Mapping the Likelihood of GW190521 with Diverse Mass and Spin Priors

Abstract

We map the likelihood of GW190521, the heaviest detected binary black hole (BBH) merger, by sampling under different mass and spin priors designed to be uninformative. We find that a source-frame total mass of $\sim$$150M_{\odot }$ is consistently supported, but posteriors in mass ratio and spin depend critically on the choice of priors. We confirm that the likelihood has a multi-modal structure with peaks in regions of mass ratio representing very different astrophysical scenarios. The unequal-mass region ($m_2/m_1<0.3$) has an average likelihood $\sim$$e^6$ times larger than the equal-mass region and a maximum likelihood $\sim$$e^2$ larger. Using ensembles of samples across priors, we examine the implications of qualitatively different BBH sources that fit the data. We find that the equal-mass solution has poorly constrained spins and at least one black hole mass that is difficult to form via stellar collapse due to (pulsational) pair instability. The unequal-mass solution can avoid this mass gap entirely but requires a negative effective spin and a precessing primary. Both of these scenarios are more easily produced by dynamical formation channels than field binary co-evolution. Drawing representative samples from each region of the likelihood map, we find a sensitive comoving volume-time $\mathcal{O}(10)$ times larger in the mass gap region than the gap-avoiding region. Accounting for this distance effect, the likelihood still reverses the advantage to favor the gap-avoiding scenario by a factor of $\mathcal{O}(100)$ before including mass and spin priors. Posterior samplers can be driven away from this high-likelihood region by common prior choices meant to be uninformative, making GW190521 parameter inference sensitive to the choice of mass and spin priors. This may be a generic issue for similarly heavy events given current detector sensitivity and waveform degeneracies.

arXiv comment14 pages, 11 figures, 2 tables, latest version has minor updates to match the version published in Physical Review D

References in corpus (75)

• Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
• GWTC-1: A Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog of Compact Binary Mergers Observed by LIGO and Virgo during the First and Second Observing Runs
• MultiNest: an efficient and robust Bayesian inference tool for cosmology and particle physics
• GWTC-2: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the First Half of the Third Observing Run
• Multimodal nested sampling: an efficient and robust alternative to MCMC methods for astronomical data analysis
• The Nucleosynthetic Signature of Population III
• X-ray spectral modelling of the AGN obscuring region in the CDFS: Bayesian model selection and catalogue
• GW190521: A Binary Black Hole Merger with a Total Mass of $150M_{\odot }$
• Importance Nested Sampling and the MultiNest Algorithm
• Binary Black Hole Population Properties Inferred from the First and Second Observing Runs of Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo
• Pulsational Pair-Instability Supernovae
• Pulsational pair instability as an explanation for the most luminous supernovae
• Properties and astrophysical implications of the 150 Msun binary black hole merger GW190521
• Computationally efficient models for the dominant and sub-dominant harmonic modes of precessing binary black holes
• Production of Intermediate-Mass Black Holes in Globular Clusters
• Candidate Electromagnetic Counterpart to the Binary Black Hole Merger Gravitational Wave Event S190521g
• The Effect of Pair-Instability Mass Loss on Black Hole Mergers
• Mind the gap: The location of the lower edge of the pair instability supernovae black hole mass gap
• Spinning-black-hole binaries: The orbital hang up
• Illuminating Black Hole Binary Formation Channels with Spins in Advanced LIGO
• Black Holes: The Next Generation -- Repeated Mergers in Dense Star Clusters and their Gravitational-Wave Properties
• Merging black hole binaries: the effects of progenitor's metallicity, mass-loss rate and Eddington factor
• Hierarchical Black Hole Mergers in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Post-Newtonian Dynamics in Dense Star Clusters: Highly-Eccentric, Highly-Spinning, and Repeated Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Post-Newtonian Dynamics in Dense Star Clusters: Formation, Masses, and Merger Rates of Highly-Eccentric Black Hole Binaries
• The origin of spin in binary black holes: Predicting the distributions of the main observables of Advanced LIGO
• A Highly Spinning and Aligned Binary Black Hole Merger in the Advanced LIGO First Observing Run
• Tidal Deformation and Dissipation of Rotating Black Holes
• Formation of GW190521 from stellar evolution: the impact of the hydrogen-rich envelope, dredge-up and ${}^{12}$C($\alpha$, $\gamma$)${}^{16}$O rate on the pair-instability black hole mass gap
• Hierarchical black hole mergers in young, globular and nuclear star clusters: the effect of metallicity, spin and cluster properties
• Evidence for hierarchical black hole mergers in the second LIGO--Virgo gravitational-wave catalog
• Monte-Carlo simulations of black hole mergers in AGN disks: Low ${\chi }_{\mathrm{eff}}$ mergers and predictions for LIGO
• Populating the upper black hole mass gap through stellar collisions in young star clusters
• Impact of the Rotation and Compactness of Progenitors on the Mass of Black Holes
• Mass-gap Mergers in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Binary black holes in young star clusters: the impact of metallicity
• Eccentric Black Hole Mergers in Active Galactic Nuclei
• On the Vanishing of Love Numbers for Kerr Black Holes
• Constraints on Binary Black Hole Populations from LIGO-Virgo Detections
• Hierarchical Black-Hole Mergers in Multiple Systems: Constrain the Formation of GW190412, GW190814 and GW190521-like events
• Minding the gap: GW190521 as a straddling binary
• GW190521 may be an intermediate mass ratio inspiral
• Distribution of Effective Spins and Masses of Binary Black Holes from the LIGO and Virgo O1-O3a Observing Runs
• The cosmic merger rate density evolution of compact binaries formed in young star clusters and in isolated binaries
• On the Origin of GW190521-like events from repeated black hole mergers in star clusters
• Aligning Nuclear Cluster Orbits with an Active Galactic Nucleus Accretion Disk
• Mass ejection by pulsational pair instability in very massive stars and implications for luminous supernovae
• Intermediate-mass Black Holes from High Massive-star Binary Fractions in Young Star Clusters
• The most ordinary formation of the most unusual double black hole merger
• Is GW190521 the merger of black holes from the first stellar generations?
• Confusing Head-On Collisions with Precessing Intermediate-Mass Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Binary black hole mergers: formation and populations
• Impact of Bayesian prior on the characterization of binary black hole coalescences
• Population III Binary Black Holes: Effects of Convective Overshooting on Formation of GW190521
• Orbital Migration of Interacting Stellar Mass Black Holes in Disks around Supermassive Black Holes II. Spins and Incoming Objects
• Massive Stellar Triples Leading to Sequential Binary Black-Hole Mergers in the Field
• Spin-Orbit Misalignment of Merging Black-Hole Binaries with Tertiary Companions
• Higher order gravitational-wave modes with likelihood reweighting
• Do LIGO/Virgo black hole mergers produce AGN flares? The case of GW190521 and prospects for reaching a confident association
• High Eccentricities and High Masses Characterize Gravitational-wave Captures in Galactic Nuclei as Seen by Earth-based Detectors
• Detecting Gravitational Waves in Data with Non-Gaussian Noise
• Binary Black Hole Mergers from LIGO/Virgo O1 and O2: Population Inference Combining Confident and Marginal Events
• A generalized precession parameter ${\chi }_{\mathrm{p}}$ to interpret gravitational-wave data
• The Population III origin of GW190521
• Pair Instability Supernovae of Very Massive Population III Stars
• The Stellar Merger Scenario for Black Holes in the Pair-instability Gap
• A trend in the effective spin distribution of LIGO binary black holes with mass
• Template Bank for Compact Binary Coalescence Searches in Gravitational Wave Data: A General Geometric Placement Algorithm
• Find the Gap: Black Hole Population Analysis with an Astrophysically Motivated Mass Function
• Poking Holes: Looking for Gaps in LIGO/Virgo's Black Hole Population
• Evolution of binary black holes in AGN accretion discs: Disc-binary interaction and gravitational wave emission
• Source properties of the lowest signal-to-noise-ratio binary black hole detections
• Growth of stellar mass black holes in dense molecular clouds and GW190521
• Search for Black Hole Merger Families
• GW190521 formation scenarios via relativistic accretion

Cited by in corpus (7)

• New binary black hole mergers in the LIGO--Virgo O3a data
• Signs of eccentricity in two gravitational-wave signals may indicate a sub-population of dynamically assembled binary black holes
• Removing degeneracy and multimodality in gravitational wave source parameters
• Interplay of spin-precession and higher harmonics in the parameter estimation of binary black holes
• Frequency- and polarization-dependent lensing of gravitational waves in strong gravitational fields
• Signs of Higher Multipoles and Orbital Precession in GW151226
• Deep follow-up for gravitational-wave inference: a case study with GW151226