Comparing galaxy formation in semi-analytic models and hydrodynamical simulations

Abstract

It is now possible for hydrodynamical simulations to reproduce a representative galaxy population. Accordingly, it is timely to assess critically some of the assumptions of traditional semi-analytic galaxy formation models. We use the Eagle simulations to assess assumptions built into the Galform semi-analytic model, focussing on those relating to baryon cycling, angular momentum and feedback. We show that the assumption in Galform that newly formed stars have the same specific angular momentum as the total disc leads to a significant overestimate of the total stellar specific angular momentum of disc galaxies. In Eagle, stars form preferentially out of low specific angular momentum gas in the interstellar medium (ISM) due to the assumed gas density threshold for stars to form, leading to more realistic galaxy sizes. We find that stellar mass assembly is similar between Galform and Eagle but that the evolution of gas properties is different, with various indications that the rate of baryon cycling in Eagle is slower than is assumed in Galform. Finally, by matching individual galaxies between Eagle and Galform, we find that an artificial dependence of AGN feedback and gas infall rates on halo mass doubling events in Galform drives most of the scatter in stellar mass between individual objects. Put together our results suggest that the Galform semi-analytic model can be significantly improved in light of recent advances.

some references corrected, 31 pages, 19 figures, submitted to MNRAS after responding to a first referee report

References in corpus (104)

• Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters
• Simulating the joint evolution of quasars, galaxies and their large-scale distribution
• The many lives of active galactic nuclei: cooling flows, black holes and the luminosities and colours of galaxies
• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• Populating a cluster of galaxies - I. Results at z=0
• The broken hierarchy of galaxy formation
• Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
• The Average Star Formation Histories of Galaxies in Dark Matter Halos from z=0-8
• Hierarchical Galaxy Formation
• The Star Formation Efficiency in Nearby Galaxies: Measuring Where Gas Forms Stars Effectively
• On the Black Hole Mass - Bulge Mass Relation
• The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: calibration of subgrid physics and model variations
• Galactic star formation and accretion histories from matching galaxies to dark matter haloes
• 3D-HST+CANDELS: The Evolution of the Galaxy Size-Mass Distribution since $z=3$
• Revisiting the Scaling Relations of Black Hole Masses and Host Galaxy Properties
• From dwarf spheroidals to cDs: Simulating the galaxy population in a LCDM cosmology
• Constraints on the relationship between stellar mass and halo mass at low and high redshift
• The size distribution of galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• A Semi-Analytic Model for the Co-evolution of Galaxies, Black Holes, and Active Galactic Nuclei
• Substructures in hydrodynamical cluster simulations
• The effect of photo-ionization on the cooling rates of enriched, astrophysical plasmas
• The Halo Occupation Distribution: Towards an Empirical Determination of the Relation Between Galaxies and Mass
• What Shapes the Luminosity Function of Galaxies?
• Dancing in the dark: galactic properties trace spin swings along the cosmic web
• Cosmological simulations of the growth of supermassive black holes and feedback from active galactic nuclei: method and tests
• The Galactic disk mass function: reconciliation of the HST and nearby determinations
• The physics driving the cosmic star formation history
• A Recipe for Galaxy Formation Shaun Cole
• Modeling Luminosity-Dependent Galaxy Clustering Through Cosmic Time
• Chemical enrichment in cosmological, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
• On the relation between the Schmidt and Kennicutt-Schmidt star formation laws and its implications for numerical simulations
• Gusty, gaseous flows of FIRE: galactic winds in cosmological simulations with explicit stellar feedback
• The Role of Pressure in GMC Formation II: The H_2 - Pressure Relation
• Star formation thresholds and galaxy edges: why and where
• Simulating galactic outflows with thermal supernova feedback
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: The dependence of galaxy clustering on luminosity and spectral type
• COLD GASS, an IRAM legacy survey of molecular gas in massive galaxies: I. Relations between H2, HI, stellar content and structural properties
• On the evolution of the HI column density distribution in cosmological simulations
• Feedback and Recycled Wind Accretion: Assembling the z=0 Galaxy Mass Function
• A unified multi-wavelength model of galaxy formation
• The Cosmic Baryon Cycle and Galaxy Mass Assembly in the FIRE Simulations
• The GALEX Arecibo SDSS Survey. I. Gas Fraction Scaling Relations of Massive Galaxies and First Data Release
• A Constant Molecular Gas Depletion Time in Nearby Disk Galaxies
• Evolution of galaxy stellar masses and star formation rates in the EAGLE simulations
• The distribution of stellar mass in the low-redshift Universe
• Baryon effects on the internal structure of LCDM halos in the EAGLE simulations
• Towards a realistic population of simulated galaxy groups and clusters
• MUFASA: Galaxy Formation Simulations With Meshless Hydrodynamics
• The Colours of Satellite Galaxies in Groups and Clusters
• The dark nemesis of galaxy formation: why hot haloes trigger black hole growth and bring star formation to an end
• The impact of angular momentum on black hole accretion rates in simulations of galaxy formation
• Angular momentum and galaxy formation revisited
• The Baryon Content of Cosmic Structures
• Semi-Analytic Galaxy Evolution (SAGE): Model Calibration and Basic Results
• Colours and luminosities of z=0.1 simulated galaxies in the EAGLE simulations
• The MORGANA model for the rise of galaxies and active nuclei
• Simulations of the galaxy population constrained by observations from z=3 to the present day: implications for galactic winds and the fate of their ejecta
• The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: the importance of the hydrodynamics scheme
• Evolution of the angular momentum of protogalaxies from tidal torques: Zel'dovich approximation
• In-N-Out: the gas cycle from dwarfs to spiral galaxies
• Cold gas properties of the Herschel Reference Survey. II. Molecular and total gas scaling relations
• Galaxy assembly, stellar feedback and metal enrichment: the view from the GAEA model
• A new model of galaxy formation: How sensitive are predicted galaxy luminosities to the choice of SPS model?
• N-body Dark Matter Haloes with simple Hierarchical Histories
• An Explanation for the Observed Weak Size Evolution of Disk Galaxies
• Angular momentum evolution of galaxies in EAGLE
• On the impact of empirical and theoretical star formation laws on galaxy formation
• What Shapes the Galaxy Mass Function? Exploring the Roles of Supernova-Driven Winds and AGN
• The EAGLE simulations: atomic hydrogen associated with galaxies
• Dark matter haloes determine the masses of supermassive black holes
• Black Hole Growth in Hierarchical Galaxy Formation
• Fundamental Mass-Spin-Morphology Relation of Spiral Galaxies
• The origin of scatter in the stellar mass - halo mass relation of central galaxies in the EAGLE simulation
• The flip-side of galaxy formation: A combined model of Galaxy Formation and Cluster Heating
• Second-order Lagrangian perturbation theory initial conditions for resimulations
• Galaxy formation using halo merger histories taken from N-body simulations
• The Effect of Structure and Star Formation on the Gas Content of Nearby Galaxies
• Modelling Element Abundances in Semi-analytic Models of Galaxy Formation
• ALLSMOG: an APEX Low-redshift Legacy Survey for MOlecular Gas. I - molecular gas scaling relations, and the effect of the CO/H2 conversion factor
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): The 0.013 < z < 0.1 cosmic spectral energy distribution from 0.1 micron to 1mm
• CARMA Survey Toward Infrared-bright Nearby Galaxies (STING) II: Molecular Gas Star Formation Law and Depletion Time Across the Blue Sequence
• Gas cooling in simulations of the formation of the galaxy population
• Galaxies in the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulation and in the Durham and Munich semi-analytical models
• Galaxy Formation Spanning Cosmic History
• Accretion, feedback and galaxy bimodality: a comparison of the GalICS semi-analytic model and cosmological SPH simulations
• Elemental Abundances in Milky Way-like Galaxies from a Hierarchical Galaxy Formation Model
• Large-scale mass distribution in the Illustris simulation
• Galaxy formation in semi-analytic models and cosmological hydrodynamic zoom simulations
• A dynamical model of supernova feedback: gas outflows from the interstellar medium
• Ram pressure stripping in a galaxy formation model. I. A novel numerical approach
• How to get cool in the heat: comparing analytic models of hot, cold, and cooling gas in haloes and galaxies with EAGLE
• The evolution of the star forming sequence in hierarchical galaxy formation models
• Cosmological Galaxy Evolution with Superbubble Feedback II: The Limits of Supernovae
• Building a Predictive Model of Galaxy Formation - I: Phenomenological Model Constrained to the $z=0$ Stellar Mass Function
• The evolution of the stellar mass versus halo mass relationship
• Modelling Galaxy Merger Timescales and Tidal Destruction
• Constraints on galaxy formation models from the galaxy stellar mass function and its evolution
• Bayesian inferences of galaxy formation from the K-band luminosity and HI mass functions of galaxies: constraining star formation and feedback
• A parametric study of possible solutions to the high-redshift overproduction of stars in modeled dwarf galaxies
• The metallicity of galactic winds
• Hydrodynamical simulations and semi-analytic models of galaxy formation: two sides of the same coin
• Gas cooling in semi-analytic models and SPH simulations: are results consistent?
• A semi-analytic model comparison: testing cooling models against hydrodynamical simulations
• Analytic and numerical realisations of a disk galaxy

Cited by in corpus (44)

• De Re Metallica: The cosmic chemical evolution of galaxies
• Shark: introducing an open source, free and flexible semi-analytic model of galaxy formation
• Galactic outflow rates in the EAGLE simulations
• Atomic hydrogen in IllustrisTNG galaxies: the impact of environment parallelled with local 21-cm surveys
• Line-Intensity Mapping: Theory Review
• The angular momentum-mass relation: a fundamental law from dwarf irregulars to massive spirals
• Quenching timescales of galaxies in the EAGLE simulations
• Horizon-AGN virtual observatory - 1. SED-fitting performance and forecasts for future imaging surveys
• Validating Semi-Analytic Models of High-Redshift Galaxy Formation using Radiation Hydrodynamical Simulations
• The impact of stellar and AGN feedback on halo-scale baryonic and dark matter accretion in the EAGLE simulations
• Origin of the galaxy HI size-mass relation
• First results from SMAUG: The need for preventative stellar feedback and improved baryon cycling in semi-analytic models of galaxy formation
• Comparing galaxy formation in the L-GALAXIES semi-analytical model and the IllustrisTNG simulations
• The specific star formation rate function at different mass scales and quenching: A comparison between cosmological models and SDSS
• The first Super Massive Black Holes: indications from models for future observations
• Multitracer cosmological line intensity mapping mock lightcone simulation
• Connecting and dissecting galaxies' angular momenta and neutral gas in a hierarchical universe: cue DARK SAGE
• Do model emission line galaxies live in filaments at z~1?
• The New Numerical Galaxy Catalogue (ν^2 GC): Properties of Active Galactic Nuclei and Their Host Galaxies
• Baryonic mass budgets for haloes in the EAGLE simulation, including ejected and prevented gas
• A Lyman limit system associated with galactic winds
• From rest-frame luminosity functions to observer-frame colour distributions: tackling the next challenge in cosmological simulations
• SH$\alpha$DE: Survey description and mass-kinematics scaling relations for dwarf galaxies
• Joint galaxy-galaxy lensing and clustering constraints on galaxy formation
• The MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Field Survey XVI. The angular momentum of low-mass star-forming galaxies. A cautionary tale and insights from TNG50
• Hybrid analytic and machine-learned baryonic property insertion into galactic dark matter haloes
• The dispersion measure and rotation measure from fast radio burst host galaxies based on the IllustrisTNG50 simulation
• Constraining the scatter in the galaxy-halo connection at Milky Way masses
• Stellar Feedback and the Energy Budget of Late-Type Galaxies: Missing Baryons and Core Creation
• The distribution and properties of DLAs at z $\le$ 2 in the EAGLE simulations
• Can a conditioning on stellar mass explain the mutual information between morphology and environment?
• Comparing galaxy morphology in hydrodynamical simulation and in semi-analytic model
• The relationship between cluster environment and molecular gas content of star-forming galaxies in the EAGLE simulation
• Evaluating the variance of individual halo properties in constrained cosmological simulations
• Machine Learning the Fates of Dark Matter Subhalos: A Fuzzy Crystal Ball
• Dark-ages Reionization and Galaxy Formation Simulation - XV. Stellar evolution and feedback in dwarf galaxies at high redshift
• Anatomy of galactic star formation history: Roles of different modes of gas accretion, feedback, and recycling
• Luminosity functions of cluster galaxies: The Near-ultraviolet luminosity function at $<z>\sim 0.05$
• Dark-ages Reionization and Galaxy Formation Simulation - XIV. Gas accretion, cooling and star formation in dwarf galaxies at high redshift
• Sensitivity analysis of a galaxy formation model
• The $K_s$-band luminosity function of the rich cluster VC04 in the Vela supercluster
• Angular momentum and morphological sequence of massive galaxies through Dark Sage
• Galaxy clustering in modified gravity from full-physics simulations. I: two-point correlation functions
• Modification of Newtonian Gravity: Implications for Hot Gas in Clusters and Galactic Angular Momentum