Parton distributions need representative sampling
arXiv:2205.10444 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.107.034008
Abstract
In global QCD fits of parton distribution functions (PDFs), a large part of the estimated uncertainty on the PDFs originates from the choices of parametric functional forms and fitting methodology. We argue that these types of uncertainties can be underestimated with common PDF ensembles in high-stake measurements at the Large Hadron Collider and Tevatron. A fruitful approach to quantify these uncertainties is to view them as arising from sampling of allowed PDF solutions in a multidimensional parametric space. This approach applies powerful insights gained in recent statistical studies of large-scale population surveys and quasi-Monte Carlo integration methods. In particular, PDF fits may be affected by the big data paradox, which stipulates that more experimental data do not automatically raise the accuracy of PDFs -- close attention to the data quality and sampling of possible PDF solutions is as essential. To test if the sampling of the PDF uncertainty of an experimental observable is truly representative of all acceptable solutions, we introduce a technique (``a hopscotch scan'') based on a combination of parameter scans and stochastic sampling. With this technique, we show that the PDF uncertainty on key LHC cross sections at 13 TeV obtained with the public NNPDF4.0 fitting code is larger than the nominal uncertainty obtained with the published NNPDF4.0 Monte-Carlo replica sets, when accounting for the likelihood distribution. On the same grounds, the uncertainties on the charm distribution at a large momentum fraction and gluon PDF at small are enlarged. In PDF ensembles obtained in the analytic minimization (Hessian) formalism, the tolerance on the PDF uncertainty must be based on sufficiently complete sampling of PDF functional forms and choices of the experiments.
arXiv comment26 pages, 10 figures; this version includes expanded discussion added in the journal version and detailed comparisons supplementary to the journal version
References in corpus (42)
- New Generation of Parton Distributions with Uncertainties from Global QCD Analysis
- Parton distributions for the LHC Run II
- Parton distributions from high-precision collider data
- PDF4LHC recommendations for LHC Run II
- Top++: a program for the calculation of the top-pair cross-section at hadron colliders
- New CTEQ global analysis of quantum chromodynamics with high-precision data from the LHC
- The CT10 NNLO Global Analysis of QCD
- Parton distributions from LHC, HERA, Tevatron and fixed target data: MSHT20 PDFs
- Parton Distribution Functions, and Heavy-Quark Masses for LHC Run II
- The Path to Proton Structure at One-Percent Accuracy
- Constraints on large- parton distributions from new weak boson production and deep-inelastic scattering data
- The automation of next-to-leading order electroweak calculations
- A posteriori inclusion of parton density functions in NLO QCD final-state calculations at hadron colliders: The APPLGRID Project
- Uncertainties of Predictions from Parton Distribution Functions I: the Lagrange Multiplier Method
- Unrepresentative Big Surveys Significantly Overestimate US Vaccine Uptake
- The Large Hadron-Electron Collider at the HL-LHC
- The Structure of the Proton in the LHC Precision Era
- Precision measurement and interpretation of inclusive , and production cross sections with the ATLAS detector
- The PDF4LHC21 combination of global PDF fits for the LHC Run III
- Measurement of and -boson production cross sections in collisions at TeV with the ATLAS detector
- Reweighting NNPDFs: the W lepton asymmetry
- A meta-analysis of parton distribution functions
- Parton Distribution Benchmarking with LHC Data
- Study of Monte Carlo approach to experimental uncertainty propagation with MSTW 2008 PDFs
- Fitting Parton Distribution Data with Multiplicative Normalization Uncertainties
- Precision phenomenology with MCFM
- Measurement of the production cross section, the top quark mass, and the strong coupling constant using dilepton events in pp collisions at 13 TeV
- Evidence for intrinsic charm quarks in the proton
- Hadron structure in high-energy collisions
- Measurement of the Proton Structure Function at low and low at HERA
- On the Higgs cross section at NLO+NLL and its uncertainty
- PineAPPL: combining EW and QCD corrections for fast evaluation of LHC processes
- Reconstruction of Monte Carlo replicas from Hessian parton distributions
- Measurements of top-quark pair to -boson cross-section ratios at TeV with the ATLAS detector
- Data set diagonalization in a global fit
- Why Cannot be Determined from Hadronic Processes without Simultaneously Determining the Parton Distributions
- Updating and Optimizing Error PDFs in the Hessian Approach. Part II
- production at NNLO: the flavour off-diagonal channels
- Testing momentum dependence of the nonperturbative hadron structure in a global QCD analysis
- Differential Top Quark Pair Production at the LHC: Challenges for PDF Fits
- Correlation of Theoretical Uncertainties in PDF Fits and Theoretical Uncertainties in Predictions
- Towards a new generation of parton densities with deep learning models
Cited by in corpus (10)
- Snowmass 2021 whitepaper: Proton structure at the precision frontier
- The persistent nonperturbative charm enigma
- Les Houches 2021: Physics at TeV Colliders: Report on the Standard Model Precision Wishlist
- B-meson hadroproduction in the SACOT- scheme
- High-energy neutrino deep inelastic scattering cross sections
- A Stress Test of Global PDF Fits: Closure Testing the MSHT PDFs and a First Direct Comparison to the Neural Net Approach
- Basics of factorization in a scalar Yukawa field theory
- Les Houches 2023 -- Physics at TeV Colliders: Report on the Standard Model Precision Wishlist
- A generalized statistical model for fits to parton distributions
- An analysis of parton distributions in a pion with Bézier parametrizations