Resolving the electron temperature discrepancies in HII Regions and Planetary Nebulae: kappa-distributed electrons

Abstract

The measurement of electron temperatures and metallicities in H ii regions and Planetary Nebulae (PNe) has-for several decades-presented a problem: results obtained using different techniques disagree. What it worse, they disagree consistently. There have been numerous attempts to explain these discrepancies, but none has provided a satisfactory solution to the problem. In this paper, we explore the possibility that electrons in H ii regions and PNe depart from a Maxwell-Boltzmann equilibrium energy distribution. We adopt a "kappa-distribution" for the electron energies. Such distributions are widely found in Solar System plasmas, where they can be directly measured. This simple assumption is able to explain the temperature and metallicity discrepancies in H ii regions and PNe arising from the different measurement techniques. We find that the energy distribution does not need to depart dramatically from an equilibrium distribution. From an examination of data from Hii regions and PNe it appears that kappa ~ 10 is sufficient to encompass nearly all objects. We argue that the kappa-distribution offers an important new insight into the physics of gaseous nebulae, both in the Milky Way and elsewhere, and one that promises significantly more accurate estimates of temperature and metallicity in these regions.

16 pages, 11 figures, 2 tables, published in ApJ

References in corpus (4)

• The localized chemical pollution in NGC 5253 revisited: Results from deep echelle spectrophotometry
• The Chemical Composition of the 30 Doradus Nebula Derived from VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry
• Magnetic Fields in Large Diameter HII Regions Revealed by the Faraday Rotation of Compact Extragalactic Radio Sources
• Analysis of two SMC HII Regions Considering Thermal Inhomogeneities: Implications for the Determinations of Extragalactic Chemical Abundances

Cited by in corpus (146)

• De Re Metallica: The cosmic chemical evolution of galaxies
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation with the Direct Method on Stacked Spectra of SDSS Galaxies
• Understanding Galaxy Evolution through Emission Lines
• Theoretical Evolution of Optical Strong Lines across Cosmic Time
• A Budget and Accounting of Metals at z~0: Results from the COS-Halos Survey
• The Universal Relation of Galactic Chemical Evolution: The Origin of the Mass-Metallicity Relation
• New calibrations for abundance determinations in HII regions
• New fully empirical calibrations of strong-line metallicity indicators in star forming galaxies
• New Strong Line Abundance Diagnostics for \HII Regions: Effects of $\kappa$-Distributed Electron Energies and New Atomic Data
• Chemical abundances in high-redshift galaxies: A powerful new emission line diagnostic
• The Cosmic BPT Diagram: Confronting Theory with Observations
• Deriving model-based T${}_e$-consistent chemical abundances in ionised gaseous nebulae
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: Shocks and Outflows in a normal star-forming galaxy
• CHAOS I: Direct Chemical Abundances for HII Regions in NGC 628
• A Census of Oxygen in Star-Forming Galaxies: An Empirical Model Linking Metallicities, Star Formation Rates and Outflows
• Effects of Pre-ionisation in Radiative Shocks I: Self-Consistent Models
• IZI: Inferring the Gas Phase Metallicity (Z) and Ionization Parameter (q) of Ionized Nebulae using Bayesian Statistics
• Nebular spectroscopy: A guide on H II regions and planetary nebulae
• "Direct" Gas-Phase Metallicity in Local Analogs of High-Redshift Galaxies: Empirical Metallicity Calibrations for High-Redshift Star-Forming Galaxies
• Chemical abundances in M31 from HII regions
• Collision Strengths for [O III] Optical and Infrared Lines
• Measuring nebular temperatures: the effect of new collision strengths with equilibrium and kappa-distributed electron energies
• Upgrading electron temperature and electron density diagnostic diagrams of forbidden line emission
• Theoretical ISM pressure and electron density diagnostics for local and high-redshift galaxies
• Young stars and ionized nebulae in M83: comparing chemical abundances at high metallicity
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: Exploring the gas-phase Mass-Metallicity Relation
• Physical properties and H-ionizing-photon production rates of extreme nearby star-forming regions
• Carbon and oxygen in HII regions of the Magellanic Clouds: abundance discrepancy and chemical evolution
• Are LGRBs biased tracers of star formation? Clues from the host galaxies of the $Swift$/BAT6 complete sample of bright LGRBs III: Stellar masses, star formation rates and metallicities at $z>1$
• Confirmation of the link between central star binarity and extreme abundance discrepancy factors in planetary nebulae
• New Radial Abundance Gradients for NGC 628 and NGC 2403
• Temperature-based metallicity measurements at z=0.8: direct calibration of strong-line diagnostics at intermediate redshift
• Coevolution of metallicity and star formation in galaxies to z=3.7: I. A fundamental plane
• BOND: Bayesian Oxygen and Nitrogen abundance Determinations in giant H II regions using strong and semi-strong lines
• Starburst-AGN mixing: II. Optically-selected active galaxies
• Hot gas around SN 1998bw: Inferring the progenitor from its environment
• Carbon and oxygen abundance gradients in NGC300 and M33 from optical recombination lines
• "Direct" Gas-phase Metallicities, Stellar Properties, and Local Environments of Emission-line Galaxies at Redshift below 0.90
• NGC 2579 and the carbon and oxygen abundance gradients beyond the solar circle
• Non-Equilibrium Processes in the Solar Corona, Transition Region, Flares, and Solar Wind \textit{(Invited Review)}
• Photoionization models of the CALIFA HII regions. I. Hybrid models
• The metallicity evolution of low mass galaxies: New constraints at intermediate redshift
• KAPPA: A Package for Synthesis of optically thin spectra for the non-Maxwellian kappa-distributions based on the CHIANTI database
• Interrogating Seyferts with NebulaBayes: Spatially probing the narrow-line region radiation fields and chemical abundances
• Chemical abundances of Seyfert 2 AGNs-III. Reducing the oxygen abundance discrepancy
• Temperature inhomogeneities cause the abundance discrepancy in H II regions
• A Recalibration of Strong Line Oxygen Abundance Diagnostics via the Direct Method and Implications for the High Redshift Universe
• Evidence for azimuthal variations of the oxygen abundance gradient tracing the spiral structure of the galaxy HCG91c
• Exploring Systematic Effects in the Relation Between Stellar Mass, Gas Phase Metallicity, and Star Formation Rate
• Anomalously low metallicity regions in MaNGA star-forming galaxies: Accretion Caught in Action?
• Discrepancies between the [OIII] and [SIII] Temperatures in HII Regions
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. II. Chemical abundances and the abundance discrepancy factor
• H to Zn Ionization Equilibrium for the Non-Maxwellian Electron kappa-distributions: Updated Calculations
• Ultraviolet spectra of extreme nearby star-forming regions: evidence for an overabundance of very massive stars
• The chemical enrichment of long-GRB nurseries up to z=2
• The Relationship between Stellar Mass, Gas Metallicity, and Star Formation Rate for Halpha-selected Galaxies at z~0.8 from the NewHalpha Survey
• Calibrating Interstellar Abundances using SNR Radiative Shocks
• Towards A Removal of Temperature Dependencies from Abundance Determinations
• Chemical abundances in 7 metal-poor HII regions and a determination of the primordial helium abundance
• The mass-metallicity relation at z~1-2 and its dependence on star formation rate
• Monte Carlo Method for Calculating Oxygen Abundances and Their Uncertainties from Strong-Line Flux Measurements
• Signatures of the non-Maxwellian $\kappa$-distributions in optically thin line spectra \subtitle{I. Theory and synthetic Fe IX--XIII spectra}
• Ejection of globular cluster interstellar media through ionization by white dwarfs
• Probing the physics of narrow-line regions of Seyfert galaxies I: The case of NGC 5427
• Metal Abundances of KISS Galaxies. VI. New Metallicity Relations for the KISS Sample of Star-Forming Galaxies
• Inferring gas-phase metallicity gradients of galaxies at the seeing limit: A forward modelling approach
• Metal-poor dwarf galaxies in the SIGRID galaxy sample. I. HII region observations and chemical abundances
• Plasma Diagnostics for Planetary Nebulae and H II Regions Using the N II and O II Optical Recombination Lines
• Recombination coefficients for O II lines in nebular conditions
• Galaxy emission line classification using 3D line ratio diagrams
• The radial abundance gradient of chlorine in the Milky Way
• H I Free-Bound Emission of Planetary Nebulae with Large Abundance Discrepancies: Two-Component Models versus Kappa-distributed electrons
• Injection of $\kappa$-like Suprathermal Particles into Diffusive Shock Acceleration
• Choirs HI Galaxy Groups: The metallicity of dwarf galaxies
• Galaxy Interactions in Compact Groups II: abundance and kinematic anomalies in HCG 91c
• The chemical composition of Galactic ring nebulae around massive stars
• Physical correlations lead to kappa distributions
• Z-FIRE: ISM properties of the z = 2.095 COSMOS Cluster
• The Cocoon Nebula and its ionizing star: do stellar and nebular abundances agree?
• Very deep spectroscopy of the bright Saturn Nebula NGC 7009 - II. Analysis of the rich optical recombination spectrum
• HOMERUN a new approach to photoionization modelling. I -- reproducing observed emission lines with percent accuracy and obtaining accurate physical properties of the ionized gas
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy I: HH529II and III
• Ionizing stellar population in the disk of NGC 3310 $-$ I. The impact of a minor merger on galaxy evolution
• Densities, temperatures, pressures, and abundances derived from OII recombination lines in HII regions and their implications
• An empirical prediction for stellar metallicity distributions in nearby galaxies
• Electron Temperatures and Free-Electron Energy Distributions of Nebulae from C II Dielectronic Recombination Lines
• Carbon Abundances in Starburst Galaxies of the Local Universe
• The Continuum Emission Spectrum of Hf 2-2 near the Balmer Limit and the ORL versus CEL abundance and temperature Discrepancy
• Neutron-capture element abundances in the planetary nebula NGC 5315 from deep optical and near-infrared spectrophotometry
• The "Green Bean" Galaxy SDSS J224024.1--092748: Unravelling the emission signature of a quasar ionization echo
• Observational Constraints on the Common Envelope Phase
• Atomic Chemistry in Turbulent Astrophysical Media II: Effect of the Redshift Zero Metagalactic Background
• Messenger Monte-Carlo MAPPINGS V (M^3) -- A self-consistent three-dimensional photoionization code
• MUSE 3D Spectroscopy and Kinematics of the gigahertz peaked spectrum Radio Galaxy PKS 1934-63: Interaction, Recently Triggered AGN and Star Formation
• Testing the existence of non-Maxwellian electron distributions in H II regions after assessing atomic data accuracy
• The Discrepant Kinematics of ORLs and CELs in NGC 7009 as a Function of Ionization Structure
• Bi-abundance photoionization models of planetary nebulae: determining the amount of Oxygen in the metal rich component
• Very Large Telescope deep echelle spectroscopy of Galactic planetary nebulae NGC 6153, M 1-42 and Hf 2-2
• Emission and recombination coefficients for hydrogen with kappa-distributed electron energies
• Metal-poor dwarf galaxies in the SIGRID galaxy sample. II. The electron temperature-abundance calibration and the parameters that affect it
• Electron Energy Distributions in HII Regions and Planetary Nebulae: kappa-Distributions Do Not Apply
• IFU spectroscopy of Southern PNe: VII Photo-ionization modelling of intermediate excitation class objects
• Ionized gas properties of the extreme starburst galaxy Haro 11. Temperature and metal abundance discrepancies
• A Framework for Empirical Galaxy Phenomenology: The Scatter in Galaxy Ages and Stellar Metallicities
• HII regions in CALIFA survey: II. The relation between their physical properties and galaxy evolution
• The Kinematics of the Permitted C II $\lambda$ 6578 Line in a Large Sample of Planetary Nebulae
• Temperature-averaged and total free-free Gaunt factors for $\kappa$ and Maxwellian distributions of electrons
• Photoionization models for extreme Ly$\alpha$ $\lambda$1216 and HeII $\lambda$1640 ratios in quasar halos, and PopIII vs AGN diagnostics
• The mass-metallicity and fundamental metallicity relations in non-AGN and AGN-host galaxies
• No temperature fluctuations in the giant HII region H 1013
• Effective collision strengths for excitation and de-excitation of nebular [O III] optical and infrared lines with kappa distributed electron energies
• The kinematical behaviour of ORLs and CELs in Galactic PNe
• Nebular metallicities in two isolated Local Void dwarf galaxies
• Extreme CII emission in type 2 quasars at z~2.5: a signature of kappa-distributed electron energies?
• Constraints on the densities and temperature of Seyfert 2 NLR
• On the non-thermal kappa-distributed electrons in planetary nebulae and HII regions: the kappa index and its correlations with other nebular properties
• Metal Abundances of KISS Galaxies. V. Nebular Abundances of Fifteen Intermediate Luminosity Star-Forming Galaxies
• A Variant Stellar-to-nebular Dust Attenuation Ratio on Subgalactic and Galactic Scales
• Extraplanar HII Regions in the edge-on Spiral Galaxies NGC 3628 and NGC 4522
• MUSE spectroscopy of the high abundance discrepancy planetary nebula NGC 6153
• Concepts for a deuterium-deuterium fusion reactor
• X-ray Spectra from Plasmas with High-Energy Electrons: kappa-distributions and e-e Bremsstrahlung
• Electron Energy Distributions in the Extended Gas Nebulae associated with High-z AGN: Maxwell-Boltzmann vs. kappa distributions
• Turbulent magnetic field in the HII region Sh 2-27
• Physical and chemical properties of Wolf-Rayet planetary nebulae
• The ultraviolet CII lines as a diagnostic of kappa-distributed electrons in planetary nebulae
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in PN M 2-36. Results from deep echelle observations
• The Slow Flow Model of Dust Efflux in Local Star-Forming Galaxies
• The Emission Nebula Sh 2-174: A Radio Investigation of the Surrounding Region
• Enhancement of fusion reactivities using non-Maxwellian energy distributions
• Bi-abundance ionization structure of the Wolf-Rayet planetary nebula PB 8
• Direct Method Gas Phase Oxygen Abundances of 4 Lyman Break Analogs
• Inferring source properties of monoenergetic electron precipitation from kappa and Maxwellian moment-voltage relationships
• Deep high spectral resolution spectroscopy and chemical composition of ionized nebulae
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in photoionized nebulae from optical spectra
• On the treatment of $\ell$-changing proton-hydrogen Rydberg atom collisions
• Discovery of a New Population of Galactic HII Regions with Ionized Gas Velocity Gradients
• Can the Kappa-distributed electron energies account for the intensity ratios of O II lines in photoionized gaseous nebulae?
• Non-Maxwellian rate coefficients for electron and ion collisions in Rydberg plasmas: implications for excitation and ionization
• Gaseous abundances in planetary nebulae: What have we learned in the past five years?
• The ADF and the t${}^2$ formalism in H II regions based on the upper mass limit of the IMF for the MW
• Close binary central stars and the abundance discrepancy - new extreme objects
• Multi-diagnostic convergence: a single measurement in weakly collisional plasmas
• SDSS-V LVM: A spatially resolved study of the physical conditions and the chemical abundance discrepancy in the Lagoon Nebula (M 8)
• The Integral Field View of the Orion Nebula
• A comparative study of O, Ne, Cl, and Ar in Hii regions and PNe of the Galactic disk: Temporal evolution of radial gradients?