Low significance of evidence for black hole echoes in gravitational wave data
arXiv:1712.09966 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.97.124037
Abstract
Recent detections of merging black holes allow observational tests of the nature of these objects. In some proposed models, non-trivial structure at or near the black hole horizon could lead to echo signals in gravitational wave data. Recently, Abedi et al. claimed tentative evidence for repeating damped echo signals following the gravitational-wave signals of the binary black hole merger events recorded in the first observational period of the Advanced LIGO interferometers. We reanalyse the same data, addressing some of the shortcomings of their method using more background data and a modified procedure. We find a reduced statistical significance for the claims of evidence for echoes, calculating increased p-values for the null hypothesis of echo-free noise. The reduced significance is entirely consistent with noise, and so we conclude that the analysis of Abedi et al. does not provide any observational evidence for the existence of Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons.
arXiv commentAs accepted by Physical Review D
References in corpus (27)
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
- Advanced Virgo: a 2nd generation interferometric gravitational wave detector
- Advanced LIGO
- GW151226: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a 22-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence
- GW170104: Observation of a 50-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence at Redshift 0.2
- GW170814: A Three-Detector Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Coalescence
- Tests of general relativity with GW150914
- Black Holes: Complementarity or Firewalls?
- GW170608: Observation of a 19-solar-mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence
- Binary Black Hole Mergers in the first Advanced LIGO Observing Run
- Properties of the Binary Black Hole Merger GW150914
- Is the gravitational-wave ringdown a probe of the event horizon?
- Echoes of ECOs: gravitational-wave signatures of exotic compact objects and of quantum corrections at the horizon scale
- Echoes from the Abyss: Tentative evidence for Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons
- The observational evidence for horizons: from echoes to precision gravitational-wave physics
- Fermi GBM Observations of LIGO Gravitational Wave event GW150914
- Tests for the existence of horizons through gravitational wave echoes
- Characterization of transient noise in Advanced LIGO relevant to gravitational wave signal GW150914
- Testing strong-field gravity with tidal Love numbers
- The LIGO Open Science Center
- A recipe for echoes from exotic compact objects
- Not quite a black hole
- Gravitational wave echoes through new windows
- Echoes from the Abyss: The Holiday Edition!
- Comments on: "Echoes from the abyss: Evidence for Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons"
- Ultra Compact Stars: Reconstructing the Perturbation Potential
- The detection of Quasinormal Mode of Pop III Binary Black Hole merger with final and would confirm the strong gravity space-time around which is only times the event horizon radius
Cited by in corpus (102)
- Testing the nature of dark compact objects: a status report
- Tests of General Relativity with Binary Black Holes from the second LIGO-Virgo Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog
- Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
- First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. VI: Testing the Black Hole Metric
- Science with the Einstein Telescope: a comparison of different designs
- Extreme Gravity Tests with Gravitational Waves from Compact Binary Coalescences: (II) Ringdown
- New Horizons for Fundamental Physics with LISA
- Gravitational Condensate Stars: An Alternative to Black Holes
- Phenomenological aspects of black holes beyond general relativity
- Tests of General Relativity with GWTC-3
- Gravitational wave echoes from black hole area quantization
- Ergoregion instability of exotic compact objects: electromagnetic and gravitational perturbations and the role of absorption
- How does a dark compact object ringdown?
- Searching for black hole echoes from the LIGO-Virgo Catalog GWTC-1
- The Science of the Einstein Telescope
- Potential gravitational-wave signatures of quantum gravity
- Analytical model for gravitational-wave echoes from spinning remnants
- Static spherical vacuum solutions in the bumblebee gravity model
- Analytical template for gravitational-wave echoes: signal characterization and prospects of detection with current and future interferometers
- Template-based Gravitational-Wave Echoes Search Using Bayesian Model Selection
- The peculiar acceleration of stellar-origin black hole binaries: measurement and biases with LISA
- Probing microstructure of black hole spacetimes with gravitational wave echoes
- Echoes from the braneworld black holes
- Black-hole microstate spectroscopy: ringdown, quasinormal modes, and echoes
- On gravitational echoes from ultracompact exotic stars
- Echoes from the Abyss: A highly spinning black hole remnant for the binary neutron star merger GW170817
- A morphology-independent data analysis method for detecting and characterizing gravitational wave echoes
- A morphology-independent search for gravitational wave echoes in data from the first and second observing runs of Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo
- On gravitational-wave echoes from neutron-star binary coalescences
- Parameter estimation for black hole echo signals and their statistical significance
- Towards a Non-singular Paradigm of Black Hole Physics
- Possible Causes of False General Relativity Violations in Gravitational Wave Observations
- Ergoregion instability and echoes for braneworld black holes: Scalar, electromagnetic and gravitational perturbations
- Phenomenology of GUP stars
- Testing Quantum Black Holes with Gravitational Waves
- Gravitational Wave "Echo" Spectra
- Can we probe Planckian corrections at the horizon scale with gravitational waves?
- Recognizing black holes in gravitational-wave observations: Challenges in telling apart impostors in mass-gap binaries
- Effective Field Theory of Black Hole Echoes
- A wider look at the gravitational-wave transients from GWTC-1 using an unmodeled reconstruction method
- Gravitational-wave constraints on the GWTC-2 events by measuring the tidal deformability and the spin-induced quadrupole moment
- Tidal heating of Quantum Black Holes and their imprints on gravitational waves
- GW190521: Search for Echoes due to Stimulated Hawking Radiation from Black Holes
- How loud are echoes from exotic compact objects?
- Oscillations in the EMRI gravitational wave phase correction as a probe of reflective boundary of the central black hole
- Gravitational Vacuum Condensate Stars
- Exploring non-singular black holes in gravitational perturbations
- Towards establishing the presence or absence of horizons in coalescing binaries of compact objects by using their gravitational wave signals
- Observational evidence for the formation of trapping horizons in astrophysical black holes
- Spectral Lines of Quantized, Spinning Black Holes and their Astrophysical Relevance
- Modeling gravitational waves from exotic compact objects
- Nonlinear treatment of a black hole mimicker ringdown
- Imprint of black hole area quantization and Hawking radiation on inspiraling binary
- Quantum Nature of Black Holes: Fast Scrambling versus Echoes
- Ringdown of Charged Compact Objects using Membrane Paradigm
- Signature of Non-uniform Area Quantization on Black Hole Echoes
- Ringing and echoes from black bounces surrounded by the string cloud
- The Inverse Problem for Hawking Radiation
- Spectral lines of extreme compact objects
- Testing the nature of dark compact objects with gravitational waves
- Spicing up the recipe for echoes from exotic compact objects: orbital differences and corrections in rotating backgrounds
- Probing horizon scale quantum effects with Love
- On Black Hole Area Quantization and Echoes
- Primordial gravastar from inflation
- Mixing of gravitational wave echoes
- Possible connection between the reflection symmetry and existence of equatorial circular orbit
- Gravitational radiation close to a black hole horizon: Waveform regularization and the out-going echo
- On echo intervals in gravitational wave echo analysis
- On Black Hole Echoes
- Probing the quantum nature of black holes with ultra-light boson environments
- Can the abyss swallow gravitational waves or why we do not observe echoes?
- Gravitational wave echoes search with combs
- SCoRe: A New Framework to Study Unmodeled Physics from Gravitational Wave Data
- Primary hairs may create echoes
- Modeling and detecting resonant tides of exotic compact objects
- Whispers from the quantum core: the ringdown of semiclassical stars
- Gravitational Waves, Holography, and Black Hole Microstates
- Echoes from corpuscular black holes
- Modifications to the signal from a gravitational wave event due to a surrounding shell of matter
- Echoes from beyond: Detecting gravitational-wave quantum imprints with LISA
- Gravitational Echoes from Braneworlds
- Gravitational Wave Perturbations on a Kerr Background and Applications for Echoes
- The Fredholm Approach to Charactize Gravitational Wave Echoes
- Efficient search method of anomalous reflection by the central object in an EMRI system by future space gravitational wave detectors
- Black holes in General Relativity and beyond
- Lower limit on the entropy of black holes as inferred from gravitational wave observations
- Evaporation of Echoing Black Holes
- Probing the horizon of black holes with gravitational waves
- Tail wavelets in the merger of binary compact objects
- Firewall black holes and echoes from an action principle
- Is GW190521 a gravitational wave echo of wormhole remnant from another universe?
- Space-based Gravitational Wave Observatories
- Spacing Statistics of Energy Spectra: Random Matrices, Black Hole Thermalization, and Echoes
- Limits on the existence of totally reflective exotic compact objects with current and future gravitational-wave detectors
- Looking for ancillary signals around GW150914
- Perturbations of Einstein--Maxwell--phantom spacetime: Instabilities of charged Ellis--Bronnikov wormholes and quasinormal modes of black holes
- Gravitational-wave echoes from spinning exotic compact objects: numerical waveforms from the Teukolsky equation
- Absorption spectroscopy of quantum black holes with gravitational waves
- Real-Time Holography and Hybrid WKB for BTZ Wormholes
- Sub-atomic constraints on the Kerr geometry of GW150914
- Axion dark matter with not quite black hole domination
- Model-agnostic search of gravitational wave echoes in LVK data