The observational evidence for horizons: from echoes to precision gravitational-wave physics
arXiv:1707.03021 · doi:10.1038/s41550-017-0225-y
Abstract
The existence of black holes and of spacetime singularities is a fundamental issue in science. Despite this, observations supporting their existence are scarce, and their interpretation unclear. We overview how strong a case for black holes has been made in the last few decades, and how well observations adjust to this paradigm. Unsurprisingly, we conclude that observational evidence for black holes is impossible to come by. However, just like Popper's black swan, alternatives can be ruled out or confirmed to exist with a single observation. These observations are within reach. In the next few years and decades, we will enter the era of precision gravitational-wave physics with more sensitive detectors. Just as accelerators require larger and larger energies to probe smaller and smaller scales, more sensitive gravitational-wave detectors will be probing regions closer and closer to the horizon, potentially reaching Planck scales and beyond. What may be there, lurking?
Expanded version of a "Perspectives" article submitted to Nature Astronomy arXiv:1709.01525; Superseded by arXiv:1904.05363 (invited Review article for Living Reviews in Relativity)
References in corpus (30)
- Ultralight scalars as cosmological dark matter
- Constraining neutron star tidal Love numbers with gravitational wave detectors
- Relativistic theory of tidal Love numbers
- Can environmental effects spoil precision gravitational-wave astrophysics?
- Echoes of ECOs: gravitational-wave signatures of exotic compact objects and of quantum corrections at the horizon scale
- Inspiral, merger and ring-down of equal-mass black-hole binaries
- Inspiral, merger and ringdown of unequal mass black hole binaries: a multipolar analysis
- Echoes from the Abyss: Tentative evidence for Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons
- Light rings as observational evidence for event horizons: long-lived modes, ergoregions and nonlinear instabilities of ultracompact objects
- Testing strong-field gravity with tidal Love numbers
- Wormholes as Black Hole Foils
- A recipe for echoes from exotic compact objects
- Fate of gravitational collapse in semiclassical gravity
- Ergoregion instability of ultra-compact astrophysical objects
- Distinguishing Boson Stars from Black Holes and Neutron Stars from Tidal Interactions in Inspiraling Binary Systems
- Testing the binary black hole nature of a compact binary coalescence
- Not quite a black hole
- Probing Planckian corrections at the horizon scale with LISA binaries
- Radiation from the non-extremal fuzzball
- Macroscopic Effects of the Quantum Trace Anomaly
- Exotic Compact Objects and How to Quench their Ergoregion Instability
- On the final fate of compact boson star mergers
- Tidal deformation of a slowly rotating black hole
- Gravitational echoes from macroscopic quantum gravity effects
- Black hole ringdown echoes and howls
- Gravitational wave sources: reflections and echoes
- Supermassive black holes or boson stars? Hair counting with gravitational wave detectors
- Search for gravitational wave ringdowns from perturbed black holes in LIGO S4 data
- When black holes collide: Probing the interior composition by the spectrum of ringdown modes and emitted gravitational waves
- Discovering the interior of black holes
Cited by in corpus (298)
- Science Case for the Einstein Telescope
- Testing the nature of dark compact objects: a status report
- Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
- Science with the Einstein Telescope: a comparison of different designs
- Prospects for Fundamental Physics with LISA
- Light ring stability in ultra-compact objects
- Shadow of a black hole surrounded by dark matter
- Extreme Gravity Tests with Gravitational Waves from Compact Binary Coalescences: (II) Ringdown
- New Horizons for Fundamental Physics with LISA
- Quasinormal modes and Strong Cosmic Censorship
- Black holes in galaxies: environmental impact on gravitational-wave generation and propagation
- Remnant baryon mass outside of the black hole after a neutron star-black hole merger
- Phenomenological aspects of black holes beyond general relativity
- White Holes as Remnants: A Surprising Scenario for the End of a Black Hole
- Black holes in an Effective Field Theory extension of GR
- Gravitational Wave Signatures of Highly Compact Boson Star Binaries
- Low significance of evidence for black hole echoes in gravitational wave data
- Anisotropic stars as ultracompact objects in General Relativity
- Classical properties of non-local, ghost- and singularity-free gravity
- Black hole mimicker hiding in the shadow: Optical properties of the -metric
- Probing Planckian corrections at the horizon scale with LISA binaries
- Black Hole Spectroscopy: Systematic Errors and Ringdown Energy Estimates
- Tests of General Relativity with GWTC-3
- Boson Stars and Oscillatons: A Review
- Observational evidence for cosmological coupling of black holes and its implications for an astrophysical source of dark energy
- Gravitational wave echoes through new windows
- Exotic Compact Objects and How to Quench their Ergoregion Instability
- Lensing and dynamics of ultra-compact bosonic stars
- Does the black hole shadow probe the event horizon geometry?
- Gravitational wave echoes from black hole area quantization
- Echoes in brane worlds: ringing at a black hole--wormhole transition
- Ergoregion instability of exotic compact objects: electromagnetic and gravitational perturbations and the role of absorption
- How does a dark compact object ringdown?
- Imaging compact boson stars with hot-spots and thin accretion disks
- Exotic Compact Objects and the Fate of the Light-Ring Instability
- Stability of the fundamental quasinormal mode in time-domain observations against small perturbations
- The Science of the Einstein Telescope
- Mapping Ricci-based theories of gravity into general relativity
- Echoes of compact objects: new physics near the surface and matter at a distance
- Analytical model for gravitational-wave echoes from spinning remnants
- Echoes from Quantum Black Holes
- Extended Uncertainty Principle Black Holes
- Static spherical vacuum solutions in the bumblebee gravity model
- Analytical template for gravitational-wave echoes: signal characterization and prospects of detection with current and future interferometers
- Quasinormal-mode filters: a new approach to analyze the gravitational-wave ringdown of binary black-hole mergers
- Stellar equilibrium in semiclassical gravity
- Conformally-flat, non-singular static metric in infinite derivative gravity
- Prospecting Black Hole Thermodynamics with Fractional Quantum Mechanics
- Extreme mass-ratio inspirals around a spinning horizonless compact object
- Axion boson stars
- Scalar field effects on the orbit of S2 star
- Post-Newtonian spin-tidal couplings for compact binaries
- On gravitational echoes from ultracompact exotic stars
- Multi-mode black hole spectroscopy
- A morphology-independent data analysis method for detecting and characterizing gravitational wave echoes
- Black Hole Echology: The Observer's Manual
- Wormhole Potentials and Throats from Quasi-Normal Modes
- CFT description of BH's and ECO's: QNMs, superradiance, echoes and tidal responses
- A morphology-independent search for gravitational wave echoes in data from the first and second observing runs of Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo
- Gravitational Waves from Dark Boson Star binary mergers
- Constraining black hole mimickers with gravitational wave observations
- On gravitational-wave echoes from neutron-star binary coalescences
- Ringdown stability: greybody factors as stable gravitational-wave observables
- Parameter estimation for black hole echo signals and their statistical significance
- Can we observe fuzzballs or firewalls?
- Hyperboloidal slicing approach to quasi-normal mode expansions: the Reissner-Nordström case
- Towards a Non-singular Paradigm of Black Hole Physics
- Exotic compact objects with soft hair
- Weak deflection angle of a dirty black hole
- Tidal Love Numbers of Black Holes and Neutron Stars in the Presence of Higher Dimensions: Implications of GW170817
- The stochastic gravitational-wave background in the absence of horizons
- Vector boson star solutions with a quartic order self-interaction
- Fuzzball Shadows: Emergent Horizons from Microstructure
- Nonlocal star as a blackhole mimicker
- Probing the Nature of Black Holes: Deep in the mHz Gravitational-Wave Sky
- Phenomenology of GUP stars
- Quasinormal modes and greybody factor of a Lorentz-violating black hole
- Probing hairy black holes caused by gravitational decoupling using quasinormal modes and greybody bounds
- Echoes of novel black-bounce spacetimes
- Gravitational wave echoes from black holes in massive gravity
- The Penrose process, superradiance and ergoregion instabilities
- Motion in time-periodic backgrounds with applications to ultralight dark matter haloes at galactic centers
- Accretion disks around the Gibbons-Maeda-Garfinkle-Horowitz-Strominger charged black holes
- Accretion in Strong Field Gravity with eXTP
- Characterization of echoes: A Dyson-series representation of individual pulses
- Compactness bounds in General Relativity
- Rotating dirty black hole and its shadow
- The modification of photon trapping orbits as a diagnostic of non-Kerr spacetimes
- Can we probe Planckian corrections at the horizon scale with gravitational waves?
- Particle-like ultracompact objects in Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet theories
- Love numbers and magnetic susceptibility of charged black holes
- Bayesian Metric Reconstruction with Gravitational Wave Observations
- Quasinormal Modes and Bounding Greybody Factors of GUP-corrected Black Holes in Kalb-Ramond Gravity
- How well can ultracompact bodies imitate black hole ringdowns?
- The quantum fate of black hole horizons
- Gravitational wave echoes from strange stars
- Strong field lensing by Damour-Solodukhin wormhole
- From micro to macro and back: probing near-horizon quantum structures with gravitational waves
- Gravitational ringing and superradiant instabilities of the Kerr-like black holes in a dark matter halo
- On the radial stability of ultra compact Schwarzschild stars beyond the Buchdahl limit
- Schwarzschild-like Topological Solitons
- New scalar compact objects in Ricci-based gravity theories
- Observational imprints of gravastars from accretion disks and hot-spots
- Quasinormal modes and greybody factors of symmergent black hole
- Towards VLBI Observations of Black Hole Structure
- Theory-agnostic Reconstruction of Potential and Couplings from Quasi-Normal Modes
- Are gravitational wave ringdown echoes always equal-interval ?
- Can the graviton have a large mass near black holes?
- Tests of CPT invariance in gravitational waves with LIGO-Virgo catalog GWTC-1
- Exploring strong-field deviations from general relativity via gravitational waves
- Superradiance in Kerr-like black holes
- Semiclassical relativistic stars
- Distinguishing black holes from horizonless objects through the excitation of resonances during inspiral
- Black hole binaries: ergoregions, photon surfaces, wave scattering, and quasinormal modes
- Absorption by black hole remnants in metric-affine gravity
- Unequal-mass boson-star binaries: Initial data and merger dynamics
- On gravastar formation: What can be the evidence of a black hole?
- Accretion disk around the rotating Damour-Solodukhin wormhole
- Wormholes in conformal gravity
- Nonlocality amplifies echoes
- Black hole evaporation and semiclassical thin shell collapse
- Properties of ultra-compact particle-like solutions in Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet theories
- Gravitational Vacuum Condensate Stars
- Not quite black holes at LIGO
- Firewalls in General Relativity
- Greybody factors, reflectionless scattering modes, and echoes of ultracompact horizonless objects
- Energy-momentum tensor and metric near the Schwarzschild sphere
- Light Primordial Exotic Compact Objects as All Dark Matter
- Observational evidence for the formation of trapping horizons in astrophysical black holes
- Waves on a vortex: rays, rings and resonances
- Spectral Lines of Quantized, Spinning Black Holes and their Astrophysical Relevance
- Echoes from a singularity
- Echoes from braneworld wormholes
- Astrophysical Gravitational-Wave Echoes from Galactic Nuclei
- Wormholes in Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet theories with a scalar self-interaction potential
- Gravitational-wave echoes from numerical-relativity waveforms via space-time construction near merging compact objects
- Turning black-holes and D-branes inside out their photon-spheres
- Quantum Hotspots: Mean Fields, Open EFTs, Nonlocality and Decoherence Near Black Holes
- Quantum hair of black holes out of equilibrium
- Implications of Symmetry and Pressure in Friedmann Cosmology. II. Stellar Remnant Black Hole Mass Function
- Non-singular black holes interiors need physics beyond the standard model
- Conformal Weyl gravity via two stages of quasinormal ringing and late-time behavior
- Distinguishing Brans-Dicke-Kerr type naked singularities and black holes with their thin disk electromagnetic radiation properties
- Nonlinear treatment of a black hole mimicker ringdown
- Radial oscillations and gravitational wave echoes of strange stars for various equations of state
- Population inference of spin-induced quadrupole moments as a probe for non-black hole compact binaries
- Searching for near-horizon quantum structures in the binary black-hole stochastic gravitational-wave background
- Shielding a charged black hole
- Echoes from Classical Black Holes
- Ringdown of Charged Compact Objects using Membrane Paradigm
- Quantum Nature of Black Holes: Fast Scrambling versus Echoes
- The physics of black hole binaries: geodesics, relaxation modes and energy extraction
- Gravitational Instability of Exotic Compact Objects
- Optical appearance of a thin-shell wormhole with a Hayward profile
- Signature of Non-uniform Area Quantization on Black Hole Echoes
- Gravitational wave echoes from interacting quark stars
- Self-consistent description of a spherically-symmetric gravitational collapse
- Tidal response and near-horizon boundary conditions for spinning exotic compact objects
- Galactic wormholes: Geometry, stability, and echoes
- Geodesic Model of HF QPOs Tested for Black Holes in Spacetimes Reflecting the Effect of Surrounding Dark Matter
- Ringing and echoes from black bounces surrounded by the string cloud
- Echoes from backreacting exotic compact objects
- The Inverse Problem for Hawking Radiation
- How does a collapsing star look?
- Spectral lines of extreme compact objects
- Ultracompact horizonless objects in order-reduced semiclassical gravity
- Testing the nature of dark compact objects with gravitational waves
- Observational signatures from horizonless black shells imitating rotating black holes
- Observational properties of hot-spots orbiting relativistic fluid spheres
- Qubit Heating Near a Hotspot
- Parameterized non-relativistic limit of stellar structure equations in Ricci-based gravity theories
- Can massless wormholes mimic a Schwarzschild black hole in the strong field lensing?
- Universal properties of the near-horizon geometry
- Pandora's box lid: geometry near the apparent horizon
- Primordial gravastar from inflation
- On Black Hole Area Quantization and Echoes
- Can accretion properties distinguish between a naked singularity, wormhole and black hole?
- Neutron stars in the bumblebee theory of gravity
- Mixing of gravitational wave echoes
- Gravitoelectromagnetic coupled perturbations and quasinormal modes of a charged black hole with scalar hair
- Observational Appearance of a Freely-falling Star in an Asymmetric Thin-shell Wormhole
- Black-hole spectroscopy: quasinormal modes, ringdown stability and the pseudospectrum
- Accretion disks and relativistic line broadening in boson star spacetimes
- Kerr-Vaidya black holes
- Stability of Schwarzschild- gravity thin-shell wormholes
- On echo intervals in gravitational wave echo analysis
- Compactness of neutron stars and Tolman VII solutions in scalar-tensor gravity
- Polariton Fluids as Quantum Field Theory Simulators on Tailored Curved Spacetimes
- Nomen non est omen: Why it is too soon to identify ultra-compact objects as black holes
- Semiclassical gravity effects near horizon formation
- Testing gravity with Extreme-Mass-Ratio Inspirals
- Dynamical quasinormal mode excitation
- Quasinormal modes and echoes of a double braneworld
- Black holes as spherically-symmetric horizon-bound objects
- Geodesic structure and quasinormal modes of a tidally perturbed spacetime
- Rescaling strange-cluster stars and its implications on gravitational-wave echoes
- On Black Hole Echoes
- Naked singularity in 4D Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet novel gravity: Echoes and (in)-stability
- Particle creation in gravitational collapse to a horizonless compact object
- String Memories ... Lost and Regained
- Spherically symmetric elastic bodies in general relativity
- Probing resonant excitations in exotic compact objects via gravitational waves
- Tidal-heating/viscous dissipation correspondence in black holes and viscous compact objects
- Quasinormal modes of slowly-spinning horizonless compact objects
- The ringing of quantum corrected Schwarzschild black hole with GUP
- Inverse spectrum problem for quasi-stationary states
- Is "Dark Energy" a Quantum Vacuum Energy?
- Echoes of charged black-bounce spacetimes
- Damping of gravitational waves in 2-2-holes
- Generalized no-hair theorems without horizons
- Gravitational lensing and accretion disk imaging of a Buchdahl dense core
- The Photon Spectrum of Asymmetric Dark Stars
- Modeling and detecting resonant tides of exotic compact objects
- On the universality of late-time ringdown tail
- Spontaneous Radiation of Black Holes
- Perturbative and non-linear analyses of gravitational turbulence in spacetimes with stable light rings
- Probing Bosonic Stars with Atomic Clocks
- SCoRe: A New Framework to Study Unmodeled Physics from Gravitational Wave Data
- Superradiant instabilities of massive bosons around exotic compact objects
- Whispers from the quantum core: the ringdown of semiclassical stars
- Schwarzschild Fuzzball and Explicitly Unitary Hawking Radiations
- Evanescent ergosurface instability
- Scattering of scalar, electromagnetic and gravitational waves from binary systems
- Highly compact Proca stars with quartic self-interactions
- New Kind of Echo from Quantum Black Holes
- Radiative gravastar with Gibbons-Hawking temperature
- Applications of the close-limit approximation: horizonless compact objects and scalar fields
- Echoes from bounded universes
- Modifications to the signal from a gravitational wave event due to a surrounding shell of matter
- Echoes from corpuscular black holes
- Echoes from beyond: Detecting gravitational-wave quantum imprints with LISA
- Quasinormal Modes and Greybody Factors of Charged Symmergent Black Hole
- Massive fields affected by echoes: New physics vs. astrophysical environment
- Information Missing Puzzle, Where Is Hawking's Error?
- Relativistic stars in mass-varying massive gravity
- Observational signatures from higher-order images of moving hotspots in accretion disks
- Lower limit on the entropy of black holes as inferred from gravitational wave observations
- The Fredholm Approach to Charactize Gravitational Wave Echoes
- Gravitational Echoes from Braneworlds
- On symmetry inheritance of nonminimally coupled scalar fields
- Symmetric wormholes in Einstein-vector-Gauss-Bonnet theory
- Ultracompact vector stars
- CLAP for modified gravity: scalar instabilities in binary black hole spacetimes
- Quasinormal modes of a charged black hole with scalar hair
- Decoding infrared imprints of quantum origins of black holes
- Optimizing Gravitational-Wave Detector Design for Squeezed Light
- Radiative gravastar with thermal spectrum; Sudden vacuum condensation without gravitational collapse
- Exotic compact object behavior in black hole analogues
- Evaporation of Echoing Black Holes
- Observational appearance of Kaluza-Klein black holes
- Spectral instability of horizonless compact objects within astrophysical environments
- Black hole spectroscopy and nonlinear echoes in Einstein-Maxwell-scalar theory
- Conformal Cores of Quantum Black Holes in Quadratic Gravity
- Gravitational Atoms from Topological Stars
- Signatures of Quantum Gravity in Gravitational Wave Memory
- Semiclassical Effects in Color Flavor Locked Strange Stars
- Hairy black holes via gravitational decoupling: light rings, absorption and spectral lines
- Lensing by black holes within astrophysical environments
- On double-black hole solutions of the Einstein-Maxwell-Dilaton theory in five dimensions
- Message in a bottle: energy extraction from bouncing geometries
- Is GW190521 a gravitational wave echo of wormhole remnant from another universe?
- Gravitational-wave bursts from spin-precessing black holes in binary systems
- Constraining black-hole horizon effects by LIGO-Virgo detections of inspiralling binary black holes
- Gravitational wave propagation in generalized hybrid metric-Palatini gravity
- Pseudospectrum of Reissner-Nordström black holes: quasinormal mode instability and universality
- QNM families: classification and competition
- Microscopic State of BHs and an Exact One Body Method for Binary Dynamics in General Relativity
- Perturbations of Einstein--Maxwell--phantom spacetime: Instabilities of charged Ellis--Bronnikov wormholes and quasinormal modes of black holes
- Neutron stars more compact than black holes in quasi-topological gravity: Equilibrium configurations and radial stability
- Stability regions of glued wormholes with massless Kim-Lee backreacted spacetimes as interior
- Excitation factors for horizonless compact objects: long-lived modes, echoes, and greybody factors
- Expanding the Quantum-Limited Gravitational-Wave Detection Horizon
- Gravity Induced Spontaneous Radiation
- Demonstration of a next-generation wavefront actuator for gravitational-wave detection
- Manifestation of Quantum Forces in Spacetime: Towards a General Theory of Quantum Forces
- Binary black holes in the heat of merger
- Gravitational-wave echoes from spinning exotic compact objects: numerical waveforms from the Teukolsky equation
- Dust stars in the minimal exponential measure model
- Influence Through Mixing: Hotspots as Benchmarks for Basic Black-Hole Behaviour
- Accreting Schwarzschild-like compact object: Plasma-photon interaction and stability
- The Effect of Mission Duration on LISA Science Objectives
- Neutron stars more compact than black holes as a probe of strong-field gravity
- Roche limit and stellar disruption in the Simpson--Visser spacetime
- Black holes and their horizons in semiclassical and modified theories of gravity
- Probing modified gravitational wave propagation with strongly lensed coalescing binaries
- Compact elastic objects in general relativity
- Polar perturbations of dilaton-Euler-Heisenberg black holes
- Strongly Interacting Dark Matter admixed Neutron Stars
- Dynamical system approach to the spectral (in)stability of black holes under localised potential perturbations
- Resonances, black hole mimickers and the greenhouse effect: consequences for gravitational-wave physics
- Timing of echoes in electromagnetic radiation from hot spots orbiting a Kerr black hole impostor
- Implications of the quantum nature of the black hole horizon on the gravitational-wave ringdown
- Gravitational wave memory in wormhole spacetimes
- Macroscopic backreaction of the trace anomaly on classical vacuum backgrounds
- Constraints on horizonless objects after the EHT observation of Sagittarius A*
- Waveform stability of black hole ringdown with stochastic horizon structure
- Tests for the existence of horizon through gravitational waves from a small binary in the vicinity of a massive object
- Superradiance and instabilities in black holes surrounded by anisotropic fluids