Low mass loss rates in O-type stars: Spectral signatures of dense clumps in the wind of two Galactic O4 stars

Abstract

We have analyzed the far-UV spectrum of two Galactic O4 stars, the O4If+ supergiant HD190429A and the O4V((f)) dwarf HD96715, using archival FUSE and IUE data. We have conducted a quantitative analysis based on the two NLTE model atmosphere and wind codes, TLUSTY and CMFGEN. We have derived the stellar and wind parameters and the surface composition of the two stars. The surface of HD190429A has a composition typical of an evolved O supergiant (N-rich, C and O-poor), while HD96715 exhibits surface N enhancement similar to the enrichment found in SMC O dwarfs and attributed to rotationally-induced mixing. We find that homogeneous wind models could not match the observed profile of O V1371 and require very low phosphorus abundance to fit the P V1118-1128 resonance lines. However, we are able to match the O V and P V lines using clumped wind models. We find that N IV1718 is also sensitive to wind clumping. For both stars, we have calculated clumped wind models that match well all these lines from different species and that remain consistent with Halpha data. These fits therefore provide a coherent and thus much stronger evidence of wind clumping in O stars than earlier claims. We find that the wind of these two stars is highly clumped, as expressed by very small volume filling factors, namely f=0.04 for HD190429A and f=0.02 for HD96715. In agreement with our analysis of SMC stars, clumping starts deep in the wind, just above the sonic point. The most crucial consequence of our analysis is that the mass loss rates of O stars need to be revised downward significantly, by a factor of 3 and more. Accounting for wind clumping is essential when determining the wind properties of O stars. Our study therefore calls for a fundamental revision in our understanding of mass loss and of O-type star winds. (abridged)

To appear in Astronomy & Astrophysics; 16 pages; accepted version after minor revision

References in corpus (5)

• A new calibration of stellar parameters of Galactic O stars
• Puzzling wind properties of young massive stars in SMC-N81
• Wind clumping and the wind-wind collision zone in the Wolf-Rayet binary gamma Velorum
• X-ray emission lines from inhomogeneous stellar winds
• Modeling the near-infrared lines of O-type stars

Cited by in corpus (174)

• Grids of stellar models with rotation - I. Models from 0.8 to 120 Msun at solar metallicity (Z = 0.014)
• Mass Loss: Its Effect on the Evolution and Fate of High-Mass Stars
• Black Hole Formation in Failing Core-Collapse Supernovae
• A Grid of NLTE Line-Blanketed Model Atmospheres of Early B-type Stars
• Mass loss from hot massive stars
• SN 2006gy: Discovery of the most luminous supernova ever recorded, powered by the death of an extremely massive star like Eta Carinae
• Observed Fractions of Core-Collapse Supernova Types and Initial Masses of their Single and Binary Progenitor Stars
• On the metallicity dependence of Wolf-Rayet winds
• On the role of continuum-driven eruptions in the evolution of very massive stars and Population III stars
• The Discordance of Mass-Loss Estimates for Galactic O-Type Stars
• Wave-Driven Mass Loss in the Last Year of Stellar Evolution: Setting the Stage for the Most Luminous Core-Collapse Supernovae
• The empirical metallicity dependence of the mass-loss rate of O- and early B-type stars
• A Library of Theoretical Ultraviolet Spectra of Massive, Hot Stars for Evolutionary Synthesis
• X-Ray Spectroscopy of Stars
• Bright OB stars in the Galaxy - III. Constraints on the radial stratification of the clumping factor in hot star winds from a combined Halpha, IR and radio analysis
• The Type IIb Supernova 2011dh from a Supergiant Progenitor
• Mass loss from late-type WN stars and its Z-dependence: very massive stars approaching the Eddington limit
• High-Mass X-ray Binaries in the Milky Way: A closer look with INTEGRAL
• The most massive stars in the Arches cluster
• Core-collapse explosions of Wolf-Rayet stars and the connection to type IIb/Ib/Ic supernovae
• Neglecting the porosity of hot-star winds can lead to underestimating mass-loss rates
• O stars with weak winds: the Galactic case
• Stellar and wind properties of massive stars in the central parsec of the Galaxy
• Spectral Evolution of the Extraordinary Type IIn Supernova 2006gy
• Bright OB stars in the Galaxy IV. Stellar and wind parameters of early to late B supergiants
• The evolution of rotating very massive stars with LMC composition
• Properties of Galactic early-type O-supergiants: A combined FUV-UV and optical analysis
• The VLT-FLAMES survey of massive stars: Wind properties and evolution of hot massive stars in the LMC
• POLLUX : a database of synthetic stellar spectra
• The evolution of massive stars and their spectra I. A non-rotating 60 Msun star from the zero-age main sequence to the pre-supernova stage
• Probing clumpy stellar winds with a neutron star
• Towards a unified view of inhomogeneous stellar winds in isolated supergiant stars and supergiant high mass X-ray binaries
• A Systematic Survey of the Effects of Wind Mass Loss Algorithms on the Evolution of Single Massive Stars
• Quantitative studies of the optical and UV spectra of Galactic early B supergiants I. Fundamental parameters
• The Effect of Porosity on X-ray Emission Line Profiles from Hot-Star Winds
• L-band spectroscopy of Galactic OB-stars
• A comparison of evolutionary tracks for single Galactic massive stars
• The Proto-neutron Star Phase of the Collapsar Model and the Route to Long-soft Gamma-ray Bursts and Hypernovae
• Abundance analysis of prime B-type targets for asteroseismology I. Nitrogen excess in slowly-rotating beta Cephei stars
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds II. Constraints from a combined optical/UV study
• On the nature of the prototype LBV AG Carinae I. Fundamental parameters during visual minimum phases and changes in the bolometric luminosity during the S-Dor cycle
• High resolution X-ray spectroscopy of bright O type stars
• 3D Models of Radiatively Driven Colliding Winds In Massive O+O Star Binaries: I. Hydrodynamics
• The R136 star cluster dissected with Hubble Space Telescope/STIS. III. The most massive stars and their clumped winds
• Mass loss from inhomogeneous hot star winds I. Resonance line formation in 2D models
• Analysis of Galactic late-type O dwarfs: more constraints on the weak wind problem
• One Dimensional Dynamical Models of the Carina Nebula Bubble
• Massive stars at low metallicity: Evolution and surface abundances of O dwarfs in the SMC
• On the role of the WNH phase in the evolution of very massive stars: Enabling the LBV instability with feedback
• The masses, and the mass discrepancy of O-type stars
• Clumped stellar winds in supergiant high-mass X-ray binaries: X-ray variability and photoionization
• Macroclumping as solution of the discrepancy between Hα and P v mass loss diagnostics for O-type stars
• 3D models of radiatively driven colliding winds in massive O+O star binaries - III. Thermal X-ray emission
• Near-IR integral field spectroscopy of ionizing stars and young stellar objects on the borders of HII regions
• Early-type stars in the core of the young open cluster Westerlund2
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey XXIV. Stellar properties of the O-type giants and supergiants in 30 Doradus
• A quantitative study of O stars in NGC2244 and the Mon OB2 association
• The transition mass-loss rate: Calibrating the role of line-driven winds in massive star evolution
• The circumstellar environment of Wolf-Rayet stars & Gamma-ray burst afterglows
• A Census of the Carina Nebula -- II. Energy Budget and Global Properties of the Nebulosity
• Measuring mass-loss rates and constraining shock physics using X-ray line profiles of O stars from the Chandra archive
• The structure of blue supergiant winds and the accretion in supergiant High Mass X-ray Binaries
• 3-D radiative transfer in clumped hot star winds I. Influence of clumping on the resonance line formation
• Detection of a magnetic field on HD108: clues to extreme magnetic braking and the Of?p phenomenon
• Measurements and analysis of helium-like triplet ratios in the X-ray spectra of O-type stars
• Properties of WNh stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud: evidence for homogeneous evolution
• Mass-loss and diffusion in subdwarf B stars and hot white dwarfs: do weak winds exist?
• The weak magnetic field of the O9.7 supergiant zeta Orionis A
• New predictions for radiation-driven, steady-state mass-loss and wind-momentum from hot, massive stars. I. Method and first results
• Two bi-stability jumps in theoretical wind models for massive stars and the implications for Luminous Blue Variable supernovae
• A very massive runaway star from Cygnus OB2
• A compact pulsar wind nebula model of the gamma-ray loud binary LS I +61 303
• Signature of wide-spread clumping in B supergiant winds
• Direct spectroscopic observations of clumping in O-star winds
• Observational effects of magnetism in O stars: surface nitrogen abundances
• Wind signatures in the X-ray emission line profiles of the late O supergiant $\zeta$ Orionis
• A mass-loss rate determination for zeta Puppis from the quantitative analysis of X-ray emission line profiles
• A Clumping Independent Diagnostic of Stellar Mass-loss Rates: Rapid Clump Destruction in Adiabatic Colliding Winds
• No breakdown of the radiatively-driven wind theory in low-metallicity environments
• A detailed X-ray investigation of zeta Puppis - The variability on short and long timescales
• Modelling the clumping-induced polarimetric variability of hot star winds
• Constraints for the Progenitor Masses of Historic Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Constraints for the Progenitor Masses of 17 Historic Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Stratified disc wind models for the AGN broad-line region: ultraviolet, optical and X-ray properties
• Can mass loss and overshooting prevent the excitation of g-modes in blue supergiants?
• Detailed Far-UV to Optical Analysis of Four [WR] Stars
• Empirical mass-loss rates and clumping properties of Galactic early-type O supergiants
• On the Importance of the Interclump Medium for Superionization: O VI Formation in the Wind of Zeta Pup
• A spectroscopic investigation of the O-type star population in four Cygnus OB associations. II. Determination of the fundamental parameters
• Chandra X-ray spectroscopy of the very early O supergiant HD 93129A: constraints on wind shocks and the mass-loss rate
• HD148937: a multiwavelength study of the third Galactic member of the Of?p class
• The solar photospheric abundance of phosphorus: results from co5bold 3D model atmospheres
• Multi-dimensional models of circumstellar shells around evolved massive stars
• Chandra spectroscopy of the hot star beta Crucis and the discovery of a pre-main-sequence companion
• Spectroscopic evolution of very massive stars at Z = 1/2.5 Zsun
• Radial dependence of line profile variability in seven O9--B0.5 stars
• A detailed X-ray investigation of ζ Puppis III. A spectral analysis of the whole RGS spectrum
• On the nature of the prototype LBV AG Carinae II. Witnessing a massive star evolving close to the Eddington and bistability limits
• High-resolution spectroscopy of SN 2017hcc and its blueshifted line profiles from post-shock dust formation
• Mass fluxes for O stars
• Massive stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud : Evolution, rotation and surface abundances
• Mass discrepancy analysis for a select sample of Type II-Plateau supernovae
• Thin shell morphology in the circumstellar medium of massive binaries
• Mass fluxes for hot stars
• Chandra X-ray spectroscopy of the focused wind in the Cygnus X-1 system III. Dipping in the low/hard state
• Evidence for the importance of resonance scattering in X-ray emission line profiles of the O star $\zeta$ Puppis
• On the H$\alpha$ Behaviour of Blue Supergiants: Rise and Fall over the Bi-stability Jump
• X-ray, UV and optical analysis of supergiants: $\epsilon$ Ori
• Ultraviolet Spectroscopy of Circumnuclear Star Clusters in M83
• Direct Constraints on the Extremely Metal-Poor Massive Stars Underlying Nebular C IV Emission from Ultra-Deep HST/COS Ultraviolet Spectroscopy
• Correlation between the gas-phase metallicity and ionization parameter in extragalactic HII regions
• The Effects of Clumps in Explaining X-ray Emission Lines from Hot Stars
• The effects of surface fossil magnetic fields on massive star evolution: IV. Grids of models at Solar, LMC, and SMC metallicities
• CMF models of hot star winds I. Test of the Sobolev approximation in the case of pure line transitions
• Clumping and X-Rays in cooler B supergiant stars
• Coronal winds powered by radiative driving
• A new investigation of the binary HD 48099
• Herschel imaging and spectroscopy of the nebula around the luminous blue variable star WRAY 15-751
• Central stars of planetary nebulae in the Galactic bulge
• Extreme broad He\2 emission at high and low redshifts: the dominant role of VMS in NGC 3125-A1 and CDFS131717
• Wind properties of Milky Way and SMC massive stars: empirical Z dependence from CMFGEN models
• New hydrodynamic solutions for line-driven winds of hot massive stars using Lambert $W$-function
• The Herschel view of the nebula around the luminous blue variable star AG Carinae
• The isolation of Luminous Blue Variables resembles aging B-type supergiants, not the most massive unevolved stars
• Brackett Lines from the Super Star Cluster Nebulae in He 2-10
• UV diagnostic of porosity-free mass-loss estimates in B stars
• Evolution of massive stars with new hydrodynamic wind models
• Self-consistent solutions for line-driven winds of hot massive stars. The m-CAK procedure
• Structure and clumping in the fast wind of NGC6543
• Non-thermal radio emission from O-type stars III. Is Cyg OB2 No. 9 a wind-colliding binary?
• X-ray diagnostics of massive star winds
• Empirical properties of Very Massive Stars
• Global modelling of X-ray spectra produced in O-type star winds
• Spectroscopic and physical parameters of Galactic O-type stars. I. Effects of rotation and spectral resolving power in the spectral classification of dwarfs and giants
• Denser Sampling of the Rosette Nebula with Faraday Rotation Measurements: Improved Estimates of Magnetic Fields in HII Regions
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity. IV. Spectral analysis methods and exemplary results for O stars
• On the origin of variable structures in the winds of hot luminous stars
• The longest observation of a low intensity state from a Supergiant Fast X-ray Transient: Suzaku observes IGRJ08408-4503
• The Polstar High Resolution Spectropolarimetry MIDEX Mission
• Empirical mass-loss rates and clumping properties of O-type stars in the LMC
• Investigating episodic mass loss in evolved massive stars: I. Spectroscopy of dusty massive stars in ten southern galaxies
• Ionization structure in the winds of B[e] supergiants II. Influence of rotation on the formation of equatorial hydrogen neutral zones
• Sub-mm free-free emission from the winds of massive stars in the age of ALMA
• An extensive grid of mass fluxes for Galactic O stars
• Spectroscopy of SMC Wolf-Rayet Stars Suggests that Wind-Clumping does not Depend on Ambient Metallicity
• Models of Forbidden Line Emission Profiles from Axisymmetric Stellar Winds
• Combined spectroscopy and intensity interferometry to determine the distances of the blue supergiants P Cygni and Rigel
• O-star mass-loss rates at low metallicity
• Mid-infrared observations of O-type stars: spectral morphology
• Revealing the Asymmetry of the Wind of the Variable Wolf-Rayet Star WR1 (HD4004) Through Spectropolarization
• The superimposed photospheric and stellar wind variability of the O-type supergiant alpha Cam
• Evolution of rotating massive stars adopting a newer, self-consistent wind prescription at SMC metallicity
• New self-consistent wind parameters fitting optical spectra of O-type stars observed with HERMES spectrograph
• Using Shell Models to Investigate Clumping in the Wind of the O7Iaf+ Supergiant AzV83
• Long-Wavelength, Free-Free Spectral Energy Distributions from Porous Stellar Winds
• Chandra View of Magnetically Confined Wind in HD191612: Theory versus Observations
• Wind properties of variable B supergiants. Evidence of pulsations connected with mass-loss episodes
• Development of convective envelopes in massive stars: Implications for gravitational wave sources
• Nucleosynthesis from massive stars 50 years after B2FH
• Theoretical X-ray light curves of young SNe II: the example of SN 2013ej
• Moving inhomogeneous envelopes of stars
• Properties of massive stars in four clusters of the VVV survey
• Unveiling the evolutionary state of three B supergiant stars: PU Gem, $\epsilon$ CMa and $\eta$ CMa
• OB-stars as extreme condition test beds
• Recombination Lines and Free-Free Continua formed in Asymptotic Ionized Winds: Analytic solution for the radiative transfer
• Detailed Simulations of Massive Hierarchical Triple Star Systems - Exploring the impact of the stellar physics on the evolutionary pathways of massive hierarchical triple systems
• On the importance of the wind emission to the optical continuum of OB supergiants
• A detailed X-ray investigation of zeta Puppis IV. Further characterization of the variability
• An Optical and Infrared Time-Domain Study of the Supergiant Fast X-ray Transient Candidate IC 10 X-2
• Mass fluxes for O-type supergiants with metallicity Z = Z_{\sun}/5
• The wind properties of O-type stars at sub-SMC metallicity
• Heating by Acoustic Waves of Multiphase Media
• Evolution of stars with 60 and 200 Msun: predictions for WNh stars in the Milky Way
• Micro-turbulence across the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. Observational constrains for stars in the MW