Infrared Radiation Feedback Does Not Regulate Star Cluster Formation
arXiv:2206.14190 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stac2702
Abstract
We present 3D radiation-hydrodynamical (RHD) simulations of star cluster formation and evolution in massive, self-gravitating clouds, whose dust columns are optically thick to infrared (IR) photons. We use \texttt{VETTAM} -- a recently developed, novel RHD algorithm, which uses the Variable Eddington Tensor (VET) closure -- to model the IR radiation transport through the cloud. We also use realistic temperature () dependent IR opacities () in our simulations, improving upon earlier works in this area, which used either constant IR opacities or simplified power laws (). We investigate the impact of the radiation pressure of these IR photons on the star formation efficiency (SFE) of the cloud, and its potential to drive dusty winds. We find that IR radiation pressure is unable to regulate star formation or prevent accretion onto the star clusters, even for very high gas surface densities (), contrary to recent semi-analytic predictions and simulation results using simplified treatments of the dust opacity. We find that the commonly adopted simplifications of or constant for the IR dust opacities leads to this discrepancy, as those approximations overestimate the radiation force. By contrast, with realistic opacities that take into account the micro-physics of the dust, we find that the impact of IR radiation pressure on star formation is very mild, even at significantly high dust-to-gas ratios ( times solar), suggesting that it is unlikely to be an important feedback mechanism in controlling star formation in the ISM.
arXiv comment28 pages, 19 figures. MNRAS accepted. v2: Minor changes made to address referee comments
References in corpus (116)
- SciPy 1.0--Fundamental Algorithms for Scientific Computing in Python
- Array Programming with NumPy
- Control of star formation by supersonic turbulence
- A Multi-Code Analysis Toolkit for Astrophysical Simulation Data
- Young massive star clusters
- A General Theory of Turbulence-Regulated Star Formation, From Spirals to ULIRGs
- Comparing the statistics of interstellar turbulence in simulations and observations: Solenoidal versus compressive turbulence forcing
- Radiation Pressure Supported Starburst Disks and AGN Fueling
- The Star Formation Rate of Turbulent Magnetized Clouds: Comparing Theory, Simulations, and Observations
- Shocks and cold fronts in galaxy clusters
- Star Clusters Across Cosmic Time
- Slow Star Formation in Dense Gas: Evidence and Implications
- The Formation of Massive Star Systems by Accretion
- Stellar Feedback in Galaxies and the Origin of Galaxy-scale Winds
- Rosseland and Planck Mean Opacities for Protoplanetary Discs
- A Universal, Local Star Formation Law in Galactic Clouds, Nearby Galaxies, High-Redshift Disks, and Starbursts
- The Density Probability Distribution in Compressible Isothermal Turbulence: Solenoidal versus Compressive Forcing
- Self-Regulated Star Formation in Galaxies via Momentum Input from Massive Stars
- The Disruption of Giant Molecular Clouds by Radiation Pressure and the Efficiency of Star Formation in Galaxies
- Modeling Collapse and Accretion in Turbulent Gas Clouds: Implementation and Comparison of Sink Particles in AMR and SPH
- Regulation of Star Formation Rates in Multiphase Galactic Disks: a Thermal/Dynamical Equilibrium Model
- The Mass-Metallicity and the Fundamental Metallicity Relation revisited on a fully Te-based abundance scale for galaxies
- Outflow Feedback Regulated Massive Star Formation in Parsec-Scale Cluster Forming Clumps
- Massive stars in massive clusters II: Disruption of bound clusters by photoionization
- A new Jeans resolution criterion for (M)HD simulations of self-gravitating gas: Application to magnetic field amplification by gravity-driven turbulence
- On the universality of supersonic turbulence
- The Dynamics of Radiation Pressure-Dominated HII Regions
- Inefficient star formation through turbulence, magnetic fields and feedback
- Protostellar Turbulence Driven by Collimated Outflows
- Three-phase Interstellar medium in Galaxies Resolving Evolution with Star formation and Supernova feedback (TIGRESS): Algorithms, Fiducial model, and Convergence
- Modeling UV Radiation Feedback from Massive Stars: II. Dispersal of Star-Forming Giant Molecular Clouds by Photoionization and Radiation Pressure
- Star Formation Relations in Nearby Molecular Clouds
- What Drives the Expansion of Giant HII Regions?: A Study of Stellar Feedback in 30 Doradus
- Stellar Feedback in Molecular Clouds and its Influence on the Mass Function of Young Star Clusters
- On Radiation Pressure in Static, Dusty HII Regions
- Feedback from Winds and Supernovae in Massive Stellar Clusters. I: Hydrodynamics
- A scheme for radiation pressure and photon diffusion with the M1 closure in RAMSES-RT
- The Global Evolution of Giant Molecular Clouds. I: Model Formulation and Quasi-Equilibrium Behavior
- Direct Numerical Simulation of Radiation Pressure-Driven Turbulence and Winds in Star Clusters and Galactic Disks
- Supernova Driving. I. The Origin of Molecular Cloud Turbulence
- Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of the Formation of Orion-Like Star Clusters II. The Initial Mass Function from Winds, Turbulence, and Radiation
- Modeling jet and outflow feedback during star cluster formation
- When Feedback Fails: The Scaling and Saturation of Star Formation Efficiency
- A robust numerical scheme for highly compressible magnetohydrodynamics: Nonlinear stability, implementation and tests
- Driving Turbulence and Triggering Star Formation by Ionizing Radiation
- The Role of Stellar Feedback in the Dynamics of HII Regions
- Equations and Algorithms for Mixed Frame Flux-Limited Diffusion Radiation Hydrodynamics
- The dynamics and outcome of star formation with jets, radiation, winds, and supernovae in concert
- Cloud Scale ISM Structure and Star Formation in M51
- The sonic scale revealed by the world's largest supersonic turbulence simulation
- A Maximum Stellar Surface Density in Dense Stellar Systems
- Studying the YMC population of M83: how long clusters remain embedded, their interaction with the ISM and implications for GC formation theories
- A Direct Multigrid Poisson Solver for Oct-Tree Adaptive Meshes
- Star clusters near and far; tracing star formation across cosmic time
- The Star Formation Efficiency per Free Fall Time in Nearby Galaxies
- The Dawes Review 8: Measuring the Stellar Initial Mass Function
- An Unstable Truth: How Massive Stars get their Mass
- Numerical Simulations of Radiatively-Driven Dusty Winds
- The Star Formation Rate in the Gravoturbulent Interstellar Medium
- Quenching star formation with quasar outflows launched by trapped IR radiation
- The molecular cloud lifecycle
- A Two-moment Radiation Hydrodynamics Module in Athena Using a Time-explicit Godunov Method
- Forming Super Star Clusters in the Central Starburst of NGC 253
- Efficiently Cooled Stellar Wind Bubbles in Turbulent Clouds I. Fractal Theory and Application to Star-Forming Clouds
- Gone With the Wind: Where is the Missing Stellar Wind Energy from Massive Star Clusters?
- A Model for the Onset of Self-gravitation and Star Formation in Molecular Gas Governed by Galactic Forces: I. Cloud-scale Gas Motions
- Numerical Simulations of Turbulent Molecular Clouds Regulated by Reprocessed Radiation Feedback from Nascent Super Star Clusters
- Numerical Simulations of Turbulent, Molecular Clouds Regulated by Radiation Feedback Forces I: Star Formation Rate and Efficiency
- The Spatial Relation between Young Star Clusters and Molecular Clouds in M 51 with LEGUS
- Outflows Driven by Quasars in High-Redshift Galaxies with Radiation Hydrodynamics
- Feedback in Clouds II: UV Photoionisation and the first supernova in a massive cloud
- Highly efficient star formation in NGC 5253 possibly from stream-fed accretion
- The origin of physical variations in the star formation law
- Sub-Eddington Star-Forming Regions are Super-Eddington: Momentum Driven Outflows from Supersonic Turbulence
- The momentum budget of clustered supernova feedback in a 3D, magnetised medium
- Radiation Feedback in ULIRGS: Are Photons Movers and Shakers?
- Star Cluster Formation in a Turbulent Molecular Cloud Self-Regulated by Photo-Ionisation Feedback
- On the stability of radiation-pressure-dominated cavities
- The rate and latency of star formation in dense, massive clumps in the Milky Way
- An Implicit Finite Volume Scheme to Solve the Time Dependent Radiation Transport Equation Based on Discrete Ordinates
- Which feedback mechanisms dominate in the high-pressure environment of the Central Molecular Zone?
- Mass Segregation and the Initial Mass Function of Super Star Cluster M82-F
- Radiation hydrodynamics simulations of massive star cluster formation in giant molecular clouds
- Evolution of Stellar Feedback in HII Regions
- A 33 GHz Survey of Local Major Mergers: Estimating the Sizes of the Energetically Dominant Regions from High Resolution Measurements of the Radio Continuum
- Modeling UV Radiation Feedback from Massive Stars: I. Implementation of Adaptive Ray Tracing Method and Tests
- Star Formation Regulation and Self-Pollution by Stellar Wind Feedback
- Star-Gas Surface Density Correlations in Twelve Nearby Molecular Clouds I: Data Collection and Star-Sampled Analysis
- ALMA Detects CO(3-2) within a Super Star Cluster in NGC5253
- Radiative Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities
- Radiation pressure driving of a dusty atmosphere
- Super Hot Cores in NGC 253: Witnessing the formation and early evolution of Super Star Clusters
- Super Star Clusters in the Central Starburst of NGC 4945
- Slow Star Formation in the Milky Way: Theory Meets Observations
- Outflows from Super Star Clusters in the Central Starburst of NGC253
- Combining radiative transfer and diffuse interstellar medium physics to model star formation
- Radiation Hydrodynamic Simulations of Dust-Driven Winds
- Radiation pressure in super star cluster formation
- Dusty Cloud Acceleration by Radiation Pressure in Rapidly Star-Forming Galaxies
- Non-linear Evolution of Rayleigh-Taylor Instability in a Radiation Supported Atmosphere
- On the compressive nature of turbulence driven by ionising feedback in the pillars of the Carina Nebula
- On the turbulence driving mode of expanding HII regions
- New Insights into the Physical Conditions and Internal Structure of a Candidate Proto-Globular Cluster
- Resolution Requirements and Resolution Problems in Simulations of Radiative Feedback in Dusty Gas
- Spectral shifting strongly constrains molecular cloud disruption by radiation pressure on dust
- Radiation Pressure Limits on the Star Formation Efficiency and Surface Density of Compact Stellar Systems
- Winds in Star Clusters Drive Kolmogorov Turbulence
- Radiation Hydrodynamics using Characteristics on Adaptive Decomposed Domains for Massively Parallel Star Formation Simulations
- Less wrong: a more realistic initial condition for simulations of turbulent molecular clouds
- VETTAM: A scheme for radiation hydrodynamics with adaptive mesh refinement using the variable Eddington tensor method
- Embedded Young Massive Star Clusters in the Antennae Merger
- The Three Young Nuclear Super Star Clusters in NGC 5253
- Radiation pressure in galactic disks: stability, turbulence, and winds in the single-scattering limit
- Towards a More Complex Understanding of Natal Super Star Clusters with Multiwavelength Observations
- High-precision star formation efficiency measurements in nearby clouds
- Is this an Early Stage Merger? A Case Study on Molecular Gas and Star Formation Properties of Arp 240
Cited by in corpus (13)
- Nitrogen-enriched, highly-pressurized nebular clouds surrounding a super star cluster at cosmic noon
- Outflows Driven by Direct and Reprocessed Radiation Pressure in Massive Star Clusters
- Pre-supernova feedback sets the star cluster mass function to a power law and reduces the cluster formation efficiency
- SPICE: the connection between cosmic reionisation and stellar feedback in the first galaxies
- SIEGE III: The formation of dense stellar clusters in sub-parsec resolution cosmological simulations with individual star feedback
- Lyman- feedback prevails at Cosmic Dawn: Implications for the first galaxies, stars, and star clusters
- The Ionization and Dynamics of the Makani Galactic Wind
- Linking stellar populations to HII regions across nearby galaxies. II. Infrared Reprocessed and UV Direct Radiation Pressure in HII Regions
- On the Origin of the High Star-Formation Efficiency in Massive Galaxies at Cosmic Dawn
- The formation of globular clusters with top-heavy initial mass functions
- Simulations of pre-supernova feedback in spherical clouds
- Non-explosive pre-supernova feedback in the COLIBRE model of galaxy formation
- The Star Formation Factory revisited I. The impact of metallicity on collapsing star-forming clouds