Dynamical Constraints On Alternatives To Massive Black Holes In Galactic Nuclei

Abstract

The compelling dynamical evidence for massive dark objects in galactic nuclei does not uniquely imply massive black holes (BHs). To argue convincingly that these objects are BHs we must rule out alternatives to a BH, and the alternative to a point mass is a cluster of some sort of nonluminous objects, such as a cluster of brown dwarfs or stellar remnants. We use simple physical considerations to derive the maximum possible lifetime of a dark cluster which may consist of any plausible form of non-luminous gravitating objects -- from brown dwarfs and very low-mass objects of cosmic composition, to white dwarfs, neutron stars, and black holes. The lower this limit relative to the galaxy age, the more implausible is the cluster hypothesis, thus arguing for a point mass. A cluster with a lifetime much shorter than ~10 Gyr is unacceptable, since observing it at the present epoch would be highly improbable. Since the goal is to rule out a dark cluster by showing that its lifetime must be very short, we make the most generous assumptions possible under the observational constraints to allow for its survival. We find that the lifetime of such an hypothetical cluster must be much shorter than the galaxy age only in the cases of NGC 4258 and our Galaxy, thus strongly arguing for a point mass. In all other galaxies, the case of a massive BH, although compelling, is not yet watertight. We also note that there are two exotic alternatives to a massive BH that cannot be ruled out even in the cases of NGC 4258 and the Galaxy: clusters of elementary particles (e.g. bosons), and clusters of very low-mass BHs. We point out, however, serious difficulties with these alternatives, and argue that they are highly implausible.

ApJ (Letters), in press. v2: corrected figure, 11 pages

References in corpus (4)

• Improved evidence for a black hole in M32 from HST/FOS spectra - II. Axisymmetric dynamical models
• Kinematics of the Nuclear Ionized Gas in the Radio Galaxy M84 (NGC 4374)
• Spectroscopic Evidence for a Supermassive Black Hole in NGC 4486B
• The Mass Distribution in the Elliptical Galaxy NGC 3377: Evidence for a 2 x 10**8 Solar Mass Black Hole

Cited by in corpus (141)

• Coevolution (Or Not) of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies
• Quasinormal modes of black holes and black branes
• The Galactic Center Massive Black Hole and Nuclear Star Cluster
• Closest Star Seen Orbiting the Supermassive Black Hole at the Centre of the Milky Way
• Supermassive Black Holes in Galactic Nuclei: Past, Present and Future Research
• Event-horizon-scale structure in the supermassive black hole candidate at the Galactic Centre
• Stellar Orbits Around the Galactic Center Black Hole
• The Proper Motion of Sgr A*: II. The Mass of Sgr A*
• Chandra X-ray Spectroscopic Imaging of Sgr A* and the Central Parsec of the Galaxy
• High Proper Motion Stars in the Vicinity of Sgr A*: Evidence for a Supermassive Black Hole at the Center of Our Galaxy
• The Supermassive Black Hole at the Galactic Center
• The Accelerations of Stars Orbiting the Milky Way's Central Black Hole
• Rates of tidal disruption of stars by massive central black holes
• Stellar dynamics in the central arcsecond of our galaxy
• On the Relationship Between Radio Emission and Black Hole Mass in Galactic Nuclei
• Black Hole Spin Evolution
• Testing black hole candidates with electromagnetic radiation
• Stellar Processes Near the Massive Black Hole in the Galactic Center
• The Megamaser Cosmology Project. III. Accurate Masses of Seven Supermassive Black Holes in Active Galaxies with Circumnuclear Megamaser Disks
• HST STIS spectroscopy of the triple nucleus of M31: two nested disks in Keplerian rotation around a Supermassive Black Hole
• A size of ~1 AU for the radio source Sgr A* at the centre of the Milky Way
• Can the supermassive objects at the centers of galaxies be traversable wormholes? The first test of strong gravity for mm/sub-mm VLBI facilities
• Gemini and Hubble Space Telescope Evidence for an Intermediate Mass Black Hole in omega Centauri
• Black Holes in Astrophysics
• The Proper Motion of SgrA*: I. First VLBA Results
• Dynamical evolution of black hole sub-systems in idealised star clusters
• LISA observations of rapidly spinning massive black hole binary systems
• Detection of the Intrinsic Size of Sagittarius A* through Closure Amplitude Imaging (includes Online Supporting Material)
• Polarimetry of near-infrared flares from Sagittarius A*
• The Geometry of and Mass Accretion Rate through the Maser Accretion Disk in NGC 4258
• Linking the spin evolution of massive black holes to galaxy kinematics
• Constraining the quadrupole moment of stellar-mass black-hole candidates with the continuum fitting method
• Measuring the Kerr spin parameter of regular black holes from their shadow
• Gravitational wave signatures of the absence of an event horizon. I. Nonradial oscillations of a thin-shell gravastar
• Methods for detecting flaring structures in Sagittarius A* with high frequency VLBI
• Distinguishing black holes from naked singularities through their accretion disk properties
• A code to compute the emission of thin accretion disks in non-Kerr space-times and test the nature of black hole candidates
• Probing the Spacetime Around Sgr A* with Radio Pulsars
• The Proper Motion of Sagittarius A*: III. The Case for a Supermassive Black Hole
• Evidence for a Supermassive Black Hole in the S0 Galaxy NGC 3245
• The Milky Way's Supermassive Black Hole: How good a case is it? A Challenge for Astrophysics & Philosophy of Science
• Evidence for a Massive Black Hole in the S0 Galaxy NGC 4342
• Evidence for a massive BH in the S0 galaxy NGC 4342
• On The Nature of the Compact Dark Mass at the Galactic Center
• Astrophysical Black Holes: A Compact Pedagogical Review
• Constraints on the spacetime geometry around 10 stellar-mass black hole candidates from the disk's thermal spectrum
• Proper Motion of the Compact, Nonthermal Radio Source in the Galactic Center, Sagittarius a*
• The Spectrum and Variability of Circular Polarization in Sagittarius A* from 1.4 to 15 GHz
• Black holes in Lorentz-violating gravity theories
• Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis
• Galaxy bulges and their massive black holes: a review
• Testing the no-hair theorem with the continuum-fitting and the iron line methods: a short review
• Detection of Circular Polarization in the Galactic Center Black Hole Candidate Sagittarius A*
• Broad K$\alpha$ iron line from accretion disks around traversable wormholes
• Dynamics of a Massive Black Hole at the Center of a Dense Stellar System
• A new Monte Carlo code for star cluster simulations: I. Relaxation
• K$\alpha$ iron line profile from accretion disks around regular and singular exotic compact objects
• Distinguishing black holes and wormholes with orbiting hot spots
• Megamaser Disks in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Black Hole Shadow Image and Visibility Analysis of Sagittarius A*
• Evidence of a Supermassive Black Hole in the Galaxy NGC 1023 from the Nuclear Stellar Dynamics
• The supermassive black hole in Centaurus A: a benchmark for gas kinematical measurements
• Dynamics of compact objects clusters: A post-Newtonian study
• Is there a Supermassive Black Hole at the Center of the Milky Way?
• Monte Carlo cluster simulations to determine the rate of compact star inspiraling to a central galactic black hole
• Using iron line reverberation and spectroscopy to distinguish Kerr and non-Kerr black holes
• Near-Infrared Microlensing of Stars by the Super-Massive Black Hole in the Galactic Center
• Full Three Dimensional Orbits For Multiple Stars on Close Approaches to the Central Supermassive Black Hole
• Supermassive black holes or boson stars? Hair counting with gravitational wave detectors
• Measuring the Kerr spin parameter of a non-Kerr compact object with the continuum-fitting and the iron line methods
• Spherical collapse of supermassive stars: neutrino emission and gamma-ray bursts
• Using Pulsars to Detect Massive Black Hole Binaries via Gravitational Radiation: Sagittarius A* and Nearby Galaxies
• The Galactic Center: An Interacting System of Unusual Sources
• A revised Cepheid distance to NGC 4258 and a test of the distance scale
• Limits on the Mass of the Central Black Hole in 16 Nearby Bulges
• Sgr A^*: A supermassive black hole or a spatially extended object?
• The Linear Polarization of Sagittarius A* II. VLA and BIMA Polarimetry at 22, 43 and 86 GHz
• Weighing the cusp at the Galactic Centre
• 7 mm lambda VLBA Observations of Sagittarius A*
• Constraint on the quadrupole moment of super-massive black hole candidates from the estimate of the mean radiative efficiency of AGN
• Towards the use of the most massive black hole candidates in AGN to test the Kerr paradigm
• On black hole sub-systems in idealized nuclear star clusters
• Testing the Kerr Nature of Black Hole Candidates using Iron Line Spectra in the CPR Framework
• LISA observations of massive black hole mergers: event rates and issues in waveform modelling
• BIMA Observations of Linear Polarization in Sagittarius A* at 112 GHz
• Images of the radiatively inefficient accretion flow surrounding a Kerr black hole: application in Sgr A*
• Accelerations of Water Masers in NGC4258
• Can we constrain the maximum value for the spin parameter of the super-massive objects in galactic nuclei without knowing their actual nature?
• The motion of stars near the Galactic center: A comparison of the black hole and fermion ball scenarios
• Toward Precision Black Hole Masses with ALMA: NGC 1332 as a Case Study in Molecular Disk Dynamics
• Testing the existence of regions of stable orbits at small radii around black hole candidates
• Stellar disruption events support the existence of the black hole event horizon
• Polarized Narrow-Line Emission from the Nucleus of NGC 4258
• Evolution of the spin parameter of accreting compact objects with non-Kerr quadrupole moment
• Testing the nature of the supermassive black hole candidate in SgrA* with light curves and images of hot spots
• Dynamics of the star S0-1 and the nature of the compact dark object at the Galactic center
• Spinning super-massive objects in galactic nuclei up to $a_{\ast }>1$
• VLBA Observations of Astrometric Reference Sources in the Galactic Center
• A parametrization to test black hole candidates with the spectrum of thin disks
• Distinguishing black holes and naked singularities with iron line spectroscopy
• Testing the Kerr nature of black hole candidates using iron line reverberation mapping in the CPR framework
• Star Formation and Dynamics in the Galactic Centre
• The Galactic Center stellar cluster: The central arcsecond
• Note on the Cardoso-Pani-Rico parametrization to test the Kerr black hole hypothesis
• RELXILL_NK: a relativistic reflection model for testing Einstein's gravity
• Rotating Ionized Gas Ring around the Galactic Center IRS13E3
• Iron K$\alpha$ line of Proca stars
• Stellar Gas Flows Into A Dark Cluster Potential At The Galactic Center
• Astrophysical implications of gravitational microlensing of gravitational waves
• Constraints on Alternatives to Supermassive Black Holes
• Caloric curve of star clusters
• Merger of Massive Black Holes using N-Body Simulations with Post-Newtonian Corrections
• Probing the nature of compact dark object at the Galactic Center by gravitational lensing
• Thick disk accretion in Kerr space-time with arbitrary spin parameters
• Gravitational waves from coalescing binaries and Doppler experiments
• Iron K$\alpha$ line of Kerr black holes with Proca hair
• A note on the observational evidence for the existence of event horizons in astrophysical black hole candidates
• Accreting Black Holes
• Constraining the Cardoso-Pani-Rico metric with future observations of SgrA${}^{\ast }$
• Testing the Kerr metric using X-ray reflection spectroscopy: spectral analysis of GX 339-4
• Accretion Rates onto Massive Black Holes in Four Quiescent Elliptical Galaxies
• Approaching the event horizon: 1.3mm VLBI of SgrA*
• Probing the spin of the central black hole in the galactic centre with secondary images
• Spectropolarimetric measurements of hidden broad lines in nearby megamaser galaxies: a lack of clear evidence for a correlation between black hole masses and virial products
• Scattering of particles by deformed non-rotating black holes
• Testing the $\delta$-Kerr metric with black hole X-ray data
• Sgr A* as probe of the theory of supermassive compact objects without event horizon
• Neutron Stars and Black Holes in Star Clusters
• Relativistic encounters in dense stellar systems
• Astrophysical black holes
• An application of the tensor virial theorem to hole + vortex + bulge systems
• Violation of the Carter-Israel conjecture and its astrophysical implications
• An interstellar mission to test astrophysical black holes
• The Galactic Center
• Tests of General Relativity using black hole X-ray data
• Black-Hole Phenomenology
• Holes within galaxies: the egg or the hen?
• Testing General Relativity with Black Holes
• A Cepheid distance to NGC 4258
• Violence in the Hearts of Galaxies - Aberration or Adolescence?
• Searching for Isolated Black Hole Candidates within 15 pc of the Solar System in Gaia DR3