Characterizing Observed Extra Mixing Trends in Red Giants using the Reduced Density Ratio from Thermohaline Models

Abstract

Observations show an almost ubiquitous presence of extra mixing in low-mass upper giant branch stars. The most commonly invoked explanation for this is thermohaline mixing. One-dimensional stellar evolution models include various prescriptions for thermohaline mixing, but the use of observational data directly to discriminate between thermohaline prescriptions has thus far been limited. Here, we propose a new framework to facilitate direct comparison: Using carbon-to-nitrogen measurements from the SDSS-IV APOGEE survey as a probe of mixing and a fluid parameter known as the reduced density ratio from one-dimensional stellar evolution programs, we compare the observed amount of extra mixing on the upper giant branch to predicted trends from three-dimensional fluid dynamics simulations. Using this method, we are able to empirically constrain how mixing efficiency should vary with the reduced density ratio. We find the observed amount of extra mixing is strongly correlated with the reduced density ratio and that trends between reduced density ratio and fundamental stellar parameters are robust across choices for modeling prescription. We show that stars with available mixing data tend to have relatively low density ratios, which should inform the regimes selected for future simulation efforts. Finally, we show that there is increased mixing at low reduced density ratios, which is consistent with current hydrodynamical models of thermohaline mixing. The introduction of this framework sets a new standard for theoretical modeling efforts, as validation for not only the amount of extra mixing, but trends between the degree of extra mixing and fundamental stellar parameters is now possible.

arXiv comment22 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ. MESA histories available on Zenodo at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7152746 . MESA inlists available on GitHub at https://github.com/afraser3/Empirical-Magnetic-Thermohaline

References in corpus (77)

• SciPy 1.0--Fundamental Algorithms for Scientific Computing in Python
• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The NumPy array: a structure for efficient numerical computation
• The Astropy Project: Building an inclusive, open-science project and status of the v2.0 core package
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST). I: Solar-Scaled Models
• The 2.5 m Telescope of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
• Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV: Mapping the Milky Way, Nearby Galaxies, and the Distant Universe
• Low Temperature Opacities
• ASPCAP: The Apogee Stellar Parameter and Chemical Abundances Pipeline
• Shell-model calculations of stellar weak interaction rates: II. Weak rates for nuclei in the mass range A=45-65 in supernovae environment
• The Fourteenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Spectroscopic Data from the extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey and from the second phase of the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
• The GALAH+ Survey: Third Data Release
• Updated Electron-Conduction Opacities: The Impact on Low-Mass Stellar Models
• APOGEE Data and Spectral Analysis from SDSS Data Release 16: Seven Years of Observations Including First Results from APOGEE-South
• The Data Reduction Pipeline for the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
• Abundances, Stellar Parameters, and Spectra From the SDSS-III/APOGEE Survey
• The APOKASC Catalog: An Asteroseismic and Spectroscopic Joint Survey of Targets in the Kepler Fields
• Thermohaline mixing: A physical mechanism governing the photospheric composition of low-mass giants
• The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE) Spectrographs
• The Second APOKASC Catalog: The Empirical Approach
• Target Selection for the SDSS-IV APOGEE-2 Survey
• APOGEE Data Releases 13 and 14: Data and Analysis
• Thermohaline instability and rotation-induced mixing. I - Low- and intermediate-mass solar metallicity stars up to the end of the AGB
• Red giant masses and ages derived from carbon and nitrogen abundances
• Thermodynamic functions of dense plasmas: analytic approximations for astrophysical applications
• Deep Mixing of He-3: Reconciling Big Bang and Stellar Nucleosynthesis
• Spectroscopic determination of masses (and implied ages) for red giants
• A Guide to Realistic Uncertainties on Fundamental Properties of Solar-Type Exoplanet Host Stars
• Red Giant Branch stars: the theoretical framework
• Coulomb tunneling for fusion reactions in dense matter: Path integral Monte Carlo versus mean field
• Carbon, nitrogen and $\alpha$-element abundances determine the formation sequence of the Galactic thick and thin disks
• Core rotation braking on the red giant branch for various mass ranges
• The APOGEE Data Release 16 Spectral Line List
• Numerically determined transport laws for fingering ("thermohaline") convection in astrophysics
• New H-band Stellar Spectral Libraries for the SDSS-III/APOGEE survey
• Angular Momentum Transport In Solar-Type Stars: Testing the Timescale For Core-Envelope Coupling
• The Correlation Between Mixing Length and Metallicity on the Giant Branch: Implications for Ages in the Gaia Era
• Skye: A Differentiable Equation of State
• The GALAH survey: An abundance, age, and kinematic inventory of the solar neighbourhood made with TGAS
• Chemical Transport and Spontaneous Layer Formation in Fingering Convection in Astrophysics
• Numerical Simulations of Thermohaline Convection: Implications for Extra-Mixing in Low-Mass RGB Stars
• Final Targeting Strategy for the SDSS-IV APOGEE-2S Survey
• Final Targeting Strategy for the SDSS-IV APOGEE-2N Survey
• Thermohaline mixing in evolved low-mass stars
• 3D Numerical Experimentation on the Core Helium Flash of low-mass Red Giants
• Not All Stars Are the Sun: Empirical Calibration of the Mixing Length for Metal-Poor Stars Using One-dimensional Stellar Evolution Models
• Thermohaline Mixing: Does It Really Govern the Atmospheric Chemical Composition of Low-Mass Red Giants?
• Post first dredge-up [C/N] ratio as age indicator. Theoretical calibration
• Rosseland and flux mean opacities for Compton scattering
• Constraining Metallicity-dependent Mixing and Extra Mixing using [C/N] in Alpha-Rich Field Giants
• On the Numerical Treatment and Dependence of Thermohaline Mixing in Red Giants
• Lithium-Rich Giants in Globular Clusters
• Investigating the Metallicity-Mixing Length Relation
• Classically and Asteroseismically constrained 1D Stellar Evolution Models of $\alpha$ Centauri A and B using Empirical Mixing Length Calibrations
• Population synthesis to constrain Galactic and Stellar Physics- I- Determining age and mass of thin-disc red-giant stars
• Magnetic signatures on mixed-mode frequencies. I. An axisymmetric fossil field inside the core of red giants
• The Gaia-ESO survey: Mixing processes in low-mass stars traced by lithium abundance in cluster and field stars
• Lithium in red giant stars: Constraining non-standard mixing with large surveys in the Gaia era
• BACCHUS Analysis of Weak Lines in APOGEE Spectra (BAWLAS)
• The Red-Giant Branch Bump Revisited: Constraints on Envelope Overshooting in a Wide Range of Masses and Metallicities
• Seismic measurement of the locations of the base of convection zone and helium ionization zone for stars in the {\it Kepler} seismic LEGACY sample
• Polluted White Dwarfs: Mixing Regions and Diffusion Timescales
• On the red-giant luminosity bump
• Insights from the APOKASC Determination of the Evolutionary State of Red-Giant Stars by consolidation of different methods
• Enhanced mixing in magnetized fingering convection, and implications for RGB stars
• Models of red giants in the CoRoT asteroseismology fields combining asteroseismic and spectroscopic constraints
• Diagnostics of Stellar Modelling from Spectroscopy and Photometry of Globular Clusters
• An Atlas of Convection in Main-Sequence Stars
• A phenomenological modification of thermohaline mixing in globular cluster red giants
• The Open Cluster Chemical Abundances and Mapping Survey: VII. APOGEE DR17 [C/N]-Age Calibration
• The Gaia-ESO survey: Lithium abundances in open cluster Red Clump stars
• Investigating the Consistency of Stellar Evolution Models with Globular Cluster Observations via the Red Giant Branch Bump
• Is Thermohaline Mixing the Full Story? Evidence for Separate Mixing Events near the Red Giant Branch Bump
• Bridging the Gap between Intermediate and Massive Stars I: Validation of MESA against the State-of-the-Art Monash Stellar Evolution Program for a 2$M_{\odot }$ AGB Star
• The Destruction of 3He by Rayleigh-Taylor Instability on the First Giant Branch

Cited by in corpus (6)

• Evidence of extra-mixing in field giants as traced by lithium and carbon isotope ratio
• Convective Mixing: The Formation Channel of Li-rich Giants
• The evolution of accretor stars in binary systems due to accretion of increasingly helium-rich material
• Spontaneous generation of helical flows by salt fingers
• Beyond MESA Defaults: The Impact of Structural Resolution Uncertainty in p-mode Asteroseismology
• Toward a Comprehensive Grid of Cepheid Models with MESA II. Impact of Physical and Numerical Assumptions on Elemental Abundances