origin of multiple velocity systems in optical spectra and of high-energy emissions
- Sudden and Steady Orbital Period Changes Across Six Classical Nova Eruptions; The End of Hibernation and Two Serious Challenges for the Magnetic Braking Model of Cataclysmic Variable Evolution
- Angular Expansion of Nova Shells
- The luminosity evolution of nova shells -- I. A new analysis of old data
- Classical Novae Masquerading as Dwarf Novae? Outburst Properties of Cataclysmic Variables with ASAS-SN
- A Theory for the Maximum Magnitude versus Rate of Decline (MMRD) Relation of Classical Novae
- Transients from the Cataclysmic Deaths of Cataclysmic Variables
- The Galactic Nova Rate: Estimates from the ASAS-SN and Gaia Surveys
- The Nova KT Eri Is a Recurrent Nova With a Recurrence Time-Scale of 40-50 Years
- Optical spectroscopic and polarization properties of 2011 outburst of the recurrent nova T Pyxidis
- Precise Measures of Orbital Period, Before and After Nova Eruption for QZ Aurigae
- The Super-Soft Source Phase of the recurrent nova V3890 Sgr
- T CrB: Radio Observations During the 2016--2017 "Super-Active" State
- Discovery of an old nova remnant in the Galactic globular cluster M 22
- Discovery of Extreme, Roughly-Daily Superflares on the Recurrent Nova V2487 Oph
- The Color Evolution of Classical Novae. IV. Time-Stretched - and - Color-Magnitude Diagrams of Novae in Outburst
- The Color Evolution of Classical Novae. III. Time-Stretched Color-Magnitude Diagram of Novae in Outburst
- Galactic Extinction: How Many Novae Does it Hide and How Does it Affect the Galactic Nova Rate?
- Gas phase SiO in the circumstellar environment of the recurrent nova T Coronae Borealis
- Two New Nova Shells associated with V4362 Sagittarii and DO Aquilae
- Fermi-LAT Observations of V549 Vel 2017: a Sub-Luminous Gamma-Ray Nova?
- The ambiguous transient ASASSN-17hx. A possible nova-impostor
- Archives of Photographic PLates for Astronomical USE (APPLAUSE) Digitisation of astronomical plates and their integration into the International Virtual Observatory
- AstroSat Soft X-ray observations of the symbiotic recurrent nova V3890 Sgr during its 2019 outburst
- -ray Emission from Classical Nova V392 Per: Measurements from Fermi and HAWC
- Life after eruption VIII: The orbital periods of novae
- Extended X-ray emission from the classic nova DQ Her -- On the possible presence of a magnetized jet
- The Luminosity Phase Space of Galactic and Extragalactic X-ray Transients Out to Intermediate Redshifts
- FUSE Spectroscopic Analysis of the Slowest Symbiotic Nova AG Peg During Quiescence
- Multiwavelength modeling the SED of nova V339~Del: Stopping the wind and long-lasting super-Eddington luminosity with dust emission
- ASASSN-16oh: A nova outburst with no mass ejection -- A new type of supersoft X-ray source in old populations
- White Dwarf Photospheric Abundances in Cataclysmic Variables -- II. White Dwarfs With and Without a Mask
- A search for cool molecular gas in GK Persei and other classical novae
- Novae in M51: a New, Much Higher Rate from Multi-epoch HST Data
- HST FUV spectroscopy of the short orbital period recurrent nova CI Aql: Implications for white dwarf mass evolution
- Interaction between the ejecta, the accretion disk, and the secondary star in the recurrent nova system U Sco
- Confirmation of the planetary nebula nature of HaTr 5. Not the remnant of Nova Sco 1437
- A Hubble Space Telescope Survey for Novae in the Globular Clusters of M87
- The peculiar ejecta of the nova V1425 Aquilae
- A Survey of Novae in M83
- BC Cassiopeiae: First Detection of IW And-Type Phenomenon Among Post-Eruption Novae
- A Speckle-Imaging Search for Close Triple Companions of Cataclysmic Binaries
- Synthesis of radioactive elements in novae and supernovae and their use as a diagnostic tool
- Morpho-kinematic modeling of the expanding ejecta of the extremely slow nova V1280 Scorpii
- AT 2017fvz: a nova in the dwarf irregular galaxy NGC 6822
- VLT VIMOS Integral Field Spectroscopy of the nova remnant FH Ser
- AT 2016dah and AT 2017fyp: the first classical novae discovered within a tidal stream
- Challenging historical novae: AT Cnc (1645), Te-11 (483), and M22 (BC 48) revisited
- Hubble Space Telescope STIS Spectroscopy of Nova T Aurigae 1891