Do LIGO/Virgo black hole mergers produce AGN flares? The case of GW190521 and prospects for reaching a confident association

Abstract

The recent report of an association of the gravitational-wave (GW) binary black hole (BBH) merger GW190521 with a flare in the Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) J124942.3+344929 has generated tremendous excitement. However, GW190521 has one of the largest localization volumes amongst all of the GW events detected so far. The 90\% localization volume likely contains $7,400$ unobscured AGN brighter than $g\le 20.5$ AB mag, and it results in a $\gtrsim 70\%$ probability of chance coincidence for an AGN flare consistent with the GW event. We present a Bayesian formalism to estimate the confidence of an AGN association by analyzing a population of BBH events with dedicated follow-up observations. Depending on the fraction of BBH arising from AGNs, counterpart searches of $\mathcal{O}(1)-\mathcal{O}(100)$ GW events are needed to establish a confident association, and more than an order of magnitude more for searches without followup (i.e, using only the locations of AGNs and GW events). Follow-up campaigns of the top $\sim 5\%$ (based on volume localization and binary mass) of BBH events with total rest frame mass $\ge 50M_{\odot }$ are expected to establish a confident association during the next LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA observing run (O4), as long as the true value of the fraction of BBH giving rise to AGN flares is $>0.1$. Our formalism allows us to jointly infer cosmological parameters from a sample of BBH events that include chance coincidence flares. Until the confidence of AGN associations is established, the probability of chance coincidence must be taken into account to avoid biasing astrophysical and cosmological constraints.

arXiv comment12 pages, 5 Figures, submitted to ApJ

References in corpus (43)

• Unified Schemes for Radio-Loud Active Galactic Nuclei
• GW170814: A Three-Detector Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Coalescence
• The Zwicky Transient Facility: System Overview, Performance, and First Results
• GW190814: Gravitational Waves from the Coalescence of a 23 M${}_{\odot }$ Black Hole with a 2.6 M${}_{\odot }$ Compact Object
• GW190521: A Binary Black Hole Merger with a Total Mass of $150M_{\odot }$
• The Zwicky Transient Facility: Data Processing, Products, and Archive
• A gravitational-wave standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant
• An Observational Determination of the Bolometric Quasar Luminosity Function
• Fast and scalable Gaussian process modeling with applications to astronomical time series
• Are the Variations in Quasar Optical Flux Driven by Thermal Fluctuations?
• Using gravitational-wave standard sirens
• Properties and astrophysical implications of the 150 Msun binary black hole merger GW190521
• Rapid and Bright Stellar-mass Binary Black Hole Mergers in Active Galactic Nuclei
• A 2 per cent Hubble constant measurement from standard sirens within 5 years
• Candidate Electromagnetic Counterpart to the Binary Black Hole Merger Gravitational Wave Event S190521g
• Rapid Bayesian position reconstruction for gravitational-wave transients
• Formation and Evolution of Compact Object Binaries in AGN Disks
• Intermediate mass black holes in AGN disks: I. Production & Growth
• The Bolometric Quasar Luminosity Function at z = 0-7
• Are merging black holes born from stellar collapse or previous mergers?
• On stellar-mass black hole mergers in AGN disks detectable with LIGO
• First measurement of the Hubble constant from a dark standard siren using the Dark Energy Survey galaxies and the LIGO/Virgo binary-black-hole merger GW170814
• Hierarchical Black Hole Mergers in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Inference of the cosmological parameters from gravitational waves: application to second generation interferometers
• Are LIGO's Black Holes Made From Smaller Black Holes?
• GW190521 as a merger of Proca stars: a potential new vector boson of $8.7\times 10^{-13}$ eV
• Going the Distance: Mapping Host Galaxies of LIGO and Virgo Sources in Three Dimensions Using Local Cosmography and Targeted Follow-up
• Active Galactic Nuclei in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: II. Emission-Line Luminosity Function
• Intermediate mass black holes in AGN disks II. Model predictions & observational constraints
• Ram-pressure stripping of a kicked Hill sphere: Prompt electromagnetic emission from the merger of stellar mass black holes in an AGN accretion disk
• Are the Variability Properties of the Kepler AGN Light Curves Consistent with a Damped Random Walk?
• Revisiting Stochastic Variability of AGNs with Structure Functions
• Understanding extreme quasar optical variability with CRTS: I. Major AGN flares
• The Kepler Light Curves of AGN: A Detailed Analysis
• A statistical standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant from the LIGO/Virgo gravitational wave compact object merger GW190814 and Dark Energy Survey galaxies
• Black Hole Formation in the Lower Mass Gap through Mergers and Accretion in AGN Disks
• Supplement: Going the Distance: Mapping Host Galaxies of LIGO and Virgo Sources in Three Dimensions Using Local Cosmography and Targeted Follow-up
• Gravitational-Wave Localization Alone Probes AGN Origin of Stellar-Mass Black Hole Mergers
• AT 2017gbl: a dust obscured TDE candidate in a luminous infrared galaxy
• Properties of AGN Multiband Optical Variability in the HSC SSP Transient Survey
• GW190521 from the Merger of Ultra-Dwarf Galaxies
• A DECam Search for Explosive Optical Transients Associated with IceCube Neutrinos
• LIGO tells us LINERs are not optically thick RIAFs

Cited by in corpus (47)

• GWTC-3: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the Second Part of the Third Observing Run
• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• Hierarchical mergers of stellar-mass black holes and their gravitational-wave signatures
• Constraints on the cosmic expansion history from GWTC-3
• Forecasting the detection capabilities of third-generation gravitational-wave detectors using $\text{GWFAST}$
• Cosmology in the dark: On the importance of source population models for gravitational-wave cosmology
• A light in the dark: searching for electromagnetic counterparts to black hole-black hole mergers in LIGO/Virgo O3 with the Zwicky Transient Facility
• A standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant using gravitational wave events from the first three LIGO/Virgo observing runs and the DESI Legacy Survey
• A detailed analysis of GW190521 with phenomenological waveform models
• Hydrodynamical Evolution of Black-Hole Binaries Embedded in AGN Discs
• The Hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy catalog approach for gravitational wave cosmology
• Accretion-modified Stars in Accretion Disks of Active Galactic Nuclei: Gravitational Wave Bursts and Electromagnetic Counterparts from Merging Stellar Black Hole Binaries
• Cosmology and modified gravitational wave propagation from binary black hole population models
• Hydrodynamical Simulations of Black-Hole Binary Formation in AGN Disks
• Gravitational Wave Astronomy With TianQin
• Observable signature of merging stellar-mass black holes in active galactic nuclei
• Target of Opportunity Observations of Gravitational Wave Events with Vera C. Rubin Observatory
• Supercritical accretion of stellar-mass compact objects in active galactic nuclei
• Quiescent and active galactic nuclei as factories of merging compact objects in the era of gravitational-wave astronomy
• The Effect of Thermal Torques on AGN Disc Migration Traps and Gravitational Wave Populations
• Compact Binary Coalescences: Astrophysical Processes and Lessons Learned
• Contracting and Expanding Binary Black Holes in 3D Low-Mass AGN Disks: The Importance of Separation
• Probing lens-induced gravitational-wave birefringence as a test of general relativity
• Ready-to-use analytic model for gravitational waves from a hierarchical triple with Kozai-Lidov oscillations
• Constraining cosmological extra dimensions with gravitational wave standard sirens: from theory to current and future multi-messenger observations
• Investigating the Nature of the Luminous Ambiguous Nuclear Transient ASASSN-17jz
• Interplay of spin-precession and higher harmonics in the parameter estimation of binary black holes
• Swift/UVOT follow-up of Gravitational Wave Alerts in the O3 era
• Optical Emission Model for Binary Black Hole Merger Remnants Travelling through Discs of Active Galactic Nuclei
• Mapping the Likelihood of GW190521 with Diverse Mass and Spin Priors
• Inferring host-galaxy properties of LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA's black holes
• Frequency- and polarization-dependent lensing of gravitational waves in strong gravitational fields
• AGN flares as counterparts to LIGO/Virgo mergers: No confident causal connection in spatial correlation analysis
• Multi-messenger Gravitational Lensing
• Constraining the AGN formation channel for detected black hole binary mergers up to z=1.5 with the Quaia catalogue
• A Standard Siren Cosmological Measurement from the Potential GW190521 Electromagnetic Counterpart ZTF19abanrhr
• Determining the Hubble Constant with AGN-assisted Black Hole Mergers
• Luminosity distance uncertainties from gravitational wave detections by third generation observatories
• Multimessenger hierarchical triple merger gravitational-wave event pair GW190514-GW190521 inside AGN J124942.3 + 344929
• Unveiling the Universe with Emerging Cosmological Probes
• Estimating Hubble Constant with Gravitational Observations: A Concise Review
• On the Formation of GW190521-like Binary Black Hole Merger Systems
• Are all models wrong? Falsifying binary formation models in gravitational-wave astronomy
• Not all roads lead to merger: AGN disc properties influence the interactions of highly unequal mass black holes
• Mass function of stellar black holes as revealed by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA observations
• Effects of an Immortal Stellar Population in AGN Disks
• Identifying Host Galaxies of Binary Black Hole Mergers with Next-Generation Gravitational Wave Detector Networks