Temperature inhomogeneities cause the abundance discrepancy in H II regions

Abstract

HII regions, ionized nebulae where massive star formation has taken place, exhibit a wealth of emission lines that are the fundamental basis for estimating the chemical composition of the Universe. For more than 80 years, a discrepancy of at least a factor of two between heavy-element abundances derived with collisional excited lines (CELs) and the weaker recombination lines (RLs) has thrown our absolute abundance determinations into doubt. Heavy elements regulate the cooling of the interstellar gas, being essential to the understanding of several phenomena such as nucleosynthesis, star formation and chemical evolution. In this work, we use the best available deep optical spectra of ionized nebulae to analyze the cause of this abundance discrepancy problem. We find for the first time general observational evidence in favor of the temperature inhomogeneities within the gas, quantified by t2. The temperature inhomogeneities inside H II regions are affecting only the gas of high ionization degree and producing the abundance discrepancy problem. This work implies that the metallicity determinations based on CELs must be revised, as they can be severely underestimated, especially in the regions of lower metallicity, such as the JWST high-z galaxies. We present methods to estimate these corrections, which will be critical for robust interpretations of the chemical composition of the Universe over cosmic time.

arXiv commentA Nature paper. The final version of this article can be found here: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-05956-2 This version of ArXiV is the initial version of the article, not refereed and without subsequent editorial changes. The accepted version will be updated here in 6 months. If you are a researcher and do not have access to the final version of Nature, please write me an email

References in corpus (63)

• The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision
• De Re Metallica: The cosmic chemical evolution of galaxies
• PyNeb: a new tool for analyzing emission lines. I. Code description and validation of results
• Understanding Galaxy Evolution through Emission Lines
• A reappraisal of the chemical composition of the Orion nebula based on VLT echelle spectrophotometry
• The chemical enrichment in the early Universe as probed by JWST via direct metallicity measurements at z~8
• Resolving the electron temperature discrepancies in HII Regions and Planetary Nebulae: kappa-distributed electrons
• The Chemical Composition of the Small Magellanic Cloud H II Region NGC 346 and the Primordial Helium Abundance
• Keck HIRES Spectroscopy of Extragalactic HII Regions: C and O Abundances from Recombination Lines
• On the abundance discrepancy problem in HII regions
• The localized chemical pollution in NGC 5253 revisited: Results from deep echelle spectrophotometry
• The Chemical Composition of the 30 Doradus Nebula Derived from VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry
• Nebular spectroscopy: A guide on H II regions and planetary nebulae
• Electron impact excitation of OII fine-structure levels
• Collision Strengths for [O III] Optical and Infrared Lines
• A First Look at the Abundance Pattern -- O/H, C/O, and Ne/O -- in $z>7$ Galaxies with JWST/NIRSpec
• Carbon and oxygen abundances from recombination lines in low-metallicity star-forming galaxies. Implications for chemical evolution
• Optical Recombination Lines of Heavy-elements in Giant Extragalactic HII Regions
• Properties of the ionized gas in HH202. II: Results from echelle spectrophotometry with UVES
• s-Process Abundances in Planetary Nebulae
• Binarity and the abundance discrepancy problem in planetary nebulae
• Faint emission lines in the Galactic H II regions M16, M20 and NGC 3603
• On the O/H, Mg/H, Si/H and Fe/H Gas and Dust Abundance Ratios in Galactic and Extragalactic H II Regions
• Chemical abundances for Hf 2-2, a planetary nebula with the strongest known heavy element recombination lines
• Chemical abundances of the Galactic H II region NGC 3576 derived from VLT echelle spectrophotometry
• Carbon and oxygen in HII regions of the Magellanic Clouds: abundance discrepancy and chemical evolution
• Chemical Composition of Two H II Regions in NGC 6822 Based on VLT Spectroscopy
• Physical conditions in the planetary nebula Abell 30
• First Insights into the ISM at $z>8$ with JWST: Possible Physical Implications of a High [O III]$\lambda 4363$/[O III]$\lambda 5007$
• Deep Echelle Spectrophotometry of S 311, a galactic H II Region Outside the Solar Circle
• VLT spectroscopy of low-metallicity emission-line galaxies: abundance patterns and abundance discrepancies
• Carbon and oxygen abundance gradients in NGC300 and M33 from optical recombination lines
• The radial abundance gradient of oxygen towards the Galactic anticentre
• A Multiwavelength Look at Galactic Massive Star Forming Regions
• Determination of the primordial helium abundance based on NGC 346 an HII region of the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Gradients of chemical abundances in the Milky Way from HII regions: distances derived from Gaia EDR3 parallaxes and temperature inhomogeneities
• Introducing EMILI: Computer Aided Emission Line Identification
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. I. Line intensities and physical conditions
• PPAK Integral Field Spectroscopy survey of the Orion Nebula: Data Release
• The effects of spatially distributed ionisation sources on the temperature structure of HII region
• Carbon, nitrogen and oxygen abundance gradients in M101 and M31
• Small scale behavior of the physical conditions and the abundance discrepancy in the Orion nebula
• MUSE spectroscopy of planetary nebulae with high abundance discrepancies
• Analysis of two SMC HII Regions Considering Thermal Inhomogeneities: Implications for the Determinations of Extragalactic Chemical Abundances
• Recombination coefficients for O II lines in nebular conditions
• The chemical composition of Galactic ring nebulae around massive stars
• C/O ratios in planetary nebulae with dual-dust chemistry from faint optical recombination lines
• The Fe/Ni ratio in ionized nebulae: clues on dust depletion patterns
• The homogeneity of chemical abundances in H II regions of the Magellanic Clouds
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy I: HH529II and III
• The planetary nebula IC 4776 and its post-common-envelope binary central star
• Densities, temperatures, pressures, and abundances derived from OII recombination lines in HII regions and their implications
• The Continuum Emission Spectrum of Hf 2-2 near the Balmer Limit and the ORL versus CEL abundance and temperature Discrepancy
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy II: HH204
• Neutron-capture element abundances in the planetary nebula NGC 5315 from deep optical and near-infrared spectrophotometry
• Photoionized Herbig-Haro objects in the Orion Nebula through deep high-spectral resolution spectroscopy III: HH514
• Temperature Structure and Metallicity in H II Regions
• A classification of HII regions based on Oxygen and Helium lines: The cases of TOL2146-391 and TOL0357-3915
• The abundance discrepancy factor and t^2 in nebulae: are non-thermal electrons the culprits?
• NGC 6153: Reality is complicated
• Temperature fluctuations in H II regions: t2 for the two-phase model
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in PN M 2-36. Results from deep echelle observations
• Physical conditions and chemical abundances in photoionized nebulae from optical spectra

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Density biases and temperature relations for DESIRED HII regions
• JADES: The star-formation and chemical enrichment history of a luminous galaxy at z~9.43 probed by ultra-deep JWST/NIRSpec spectroscopy
• HOMERUN a new approach to photoionization modelling. I -- reproducing observed emission lines with percent accuracy and obtaining accurate physical properties of the ionized gas
• Gas-phase Fe/O and Fe/N abundances in Star-Forming Regions. Relations between nucleosynthesis, metallicity and dust
• Metallicity calibrations based on auroral lines from PHANGS-MUSE data
• Trading oxygen for iron I: the [O/Fe] -- specific star formation rate relation of galaxies
• Constraints on the densities and temperature of Seyfert 2 NLR
• Machine learning the gap between real and simulated nebulae: A domain-adaptation approach to classify ionised nebulae in nearby galaxies
• MUSE spectroscopy of the high abundance discrepancy planetary nebula NGC 6153
• Chemical abundances and deviations from the solar S/O ratio in the gas-phase ISM of galaxies based on infrared emission lines
• MARTA: Temperature-temperature relationships and strong-line metallicity calibrations from multiple auroral-line detections at cosmic noon
• Oxygen Abundance Throughout the Dwarf Starburst IC 10
• Constraining the physical properties of gas in high-z galaxies with far-infrared and submillimetre line ratios
• SDSS-V LVM: Resolving Physical Conditions in the Trifid Nebula
• Temperature based radial metallicity gradients in nearby galaxies
• MARTA: The connection between chemical enrichment, feedback, and dust in a Wolf-Rayet galaxy at z$\sim$2
• Kinematical analysis of PNe with high ADF: Hf 2-2 and M 1-42
• SDSS-V LVM: A spatially resolved study of the physical conditions and the chemical abundance discrepancy in the Lagoon Nebula (M 8)
• Chemical enrichment in LINERs from MaNGA. I. Tracing Oxygen and Nitrogen Nuclear Abundances in LINERs with Varied Ionizing Sources
• The ionization structure and chemical history in isolated H ii regions of dwarf galaxies with VIMOS/IFU II. The Leo A galaxy
• A comparative study of O, Ne, Cl, and Ar in Hii regions and PNe of the Galactic disk: Temporal evolution of radial gradients?
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: Data-Model Discrepancy in Temperature-sensitive Line Ratios for Star-forming Galaxies