The Aarhus Red Giants Challenge I: Stellar structures in the red giant branch phase

Abstract

(Abridged). We introduce the Aarhus Red Giants Challenge, a series of detailed comparisons between widely used stellar evolution and oscillation codes aiming at establishing the minimum level of uncertainties in properties of red giants arising solely from numerical implementations. Using 9 state-of-the-art stellar evolution codes, we defined a set of input physics and physical constants for our calculations and calibrated the convective efficiency to a specific point on the main sequence. We produced evolutionary tracks and stellar structure models at fixed radius along the red-giant branch for masses of 1.0 M${}_{\odot }$, 1.5 M${}_{\odot }$, 2.0 M${}_{\odot }$, and 2.5 M${}_{\odot }$, and compared the predicted stellar properties. Once models have been calibrated on the main sequence we find a residual spread in the predicted effective temperatures across all codes of ~20 K at solar radius and ~30-40 K in the RGB regardless of the considered stellar mass. The predicted ages show variations of 2-5% (increasing with stellar mass) which we track down to differences in the numerical implementation of energy generation. The luminosity of the RGB-bump shows a spread of about 10% for the considered codes, which translates into magnitude differences of ~0.1 mag in the optical V-band. We also compare the predicted [C/N] abundance ratio and found a spread of 0.1 dex or more for all considered masses. Our comparisons show that differences at the level of a few percent still remain in evolutionary calculations of red giants branch stars despite the use of the same input physics. These are mostly due to differences in the energy generation routines and interpolation across opacities, and call for further investigations on these matters in the context of using properties of red giants as benchmarks for astrophysical studies.

arXiv commentaccepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics

References in corpus (72)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the PAdova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST). I: Solar-Scaled Models
• The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database
• A large stellar evolution database for population synthesis studies. I. Scaled solar models and isochrones
• Low Temperature Opacities
• CODATA Recommended Values of the Fundamental Physical Constants: 2014
• The Fourteenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Spectroscopic Data from the extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey and from the second phase of the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
• A large stellar evolution database for population synthesis studies. II. Stellar models and isochrones for an alpha-enhanced metal distribution
• Gravity modes as a way to distinguish between hydrogen- and helium-burning red giant stars
• Fast core rotation in red-giant stars revealed by gravity-dominated mixed modes
• Updated Electron-Conduction Opacities: The Impact on Low-Mass Stellar Models
• Kepler Asteroseismology Program: Introduction and First Results
• Spin down of the core rotation in red giants
• New models for the evolution of Post-Asymptotic Giant Branch stars and Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae
• Post-Asymptotic Giant Branch Evolution of Low- and Intermediate-Mass Stars. Preliminary Results
• The Updated BaSTI Stellar Evolution Models and Isochrones: I. Solar Scaled Calculations
• The APOKASC Catalog: An Asteroseismic and Spectroscopic Joint Survey of Targets in the Kepler Fields
• Seismic diagnostics for transport of angular momentum in stars 1. Rotational splittings from the PMS to the RGB
• The Second APOKASC Catalog: The Empirical Approach
• Angular momentum transport within evolved low-mass stars
• ASTEC -- the Aarhus STellar Evolution Code
• Asteroseismology and Gaia: Testing Scaling Relations Using 2200 Kepler Stars with TGAS Parallaxes
• Standing on the shoulders of Dwarfs: the $Kepler$ asteroseismic LEGACY sample I - oscillation mode parameters
• Red giant masses and ages derived from carbon and nitrogen abundances
• Fundamental Properties of Stars using Asteroseismology from Kepler & CoRoT and Interferometry from the CHARA Array
• Asteroseismology of 16000 Kepler Red Giants: Global Oscillation Parameters, Masses, and Radii
• YREC: The Yale Rotating Stellar Evolution Code
• Galactic archaeology: mapping and dating stellar populations with asteroseismology of red-giant stars
• Standard and Non-Standard Plasma Neutrino Emission Revisited
• Spectroscopic determination of masses (and implied ages) for red giants
• Stellar population synthesis based modelling of the Milky Way using asteroseismology of 13000 Kepler red giants
• Low-temperature gas opacity - AESOPUS: a versatile and quick computational tool
• CESAM: a free code for stellar evolution calculations
• Testing the asteroseismic scaling relations for Red Giants with Eclipsing Binaries Observed by Kepler
• Bayesian distances and extinctions for giants observed by Kepler and APOGEE
• Verifying asteroseismically determined parameters of Kepler stars using hipparcos parallaxes: self-consistent stellar properties and distances
• A prevalence of dynamo-generated magnetic fields in the cores of intermediate-mass stars
• Oscillation frequencies for 35 \Kepler solar-type planet-hosting stars using Bayesian techniques and machine learning
• Measuring the vertical age structure of the Galactic disc using asteroseismology and SAGA
• Interferometric radii of bright Kepler stars with the CHARA Array: θ Cygni and 16 Cygni A and B
• A large stellar evolution database for population synthesis studies. V. Stellar models and isochrones with CNONa abundance anticorrelations
• Sounding open clusters: asteroseismic constraints from Kepler on the properties of NGC 6791 and NGC 6819
• Bayesian analysis of ages, masses, and distances to cool stars with non-LTE spectroscopic parameters
• The Yale-Potsdam Stellar Isochrones (YaPSI)
• Stroemgren survey for Asteroseismology and Galactic Archaeology: let the SAGA begin
• Testing convective-core overshooting using period spacings of dipole modes in red giants
• New evolutionary models for massive ZZ Ceti stars: I. First results for their pulsational properties
• Galactic Archaeology with asteroseismology and spectroscopy: Red giants observed by CoRoT and APOGEE
• Establishing the accuracy of asteroseismic mass and radius estimates of giant stars. I. Three eclipsing systems at [Fe/H]~ -0.3 and the need for a large high-precision sample
• Age and helium content of the open cluster NGC 6791 from multiple eclipsing binary members. I. Measurements, methods, and first results
• KIC 8410637: a 408-day period eclipsing binary containing a pulsating red giant
• Constraining mixing processes in stellar cores using asteroseismology. Impact of semiconvection in low-mass stars
• On the proper use of the Schwarzschild and Ledoux criteria in stellar evolution computations
• Structural glitches near the cores of red giants revealed by oscillations in g-mode period spacings from stellar models
• The BaSTI Stellar Evolution Database: models for extremely metal-poor and super-metal-rich stellar populations
• Post first dredge-up [C/N] ratio as age indicator. Theoretical calibration
• Dipole modes with depressed amplitudes in red giants are mixed modes
• Oscillating red giants in eclipsing binary systems: empirical reference value for asteroseismic scaling relation
• Kepler red-clump stars in the field and in open clusters: constraints on core mixing
• The Red-Giant Branch Bump Revisited: Constraints on Envelope Overshooting in a Wide Range of Masses and Metallicities
• On the red-giant luminosity bump
• On the magnitude difference between the main sequence turn off and the red giant branch bump in Galactic globular clusters
• The CoRoT Evolution and Seismic Tools Activity: Goals and Tasks
• Stellar models with the ML2 theory of convection
• Diagnostics of Stellar Modelling from Spectroscopy and Photometry of Globular Clusters
• Asteroseismic versus Gaia distances: a first comparison
• The Aarhus red giants challenge II. Stellar oscillations in the red giant branch phase
• Testing Asteroseismic Radii of Dwarfs and Subgiants with Kepler and Gaia
• Asteroseismic age determination for dwarfs and giants
• Table of Contents of: "Asteroseismology of Stellar Populations in the Milky Way"

Cited by in corpus (35)

• Probing the interior physics of stars through asteroseismology
• A Guide to Realistic Uncertainties on Fundamental Properties of Solar-Type Exoplanet Host Stars
• Solar structure and evolution
• The BAyesian STellar Algorithm (BASTA): a fitting tool for stellar studies, asteroseismology, exoplanets, and Galactic archaeology
• The formation of ultra-massive carbon-oxygen core white dwarfs and their evolutionary and pulsational properties
• Forever young white dwarfs: when stellar ageing stops
• The Aarhus red giants challenge II. Stellar oscillations in the red giant branch phase
• Age-Dating Red Giant Stars Associated with Galactic Disk and Halo Substructures
• A comparison of the dynamical and model-derived parameters of the pulsating eclipsing binary KIC9850387
• The evolution of ultra-massive carbon oxygen white dwarfs
• Structure and evolution of ultra-massive white dwarfs in general relativity
• TESS Asteroseismic Analysis of the Known Exoplanet Host Star HD 222076
• The APO-K2 Catalog. II. Accurate Stellar Ages for Red Giant Branch Stars across the Milky Way
• Dynamics in a stellar convective layer and at its boundary: Comparison of five 3D hydrodynamics codes
• SPECIES II. Stellar parameters of the EXPRESS program giant star sample
• Carbon-oxygen ultra-massive white dwarfs in general relativity
• Bridging the Gap between Intermediate and Massive Stars I: Validation of MESA against the State-of-the-Art Monash Stellar Evolution Program for a 2$M_{\odot }$ AGB Star
• BESTP -- An Automated Bayesian Modeling Tool for Asteroseismology
• Mixed Modes and Asteroseismic Surface Effects: II. Subgiant Systematics
• Connecting integrated RGB mass loss from asteroseismology and globular clusters
• Revisiting the Red-giant Branch Hosts KOI-3886 and $\iota$ Draconis. Detailed Asteroseismic Modeling and Consolidated Stellar Parameters
• New DA white dwarf models for asteroseismology of ZZ Ceti stars
• A Red Giants' Toy Story
• New simulations of accreting DA white dwarfs: inferring accretion rates from the surface contamination
• The impact of Coulomb diffusion of ions on the pulsational properties of DA white dwarfs
• Core overshoot constrained by the absence of a solar convective core and some solar-like stars
• Asteroseismology of the G8 subgiant beta Aquilae with SONG-Tenerife, SONG-Australia and TESS
• The pulsational properties of ultra-massive DB white dwarfs with carbon-oxygen cores coming from single-star evolution
• Weighing stars from birth to death: mass determination methods across the HRD
• The K2 Galactic Archaeology Program: Overview, target selection and survey properties
• A comparison of best fits obtained in white dwarf asteroseismology using the WDEC and the LPCODE
• Discovery of an optical cocoon tail behind the runaway HD 185806
• Realising efficient computation of individual frequencies for red-giant models
• Constraints from parallaxes and average period spacings in the asteroseismic study of 8 DAVs
• Two sequences in the age-metallicity relation as seen from [C/N] abundances in APOGEE