No tension between assembly models of supermassive black hole binaries and pulsar observations

Abstract

Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) are presently the only means to search for the gravitational wave stochastic background from supermassive black hole binary populations, considered to be within the grasp of current or near future observations. However, the stringent upperlimit set by the Parkes PTA (Shannon et al. 2013, 2015) has been interpreted as excluding at $>90\%$ confidence the current paradigm of binary assembly through galaxy mergers and hardening via stellar interactions, suggesting evolution is accelerated (by stars and/or gas) or stalled. Using Bayesian hierarchical modelling, we consider implications of this upperlimit for a comprehensive range of astrophysical scenarios, without invoking stalling nor more exotic physical processes. We find they are fully consistent with the upperlimit, but (weak) bounds on population parameters can be inferred. Bayes factors between models vary between $\approx 1.03$ -- $5.81$ and Kullback-Leibler divergences between characteristic amplitude prior and posterior lie between $0.37$ -- $0.85$. Considering prior astrophysical information on galaxy merger rates, recent upwards revisions of the black hole-galaxy bulge mass relation (Kormendy & Ho 2013) are disfavoured at $1.6\sigma$ against lighter models (e.g. Shankar et al. 2016). We also show, if no detection is achieved once sensitivity improves by an order of magnitude, the most optimistic scenario is disfavoured at $3.9\sigma$.

arXiv comment20 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (43)

• Coevolution (Or Not) of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies
• The M-sigma and M-L Relations in Galactic Bulges and Determinations of their Intrinsic Scatter
• Revisiting the Scaling Relations of Black Hole Masses and Host Galaxy Properties
• Mass assembly in quiescent and star-forming galaxies since z=4 from UltraVISTA
• The Evolution of the Stellar Mass Functions of Star-Forming and Quiescent Galaxies to z = 4 from the COSMOS/UltraVISTA Survey
• The Five-Hundred-Meter Aperture Spherical Radio Telescope (FAST) Project
• European Pulsar Timing Array Limits On An Isotropic Stochastic Gravitational-Wave Background
• The stochastic gravitational-wave background from massive black hole binary systems: implications for observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• The dynamical evolution of massive black hole binaries - I. Hardening in a fixed stellar background
• Gravitational waves from binary supermassive black holes missing in pulsar observations
• Galaxy Stellar Mass Functions from ZFOURGE/CANDELS: An Excess of Low-Mass Galaxies Since z=2 and the Rapid Buildup of Quiescent Galaxies
• The International Pulsar Timing Array: First Data Release
• The Major and Minor Galaxy Merger Rates at z < 1.5
• Massive black hole binary mergers within sub-pc scale gas discs
• Two ten-billion-solar-mass black holes at the centres of giant elliptical galaxies
• The NANOGrav Nine-year Data Set: Limits on the Isotropic Stochastic Gravitational Wave Background
• Gravitational waves from resolvable massive black hole binary systems and observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• The Greater Impact of Mergers on the Growth of Massive Galaxies: Implications for Mass Assembly and Evolution Since z~1
• Selection bias in dynamically-measured super-massive black hole samples: its consequences and the quest for the most fundamental relation
• The Effect of Mass Ratio on the Morphology and Time-scales of Disc Galaxy Mergers
• Massive Black Hole Binary Mergers in Dynamical Galactic Environments
• Systematic investigation of the expected gravitational wave signal from supermassive black hole binaries in the pulsar timing band
• A calibration of the relation between the abundance of close galaxy pairs and the rate of galaxy mergers
• The VIMOS VLT Deep Survey :Evolution of the major merger rate since z~1 from spectroscopicaly confirmed galaxy pairs
• The final-parsec problem in the collisionless limit
• The dominant role of mergers in the size evolution of massive early-type galaxies since z ~ 1
• Scattering experiments meet N-body I: a practical recipe for the evolution of massive black hole binaries in stellar environments
• Galaxy Pairs in COSMOS -- Merger Rate Evolution Since z=1
• A consistent measure of the merger histories of massive galaxies using close-pair statistics I: Major mergers at $z<3.5$
• Insights on the astrophysics of supermassive black hole binaries from pulsar timing observations
• Prospects for gravitational-wave detection and supermassive black hole astrophysics with pulsar timing arrays
• Are we there yet? Time to detection of nanohertz gravitational waves based on pulsar-timing array limits
• Gravitational waves and stalled satellites from massive galaxy mergers at z <= 1
• Post-Newtonian evolution of massive black hole triplets in galactic nuclei -- III. A robust lower limit to the nHz stochastic background of gravitational waves
• Selection bias in dynamically-measured super-massive black hole samples: consequences for pulsar timing arrays
• Understanding black hole mass assembly via accretion and mergers at late times in cosmological simulations
• On the hunt for ultramassive black holes in brightest cluster galaxies
• Efficient computation of the gravitational wave spectrum emitted by eccentric massive black hole binaries in stellar environments
• Constraints on Black Hole/Host Galaxy Co-evolution and Binary Stalling Using Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Prospects for measuring supermassive black hole masses with future extremely large telescopes
• The massive end of the luminosity and stellar mass functions and clustering from CMASS to SDSS: Evidence for and against passive evolution
• Probing the assembly history and dynamical evolution of massive black hole binaries with pulsar timing arrays
• Evolution Of Massive Black Hole Binaries In Rotating Stellar Nuclei: Implications For Gravitational Wave Detection

Cited by in corpus (24)

• Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
• The Quest for Dual and Binary Supermassive Black Holes: A Multi-Messenger View
• The NANOGrav 11-Year Data Set: Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
• Massive black hole merger rates: the effect of kpc separation wandering and supernova feedback
• Constraining astrophysical observables of Galaxy and Supermassive Black Hole Binary Mergers using Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Massive black hole binary systems and the NANOGrav 12.5 year results
• Massive BH Binaries as Periodically-Variable AGN
• Constraining Sub-Parsec Binary Supermassive Black Holes in Quasars with Multi-Epoch Spectroscopy. III. Candidates from Continued Radial Velocity Tests
• Constraining alternative theories of gravity using pulsar timing arrays
• A quasar-based supermassive black hole binary population model: implications for the gravitational-wave background
• Pulsar timing array signals induced by black hole binaries in relativistic eccentric orbits
• The minimum and maximum gravitational-wave background from supermassive binary black holes
• Gravitational Waves from the Inspiral of Supermassive Black Holes in Galactic-scale Simulations
• The recoiling black hole candidate 3C 186: spatially-resolved quasar feedback and further evidence of a blue-shifted broad line region
• Associating Host Galaxy Candidates to Massive Black Hole Binaries resolved by Pulsar Timing Arrays
• An estimate of the stochastic gravitational wave background from the MassiveBlackII simulation
• Pulsar Timing Array Constraints on the Merger Timescale of Subparsec Supermassive Black Hole Binary Candidates
• Constraining the host galaxy halos of massive black holes from LISA event rates
• Reading signatures of supermassive binary black holes in pulsar timing array observations
• Very Large Array imaging rules out precessing radio jets in three DES$-$SDSS-selected candidate periodic quasars
• Memory of a Random Walk: Astrometric deflections from gravitational wave memory accumulation over cosmological scales
• The Fates of Merging Supermassive Black Holes and a Proposal for a New Class of X-Ray Sources
• Implications for Pulsar Timing Arrays of Sub-solar Black Hole Detections: From LVK to Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer
• Testing No slip model with pulsar timing arrays: NANOGrav and IPTA