The Te[N II]-Te[O III] temperature relation in H II regions and the reliability of strong-line methods

Abstract

We use a sample of 154 observations of 124 H II regions that have measurements of both Te[O III] and Te[N II], compiled from the literature, to explore the behaviour of the Te[O III]-Te[N II] temperature relation. We confirm that the relation depends on the degree of ionization and present a new set of relations for two different ranges of this parameter. We study the effects introduced by our temperature relations and four other available relations in the calculation of oxygen and nitrogen abundances. We find that our relations improve slightly on the results obtained with the previous ones. We also use a sample of 26 deep, high-resolution spectra to estimate the contribution of blending to the intensity of the temperature-sensitive line [O III] $\lambda 4363$, and we derive a relation to correct Te[O III] for this effect. With our sample of 154 spectra, we analyse the reliability of the R, S, O3N2, N2, ONS, and C strong-line methods by comparing the metallicity obtained with these methods with the one implied by the direct method. We find that the strong-line methods introduce differences that reach ~ 0.2 dex or more, and that these differences depend on O/H, N/O, and the degree of ionization.

arXiv comment22 pages, 11 figures and 6 Tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (65)

• Metallicity Calibrations and the Mass-Metallicity Relation for Star-Forming Galaxies
• The MAPPINGS III Library of Fast Radiative Shock Models
• Metallicities of 0.3<z<1.0 Galaxies in the GOODS-North Field
• PyNeb: a new tool for analyzing emission lines. I. Code description and validation of results
• The O3N2 and N2 abundance indicators revisited: improved calibrations based on CALIFA and Te-based literature data
• New light on the search for low metallicity galaxies I. The N2 method
• The Composition Gradient in M101 Revisited. II. Electron Temperatures and Implications for the Nebular Abundance Scale
• New calibrations for abundance determinations in HII regions
• Systematic effects and a new determination of the primordial abundance of 4He and dY/dZ from observations of blue compact galaxies
• New fully empirical calibrations of strong-line metallicity indicators in star forming galaxies
• The impact of the nitrogen-to-oxygen ratio on ionized nebulae diagnostics based on [NII] emission lines
• A reappraisal of the chemical composition of the Orion nebula based on VLT echelle spectrophotometry
• Extragalactic chemical abundances: do HII regions and young stars tell the same story? The case of the spiral galaxy NGC 300
• Deriving model-based T${}_e$-consistent chemical abundances in ionised gaseous nebulae
• Keck HIRES Spectroscopy of Extragalactic HII Regions: C and O Abundances from Recombination Lines
• CHAOS I: Direct Chemical Abundances for HII Regions in NGC 628
• Biases in abundance derivations for metal-rich nebulae
• Heavy elements in Galactic and Magellanic Cloud HII regions: recombination-line versus forbidden-line abundances
• The localized chemical pollution in NGC 5253 revisited: Results from deep echelle spectrophotometry
• CHAOS III: Gas-Phase Abundances in NGC5457
• The Chemical Composition of the 30 Doradus Nebula Derived from VLT Echelle Spectrophotometry
• The oxygen abundance in the inner HII regions of M101. Implications for the calibration of strong-line metallicity indicators
• Chemical abundances in M31 from HII regions
• Line temperatures and elemental abundances in HII galaxies
• Ionized gaseous nebulae chemical abundance determination using the direct method
• Collision Strengths for [O III] Optical and Infrared Lines
• Precision abundance analysis of bright HII galaxies
• "Counterpart" method for abundance determinations in HII regions
• Carbon and oxygen abundances from recombination lines in low-metallicity star-forming galaxies. Implications for chemical evolution
• Optical Recombination Lines of Heavy-elements in Giant Extragalactic HII Regions
• Properties of the ionized gas in HH202. II: Results from echelle spectrophotometry with UVES
• Faint emission lines in the Galactic H II regions M16, M20 and NGC 3603
• The temperature and ionization structure of the emitting gas in HII galaxies: Implications for the accuracy of abundance determinations
• Chemical abundances of the Galactic H II region NGC 3576 derived from VLT echelle spectrophotometry
• Carbon and oxygen in HII regions of the Magellanic Clouds: abundance discrepancy and chemical evolution
• New Radial Abundance Gradients for NGC 628 and NGC 2403
• Deep Echelle Spectrophotometry of S 311, a galactic H II Region Outside the Solar Circle
• BOND: Bayesian Oxygen and Nitrogen abundance Determinations in giant H II regions using strong and semi-strong lines
• [O II] line ratios
• VLT spectroscopy of low-metallicity emission-line galaxies: abundance patterns and abundance discrepancies
• Carbon and oxygen abundance gradients in NGC300 and M33 from optical recombination lines
• NGC 2579 and the carbon and oxygen abundance gradients beyond the solar circle
• Oxygen enrichment in carbon-rich planetary nebulae
• The radial abundance gradient of oxygen towards the Galactic anticentre
• Present-day mass-metallicity relation for galaxies using a new electron-temperature method
• Chemical distribution of HII regions towards the Galactic anticentre
• The population of planetary nebulae and HII regions in M81. A study of radial metallicity gradients and chemical evolution
• The effects of spatially distributed ionisation sources on the temperature structure of HII region
• On the relation between electron temperatures in the O+ and O++ zones in high-metallicity HII regions
• Analysis of two SMC HII Regions Considering Thermal Inhomogeneities: Implications for the Determinations of Extragalactic Chemical Abundances
• An Oxygen Abundance Gradient into the Outer Disk of M81
• The radial abundance gradient of chlorine in the Milky Way
• The chemical composition of Galactic ring nebulae around massive stars
• On the electron temperature determination in high-metallicity HII regions
• Heating of blue compact dwarf galaxies: gas distribution and photoionization by stars in I Zw 18
• The impact of atomic data selection on nebular abundance determinations
• The electron temperatures of SDSS high-metallicity giant extragalactic HII regions
• The oxygen abundance gradient in M81 and the robustness of abundance determinations in H II regions
• WR bubbles and HeII emission
• The Oxygen Abundance in the Solar Neighborhood
• A study of the neglected Galactic HII region NGC 2579 and its companion ESO 370-9
• Ionizing stellar population in the disc of NGC 3310 - II. The Wolf-Rayet population
• Chemical Abundances of NGC 5461 and NGC 5471 derived from Echelle Spectrophotometry
• Optical spectroscopy of star-forming regions in dwarf Wolf-Rayet galaxies
• Photoionization models of Planetary Nebulae

Cited by in corpus (22)

• A First Look at the Abundance Pattern -- O/H, C/O, and Ne/O -- in $z>7$ Galaxies with JWST/NIRSpec
• CHAOS VI: Direct Abundances in NGC 2403
• Ionization correction factors and dust depletion patterns in giant HII regions
• Density biases and temperature relations for DESIRED HII regions
• On the radial abundance gradients of nitrogen and oxygen in the inner Galactic disc
• CHAOS VII: A Large-Scale Direct Abundance Study in M33
• About Metallicity Variations in the Local Galactic Interstellar Medium
• Gas-phase Fe/O and Fe/N abundances in Star-Forming Regions. Relations between nucleosynthesis, metallicity and dust
• CLASSY V: The impact of aperture effects on the inferred nebular properties of local star-forming galaxies
• Chemical abundances in Seyfert galaxies X. Sulphur abundance estimates
• New Ionization Models and the Shocking Nitrogen Excess at z > 5
• New calibrations for estimating the N/O ratio in HII regions
• Using KCWI to Explore the Chemical Inhomogeneities and Evolution of J1044+0353
• UM462, a local green pea galaxy analogue under the MUSE magnifying glass
• Physical Origins of Outflowing Cold Clouds in Local Star-forming Dwarf Galaxies
• The JWST EXCELS Survey: gas-phase metallicity evolution at 2 < z < 8
• Spatially resolved direct method metallicity in a high-redshift analogue local galaxy: temperature structure impact on metallicity gradients
• MARTA: Temperature-temperature relationships and strong-line metallicity calibrations from multiple auroral-line detections at cosmic noon
• First direct electron temperature measurement in [O II] zone in I Zw 18
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: Data-Model Discrepancy in Temperature-sensitive Line Ratios for Star-forming Galaxies
• Chemical abundances in Seyfert galaxies -- VII. Direct abundance determination of neon based on optical and infrared emission lines
• Nebular abundance gradient in the Cartwheel galaxy using MUSE data