Bright OB stars in the Galaxy - III. Constraints on the radial stratification of the clumping factor in hot star winds from a combined Halpha, IR and radio analysis

Abstract

Recent results strongly challenge the canonical picture of massive star winds: various evidence indicates that currently accepted mass-loss rates, Mdot, may need to be revised downwards significantly. This is because the most commonly used mass-loss diagnostics are affected by ``clumping'' (small-scale density inhomogeneities), influencing our interpretation of observed spectra and fluxes. Such downward revisions would have dramatic consequences for the evolution of, and feedback from, massive stars, and thus robust determinations of the clumping properties and mass-loss rates are urgently needed. Here, we present a first attempt to constrain the radial stratification of the so-called clumping factor. To this end, we have analyzed a sample of 19 Galactic O-type supergiants/giants, by combining data for Halpha, IR, mm and radio fluxes, and using appropriate analysis methods. Clumping has been included into our analysis in the ``conventional'' way, by assuming the inter-clump matter to be void. Because (almost) all our diagnostics depends on the square of density, we cannot derive absolute clumping factors, but only factors normalized to a certain minimum. This minimum was usually found to be located in the outermost, radio-emitting region, i.e., the radio mass-loss rates are the lowest ones, compared to Mdot derived from Halpha and the IR. The radio rates agree well with those predicted by theory, but are only upper limits, due to unknown clumping in the outer wind. Our most important result concerns a (physical) difference between denser and thinner winds: for denser winds, the innermost region is more strongly clumped than the outermost one (with a normalized clumping factor of 4.1+/-1.4), whereas thinner winds have similar clumping properties in the inner and outer regions.

40 pages, 17 figures, accepted by A&A

References in corpus (26)

• A new calibration of stellar parameters of Galactic O stars
• SCUBA: A common-user submillimetre camera operating on the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope
• Atmospheric NLTE-Models for the Spectroscopic Analysis of Blue Stars with Winds. II. Line-Blanketed Models
• Generic Spectrum and Ionization Efficiency of a Heavy Initial Mass Function for the First Stars
• The Discordance of Mass-Loss Estimates for Galactic O-Type Stars
• Quantitative Spectroscopy of O Stars at Low Metallicity. O Dwarfs in NGC 346
• Line-driven winds, ionizing fluxes and UV-spectra of hot stars at extremely low metallicity. I. Very massive O-stars
• Hydrodynamical Simulations of Corotating Interaction Regions and Discrete Absorption Components in Rotating O-Star Winds
• Low mass loss rates in O-type stars: Spectral signatures of dense clumps in the wind of two Galactic O4 stars
• A Porosity-Length Formalism for Photon-Tiring-Limited Mass Loss from Stars Above the Eddington Limit
• A Galactic O-Star Catalog
• The Mauna Kea Observatories Near-Infrared Filter Set. III. Isophotal Wavelengths and Absolute Calibration
• A Study of Cyg OB2: Pointing the Way Towards Finding Our Galaxy's Super Star Clusters
• Structure in the Dusty Debris around Vega
• Hydrodynamic model atmospheres for WR stars: Self-consistent modeling of a WC star wind
• 2D Simulations of the Line-Driven Instability in Hot-Star Winds: II. Approximations for the 2D Radiation Force
• Quantitative H and K band spectroscopy of Galactic OB-stars at medium resolution
• Large-scale wind structures in OB supergiants: a search for rotationally modulated Hαvariability
• Bright OB stars in the Galaxy.II. Wind variability in O supergiants as traced by H-alpha
• X-ray emission lines from inhomogeneous stellar winds
• A Spectroscopic study of the non-thermal radio emitter Cyg OB2 #8A: Discovery of a new binary system
• Modeling the near-infrared lines of O-type stars
• A pseudo-planar, periodic-box formalism for modelling the outer evolution of structure in spherically expanding stellar winds
• Early chemical enrichment of the universe and the role of very massive pop III stars
• Radio and submillimetre observations of wind structure in zeta Pup
• A Study of the Near-Ultraviolet Spectrum of Vega

Cited by in corpus (179)

• Mass Loss: Its Effect on the Evolution and Fate of High-Mass Stars
• Black Hole Formation in Failing Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Mass loss from hot massive stars
• Observed Fractions of Core-Collapse Supernova Types and Initial Masses of their Single and Binary Progenitor Stars
• The empirical metallicity dependence of the mass-loss rate of O- and early B-type stars
• Sub-surface convection zones in hot massive stars and their observable consequences
• Cygnus X-1 contains a 21-solar mass black hole -- implications for massive star winds
• The most massive stars in the Arches cluster
• Spitzer SAGE Infrared Photometry of Massive Stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The Wolf-Rayet stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud: A comprehensive analysis of the WN class
• Neglecting the porosity of hot-star winds can lead to underestimating mass-loss rates
• Bright OB stars in the Galaxy IV. Stellar and wind parameters of early to late B supergiants
• Properties of Galactic early-type O-supergiants: A combined FUV-UV and optical analysis
• The VLT-FLAMES survey of massive stars: Wind properties and evolution of hot massive stars in the LMC
• The evolution of massive stars and their spectra I. A non-rotating 60 Msun star from the zero-age main sequence to the pre-supernova stage
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey XVII. Physical and wind properties of massive stars at the top of the main sequence
• Towards a unified view of inhomogeneous stellar winds in isolated supergiant stars and supergiant high mass X-ray binaries
• Magnetic spots on hot massive stars
• The Effect of Porosity on X-ray Emission Line Profiles from Hot-Star Winds
• L-band spectroscopy of Galactic OB-stars
• Statistical properties of a sample of periodically variable B-type supergiants - Evidence for opacity-driven gravity-mode oscillations
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds II. Constraints from a combined optical/UV study
• Metallicity in the Galactic Center: The Quintuplet cluster
• On the nature of the prototype LBV AG Carinae I. Fundamental parameters during visual minimum phases and changes in the bolometric luminosity during the S-Dor cycle
• High resolution X-ray spectroscopy of bright O type stars
• The R136 star cluster dissected with Hubble Space Telescope/STIS. III. The most massive stars and their clumped winds
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds I. Resonance line formation in 2D models
• Theory and Diagnostics of Hot Star Mass Loss
• 3D modelling of the colliding winds in Eta Carinae - evidence for radiative inhibition
• Analysis of Galactic late-type O dwarfs: more constraints on the weak wind problem
• Why binary interaction does not necessarily dominate the formation of Wolf-Rayet stars at low metallicity
• One Dimensional Dynamical Models of the Carina Nebula Bubble
• Nitrogen line spectroscopy in O-stars -- II. Surface nitrogen abundances for O-stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Clumping in the inner winds of hot, massive stars from hydrodynamical line-driven instability simulations
• On the role of the WNH phase in the evolution of very massive stars: Enabling the LBV instability with feedback
• Massive stars at low metallicity: Evolution and surface abundances of O dwarfs in the SMC
• Variability in the CoRoT photometry of three hot O-type stars. HD 46223, HD 46150 and HD 46966
• Clumped stellar winds in supergiant high-mass X-ray binaries: X-ray variability and photoionization
• Macroclumping as solution of the discrepancy between Hα and P v mass loss diagnostics for O-type stars
• The IACOB project. V. Spectroscopic parameters of the O-type stars in the modern grid of standards for spectral classification
• Repeating fast radio burst 20201124A originates from a magnetar/Be star binary
• On the photometric detection of Internal Gravity Waves in upper main-sequence stars I. Methodology and application to CoRoT targets
• A quantitative study of O stars in NGC2244 and the Mon OB2 association
• Spectroscopic and physical parameters of Galactic O-type stars. III. Mass discrepancy and rotational mixing
• Measuring mass-loss rates and constraining shock physics using X-ray line profiles of O stars from the Chandra archive
• Spectroscopic determination of the fundamental parameters of 66 B-type stars in the field-of-view of the CoRoT satellite
• Modeling Ultraviolet Wind Line Variability in Massive Hot Stars
• Measurements and analysis of helium-like triplet ratios in the X-ray spectra of O-type stars
• Atmospheric NLTE-models for the spectroscopic analysis of blue stars with winds. IV. Porosity in physical and velocity space
• Properties of WNh stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud: evidence for homogeneous evolution
• Mass-loss and diffusion in subdwarf B stars and hot white dwarfs: do weak winds exist?
• New predictions for radiation-driven, steady-state mass-loss and wind-momentum from hot, massive stars. I. Method and first results
• Two bi-stability jumps in theoretical wind models for massive stars and the implications for Luminous Blue Variable supernovae
• A compact pulsar wind nebula model of the gamma-ray loud binary LS I +61 303
• Nitrogen line spectroscopy of O-stars -- I. Nitrogen III emission line formation revisited
• Signature of wide-spread clumping in B supergiant winds
• A new radio census of neutron star X-ray binaries
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds III. An effective-opacity formalism for line radiative transfer in accelerating, clumped two-component media, and first results on theory and diagnostics
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey XXVI: Properties of the O-dwarf population in 30 Doradus
• High-energy emission from jet-clump interactions in microquasars
• No breakdown of the radiatively-driven wind theory in low-metallicity environments
• A Clumping Independent Diagnostic of Stellar Mass-loss Rates: Rapid Clump Destruction in Adiabatic Colliding Winds
• A mass-loss rate determination for zeta Puppis from the quantitative analysis of X-ray emission line profiles
• On the interaction of microquasar jets with stellar winds
• Radiation-driven winds of hot luminous stars. XVI. Expanding atmospheres of massive and very massive stars and the evolution of dense stellar clusters
• MOST detects corotating bright spots on the mid-O type giant ξ Persei
• Long term variability of Cygnus X-1: VII. Orbital variability of the focussed wind in Cyg X-1 / HDE 226868 system
• Stratified disc wind models for the AGN broad-line region: ultraviolet, optical and X-ray properties
• Modeling the early evolution of massive OB stars with an experimental wind routine
• Empirical mass-loss rates and clumping properties of Galactic early-type O supergiants
• NLTE models of line-driven stellar winds III. Influence of X-ray radiation on wind structure of O stars
• Chandra X-ray spectroscopy of the very early O supergiant HD 93129A: constraints on wind shocks and the mass-loss rate
• Compact Binary Coalescences: Astrophysical Processes and Lessons Learned
• Gamma-ray variability from wind clumping in HMXBs with jets
• Spectroscopic evolution of massive stars on the main sequence
• On the presence and absence of disks around O-type stars
• Non-thermal emission from secondary pairs in close TeV binary systems
• A generalised porosity formalism for isotropic and anisotropic effective opacity and its effects on X-ray line attenuation in clumped O star winds
• The Quintuplet Cluster II. Analysis of the WN stars
• Theoretical wind clumping predictions of OB supergiants from line-driven instability simulations across the bi-stability jump
• Non-thermal radio emission from O-type stars. IV. Cyg OB2 No. 8A
• Constraints on porosity and mass loss in O-star winds from modeling of X-ray emission line profile shapes
• On the nature of the prototype LBV AG Carinae II. Witnessing a massive star evolving close to the Eddington and bistability limits
• Testing the predicted mass-loss bi-stability jump at radio wavelengths
• Impact of clumping on core-collapse supernova radiation
• Mass fluxes for O stars
• Atmospheric NLTE models for the spectroscopic analysis of blue stars with winds. V. Complete comoving frame transfer, and updated modeling of X-ray emission
• Global hot-star wind models for stars from Magellanic Clouds
• Chandra X-ray spectroscopy of the focused wind in the Cygnus X-1 system III. Dipping in the low/hard state
• New mass-loss rates of B supergiants from global wind models
• Rotation Measure Variations and Reversals of Repeating Fast Radio Bursts in Massive Binary Systems
• On the H$\alpha$ Behaviour of Blue Supergiants: Rise and Fall over the Bi-stability Jump
• X-ray, UV and optical analysis of supergiants: $\epsilon$ Ori
• Observational properties of massive black hole binary progenitors
• First detections of 610 MHz radio emission from hot magnetic stars
• Upper Mass-Loss Limits and Clumping in the Intermediate and Outer Wind Regions of OB stars
• Correlation between the gas-phase metallicity and ionization parameter in extragalactic HII regions
• An ALMA 3mm continuum census of Westerlund 1
• The Tarantula Massive Binary Monitoring V. R 144: a wind-eclipsing binary with a total mass > 140 Msun
• The influence of rotation on optical emission profiles of O stars
• Clumping and X-Rays in cooler B supergiant stars
• Mass-loss rates of Very Massive Stars
• Wind inhibition by X-ray irradiation in HMXBs: the influence of clumping and the final X-ray luminosity
• Suzaku monitoring of the Wolf-Rayet binary WR140 around periastron passage: An approach for quantifying the wind parameters
• The 2.35 year itch of Cyg OB2 #9. II. Radio monitoring
• Central stars of planetary nebulae in the Galactic bulge
• New hydrodynamic solutions for line-driven winds of hot massive stars using Lambert $W$-function
• Demonstration of a novel method for measuring mass-loss rates for massive stars
• Shock-heated radiation-driven outflows as a solution to the weak-wind problem of late O-type stars
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive Stars at low metallicity IX: Empirical constraints on mass-loss rates and clumping parameters for OB supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Self-consistent solutions for line-driven winds of hot massive stars. The m-CAK procedure
• UV diagnostic of porosity-free mass-loss estimates in B stars
• On the possibility of disk-fed formation in supergiant high-mass X-ray binaries
• e-MERLIN 21cm constraints on the mass-loss rates of OB stars in Cyg OB2
• The Effects of Magnetic Fields on the Dynamics of Radiation Pressure Dominated Massive Star Envelopes
• X-ray diagnostics of massive star winds
• Effect of scattering on the transonic solution topology and intrinsic variability of line-driven stellar winds
• Clumpy stellar winds and high-energy emission in high-mass binaries hosting a young pulsar
• Stellar wind models of central stars of planetary nebulae
• The distance, rotation, and physical parameters of zeta Pup
• The IACOB project XI. No increase of mass-loss rates over the bistability region
• Optical spectroscopy of the blue supergiant Sk-69 279 and its circumstellar shell with SALT
• The Importance of XUV Radiation as a Solution to the P V Mass Loss Rate Discrepancy in O-Stars
• ALMA observations of the supergiant B[e] star Wd1-9
• Influence of XUV radiation on Pv ionization fraction in hot star winds
• X-ray emission from hydrodynamical simulations in non-LTE wind models
• Empirical mass-loss rates and clumping properties of O-type stars in the LMC
• Radio observations of candidate magnetic O stars
• The Infrared Massive Stellar Content of M83
• Multiple short-lived stellar prominences on O stars: The O6.5I(n)fp star lambda Cephei
• Spectroscopy of SMC Wolf-Rayet Stars Suggests that Wind-Clumping does not Depend on Ambient Metallicity
• Radiation-driven winds of hot luminous stars XVII. Parameters of selected central stars of PN from consistent optical and UV spectral analysis and the universality of the mass-luminosity relation
• A Transparent Window into Early-Type Stellar Variability
• Using Shell Models to Investigate Clumping in the WN4 Star HD 50896
• Theoretical wind clumping predictions from 2D LDI models of O-star winds at different metallicities
• Chandra grating spectroscopy of embedded wind shock X-ray emission from O stars shows low plasma temperatures and significant wind absorption
• Mid-infrared observations of O-type stars: spectral morphology
• A Deep Exposure in High Resolution X-Rays Reveals the Hottest Plasma in the $\zeta$Puppis Wind
• Expectations for Fast Radio Bursts in Neutron Star-Massive Star binaries
• Angular Sizes and Effective Temperatures of O-type Stars from Optical Interferometry with the CHARA Array
• Neon Abundances from a Spitzer/IRS Survey of Wolf-Rayet Stars
• New self-consistent wind parameters fitting optical spectra of O-type stars observed with HERMES spectrograph
• A Radio Census of the Massive Stellar Cluster Westerlund 1
• Mass loss rates from mid-IR excesses in LMC and SMC O stars
• The population synthesis of Wolf-Rayet stars involving binary merger channels
• Hot star wind models with new solar abundances
• Using Shell Models to Investigate Clumping in the Wind of the O7Iaf+ Supergiant AzV83
• Coordinated UV and X-ray spectroscopic observations of the O-type giant xi Per: the connection between X-rays and large-scale wind structure
• Simulations of the line-driven instability in magnetic hot star winds
• Long-Wavelength, Free-Free Spectral Energy Distributions from Porous Stellar Winds
• Towards early-type eclipsing binaries as extragalactic milestones: II. NLTE spectral analysis and stellar parameters of the detached O-type system OGLE-LMC-ECL-06782 in the LMC
• To clump or not to clump The impact of wind inhomogeneities on the optical and NIR spectroscopic analysis of massive OB stars
• Clumpy wind accretion in Cygnus X-1
• The nature of the light variability of magnetic Of?p star HD 191612
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: massive stars at low metallicity: XII. The clumped winds of O-type (super)giants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• X-ray irradiation of the stellar wind in HMXBs with B supergiants: Implications for ULXs
• Theoretical X-ray light curves of young SNe II: the example of SN 2013ej
• Moving inhomogeneous envelopes of stars
• Far-infrared emission of massive stars
• How long can LBVs sleep? A long-term photometric vaiability and spectral study of the Galactic candidate luminous blue variable MN112
• Variable structures in the stellar wind of the HMXB Vela X-1
• Weak wind effects in CNO driven winds of hot first stars
• Ultraviolet Spectropolarimetry with Polstar: Clumping and Mass-loss Rate Corrections
• Period change of massive binaries from combined photometric and spectroscopic data in Cygnus OB2
• On the importance of the wind emission to the optical continuum of OB supergiants
• Radio Variability from Co-Rotating Interaction Regions Threading Wolf-Rayet Winds
• Investigation of CygOB2 #11 (O5 Ifc) by modeling its atmosphere
• Observed epochal variations in X-ray lines from the O Supergiant $\zeta$ Puppis do not require substantial changes in the wind mass flux
• COBRaS: The e-MERLIN 21 cm Legacy survey of Cygnus OB2
• Structure formation in O-type stars and Wolf-Rayet stars
• Wray 15-906: a candidate luminous blue variable discovered with WISE, Herschel and SALT
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity XV. On the metallicity dependence of B-supergiant mass-loss rates
• Low-frequency spectra of neutron star + OB supergiant binaries: Does wind density drive persistent and flaring modes of accretion?
• Radio Spectral Energy Distributions for Single Massive Star Winds with Free-Free and Synchrotron Emission
• ALMA measurements of mass loss and wind clumping in the massive stars of the Arches cluster
• Accretion in massive colliding wind binaries and the effect of wind momentum ratio
• Stellar feedback and triggered star formation in the prototypical bubble RCW 120
• Fe XVII $2p$-$3s$ line ratio diagnostic of shock formation radius in O stars
• Wind structure of late B supergiants I. Multi-line analyses of near-surface and wind structure in HD 199 478 (B8 Iae)