Resolution Requirements and Resolution Problems in Simulations of Radiative Feedback in Dusty Gas
arXiv:1805.00210 · doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2105
Abstract
In recent years a number of authors have introduced methods to model the effects of radiation pressure feedback on flows of interstellar and intergalactic gas, and have posited that the forces exerted by stars' radiation output represents an important feedback mechanism capable of halting accretion and thereby regulating star formation. However, numerical simulations have reached widely varying conclusions about the effectiveness of this feedback. In this paper I show that much of the divergence in the literature is a result of failure to obey an important resolution criterion: whether radiation feedback is able to reverse an accretion flow is determined on scales comparable to the dust destruction radius, which is AU even for the most luminous stellar sources. Simulations that fail to resolve this scale can produce unphysical results, in many cases leading to a dramatic overestimate of the effectiveness of radiation feedback. Most published simulations of radiation feedback on molecular cloud and galactic scales fail to satisfy this condition. I show how the problem can be circumvented by introducing a new subgrid model that explicitly accounts for momentum balance on unresolved scales, making it possible to simulate dusty accretion flows safely even at low resolution.
arXiv comment15 pages, 5 figures, MNRAS in press; this version has some added discussion, but no changes to figures or conclusions
References in corpus (59)
- Grids of stellar models with rotation - I. Models from 0.8 to 120 Msun at solar metallicity (Z = 0.014)
- FIRE-2 Simulations: Physics versus Numerics in Galaxy Formation
- On the Maximum Luminosity of Galaxies and Their Central Black Holes: Feedback From Momentum-Driven Winds
- Modelling Accretion in Protobinary Systems
- Radiation Pressure Supported Starburst Disks and AGN Fueling
- The Formation of Massive Star Systems by Accretion
- Stellar Feedback in Galaxies and the Origin of Galaxy-scale Winds
- Rosseland and Planck Mean Opacities for Protoplanetary Discs
- Towards a complete accounting of energy and momentum from stellar feedback in galaxy formation simulations
- Self-Regulated Star Formation in Galaxies via Momentum Input from Massive Stars
- The Disruption of Giant Molecular Clouds by Radiation Pressure and the Efficiency of Star Formation in Galaxies
- On the formation of massive stars
- Modeling Collapse and Accretion in Turbulent Gas Clouds: Implementation and Comparison of Sink Particles in AMR and SPH
- The Dynamics of Radiation Pressure-Dominated HII Regions
- Circumventing the radiation pressure barrier in the formation of massive stars via disk accretion
- Embedding Lagrangian Sink Particles in Eulerian Grids
- Radiation pressure from massive star clusters as a launching mechanism for super-galactic winds
- Modeling UV Radiation Feedback from Massive Stars: II. Dispersal of Star-Forming Giant Molecular Clouds by Photoionization and Radiation Pressure
- High Mass, OB Star Formation in M51 : HST Halpha and Palpha Imaging
- Three-dimensional simulation of massive star formation in the disk accretion scenario
- The Formation of Massive Stars by Accretion Through Trapped Hypercompact HII Regions
- Stellar Feedback in Molecular Clouds and its Influence on the Mass Function of Young Star Clusters
- On Radiation Pressure in Static, Dusty HII Regions
- Radiative feedback and the low efficiency of galaxy formation in low-mass haloes at high redshift
- SLUG - Stochastically Lighting Up Galaxies I: Methods and Validating Tests
- A scheme for radiation pressure and photon diffusion with the M1 closure in RAMSES-RT
- The Fragmentation of Magnetized, Massive Star-Forming Cores with Radiative Feedback
- When Feedback Fails: The Scaling and Saturation of Star Formation Efficiency
- Equations and Algorithms for Mixed Frame Flux-Limited Diffusion Radiation Hydrodynamics
- Stellar Feedback & Bulge Formation in Clumpy Disks
- Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of Massive Star Formation with Protostellar Outflows
- An Unstable Truth: How Massive Stars get their Mass
- Infall Collapse Solutions in the Inner Limit: Radiation Pressure and its Effects on Star Formation
- A Godunov Method for Multidimensional Radiation Magnetohydrodynamics based on a variable Eddington tensor
- Galaxies that Shine: radiation-hydrodynamical simulations of disk galaxies
- A Radiation Transfer Solver for Athena using Short Characteristics
- AREPO-RT: Radiation hydrodynamics on a moving mesh
- Fast and accurate frequency-dependent radiation transport for hydrodynamics simulations in massive star formation
- A Two-moment Radiation Hydrodynamics Module in Athena Using a Time-explicit Godunov Method
- Numerical Simulations of Turbulent Molecular Clouds Regulated by Reprocessed Radiation Feedback from Nascent Super Star Clusters
- Numerical Simulations of Turbulent, Molecular Clouds Regulated by Radiation Feedback Forces I: Star Formation Rate and Efficiency
- Simulating the Formation of Massive Protostars: I. Radiative Feedback and Accretion Disks
- Sub-Eddington Star-Forming Regions are Super-Eddington: Momentum Driven Outflows from Supersonic Turbulence
- Protostellar Outflows and Radiative Feedback from Massive Stars. II. Feedback, Star Formation Efficiency, and Outflow Broadening
- Protostellar Outflows and Radiative Feedback from Massive Stars
- Implementation of Sink Particles in the Athena Code
- Stellar feedback by radiation pressure and photoionization
- Mean gas opacity for circumstellar environments and equilibrium temperature degeneracy
- Modeling UV Radiation Feedback from Massive Stars: I. Implementation of Adaptive Ray Tracing Method and Tests
- Radiation pressure driving of a dusty atmosphere
- Far-Infrared Spectral Energy Distributions of Embedded Protostars and Dusty Galaxies: I. Theory for Spherical Sources
- Radiation Pressure Driven Galactic Winds from Self-Gravitating Discs
- Numerical Problems in Coupling Photon Momentum (Radiation Pressure) to Gas
- Hybrid Adaptive Ray-Moment Method (HARM): A Highly Parallel Method for Radiation Hydrodynamics on Adaptive Grids
- Radiation pressure in super star cluster formation
- Numerical Simulations of Turbulent Molecular Clouds Regulated by Radiation Feedback Forces II: Radiation-Gas Interactions and Outflows
- Spectral shifting strongly constrains molecular cloud disruption by radiation pressure on dust
- The Maximum Flux of Star-Forming Galaxies
- Far-Infrared Spectral Energy Distributions and Photometric Redshifts of Dusty Galaxies
Cited by in corpus (23)
- Star Clusters Across Cosmic Time
- Cool Outflows in Galaxies and their Implications
- STARFORGE: Toward a comprehensive numerical model of star cluster formation and feedback
- Simulating the interstellar medium and stellar feedback on a moving mesh: Implementation and isolated galaxies
- Simulating an Isolated Dwarf Galaxy with Multi-Channel Feedback and Chemical Yields from Individual Stars
- Understanding the escape of LyC and Ly photons from turbulent clouds
- Stellar Radiation is Critical for Regulating Star Formation and Driving Outflows in Low Mass Dwarf Galaxies
- Radiation hydrodynamics simulations of massive star cluster formation in giant molecular clouds
- Star cluster formation and cloud dispersal by radiative feedback: dependence on metallicity and compactness
- Modeling UV Radiation Feedback from Massive Stars: III. Escape of Radiation from Star-forming Giant Molecular Clouds
- Outflows Driven by Direct and Reprocessed Radiation Pressure in Massive Star Clusters
- Trapping of HII regions in Population III star formation
- Momentum feedback from marginally-resolved HII regions in isolated disc galaxies
- Pre-supernova feedback sets the star cluster mass function to a power law and reduces the cluster formation efficiency
- Super-Eddington accretion of dusty gas onto seed black holes: metallicity-dependent efficiency of mass growth
- The Elephant in the Room: The Importance of Where and When Massive Stars Form in Molecular Clouds
- Formation of massive stars under protostellar radiation feedback: Very metal-poor stars
- Infrared Radiation Feedback Does Not Regulate Star Cluster Formation
- Simulating ionization feedback from young massive stars: impact of numerical resolution
- Lyman- feedback prevails at Cosmic Dawn: Implications for the first galaxies, stars, and star clusters
- The longevity of the oldest open clusters: Structural parameters of NGC 188, NGC 2420, NGC 2425, NGC 2682, NGC 6791, NGC 6819
- Dust-Evacuated Zones Near Massive Stars: Consequences of Dust Dynamics on Star-forming Regions
- Population III star formation in the presence of turbulence, magnetic fields and ionizing radiation feedback