Neglecting the porosity of hot-star winds can lead to underestimating mass-loss rates

Abstract

Context: The mass-loss rate is a key parameter of massive stars. Adequate stellar atmosphere models are required for spectral analyses and mass-loss determinations. Present models can only account for the inhomogeneity of stellar winds in the approximation of small-scale structures that are optically thin. This treatment of ``microclumping'' has led to reducing empirical mass-loss rates by factors of two and more. Aims: Stellar wind clumps can be optically thick in spectral lines. We investigate how this ``macroclumping'' impacts on empirical mass-loss rates. Methods: The Potsdam Wolf-Rayet (PoWR) model atmosphere code is generalized in the ``formal integral'' to account for clumps that are not necessarily optically thin. Results: Optically thick clumps reduce the effective opacity. This has a pronounced effect on the emergent spectrum. Our modeling for the O-type supergiant zeta Puppis reveals that the optically thin H-alpha line is not affected by wind porosity, but that the PV resonance doublet becomes significantly weaker when macroclumping is taken into account. The reported discrepancies between resonance-line and recombination-line diagnostics can be resolved entirely with the macroclumping modeling without downward revision of the mass-loss rate. Conclusions: Mass-loss rates inferred from optically thin emission, such as the H-alpha line in O stars, are not influenced by macroclumping. The strength of optically thick lines, however, is reduced because of the porosity effects. Therefore, neglecting the porosity in stellar wind modeling can lead to underestimating empirical mass-loss rates.

arXiv commentA&A (in press), see full abstract in the text

References in corpus (15)

• The Discordance of Mass-Loss Estimates for Galactic O-Type Stars
• Bright OB stars in the Galaxy - III. Constraints on the radial stratification of the clumping factor in hot star winds from a combined Halpha, IR and radio analysis
• Low mass loss rates in O-type stars: Spectral signatures of dense clumps in the wind of two Galactic O4 stars
• A Porosity-Length Formalism for Photon-Tiring-Limited Mass Loss from Stars Above the Eddington Limit
• Stellar and Wind Properties of LMC WC4 stars - A metallicity dependence for Wolf-Rayet mass-loss rates
• The Effect of Porosity on X-ray Emission Line Profiles from Hot-Star Winds
• The porous atmosphere of eta Carinae
• High resolution X-ray spectroscopy of bright O type stars
• X-ray line emission from a fragmented stellar wind
• Constraints on the Ionization Balance of Hot-Star Winds from FUSE Observations of O Stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• 2D Simulations of the Line-Driven Instability in Hot-Star Winds: II. Approximations for the 2D Radiation Force
• Bright OB stars in the Galaxy.II. Wind variability in O supergiants as traced by H-alpha
• X-ray emission lines from inhomogeneous stellar winds
• Mass fluxes for O stars
• Optically Thick Clumps - Not the Solution to the Wolf-Rayet Wind Momentum Problem?

Cited by in corpus (153)

• Mass loss from hot massive stars
• X-Ray Spectroscopy of Stars
• A coordinated X-ray and Optical Campaign of the Nearest Massive Eclipsing Binary, $\delta$ Orionis Aa: IV. A multiwavelength, non-LTE spectroscopic analysis
• Properties of Galactic early-type O-supergiants: A combined FUV-UV and optical analysis
• The evolution of massive stars and their spectra I. A non-rotating 60 Msun star from the zero-age main sequence to the pre-supernova stage
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey XVII. Physical and wind properties of massive stars at the top of the main sequence
• On the consistent treatment of the quasi-hydrostatic layers in hot star atmospheres
• Towards a unified view of inhomogeneous stellar winds in isolated supergiant stars and supergiant high mass X-ray binaries
• L-band spectroscopy of Galactic OB-stars
• New predictions for radiation-driven, steady-state mass-loss and wind-momentum from hot, massive stars II. A grid of O-type stars in the Galaxy and the Magellanic Clouds
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds II. Constraints from a combined optical/UV study
• NuSTAR discovery of a luminosity dependent cyclotron line energy in Vela X-1
• The R136 star cluster dissected with Hubble Space Telescope/STIS. III. The most massive stars and their clumped winds
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds I. Resonance line formation in 2D models
• Early magnetic B-type stars: X-ray emission and wind properties
• Theory and Diagnostics of Hot Star Mass Loss
• Why binary interaction does not necessarily dominate the formation of Wolf-Rayet stars at low metallicity
• Wolf-Rayet stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud: II. Analysis of the binaries
• Coupling hydrodynamics with comoving frame radiative transfer: I. A unified approach for OB and WR stars
• Chandra X-ray spectroscopy of the focused wind in the Cygnus X-1 system. I. The non-dip spectrum in the low/hard state
• Clumped stellar winds in supergiant high-mass X-ray binaries: X-ray variability and photoionization
• Macroclumping as solution of the discrepancy between Hα and P v mass loss diagnostics for O-type stars
• Metallicity-dependent wind parameter predictions for OB stars
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey XXIV. Stellar properties of the O-type giants and supergiants in 30 Doradus
• The transition mass-loss rate: Calibrating the role of line-driven winds in massive star evolution
• Carina OB Stars: X-ray Signatures of Wind Shocks and Magnetic Fields
• X-ray variation statistics and wind clumping in Vela X-1
• A quantitative study of O stars in NGC2244 and the Mon OB2 association
• Measuring mass-loss rates and constraining shock physics using X-ray line profiles of O stars from the Chandra archive
• The structure of blue supergiant winds and the accretion in supergiant High Mass X-ray Binaries
• 3-D radiative transfer in clumped hot star winds I. Influence of clumping on the resonance line formation
• Atmospheric NLTE-models for the spectroscopic analysis of blue stars with winds. IV. Porosity in physical and velocity space
• Mass-loss and diffusion in subdwarf B stars and hot white dwarfs: do weak winds exist?
• Properties of WNh stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud: evidence for homogeneous evolution
• Two bi-stability jumps in theoretical wind models for massive stars and the implications for Luminous Blue Variable supernovae
• Stellar population of the superbubble N206 in the LMC II. Parameters of the OB and WR stars, and the total massive star feedback
• Signature of wide-spread clumping in B supergiant winds
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds III. An effective-opacity formalism for line radiative transfer in accelerating, clumped two-component media, and first results on theory and diagnostics
• Measuring the stellar wind parameters in IGR J17544-2619 and Vela X-1 constrains the accretion physics in Supergiant Fast X-ray Transient and classical Supergiant X-ray Binaries
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: massive stars at low metallicity. I. Project Description
• The Formation of a 70 Msun Black Hole at High Metallicity
• Coupling hydrodynamics with comoving frame radiative transfer: II. Stellar wind stratification in the high-mass X-ray binary Vela X-1
• Accretion form a clumpy massive-star wind in Supergiant X-ray binaries
• A detailed X-ray investigation of zeta Puppis - The variability on short and long timescales
• No breakdown of the radiatively-driven wind theory in low-metallicity environments
• Modeling the early evolution of massive OB stars with an experimental wind routine
• The 100-month Swift catalogue of supergiant fast X-ray transients I. BAT on-board and transient monitor flares
• Multiple flaring activity in the supergiant fast X-ray transient IGR J08408-4503 observed with Swift
• Empirical mass-loss rates and clumping properties of Galactic early-type O supergiants
• XMM-Newton observations of IGRJ18410-0535: The ingestion of a clump by a supergiant fast X-ray transient
• Probing the evolving massive star population in Orion with kinematic and radioactive tracers
• Study of the many fluorescent lines and the absorption variability in GX 301-2 with XMM-Newton
• NLTE models of line-driven stellar winds III. Influence of X-ray radiation on wind structure of O stars
• Simultaneous X-ray and optical spectroscopy of the Oef supergiant lambda Cep
• Discovery of a short orbital period in the Supergiant Fast X-ray Transient IGR J16479-4514
• On the optically-thick winds of Wolf-Rayet stars
• Fast & slow winds from supergiants and Luminous Blue Variables
• Stellar mass-loss near the Eddington limit. Tracing the sub-photospheric layers of classical Wolf-Rayet stars
• Two extremely luminous WN stars in the Galactic center with circumstellar emission from dust and gas
• Subsonic structure and optically thick winds from Wolf--Rayet stars
• A generalised porosity formalism for isotropic and anisotropic effective opacity and its effects on X-ray line attenuation in clumped O star winds
• A detailed X-ray investigation of ζ Puppis III. A spectral analysis of the whole RGS spectrum
• The stellar and wind parameters of six prototypical HMXBs and their evolutionary status
• The supergiant fast X-ray transients XTE J1739-302 and IGR J08408-4503 in quiescence with XMM-Newton
• Constraints on porosity and mass loss in O-star winds from modeling of X-ray emission line profile shapes
• Stellar wind properties of the nearly complete sample of O stars in the low metallicity young star cluster NGC346 in the SMC galaxy
• Instabilities in the Envelopes and Winds of Very Massive Stars
• Atmospheric NLTE models for the spectroscopic analysis of blue stars with winds. V. Complete comoving frame transfer, and updated modeling of X-ray emission
• Discovery of an eccentric 30 days period in the supergiant X-ray binary SAX J1818.6-1703 with INTEGRAL
• Global hot-star wind models for stars from Magellanic Clouds
• One of the most massive stars in the Galaxy may have formed in isolation
• Physics and evolution of the most massive stars in 30 Dor. Mass loss, envelope inflation, and a variable upper stellar mass limit
• Stochastic light variations in hot stars from wind instability: Finding photometric signatures and testing against the TESS data
• Breaking news from the HST: The central star of the Stingray Nebula is now returning towards the AGB
• New mass-loss rates of B supergiants from global wind models
• Supergiant, fast, but not so transient 4U 1907+09
• The Shortest-period Wolf-Rayet binary in the Small Magellanic Cloud: Part of a high-order multiple system
• Optical/infrared observations unveiling the formation, nature and evolution of High-Mass X-ray Binaries
• On the H$\alpha$ Behaviour of Blue Supergiants: Rise and Fall over the Bi-stability Jump
• X-ray, UV and optical analysis of supergiants: $\epsilon$ Ori
• The X-ray catalog of spectroscopically identified Galactic O stars: Investigating the dependence of X-ray luminosity on stellar and wind parameters
• Observational properties of massive black hole binary progenitors
• Upper Mass-Loss Limits and Clumping in the Intermediate and Outer Wind Regions of OB stars
• Light variations due to the line-driven wind instability and wind blanketing in O stars
• The Wolf-Rayet stars in M31: I. Analysis of the late-type WN stars
• Characterizing the turbulent porosity of stellar-wind structure generated by the line-deshadowing instability
• A Comprehensive Spectral Analysis of the X-Ray Pulsar 4U 1907+09 from Two Observations with the Suzaku X-Ray Observatory
• The Tarantula Massive Binary Monitoring V. R 144: a wind-eclipsing binary with a total mass > 140 Msun
• X-ray Observations of Bow Shocks around Runaway O Stars. The case of $\zeta$ Oph and BD+43${}^{\circ }$3654
• The XMM-Newton EPIC X-ray Light Curve Analysis of WR 6
• 2dF-AAOmega spectroscopy of massive stars in the Magellanic Clouds: The north-eastern region of the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Mass-loss rates of Very Massive Stars
• Reacceleration of electrons in supernova remnants
• Wind inhibition by X-ray irradiation in HMXBs: the influence of clumping and the final X-ray luminosity
• Clumping and X-Rays in cooler B supergiant stars
• Footprints in the wind of Vela X-1 traced with MAXI
• Probing Wolf-Rayet Winds: Chandra/HETG X-Ray Spectra of WR 6
• First detection of a magnetic field in the fast rotating runaway Oe star zeta Ophiuchi
• Continuum, cyclotron line, and absorption variability in the high-mass X-ray binary Vela X-1
• Probing the weak wind phenomenon in Galactic O-type giants
• INTEGRAL long-term monitoring of the Supergiant Fast X-ray Transient XTE J1739-302
• Discovery of X-ray emission from young suns in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• UV diagnostic of porosity-free mass-loss estimates in B stars
• UV spectral analysis of very hot H-deficient [WCE]-type central stars of planetary nebulae: NGC 2867, NGC 5189, NGC 6905, Pb 6, and Sand 3
• Shock-heated radiation-driven outflows as a solution to the weak-wind problem of late O-type stars
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive Stars at low metallicity IX: Empirical constraints on mass-loss rates and clumping parameters for OB supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• A rare early-type star revealed in the Wing of the Small Magellanic Cloud
• X-ray diagnostics of massive star winds
• INTEGRAL and XMM-Newton observations of AX J1845.0-0433
• Mass loss and stellar superwinds
• The IACOB project XI. No increase of mass-loss rates over the bistability region
• The Wolf-Rayet binaries of the nitrogen sequence in the Large Magellanic Cloud: spectroscopy, orbital analysis, formation, and evolution
• Stellar wind models of central stars of planetary nebulae
• The Importance of XUV Radiation as a Solution to the P V Mass Loss Rate Discrepancy in O-Stars
• Observations of Supergiant Fast X-ray Transients with LOFT
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity. IV. Spectral analysis methods and exemplary results for O stars
• Empirical mass-loss rates and clumping properties of O-type stars in the LMC
• Influence of XUV radiation on Pv ionization fraction in hot star winds
• Sub-mm free-free emission from the winds of massive stars in the age of ALMA
• Staring at 4U 1909+07 with Suzaku
• Hard X-ray emission in the star-forming region ON2: discovery with XMM-Newton
• X-ray Emission Line Profiles from Wind Clump Bow Shocks in Massive Stars
• Mass and wind luminosity of young Galactic open clusters in Gaia DR2
• Using Shell Models to Investigate Clumping in the WN4 Star HD 50896
• Fe xxv line profiles in colliding wind binaries
• Fast flaring observed from XMMU J053108.3-690923 by eROSITA: a supergiant fast X-ray transient in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• A New Grid of Synthetic Spectra for the Analysis of [WC]-type Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae
• Using Shell Models to Investigate Clumping in the Wind of the O7Iaf+ Supergiant AzV83
• Polarization Variability Arising from Clumps in the Winds of Wolf-Rayet Stars
• Long-Wavelength, Free-Free Spectral Energy Distributions from Porous Stellar Winds
• Coordinated UV and X-ray spectroscopic observations of the O-type giant xi Per: the connection between X-rays and large-scale wind structure
• New ATCA, ALMA and VISIR observations of the candidate LBV SK-67266 (S61): the nebular mass from modelling 3D density distributions
• Strong nebular HeII emission induced by He${}^{+}$ ionizing photons escaping through the clumpy winds of massive stars
• To clump or not to clump The impact of wind inhomogeneities on the optical and NIR spectroscopic analysis of massive OB stars
• Analysis of the WN star WR 102c, its WR nebula, and the associated cluster of massive stars in the Sickle Nebula
• Creating and using large grids of precalculated model atmospheres for a rapid analysis of stellar spectra
• The First Candidate Colliding-Wind Binary in M33
• UV Spectropolarimetry with Polstar: Massive Star Binary Colliding Winds
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: massive stars at low metallicity: XII. The clumped winds of O-type (super)giants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The Effective Temperatures of O-type Stars from UV spectroscopy
• Moving inhomogeneous envelopes of stars
• Orbital parameters of supergiant fast X-ray transients
• The bright, dusty aftermath of giant eruptions & H-rich supernovae. Late interaction of supernova shocks & dusty circumstellar shells
• Optically-thick Structure in Early B Type Supergiant Stellar Winds at Low Metallicities
• Recombination Lines and Free-Free Continua formed in Asymptotic Ionized Winds: Analytic solution for the radiative transfer
• Ultraviolet Spectropolarimetry with Polstar: Clumping and Mass-loss Rate Corrections
• An Optical and Infrared Time-Domain Study of the Supergiant Fast X-ray Transient Candidate IC 10 X-2
• Structure formation in O-type stars and Wolf-Rayet stars
• Could AX J1841.0$-$0536 Be an Anti-Magnetar?
• Probing Thin Winds in Massive OB Stars of the SMC with JWST/NIRSPEC Br-alpha Spectroscopy
• Spherically symmetric model atmospheres using approximate lambda operators V. Static inhomogeneous atmospheres of hot dwarf stars
• Accretion in massive colliding wind binaries and the effect of wind momentum ratio
• ALMA measurements of mass loss and wind clumping in the massive stars of the Arches cluster