A comparative study of O, Ne, Cl, and Ar in Hii regions and PNe of the Galactic disk: Temporal evolution of radial gradients?

Abstract

(Abridged) We compare the radial abundance gradients of O, Ne, Cl, and Ar using a sample of 42 HII regions and 176 planetary nebulae (PNe) from the DESIRED catalogue in the Galactic disk, comprising the highest-quality observations currently available and presenting the first gradient analysis for this dataset. For all objects, two sets of chemical abundances were compiled: one derived from collisionally excited lines (CELs) and another incorporating the temperature fluctuation parameter (t^2). Oxygen abundances were corrected for dust depletion, and HII region results were compared with Cepheid stars, which trace the present-day interstellar medium. PNe distances were compiled from recent literature, excluding bulge or halo objects to ensure a disk-only sample. All gradients are statistically significant (p < 0.05), except for Cl and Ar in HII regions. The O/H gradients from HII regions and Cepheids are consistent when t^2 is included, underscoring the importance of accounting for temperature inhomogeneities in nebular analyses. The O and Ne gradients traced by older objects are flatter than the present-day gradient by -0.028 +- 0.008 dex kpc-1 on average from both RLs and CELs. This could indicate a temporal steepening of the Galactic abundance gradient; however, this behavior is not reproduced by chemical evolution models, suggesting additional physical processes are at play. The most plausible explanation is that our PNe sample has been strongly affected by radial migration. Under this interpretation, the PNe gradient cannot reliably trace past abundance gradients, but provides a valuable constraint on radial stellar migration, offering important input for chemo-dynamical models of the Galactic disk and for hydrodynamical simulations.

arXiv comment14 pages, 5 figures, 1 table. Additional four long tables in the appendix (16 pages). Accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (115)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• Estimating distances from parallaxes. V: Geometric and photogeometric distances to 1.47 billion stars in Gaia Early Data Release 3
• The Galaxy in Context: Structural, Kinematic and Integrated Properties
• The Chemical Evolution of the Galaxy: the two-infall model
• Gaia Data Release 2: using Gaia parallaxes
• The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision
• The chemical composition of metal-poor emission-line galaxies in the Data Release 3 of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Chemical Cartography with APOGEE: Metallicity Distribution Functions and the Chemical Structure of the Milky Way Disk
• New models for the evolution of Post-Asymptotic Giant Branch stars and Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae
• Post-Asymptotic Giant Branch Evolution of Low- and Intermediate-Mass Stars. Preliminary Results
• The Distribution of the Elements in the Galactic Disk III. A Reconsideration of Cepheids from l = 30 to 250 Degrees
• Mapping the stellar structure of the Milky Way thick disk and halo using SEGUE photometry
• A cosmic abundance standard: chemical homogeneity of the solar neighbourhood and the ISM dust-phase composition
• Metallicity Gradients in Disks: Do Galaxies Form Inside-Out?
• Resolving the electron temperature discrepancies in HII Regions and Planetary Nebulae: kappa-distributed electrons
• HII Region Metallicity Distribution in the Milky Way Disk
• The Hα surface brightness - radius relation: a robust statistical distance indicator for planetary nebulae
• The evolution of the Galactic metallicity gradient from high-resolution spectroscopy of open clusters
• Accuracy and precision of industrial stellar abundances
• On the abundance discrepancy problem in HII regions
• Using Cepheids to determine the galactic abundance gradient I. The solar neighbourhood
• Heavy elements in Galactic and Magellanic Cloud HII regions: recombination-line versus forbidden-line abundances
• Ionization Correction Factors for Planetary Nebulae: I- Using optical spectra
• The Chemical Composition of the 30 Doradus Nebula Derived from VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry
• Using Cepheids to determine the galactic abundance gradient II. Towards the galactic center
• The Galactic structure and chemical evolution traced by the population of planetary nebulae
• Using Cepheids to determine the galactic abundance gradient. III.First results for the outer disc
• The radial profile and flattening of the Milky Way's stellar halo to $80$kpc from the SEGUE K-giant Survey
• The Distribution of the Elements in the Galactic Disk II. Azimuthal and Radial Variation in Abundances from Cepheids
• Abundances of Galactic Anticenter Planetary Nebulae and the Oxygen Abundance Gradient in the Galactic Disk
• An estimate of the time variation of the O/H radial gradient from planetary nebulae
• The Inside-out Growth of the Galactic Disk
• Properties of the ionized gas in HH202. II: Results from echelle spectrophotometry with UVES
• s-Process Abundances in Planetary Nebulae
• Binarity and the abundance discrepancy problem in planetary nebulae
• On the O/H, Mg/H, Si/H and Fe/H Gas and Dust Abundance Ratios in Galactic and Extragalactic H II Regions
• Metal production in M33: space and time variations
• Cepheid Abundances: Multiphase Results and Spatial Gradients
• The Galactic radial abundance gradients of C, N, O, Ne, S, Cl and Ar from deep spectra of H II regions
• Sulfur, Chlorine, & Argon Abundances in Planetary Nebulae. I: Observations and Abundances in a Northern Sample
• The [Fe IV] Discrepancy: Constraining the Iron Abundances in Nebulae
• Confirmation of the link between central star binarity and extreme abundance discrepancy factors in planetary nebulae
• Elemental abundances of Galactic bulge planetary nebulae from optical recombination lines
• Galactic abundance gradients from Cepheids: alpha and heavy elements in the outer disk
• Revisiting the radial abundance gradients of nitrogen and oxygen of the Milky Way
• The Gaia-ESO survey: mapping the shape and evolution of the radial abundance gradients with open clusters
• Stellar migrations and metal flows -- Chemical evolution of the thin disc of a simulated Milky Way analogous galaxy
• Chemical evolution of the Milky Way: constraints on the formation of the thick and thin discs
• Evolution of the Milky Way with radial motions of stars and gas II. The evolution of abundance profiles from H to Ni
• Oxygen enrichment in carbon-rich planetary nebulae
• Metallicity Structure in the Milky Way Disk Revealed by Galactic HII Regions
• A New Look At Carbon Abundances In Planetary Nebulae. IV. Implications For Stellar Nucleosynthesis
• The building up of the disk galaxy M33 and the evolution of the metallicity gradient
• VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry of the Planetary Nebula NGC 5307 and Temperature Variations
• Abundance gradients along the Galactic disc from chemical evolution models
• Gradients of chemical abundances in the Milky Way from HII regions: distances derived from Gaia EDR3 parallaxes and temperature inhomogeneities
• Introducing EMILI: Computer Aided Emission Line Identification
• Galactic planetary nebulae as probes of radial metallicity gradients and other abundance patterns
• Very deep spectroscopy of the bright Saturn Nebula NGC 7009 -- I. Observations and plasma diagnostics
• Temperature inhomogeneities cause the abundance discrepancy in H II regions
• Morphology and Composition of the Helix Nebula
• The evolution of planetary nebulae. VIII. True expansion rates and visibility times
• Alpha Element Abundances in a Large Sample of Galactic Planetary Nebulae
• The nature of dust in compact Galactic planetary nebulae from Spitzer spectra
• Density biases and temperature relations for DESIRED HII regions
• Evolution of N/O ratios in galaxies from cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
• Planetary Nebulae in Gaia EDR3: Central Star identification, properties and binarity
• Carbon and oxygen in metal-poor halo stars
• Observations and 3D photoionisation modelling of the Wolf-Rayet planetary nebula NGC 1501
• Metallicity gradients in Local Universe galaxies: time evolution and effects of radial migration
• On the radial abundance gradients of nitrogen and oxygen in the inner Galactic disc
• Sulfur, Chlorine, and Argon Abundances in Planetary Nebulae. III: Observations and Results for a Final Sample
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. I. Line intensities and physical conditions
• The Distance Scale of Planetary Nebulae
• Planetary nebulae and HII regions in the spiral galaxy NGC 300. Clues on the evolution of abundance gradients and on AGB nucleosynthesis
• Beyond the two-infall model I. Indications for a recent gas infall with Gaia DR3 chemical abundances
• Unusual integrated metallicity profile of our Milky Way
• Faint recombination lines in Galactic PNe with [WC] nucleus
• One star, two star, red star, blue star: an updated planetary nebula central star distance catalogue from Gaia EDR3
• S-process enrichment in the planetary nebula NGC 3918. Results from deep echelle spectrophotometry
• New results on the time variation of the radial abundance gradients from planetary nebulae
• Bayesian posterior classification of planetary nebulae according to the Peimbert types
• Iron abundance in HII regions
• MUSE spectroscopy of planetary nebulae with high abundance discrepancies
• Disk stars in the Milky Way detected beyond 25 kpc from its center
• Evolutionary and pulsation properties of Type II Cepheids
• C/O ratios in planetary nebulae with dual-dust chemistry from faint optical recombination lines
• The evolution of the Milky Way's thin disc radial metallicity gradient with K2 asteroseismic ages
• The essential elements of dust evolution: A viable solution to the interstellar oxygen depletion problem?
• The radial metallicity gradient and the history of elemental enrichment in M81 through emission-line probes
• Mapping the anisotropic Galactic stellar halo with Blue Horizontal Branch stars
• The survey of planetary nebulae in Andromeda (M 31) V. Chemical enrichment of the thin and thicker discs of Andromeda. Oxygen to argon abundance ratios for planetary nebulae and H II regions
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy I: HH529II and III
• Sulfur, Chlorine, and Argon in Planetary Nebulae. IIA: Observations of a Southern Sample
• The population of Galactic planetary nebulae: a study of distance scales and central stars based on the second GAIA release
• Densities, temperatures, pressures, and abundances derived from OII recombination lines in HII regions and their implications
• Time variation of radial gradients in the galactic disk: electron temperatures and abundances
• Helium abundances and its radial gradient from the spectra of HII regions and ring nebulae of the Milky Way
• The last 5 Gyr of Galactic chemical evolution based on H II region abundances derived from a temperature independent method
• Neutron-capture element abundances in the planetary nebula NGC 5315 from deep optical and near-infrared spectrophotometry
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy III: HH514
• Gas-phase Fe/O and Fe/N abundances in Star-Forming Regions. Relations between nucleosynthesis, metallicity and dust
• Age distribution of the central stars of galactic disk planetary nebulae
• The impact of spectra quality on nebular abundances
• Trading oxygen for iron I: the [O/Fe] -- specific star formation rate relation of galaxies
• A modern guide to quantitative spectroscopy of massive OB stars
• Tracing the Galactic Disk with Planetary Nebulae using Gaia DR3
• Helium contamination from the progenitor stars of planetary nebulae: The He/H radial gradient and the Delta Y/Delta Z enrichment ratio
• NGC 6153: Reality is complicated
• MUSE spectroscopy of the high abundance discrepancy planetary nebula NGC 6153
• Neon, sulphur and argon abundances of planetary nebulae in the sub-solar metallicity Galactic anti-centre
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in PN M 2-36. Results from deep echelle observations
• A study of extragalactic planetary nebulae populations based on spectroscopy. I. Data compilation and first findings
• Latest advances in the abundance discrepancy problem in photoionized nebulae
• Radial abundance gradients from planetary nebulae at different distances from the galactic plane