Distinguishing black holes and naked singularities with iron line spectroscopy

Abstract

It is commonly thought that the final product of gravitational collapse is a black hole. Nevertheless, theoretical studies have not yet provided a final answer to the question whether black holes are the only possible outcome or whether naked singularities are also allowed. Observational tests may thus represent a complementary approach. In the present paper, we consider the Janis-Newman-Winicour metric, which describes a rotating source with a surface-like naked singularity. We calculate iron line shapes in the reflection spectrum of a putative disk around a Janis-Newman-Winicour singularity and we compare our results with the iron line shapes expected in the spectrum of a Kerr black hole. While it is difficult to distinguish the two spacetimes from the iron line shape in general, it seems that Janis-Newman-Winicour singularities cannot mimic fast-rotating Kerr black holes observed at a low or moderate inclination angle. Our analysis thus suggests that available observations of specific sources can already constrain the possible existence of Janis-Newman-Winicour singularities in the Universe.

arXiv comment1+15 pages, 4 figures. v2: refereed version

References in corpus (48)

• The Dynamics of General Relativity
• Tests of general relativity with GW150914
• The Nuclear Equation of State and Neutron Star Masses
• Is the gravitational-wave ringdown a probe of the event horizon?
• Advection-Dominated Accretion and the Black Hole Event Horizon
• Measuring Black Hole Spin using X-ray Reflection Spectroscopy
• The Neutron Star and Black Hole Initial Mass Function
• Apparent shape of super-spinning black holes
• Broad emission lines for negatively spinning black holes
• Testing black hole candidates with electromagnetic radiation
• Recent developments in gravitational collapse and spacetime singularities
• Thin accretion disks in stationary axisymmetric wormhole spacetimes
• Constraining the spin and the deformation parameters from the black hole shadow
• Dynamical Constraints On Alternatives To Massive Black Holes In Galactic Nuclei
• Black Hole Based Tests of General Relativity
• Constraining the quadrupole moment of stellar-mass black-hole candidates with the continuum fitting method
• Optical phenomena in brany Kerr spacetimes
• Janis-Newman-Winicour and Wyman solutions are the same
• Distinguishing black holes from naked singularities through their accretion disk properties
• Appearance of Keplerian discs orbiting Kerr superspinars
• A code to compute the emission of thin accretion disks in non-Kerr space-times and test the nature of black hole candidates
• Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
• Circular geodesics and accretion disks in Janis-Newman-Winicour and Gamma metric
• Can accretion disk properties observationally distinguish black holes from naked singularities?
• On the determination of the spin of the black hole in Cyg X-1 from X-ray reflection spectra
• Testing the space-time geometry around black hole candidates with the analysis of the broad K$\alpha$ iron line
• Testing the No-Hair Theorem with Observations in the Electromagnetic Spectrum. III. Quasi-Periodic Variability
• Testing the No-Hair Theorem with Observations in the Electromagnetic Spectrum. IV. Relativistically Broadened Iron Lines
• Testing Hořava-Lifshitz gravity using thin accretion disk properties
• Astrophysical Violations of the Kerr Bound as a Possible Signature of String Theory
• Profiles of emission lines generated by rings orbiting braneworld Kerr black holes
• Probing the space-time geometry around black hole candidates with the resonance models for high-frequency QPOs and comparison with the continuum-fitting method
• Astrophysical Black Holes: A Compact Pedagogical Review
• Gravitational Lensing by Rotating Naked Singularities
• Thin accretion disk signatures in dynamical Chern-Simons modified gravity
• Testing the no-hair theorem with the continuum-fitting and the iron line methods: a short review
• Testing the No-Hair Theorem with Observations of Black Holes in the Electromagnetic Spectrum
• Search for astrophysical rotating Ellis wormholes with X-ray reflection spectroscopy
• Iron K$\alpha$ line of Kerr black holes with scalar hair
• Testing general relativity with the reflection spectrum of the supermassive black hole in 1H0707$-$495
• K$\alpha$ iron line profile from accretion disks around regular and singular exotic compact objects
• Distinguishing black holes and wormholes with orbiting hot spots
• Exploring The Effects Of Disk Thickness On The Black Hole Reflection Spectrum
• Test-particle dynamics in general spherically symmetric black hole spacetimes
• Testing the Kerr Nature of Black Hole Candidates using Iron Line Spectra in the CPR Framework
• Iron K$\alpha$ line of boson stars
• Testing the Kerr nature of the supermassive black hole in Ark 564
• 3D simulations of the accretion process in Kerr space-time with arbitrary value of the spin parameter

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Horizon-scale tests of gravity theories and fundamental physics from the Event Horizon Telescope image of Sagittarius A${}^{\ast }$
• Charged particle motion and electromagnetic field in $\gamma$ spacetime
• Distinguishing a Kerr-like black hole and a naked singularity in perfect fluid dark matter via precession frequencies
• Distinguishing rotating naked singularities from Kerr-like wormholes by their deflection angles of massive particles
• Spacetime Singularities and Cosmic Censorship Conjecture: A Review with Some Thoughts
• Charged particle motion around a quasi-Kerr compact object immersed in an external magnetic field
• Generation of rotating solutions in Einstein-scalar gravity
• Echoes from a singularity
• Distinguishing Brans-Dicke-Kerr type naked singularities and black holes with their thin disk electromagnetic radiation properties
• Testing No-Hair Theorem by Quasi-Periodic Oscillations: the quadrupole of GRO J1655$-$40
• Shadows around the q-metric
• Singularities in static spherically symmetric configurations of General Relativity with strongly nonlinear scalar fields
• Testing Gravity with Black Hole X-Ray Data
• Synchrotron emitting Komissarov torus around naked singularities
• Reflecting on naked singularities: iron line fitting as a probe of the cosmic censorship conjecture
• On Some Applications of the Sagnac Effect
• Accretion Geometry of Black Hole X-ray Binaries: Insights from X-ray Observations
• Some applications of the Shapiro time delay
• Photon surfaces, shadows and accretion disks in gravity with minimally coupled scalar field