Bridging the Gap between Intermediate and Massive Stars I: Validation of MESA against the State-of-the-Art Monash Stellar Evolution Program for a 2$M_{\odot }$ AGB Star

Abstract

One--dimensional stellar structure and evolution programs are built using different physical prescriptions and algorithms, which means there can be variations between models' predictions even when using identical input physics. This leads to questions about whether such deviations are physical or numerical; code validation studies are important and necessary tools for studying these questions. We provide the first direct comparison between the Monash stellar evolution program and MESA for a $2M_{\odot }$ model evolved from the zero-age main sequence to the tip of the thermally pulsing asymptotic giant branch. We compare the internal structure of the two models at six critical evolutionary points and find that they are in excellent agreement in characteristics like central temperature, central density and the temperature at the base of the convective envelope during the thermally pulsing asymptotic giant branch. The hydrogen-exhausted core mass between the models differs by less than 4.2% throughout the entire evolution, the final values vary only by 1.5%. Surface quantities such as luminosity and radius vary by less than 0.2% prior to the asymptotic giant branch. During thermal pulses, the difference extends to 3.4%, largely due to uncertainties in mixing and the treatment of atmospheric boundary conditions. Given that the veteran Monash code is closed source, the present work provides the first fully open-source computational analog. This increases accessibility to precision modeling on the asymptotic giant branch and lays the groundwork for higher-mass calculations that are performed with MESA but preserve the standards of the Monash code during the AGB.

arXiv commentSubmitted, ApJ

References in corpus (80)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the PAdova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST) 0: Methods for the construction of stellar isochrones
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• A large stellar evolution database for population synthesis studies. I. Scaled solar models and isochrones
• Low Temperature Opacities
• The NextGen Model Atmosphere grid for $3000\le \Teff \le 10000\K$
• Rotating Massive Main-Sequence Stars I: Grids of Evolutionary Models and Isochrones
• Solar Models with Helium and Heavy Element Diffusion
• Nucleosynthesis and Remnants in Massive Stars of Solar Metallicity
• Updated stellar yields from Asymptotic Giant Branch models
• Shell-model calculations of stellar weak interaction rates: II. Weak rates for nuclei in the mass range A=45-65 in supernovae environment
• The Dawes Review 2: Nucleosynthesis and stellar yields of low and intermediate-mass single stars
• Theory of Low-Mass Stars and Substellar Objects
• The NextGen Model Atmosphere grid: II. Spherically symmetric model atmospheres for giant stars with effective temperatures between 3000 and 6800~K
• The nucleosynthesis of Al26 and Fe60 in solar metallicity stars extending in mass from 11 to 120 Msun: the hydrostatic and explosive contributions
• The Updated BaSTI Stellar Evolution Models and Isochrones: I. Solar Scaled Calculations
• Stellar yields from metal-rich asymptotic giant branch models
• Stellar Models and Yields of Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars
• The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. II. Stellar Evolution Tracks, Isochrones, Luminosity Functions, and Synthetic Horizontal-Branch Models
• Stellar Turbulent Convection: A Selfconsistent Model
• The Compactness of Presupernova Stellar Cores
• Yields of AGB and SAGB models with chemistry of low- and high-metallicity Globular Clusters
• Thermohaline instability and rotation-induced mixing. I - Low- and intermediate-mass solar metallicity stars up to the end of the AGB
• Thermodynamic functions of dense plasmas: analytic approximations for astrophysical applications
• NuGrid stellar data set I. Stellar yields from H to Bi for stars with metallicities Z = 0.02 and Z = 0.01
• YREC: The Yale Rotating Stellar Evolution Code
• Low-temperature gas opacity - AESOPUS: a versatile and quick computational tool
• STARLIB: A Next-Generation Reaction-Rate Library for Nuclear Astrophysics
• The updated BaSTI stellar evolution models and isochrones: II. alpha-enhanced calculations
• NuGrid Stellar Data Set. II. Stellar Yields from H to Bi for Stellar Models with Mzams = 1 to 25Msun and Z = 0.0001 to 0.02
• Evolution and Nucleosynthesis of Extremely Metal Poor & Metal-Free Low- and Intermediate-Mass Stars I: Stellar Yield Tables and the CEMPs
• The primordial helium abundance from updated emissivities
• A comparison of evolutionary tracks for single Galactic massive stars
• Reevaluating the Mass-Radius Relation for Low-Mass, Main Sequence Stars
• Dust formation around AGB and SAGB stars: a trend with metallicity?
• Mass loss on the red giant branch: the value and metallicity dependence of Reimers' η in globular clusters
• The Helium abundance and Delta Y / Delta Z in Lower Main Sequence stars
• Helium enrichment and Carbon-star Production in Metal-rich Populations
• Heavy-element yields and abundances of Asymptotic Giant Branch models with a Small Magellanic Cloud metallicity
• Empirical Tests of Pre-Main-Sequence Stellar Evolution Models with Eclipsing Binaries
• Heavy Element Diffusion in Metal Poor Stars
• Dredge-up and envelope burning in intermediate mass giants of very low metallicity
• Uncertainties on near-core mixing in red-clump stars: effects on the period spacing and on the luminosity of the AGB bump
• 3D hydrodynamical simulations of a proton ingestion episode in a low-metallicity asymptotic giant branch star
• Not All Stars Are the Sun: Empirical Calibration of the Mixing Length for Metal-Poor Stars Using One-dimensional Stellar Evolution Models
• Molecular opacities for low-mass metal-poor AGB stars undergoing the Third Dredge Up
• Is Extra Mixing Really Needed in Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars?
• Low temperature Rosseland opacities with varied abundances of carbon and nitrogen
• On the Numerical Treatment and Dependence of Thermohaline Mixing in Red Giants
• Classically and Asteroseismically constrained 1D Stellar Evolution Models of $\alpha$ Centauri A and B using Empirical Mixing Length Calibrations
• Nuclear Reaction Rates and Carbon Star Formation
• NuGrid stellar data set - III. Updated low-mass AGB models and s-process nucleosynthesis with metallicities Z=0.01, Z=0.02 and Z=0.03
• The updated BaSTI stellar evolution models and isochrones. III. White Dwarfs
• The Core Mass Growth and Stellar Lifetime of Thermally Pulsing Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars
• The treatment of mixing in core helium burning models -- II. Constraints from cluster star counts
• Observational Tests and Predictive Stellar Evolution
• The Aarhus Red Giants Challenge I: Stellar structures in the red giant branch phase
• Evolution and Nucleosynthesis of AGB stars in Three Magellanic Cloud Clusters
• Code dependencies of pre-supernova evolution and nucleosynthesis in massive stars: Evolution to the end of core helium burning
• Thermohaline instability and rotation-induced mixing II- Yields of 3He for low- and intermediate-mass stars
• A He3 driven instability near the fully convective boundary
• The treatment of mixing in core helium burning models -- III. Suppressing core breathing pulses with a new constraint on overshoot
• Evolutionary modelling of subdwarf B stars using MESA with the predictive mixing and convective premixing schemes
• Effects of thermohaline instability and rotation-induced mixing on the evolution of light elements in the Galaxy : D, 3He and 4He
• Diagnostics of Stellar Modelling from Spectroscopy and Photometry of Globular Clusters
• Explaining the differences in massive star models from various simulations
• On Monolithic Supermassive Stars
• Modeling lithium rich carbon stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud: an independent distance indicator ?
• A phenomenological modification of thermohaline mixing in globular cluster red giants
• Schwarzschild and Ledoux are equivalent on evolutionary timescales
• The most metal-rich stars in the universe: chemical contributions of low and intermediate mass asymptotic giant branch stars with metallicities between $0.04\le Z\le \mathrm{0.10.}$
• The most metal-rich asymptotic giant branch stars
• Testing the entropy calibration of the radii of cool stars: models of alpha Centauri A and B
• Atomic diffusion in solar-like stars with MESA. Comparison with the Montreal/Montpellier and CESTAM stellar evolution codes
• Density Conversion between 1-D and 3-D Stellar Models with 1D-MESA2HYDRO-3D
• The NuGrid AGB Evolution and Nucleosynthesis Data Set

Cited by in corpus (9)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Time-Dependent Convection, Energy Conservation, Automatic Differentiation, and Infrastructure
• Characterizing Observed Extra Mixing Trends in Red Giants using the Reduced Density Ratio from Thermohaline Models
• Modelling the evolution and influence of dust in cosmological simulations that include the cold phase of the interstellar medium
• Red giants evolutionary status determination: the complete Kepler catalog
• New Constraints on Sodium Production in Globular Clusters From the ${}^{23}$Na${(}^3$He$,\text{d}{)}^{24}$Mg Reaction
• Evidence for the Keplerian orbit of a close companion around a giant star
• Beyond MESA Defaults: The Impact of Structural Resolution Uncertainty in p-mode Asteroseismology
• White dwarf eccentricity fluctuation and dissipation by AGB convection
• Aluminium-26 production in low- and intermediate-mass binary systems