The Correlation Between Mixing Length and Metallicity on the Giant Branch: Implications for Ages in the Gaia Era

Abstract

In the updated APOGEE-Kepler catalog, we have asteroseismic and spectroscopic data for over 3000 first ascent red giants. Given the size and accuracy of this sample, these data offer an unprecedented test of the accuracy of stellar models on the post-main-sequence. When we compare these data to theoretical predictions, we find a metallicity dependent temperature offset with a slope of around 100 K per dex in metallicity. We find that this effect is present in all model grids tested and that theoretical uncertainties in the models, correlated spectroscopic errors, and shifts in the asteroseismic mass scale are insufficient to explain this effect. Stellar models can be brought into agreement with the data if a metallicity dependent convective mixing length is used, with $\Delta {\alpha }_{\mathrm{ML},\mathrm{YREC}}\sim 0.2$ per dex in metallicity, a trend inconsistent with the predictions of three dimensional stellar convection simulations. If this effect is not taken into account, isochrone ages for red giants from the Gaia data will be off by as much as a factor of 2 even at modest deviations from solar metallicity ([Fe/H]=$-$0.5).

13 pages, 10 figures. Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal. For a brief video discussing key results from this paper see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cV_0AhPAIRo . The data and models used in this paper are available at http://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/~tayar/MixingLength.htm

References in corpus (17)

• The 2.5 m Telescope of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling I: The relevance of uncertain aspects of stellar evolution and the IMF to the derived physical properties of galaxies
• How to Constrain Your M Dwarf: measuring effective temperature, bolometric luminosity, mass, and radius
• The Dawes Review 2: Nucleosynthesis and stellar yields of low and intermediate-mass single stars
• Gaia Data Release 1: Astrometry - one billion positions, two million proper motions and parallaxes
• A new implementation of the infrared flux method using the 2MASS catalogue
• The APOKASC Catalog: An Asteroseismic and Spectroscopic Joint Survey of Targets in the Kepler Fields
• Standing on the shoulders of Dwarfs: the Kepler asteroseismic LEGACY sample II - radii, masses, and ages
• The APOGEE red-clump catalog: Precise distances, velocities, and high-resolution elemental abundances over a large area of the Milky Way's disk
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: Spatially resolved star formation histories in galaxies as a function of galaxy mass and type
• Improvements to stellar structure models, based on a grid of 3D convection simulations. II. Calibrating the mixing-length formulation
• The Stagger-grid: A grid of 3D stellar atmosphere models - III. The relation to mixing-length convection theory
• New H-band Stellar Spectral Libraries for the SDSS-III/APOGEE survey
• Automated preparation of Kepler time series of planet hosts for asteroseismic analysis
• Chemical Abundances in a Sample of Red Giants in the Open Cluster NGC 2420 from APOGEE
• Calibrating the α parameter of convective efficiency using observed stellar properties
• The effects of individual metal contents on isochrones for C, N, O, Na, Mg, Al, Si, and Fe

Cited by in corpus (84)

• The Updated BaSTI Stellar Evolution Models and Isochrones: I. Solar Scaled Calculations
• The Second APOKASC Catalog: The Empirical Approach
• Target Selection for the SDSS-IV APOGEE-2 Survey
• Constraining the thermally-pulsing asymptotic giant branch phase with resolved stellar populations in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• A Guide to Realistic Uncertainties on Fundamental Properties of Solar-Type Exoplanet Host Stars
• Age dissection of the Milky Way discs: red giants in the Kepler field
• Confirming chemical clocks: asteroseismic age dissection of the Milky Way disk(s)
• Age Determinations of the Hyades, Praesepe, and Pleiades via MESA Models with Rotation
• Solar structure and evolution
• APOGEE DR16: a multi-zone chemical evolution model for the Galactic disc based on MCMC methods
• Not All Stars Are the Sun: Empirical Calibration of the Mixing Length for Metal-Poor Stars Using One-dimensional Stellar Evolution Models
• Massive donors in interacting binaries: effect of metallicity
• Stellar population models based on the SDSS-IV MaStar library of stellar spectra. I. Intermediate-age/old models
• Constraining Metallicity-dependent Mixing and Extra Mixing using [C/N] in Alpha-Rich Field Giants
• Investigating the Metallicity-Mixing Length Relation
• APOKASC-3: The Third Joint Spectroscopic and Asteroseismic catalog for Evolved Stars in the Kepler Fields
• Modelling Kepler Red Giants in Eclipsing Binaries:Calibrating the Mixing Length Parameter with Asteroseismology
• Classically and Asteroseismically constrained 1D Stellar Evolution Models of $\alpha$ Centauri A and B using Empirical Mixing Length Calibrations
• Oscillating red giants in eclipsing binary systems: empirical reference value for asteroseismic scaling relation
• A Unified tool to estimate Distances, Ages and Masses (UniDAM) from spectrophotometric data
• Metallicity effect on stellar granulation detected from oscillating red giants in open clusters
• White dwarf binaries suggest a common envelope efficiency $\alpha \sim 1/3$
• Exploring the stellar age distribution of the Milky Way Bulge using APOGEE
• Uncertain Times: The Redshift-Time Relation from Cosmology and Stars
• Effective temperatures of red giants in the APOKASC catalogue and the mixing length calibration in stellar models
• Asteroseismology of 36 Kepler subgiants -- II: Determining ages from detailed modelling
• An Ultra Metal-poor Star Near the Hydrogen-burning Limit
• Stellar models with calibrated convection and temperature stratification from 3D hydrodynamics simulations
• Asteroseismology of 3,642 Kepler Red Giants: Correcting the Scaling Relations based on Detailed Modeling
• Evolutionary models of red supergiants: Evidence for a metallicity-dependent mixing length and implications for Type IIP supernova progenitors
• A revisit of PSR J1909$-$3744 with 15-year high-precision timing
• Modelling depletion by re-accretion of gas from a dusty disc in post-AGB stars
• A prescription for the asteroseismic surface correction
• The Ages of Galactic Bulge Stars with Realistic Uncertainties
• The GALAH Survey: Chemical Clocks
• Coupling 1D stellar evolution with 3D-hydrodynamical simulations on-the-fly II: Stellar Evolution and Asteroseismic Applications
• Surface effects on the red giant branch
• Estimating stellar ages and metallicities from parallaxes and broadband photometry - successes and shortcomings
• APOGEE [C/N] Abundances Across the Galaxy: Migration and Infall from Red Giant Ages
• The Evolution of Rotation and Magnetic Activity in 94 Aqr Aa from Asteroseismology with TESS
• Cannibals in the thick disk II -- Radial-velocity monitoring of the young alpha-rich stars
• On the Red Giant Branch: Ambiguity in the Surface Boundary Condition Leads to ~100 K Uncertainty in Model Effective Temperatures
• Core-Envelope Coupling in Intermediate-Mass Core-Helium Burning Stars
• Testing Angular Momentum Transport and Wind Loss in Intermediate Mass Core Helium Burning Stars
• On the impact of the structural surface effect on global stellar properties and asteroseismic analyses
• Hierarchically modelling Kepler dwarfs and subgiants to improve inference of stellar properties with asteroseismology
• Globular Clusters in High-Redshift Dwarf Galaxies: A Case Study from the Local Group
• Nature vs. Nurture: Distinguishing Effects from Stellar Processing and Chemical Evolution on Carbon and Nitrogen in Red Giant Stars
• The APO-K2 Catalog. II. Accurate Stellar Ages for Red Giant Branch Stars across the Milky Way
• An Intermediate-age Alpha-rich Galactic Population in K2
• Overcoming the structural surface effect with a realistic treatment of turbulent convection in 1D stellar models
• Mending the structural surface effect of 1D stellar structure models with non-solar metallicities based on interpolated 3D envelopes
• Precise Masses, Ages of ~1.0 million RGB and RC stars observed by the LAMOST
• Star Cluster Ages in the Gaia Era
• Characterizing Observed Extra Mixing Trends in Red Giants using the Reduced Density Ratio from Thermohaline Models
• Improved calibration of the radii of cool stars based on 3D simulations of convection: implications for the solar model
• Benchmarking Substellar Evolutionary Models Using New Age Estimates for HD 4747 B and HD 19467 B
• Uranium Abundances and Ages of $R$-process Enhanced Stars with Novel U II Lines
• Inference of stellar parameters from brightness variations
• The ages of (the oldest) stars
• The RR Lyrae Delay-Time Distribution: A Novel Perspective on Models of Old Stellar Populations
• A 5% measurement of the gravitational constant in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• First detection of oscillations in the Halo giant HD 122563: validation of seismic scaling relations and new fundamental parameters
• Is [Y/Mg] a Reliable Age Diagnostic for FGK Stars?
• Lithium in Kepler Red Giants: Defining Normal and Anomalous
• Bayesian inference of stellar parameters based on 1D stellar models coupled with 3D envelopes
• The Kepler Smear Campaign: Light curves for 102 Very Bright Stars
• Red giants evolutionary status determination: the complete Kepler catalog
• Asteroseismic age estimates of RGB stars in open clusters. A statistical investigation of different estimation methods
• Red supergiant stars in IC 1613 and metallicity-dependent mixing length in the evolutionary model
• Carbon Isotope Ratios in M10 Giants
• Weighing stars from birth to death: mass determination methods across the HRD
• Asteroseismology of the young open cluster NGC 2516 II. Constraining cluster age using gravity-mode pulsators
• Pushing the boundaries of asteroseismic individual frequency modelling: unveiling two evolved very-low metallicity red giants
• Asteroseismology of the G8 subgiant beta Aquilae with SONG-Tenerife, SONG-Australia and TESS
• Benchmarking the effective temperature scale of red giant branch stellar models: the case of the metal-poor halo giant HD 122563
• J01020100-7122208: an accreted evolved blue straggler that wasn't ejected from a supermassive black hole
• Beyond the Nyquist frequency: Asteroseismic catalog of undersampled Kepler late subgiants and early red giants
• Asteroseismically Inferred Ages of 132,000 Red Giants with TESS
• Concerning Li-rich status of KIC~9821622: A Kepler field RGB star reported as Li-rich Giant
• Mixing-length calibration from field stars. An investigation on statistical errors, systematic biases, and spurious metallicity trends
• Galactic Surveys in the Gaia Era
• Two sequences in the age-metallicity relation as seen from [C/N] abundances in APOGEE
• Testing the 3-equation Kuhfuss Convection Model using the Sun