Evidence for intrinsic charm quarks in the proton

Abstract

The theory of the strong force, quantum chromodynamics, describes the proton in terms of quarks and gluons. The proton is a state of two up quarks and one down quark bound by gluons, but quantum theory predicts that in addition there is an infinite number of quark-antiquark pairs. Both light and heavy quarks, whose mass is respectively smaller or bigger than the mass of the proton, are revealed inside the proton in high-energy collisions. However, it is unclear whether heavy quarks also exist as a part of the proton wavefunction, which is determined by non-perturbative dynamics and accordingly unknown: so-called intrinsic heavy quarks. It has been argued for a long time that the proton could have a sizable intrinsic component of the lightest heavy quark, the charm quark. Innumerable efforts to establish intrinsic charm in the proton have remained inconclusive. Here we provide evidence for intrinsic charm by exploiting a high-precision determination of the quark-gluon content of the nucleon based on machine learning and a large experimental dataset. We disentangle the intrinsic charm component from charm-anticharm pairs arising from high-energy radiation. We establish the existence of intrinsic charm at the 3-standard-deviation level, with a momentum distribution in remarkable agreement with model predictions. We confirm these findings by comparing to very recent data on Z-boson production with charm jets from the LHCb experiment.

arXiv comment10 pages, 4 figures + Supplementary Information, published version available in https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04998-2. v2: updated comparison with the MBC model in Fig. 1 right (thanks to Tim Hobbs for the suggestion)

References in corpus (45)

• The anti-k_t jet clustering algorithm
• A Brief Introduction to PYTHIA 8.1
• A general framework for implementing NLO calculations in shower Monte Carlo programs: the POWHEG BOX
• Parton distributions from high-precision collider data
• The Path to Proton Structure at One-Percent Accuracy
• A first unbiased global NLO determination of parton distributions and their uncertainties
• APFEL: A PDF Evolution Library with QED corrections
• A Higher Order Perturbative Parton Evolution Toolkit (HOPPET)
• QCDNUM: Fast QCD Evolution and Convolution
• Heavy quarks in deep-inelastic scattering
• Charm electroproduction viewed in the variable-flavour number scheme versus fixed-order perturbation theory
• A determination of parton distributions with faithful uncertainty estimation
• Efficient evolution of unpolarized and polarized parton distributions with QCD-PEGASUS
• The Structure of the Proton in the LHC Precision Era
• The Forward Physics Facility: Sites, Experiments, and Physics Potential
• Parton distributions and lattice QCD calculations: toward 3D structure
• Mellin Moments of the {$O({\alpha }_s^3$)} Heavy Flavor Contributions to unpolarized Deep-Inelastic Scattering at $Q^2\gg m^2$ and Anomalous Dimensions
• Science Requirements and Detector Concepts for the Electron-Ion Collider: EIC Yellow Report
• Reweighting NNPDFs: the W lepton asymmetry
• Reanalysis of the EMC charm production data with extrinsic and intrinsic charm at NLO
• Collider Physics at the Precision Frontier
• A review of the intrinsic heavy quark content of the nucleon
• The 3-Loop Non-Singlet Heavy Flavor Contributions and Anomalous Dimensions for the Structure Function $F_2(x,Q^2)$ and Transversity
• The 3-Loop Pure Singlet Heavy Flavor Contributions to the Structure Function $F_2(x,Q^2)$ and the Anomalous Dimension
• CT14 Intrinsic Charm Parton Distribution Functions from CTEQ-TEA Global Analysis
• The Gluonic Operator Matrix Elements at O(α_s^2) for DIS Heavy Flavor Production
• The O(α_s^3) Massive Operator Matrix Elements of O(n_f) for the Structure Function F_2(x,Q^2) and Transversity
• Neural network determination of parton distributions: the nonsinglet case
• Hadron structure in high-energy collisions
• New limits on intrinsic charm in the nucleon from global analysis of parton distributions
• Phenomenology of nonperturbative charm in the nucleon
• Light-Cone Models for Intrinsic Charm and Bottom
• The Transition Matrix Element A_{gq}(N) of the Variable Flavor Number Scheme at O(α_s^3)
• First measurement of charm production in fixed-target configuration at the LHC
• Intrinsic charm in a matched general-mass scheme
• The Logarithmic Contributions to the O(α_s^3) Asymptotic Massive Wilson Coefficients and Operator Matrix Elements in Deeply Inelastic Scattering
• The O(α_s^3 T_F^2) Contributions to the Gluonic Operator Matrix Element
• Virtual Meson Cloud of the Nucleon and Intrinsic Strangeness and Charm
• EKO: Evolution Kernel Operators
• Structure Functions
• A Fixed-Target Programme at the LHC: Physics Case and Projected Performances for Heavy-Ion, Hadron, Spin and Astroparticle Studies
• Charm in Deep-Inelastic Scattering
• The QCD/SM Working Group: Summary Report
• On the Charm Contribution to the Atmospheric Neutrino Flux
• A direct probe of the intrinsic charm content of the proton

Cited by in corpus (48)

• 50 Years of Quantum Chromodynamics
• Snowmass 2021 whitepaper: Proton structure at the precision frontier
• The Present and Future of QCD
• EKO: Evolution Kernel Operators
• The persistent nonperturbative charm enigma
• Parton distributions need representative sampling
• Far-forward production of charm mesons and neutrinos at Forward Physics Facilities at the LHC and the intrinsic charm in the proton
• NNLO QCD predictions for Z-boson production in association with a charm jet within the LHCb fiducial region
• Fully charmed tetraquarks from LHC to FCC: Natural stability from fragmentation
• High-energy QCD dynamics from bottom flavor fragmentation at the Hi-Lumi LHC
• Strong Interaction Physics at the Luminosity Frontier with 22 GeV Electrons at Jefferson Lab
• B-meson hadroproduction in the SACOT-$m_{\mathrm{T}}$ scheme
• Open charm production and asymmetry in $p$Ne collisions at $\sqrt{s_{\mathrm{NN}}}=$ 68.5 GeV
• Science and Project Planning for the Forward Physics Facility in Preparation for the 2024-2026 European Particle Physics Strategy Update
• Bottomoniumlike states in proton collisions: Fragmentation and resummation
• Transverse Momentum Distributions of Heavy Hadrons and Polarized Heavy Quarks
• Fragmentation functions for axial-vector heavy tetraquarks: A TQ4Q1.1 update
• An FONLL prescription with coexisting flavor number PDFs
• Fragmentation of fully heavy tetraquarks: The TQ4Q1.1 functions as a case study
• A Stress Test of Global PDF Fits: Closure Testing the MSHT PDFs and a First Direct Comparison to the Neural Net Approach
• Flavoured jet algorithms: a comparative study
• Unwinding the rare $\Omega$ sector: Fragmentation of fully charmed baryons from HL-LHC to FCC
• Basics of factorization in a scalar Yukawa field theory
• Toponium: the smallest bound state and simplest hadron in quantum mechanics
• Hadron Structure using Continuum Schwinger Function Methods
• Connected and Disconnected Sea Partons from CT18 Parametrization of PDFs
• Pseudoscalar heavy-quarkonium hadroproduction from nonrelativistic fragmentation at NLL/NLO${}^{+}$
• Letter of Intent: the NA60+ experiment
• Triply Heavy $\Omega$ Baryons with JETHAD: A High-Energy Viewpoint
• Deep-Inelastic Scattering at TeV Energies with LHC Muons
• Tetraquark-Jet Systems at the High-Luminosity LHC
• Parton distribution functions of ground state mesons composed of $c$ or $b$ quarks
• Contribution from Intrinsic Charm Production to Fixed-Target Interactions at the LHC
• General mass variable flavor number scheme for $Z$ boson production in association with a heavy quark at hadron colliders
• On the impact of heavy meson production spectra on searches for heavy neutral leptons
• A generalized statistical model for fits to parton distributions
• Axial-vector charges of the spin ${\frac{1}{2}}^{+}$ and spin ${\frac{3}{2}}^{+}$ light and charmed baryons in the SU(4) chiral quark constituent model
• Measurements of the production cross-section for a $Z$ boson in association with $b$- or $c$-jets in proton-proton collisions at $\sqrt{s}=13$ TeV with the ATLAS detector
• Heavy quark contribution to the electromagnetic properties of the nucleon
• All-charm tetraquarks at hadron colliders: A high-precision fragmentation perspective
• Challenges in the extraction of physics beyond the Standard Model from electron scattering
• Multimodal Fragmentation of All-Heavy Pentaquarks: Uncertainty-Aware Predictions for Hadron Colliders
• A semi-analytical $x$-space solution for parton evolution -- Application to non-singlet and singlet DGLAP equation
• Letter of Intent: The Forward Physics Facility
• QCD analysis of valence structure functions using deep inelastic lepton-nucleon scattering
• Illuminating the charged leptons in the proton
• Reconstruction of the Dipole Amplitude in the Dipole Picture as a mathematical Inverse Problem
• Theory pipeline for PDF fitting