SDSS-IV MaNGA: Data-Model Discrepancy in Temperature-sensitive Line Ratios for Star-forming Galaxies

Abstract

Gas-phase metallicity is a fundamental parameter that helps constrain the star-forming history and chemical evolution of a galaxy. Measuring electron temperature through auroral-to-strong line ratios is a direct approach to deriving metallicity. However, there is a longstanding discrepancy between metallicity measured through the direct method and that based on the photoionization models. This paper aims to verify and understand the discrepancies. We bin ~ 1.5 million spaxels from SDSS-IV MaNGA according to metallicity and ionization parameters derived from theoretical strong-line calibrations. We stack the spectra of spaxels within each bin and measure the flux of strong lines and faint auroral lines. Auroral lines for [OII], [SII], [OIII], and [SIII] are detected in the stacked spectra of most bins, and the [NII] auroral line is detected in fewer bins. We apply an empirical method to correct dust attenuation, which makes more realistic corrections for low ionization lines. We derive electron temperatures for these five ionic species and measure the oxygen and sulfur abundances using the direct method. We present the resulting abundance measurements and compare them with those model-calibrated strong-line abundances. The chemical abundances measured with the direct method are lower than those derived from the photoionization model, with a median of 0.09 dex. This discrepancy is smaller compared to the results based on other metallicity calibrations previously reported. However, we notice that the direct method could not account for the variation in ionization parameters, indicating that the precise calibration of metallicity using the direct method has yet to be fully realized. We report significant discrepancies between data and the photoionization model, which illustrates that the one-dimensional photoionization model is incapable of representing the complexity of real situations.

17 pages, 12 figures, accepted by A&A. Comments are welcome

References in corpus (67)

• Array Programming with NumPy
• The chemical composition of the Sun
• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• The Dust Content and Opacity of Actively Star-Forming Galaxies
• The Astropy Project: Sustaining and Growing a Community-oriented Open-source Project and the Latest Major Release (v5.0) of the Core Package
• The slope of the black-hole mass versus velocity dispersion correlation
• Overview of the SDSS-IV MaNGA Survey: Mapping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory
• Metallicity Calibrations and the Mass-Metallicity Relation for Star-Forming Galaxies
• Improving the full spectrum fitting method: accurate convolution with Gauss-Hermite functions
• Using Strong Lines to Estimate Abundances in Extragalactic HII Regions and Starburst Galaxies
• The Multi-Object, Fiber-Fed Spectrographs for SDSS and the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey
• Gas-regulation of galaxies: the evolution of the cosmic sSFR, the metallicity-mass-SFR relation and the stellar content of haloes
• De Re Metallica: The cosmic chemical evolution of galaxies
• PyNeb: a new tool for analyzing emission lines. I. Code description and validation of results
• The O3N2 and N2 abundance indicators revisited: improved calibrations based on CALIFA and Te-based literature data
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation with the Direct Method on Stacked Spectra of SDSS Galaxies
• Understanding Galaxy Evolution through Emission Lines
• The MaNGA Integral Field Unit Fiber Feed System for the Sloan 2.5 m Telescope
• The Data Reduction Pipeline for the SDSS-IV MaNGA IFU Galaxy Survey
• The SDSS-IV MaNGA Sample: Design, Optimization, and Usage Considerations
• SDSS-IV MaNGA IFS Galaxy Survey --- Survey Design, Execution, and Initial Data Quality
• The Data Analysis Pipeline for the SDSS-IV MaNGA IFU Galaxy Survey: Overview
• New calibrations for abundance determinations in HII regions
• New fully empirical calibrations of strong-line metallicity indicators in star forming galaxies
• New Strong Line Abundance Diagnostics for \HII Regions: Effects of $\kappa$-Distributed Electron Energies and New Atomic Data
• Chemical abundances in high-redshift galaxies: A powerful new emission line diagnostic
• Full spectrum fitting with photometry in pPXF: stellar population versus dynamical masses, non-parametric star formation history and metallicity for 3200 LEGA-C galaxies at redshift z~0.8
• SDSS-IV/MaNGA: Spectrophotometric Calibration Technique
• The Dust Attenuation Law in Galaxies
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: The Impact of Diffuse Ionized Gas on Emission-line Ratios, Interpretation of Diagnostic Diagrams, and Gas Metallicity Measurements
• The Data Analysis Pipeline for the SDSS-IV MaNGA IFU Galaxy Survey: Emission-Line Modeling
• Deriving model-based T${}_e$-consistent chemical abundances in ionised gaseous nebulae
• Eliminating Error in the Chemical Abundance Scale for Extragalactic HII Regions
• CHAOS I: Direct Chemical Abundances for HII Regions in NGC 628
• Diffuse ionized gas in galaxies across the Hubble sequence at the CALIFA resolution
• CHAOS IV: Gas-Phase Abundance Trends From The First Four CHAOS Galaxies
• IZI: Inferring the Gas Phase Metallicity (Z) and Ionization Parameter (q) of Ionized Nebulae using Bayesian Statistics
• Nebular spectroscopy: A guide on H II regions and planetary nebulae
• A comparative analysis of empirical calibrators for nebular metallicity
• Ionized gaseous nebulae chemical abundance determination using the direct method
• SDSS-IV MaStar -- A Large and Comprehensive Empirical Stellar Spectral Library: First Release
• Carbon and oxygen abundances from recombination lines in low-metallicity star-forming galaxies. Implications for chemical evolution
• BOND: Bayesian Oxygen and Nitrogen abundance Determinations in giant H II regions using strong and semi-strong lines
• Analyzing derived metallicities and ionization parameters from model-based determinations in ionized gaseous nebulae
• CHAOS VI: Direct Abundances in NGC 2403
• Photoionization models of the CALIFA HII regions. I. Hybrid models
• Temperature inhomogeneities cause the abundance discrepancy in H II regions
• HII regions in the CALIFA survey: I. Catalog presentation
• Density biases and temperature relations for DESIRED HII regions
• Discrepancies between the [OIII] and [SIII] Temperatures in HII Regions
• Extreme Emission-Line Galaxies in SDSS. I. Empirical and model-based calibrations of chemical abundances
• The direct oxygen abundances of metal-rich galaxies derived from electron temperature
• Atomic Data Assessment with PyNeb
• The Te[N II]-Te[O III] temperature relation in H II regions and the reliability of strong-line methods
• Bar effect on gas-phase abundance gradients. I. Data sample and chemical abundances
• The diffuse ionized gas (DIG) in star-forming galaxies: the influence of aperture effects on local HII regions
• Constraining Photoionization Models With a Reprojected Optical Diagnostic Diagram
• Galaxy emission line classification using 3D line ratio diagrams
• Sulphur abundance determinations in star-forming regions-I: Ionization Correction Factor
• Correlation between the gas-phase metallicity and ionization parameter in extragalactic HII regions
• Accurate Oxygen Abundance of Interstellar Gas in Mrk 71 from Optical and Infrared Spectra
• Densities, temperatures, pressures, and abundances derived from OII recombination lines in HII regions and their implications
• Shocks or Photoionization: Direct Temperature Measurements of the Low-Ionization Gas in Quiescent Galaxies
• Metallicity calibrations based on auroral lines from PHANGS-MUSE data
• Direct-method metallicity gradients derived from spectral stacking with SDSS-IV MaNGA
• The need for multicomponent dust attenuation in modeling nebular emission: Constraints from SDSS-IV MaNGA
• Ionized gas in quiescent galaxies: Temperature measurement and constraint on the ionization source