A Temporary Epoch of Stalled Spin-Down for Low-Mass Stars: Insights from NGC 6811 with Gaia and Kepler

Abstract

Stellar rotation was proposed as a potential age diagnostic that is precise, simple, and applicable to a broad range of low-mass stars ($\le$1 $M_{\odot }$). Unfortunately, rotation period $(P_{\mathrm{rot}})$ measurements of low-mass members of open clusters have undermined the idea that stars spin down with a common age dependence (i.e., $P_{\mathrm{rot}}\propto \sqrt{\mathrm{age}}$): K dwarfs appear to spin down more slowly than F and G dwarfs. Agüeros et al. (2018) interpreted data for the $\approx$1.4-Gyr-old cluster NGC 752 differently, proposing that after having converged onto a slow-rotating sequence in their first 600-700 Myr (by the age of Praesepe), K dwarf $P_{\mathrm{rot}}$ stall on that sequence for an extended period of time. We use data from Gaia DR2 to identify likely single-star members of the $\approx$1-Gyr-old cluster NGC 6811 with Kepler light curves. We measure $P_{\mathrm{rot}}$ for 171 members, more than doubling the sample relative to the existing catalog and extending the mass limit from $\approx$0.8 to $\approx$0.6 $M_{\odot }$. We then apply a gyrochronology formula calibrated with Praesepe and the Sun to 27 single G dwarfs in NGC 6811 to derive a precise gyrochronological age for the cluster of 1.04$\pm$0.07 Gyr. However, when our new low-mass rotators are included, NGC 6811's color-$P_{\mathrm{rot}}$ sequence deviates away from the naive 1 Gyr projection down to $T_{\mathrm{eff}}\approx 4295$ K (K5V, 0.7 $M_{\odot }$), where it clearly overlaps with Praesepe's. Combining these data with $P_{\mathrm{rot}}$ for other clusters, we conclude that the assumption that mass and age are separable dependencies is invalid. Furthermore, the cluster data show definitively that stars experience a temporary epoch of reduced braking efficiency where $P_{\mathrm{rot}}$ stall, and that the duration of this epoch lasts longer for lower-mass stars.

arXiv comment18 pages, 8 figures, 1 table

References in corpus (47)

• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the PAdova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code
• The SIMBAD astronomical database
• The VizieR database of Astronomical Catalogues
• The Palomar Transient Factory: System Overview, Performance and First Results
• Kepler Presearch Data Conditioning II - A Bayesian Approach to Systematic Error Correction
• Ages for illustrative field stars using gyrochronology: viability, limitations and errors
• Kepler Presearch Data Conditioning I - Architecture and Algorithms for Error Correction in Kepler Light Curves
• Gaia Data Release 2: Photometric content and validation
• Exploring the Optical Transient Sky with the Palomar Transient Factory
• Rotation Periods of 34,030 Kepler Main-Sequence Stars: The Full Autocorrelation Sample
• How to Constrain Your M Dwarf: measuring effective temperature, bolometric luminosity, mass, and radius
• On the rotational evolution of solar- and late-type stars, its magnetic origins, and the possibility of stellar gyrochronology
• Improving PARSEC models for very low mass stars
• Stellar Diameters and Temperatures II. Main Sequence K & M Stars
• The Ages of Stars
• Gaia Data Release 2: first stellar parameters from Apsis
• Galactic Reddening in 3D from Stellar Photometry - An Improved Map
• Weakened magnetic braking as the origin of anomalously rapid rotation in old field stars
• Improved angular momentum evolution model for solar-like stars
• Spectral Properties of Cool Stars: Extended Abundance Analysis of 1617 Planet Search Stars
• The Stellar Populations of Praesepe and Coma Berenices
• A Robust Measure of Tidal Circularization in Coeval Binary Populations: The solar-type spectroscopic Binary Population in The Open Cluster M35
• A spin-down clock for cool stars from observations of a 2.5-billion-year-old cluster
• The Kepler Cluster Study: Stellar Rotation in NGC6811
• Stellar Rotation in M35: Mass-Period Relations, Spin-Down Rates, and Gyrochronology
• Rotation in the Pleiades with K2: I. Data and First Results
• Improved angular momentum evolution model for solar-like stars II. Exploring the mass dependence
• Fast Star, Slow Star; Old Star, Young Star: Subgiant Rotation as a Population and Stellar Physics Diagnostic
• Calibrating Gyrochronology using Kepler Asteroseismic targets
• Lithium depletion and the rotational history of exoplanet host stars
• The Age and Age Spread of the Praesepe and Hyades Clusters: a Consistent, ~800 Myr Picture from Rotating Stellar Models
• The Gaia astrophysical parameters inference system (Apsis). Pre-launch description
• The Color-Period Diagram and Stellar Rotational Evolution - New Rotation Period Measurements in the Open Cluster M34
• Angular Momentum Transport In Solar-Type Stars: Testing the Timescale For Core-Envelope Coupling
• Poking the Beehive From Space: K2 Rotation Periods For Praesepe
• K2 Rotation Periods for low-mass Hyads and the Implications for Gyrochronology
• A New Look at an Old Cluster: The Membership, Rotation, and Magnetic Activity of Low-Mass Stars in the 1.3-Gyr-Old Open Cluster NGC 752
• Rotational evolution of slow-rotators sequence stars
• The Effect of Binarity on Stellar Rotation - Beyond the Reach of Tides
• Ruprecht 147: The oldest nearby open cluster as a new benchmark for stellar astrophysics
• The Age and Distance of the Kepler Open Cluster NGC 6811 from an Eclipsing Binary, Turnoff Star Pulsation, and Giant Asteroseismology
• Identification of the Lithium Depletion Boundary and Age of the Southern Open Cluster Blanco 1
• Evaluating Gyrochronology on the Zero-Age-Main-Sequence: Rotation Periods in the Southern Open Cluster Blanco 1 from the KELT-South Survey
• A uvbyCaHbeta Analysis of the Old Open Cluster, NGC 6819
• Eclipsing binaries in the open cluster Ruprecht 147. I: EPIC 219394517
• Are Starspots and Plages Co-Located on Active G and K Stars?

Cited by in corpus (86)

• The active lives of stars: a complete description of rotation and XUV evolution of F, G, K, and M dwarfs
• When Do Stalled Stars Resume Spinning Down? Advancing Gyrochronology with Ruprecht 147
• Towards precise stellar ages: combining isochrone fitting with empirical gyrochronology
• On the competing effect of wind braking and interior coupling in the rotational evolution of solar-like stars
• Stellar rotation periods from K2 Campaigns 0-18 -- Evidence for rotation period bimodality and simultaneous variability decrease
• WASP-107b's density is even lower: a case study for the physics of planetary gas envelope accretion and orbital migration
• TESS reveals that the nearby Pisces-Eridanus stellar stream is only 120 Myr old
• Relation of X-ray activity and rotation in M dwarfs and predicted time-evolution of the X-ray luminosity
• The Empirical Limits of Gyrochronology
• TOI-1136 is a Young, Coplanar, Aligned Planetary System in a Pristine Resonant Chain
• Stellar Rotation in the Gaia Era: Revised Open Clusters Sequences
• Cluster Difference Imaging Photometric Survey. II. TOI 837: A Young Validated Planet in IC 2602
• Chemical Evolution in the Milky Way: Rotation-based ages for APOGEE-Kepler cool dwarf stars
• Evaluating Rotation Periods of M Dwarfs Across the Ages
• Stellar Rotation in the K2 Sample: Evidence for Modified Spindown
• A Relationship Between Stellar Age and Spot Coverage
• A 4 Gyr M-dwarf Gyrochrone from CFHT/MegaPrime Monitoring of the Open Cluster M67
• The Origin of Weakened Magnetic Braking in Old Solar Analogs
• Exploring the evolution of stellar rotation using Galactic kinematics
• Rotation and Lithium Confirmation of a 500 Parsec Halo for the Open Cluster NGC 2516
• Gyro-Kinematic Ages for around 30,000 Kepler Stars
• Bridging the gap -- the disappearance of the intermediate period gap for fully convective stars, uncovered by new ZTF rotation periods
• Rotation periods for cool stars in the open cluster NGC 3532. The transition from fast to slow rotation
• Further Evidence of Modified Spin-down in Sun-like Stars: Pileups in the Temperature-Period Distribution
• The TESS Grand Unified Hot Jupiter Survey. II. Twenty New Giant Planets
• Rotation Distributions around the Kraft Break with TESS and Kepler: The Influences of Age, Metallicity, and Binarity
• Untangling the Galaxy. IV. Empirical Constraints on Angular Momentum Evolution and Gyrochronology for Young Stars in the Field
• TESS observations of the Pleiades cluster: a nursery for delta Scuti stars
• The TIME Table: Rotation and Ages of Cool Exoplanet Host Stars
• MESA models with magnetic braking
• The influence of the environment on the spin evolution of low-mass stars. I. External photoevaporation of circumstellar disks
• Mutual Inclination Excitation by Stellar Oblateness
• Stellar Rotation and Structure of the $\alpha$ Persei Complex: When Does Gyrochronology Start to Work?
• Magnetic activity evolution of solar-like stars: I. S_ph-Age relation derived from Kepler observations
• Are WASP-107-like Systems Consistent with High-eccentricity Migration?
• Magnetic braking with MESA evolutionary models in the single star and LMXB regimes
• Rotation periods for cool stars in the open cluster Ruprecht 147 (NGC 6774): Implications for gyrochronology
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs: Spectroscopic orbits of nine M-dwarf multiple systems, including two triples, two brown dwarf candidates, and one close M-dwarf-white dwarf binary
• Confirmation of an He I evaporating atmosphere around the 650-Myr-old sub-Neptune HD235088 b (TOI-1430 b) with CARMENES
• NEID Rossiter-McLaughlin Measurement of TOI-1268b: A Young Warm Saturn Aligned with Its Cool Host Star
• HAZMAT. VIII. A Spectroscopic Analysis of the Ultraviolet Evolution of K Stars: Additional Evidence for K Dwarf Rotational Stalling in the First Gigayear
• ALMA Images the Eccentric HD 53143 Debris Disk
• TOI-1268b: the youngest, hot, Saturn-mass transiting exoplanet
• TOI-1259Ab -- a gas giant planet with 2.7% deep transits and a bound white dwarf companion
• New insights into the rotational evolution of near-solar age stars from the open cluster M67
• HAZMAT. IX. An Analysis of the UV and X-Ray Evolution of Low-Mass Stars in the Era of Gaia
• Rotation at the Fully Convective Boundary: Insights from Wide WD + MS Binary Systems
• The Solar Wind Angular Momentum Flux as Observed by Parker Solar Probe
• Kepler meets Gaia DR3: homogeneous extinction-corrected color-magnitude diagram and binary classification
• TOI-1801 b: A temperate mini-Neptune around a young M0.5 dwarf
• TOI-4562 b: A highly eccentric temperate Jupiter analog orbiting a young field star
• Constraining Tidal Quality Factor using Spin Period in Eclipsing Binaries
• Interior heating of rocky exoplanets from stellar flares with application to TRAPPIST-1
• Kepler main-sequence solar-like stars: surface rotation and magnetic-activity evolution
• A collage of small planets from the Lick Carnegie Exoplanet Survey : Exploring the super-Earth and sub-Neptune mass regime
• The Contribution of Alpha Particles to the Solar Wind Angular Momentum Flux in the Inner Heliosphere
• Is [Y/Mg] a Reliable Age Diagnostic for FGK Stars?
• Wide binaries demonstrate the consistency of rotational evolution between open cluster and field stars
• The breakdown of current gyrochronology as evidenced by old coeval stars
• A rotational age for the open cluster NGC 2281
• Revisiting the HD 21749 Planetary System with Stellar Activity Modeling
• Signature of spin-down stalling in stellar magnetic activity. The case of the open cluster NGC 6811
• Accounting for Differential Rotation in Calculations of the Sun's Angular Momentum-loss Rate
• TOI-712: a system of adolescent mini-Neptunes extending to the habitable zone
• HD 183579b: A Warm Sub-Neptune Transiting a Solar Twin Detected by TESS
• The Impact of Tidal Migration of Hot Jupiters on the Rotation of Sun-like Main-sequence Stars
• Sub-stellar engulfment by a main sequence star: where is the lithium?
• A Monte Carlo Method for Evaluating Empirical Gyrochronology Models and its Application to Wide Binary Benchmarks
• Tidal excitation of autoresonant oscillations in stars with close-by planets
• Testing the Rossby Paradigm: Weakened Magnetic Braking in early K-type Stars
• Rotational evolution of young-to-old stars with data-driven three-dimensional wind models
• ChronoFlow: A Data-Driven Model for Gyrochronology
• Photometric activity cycles in fast-rotating stars: Revisiting the reality of stellar activity cycle branches
• Asteroseismic analysis of eight solar-like oscillating evolved stars in the open cluster NGC 6811
• Four ages of rotating stars in the rotation--activity relationship and gyrochronology
• Unravelling the Period Gap using LAMOST Chromospheric Activity Indices
• Spindown of massive main sequence stars in the Milky Way
• The Proxima Centauri Campaign -- First Constraints On Millimeter Flare Rates from ALMA
• The Evolution of the Solar-Stellar Activity
• A modest change in magnetic braking at the fully convective boundary explains cataclysmic variable evolution
• Lost Sisters Found: TESS and Gaia Reveal a Dissolving Pleiades Complex
• Towards a holistic magnetic braking model -- II: explaining several long-term internal- and surface-spin properties of solar-like stars and the Sun
• Perspectives on the Physics of Late-Type Stars from Beyond Low Earth Orbit, the Moon and Mars
• New constraints on the minimum mass for thermonuclear lithium burning in brown dwarfs
• Constraints on the Spindown of Fully-Convective M Dwarfs Using Wide Field Binaries
• Transit Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) VIII: a Pleiades-age association harboring two transiting planetary systems from Kepler