Schwarzschild and Ledoux are equivalent on evolutionary timescales

Abstract

Stellar evolution models calculate convective boundaries using either the Schwarzschild or Ledoux criterion, but confusion remains regarding which criterion to use. Here we present a 3D hydrodynamical simulation of a convection zone and adjacent radiative zone, including both thermal and compositional buoyancy forces. As expected, regions which are unstable according to the Ledoux criterion are convective. Initially, the radiative zone adjacent to the convection zone is Schwarzschild-unstable but Ledoux-stable due to a composition gradient. Over many convective overturn timescales the convection zone grows via entrainment. The convection zone saturates at the size originally predicted by the Schwarzschild criterion, although in this final state the Schwarzschild and Ledoux criteria agree. Therefore, the Schwarzschild criterion should be used to determine the size of stellar convection zones, except possibly during short-lived evolutionary stages in which entrainment persists.

arXiv commentManuscript accepted in ApJ Letters. Supplemental materials are in a Zenodo repository (https://zenodo.org/record/6344868). Code is in a Github repository (https://github.com/evanhanders/schwarzschild_or_ledoux)

References in corpus (28)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• Dedalus: A Flexible Framework for Numerical Simulations with Spectral Methods
• Mind the gap: The location of the lower edge of the pair instability supernovae black hole mass gap
• Turbulent Convection in Stellar Interiors. I. Hydrodynamic Simulation
• Time scales of Li evolution: a homogeneous analysis of open clusters from ZAMS to late-MS
• Internal mixing of rotating stars inferred from dipole gravity modes
• Global Seismology of the Sun
• A new model for mixing by double-diffusive convection (semi-convection): I. The conditions for layer formation
• The dependence of convective core overshooting on stellar mass: Additional binary systems and improved calibration
• Idealised hydrodynamic simulations of turbulent oxygen-burning shell convection in 4π geometry
• Constraining mixing processes in stellar cores using asteroseismology. Impact of semiconvection in low-mass stars
• On the proper use of the Schwarzschild and Ledoux criteria in stellar evolution computations
• Observing intermediate-mass black holes and the upper--stellar-mass gap with LIGO and Virgo
• Effect of uncertainties in stellar model parameters on estimated masses and radii of single stars
• Classically and Asteroseismically constrained 1D Stellar Evolution Models of $\alpha$ Centauri A and B using Empirical Mixing Length Calibrations
• The Li-age correlation: the Sun is unusually Li deficient for its age
• 3D hydrodynamic simulations of C ingestion into a convective O shell
• Convective core entrainment in 1D main sequence stellar models
• Dependence of Convective Boundary Mixing on Boundary Properties and Turbulence Strength
• Lithium depletion and angular momentum transport in solar-type stars
• Stellar convective penetration: parameterized theory and dynamical simulations
• Convective overshooting and penetration in a Boussinesq spherical shell
• Main Sequence Evolution with Layered Semiconvection
• Examining the Relationship Between Convective Core Overshoot and Stellar Properties Using Asteroseismology
• Blue supergiants as tests for stellar physics
• Penetration of a cooling convective layer into a stably-stratified composition gradient: entrainment at low Prandtl number

Cited by in corpus (18)

• Rejuvenated accretors have less bound envelopes: Impact of Roche lobe overflow on subsequent common envelope events
• Convective boundary mixing in main-sequence stars: theory and empirical constraints
• Convective Mixing in Gas Giant Planets with Primordial Composition Gradients
• Rotation reduces convective mixing in Jupiter and other gas giants
• Is Thermohaline Mixing the Full Story? Evidence for Separate Mixing Events near the Red Giant Branch Bump
• Dissecting the microphysics behind the metallicity-dependence of massive stars radii
• Bridging the Gap between Intermediate and Massive Stars I: Validation of MESA against the State-of-the-Art Monash Stellar Evolution Program for a 2$M_{\odot }$ AGB Star
• The impact of convective criteria on the properties of massive stars
• An efficient tidal dissipation mechanism via stellar magnetic fields
• Theoretical investigation of the occurrence of tidally excited oscillations in massive eccentric binary systems
• The imprint of convection on Type I X-ray bursts: Pauses in photospheric radius expansion lightcurves
• Convective Mixing: The Formation Channel of Li-rich Giants
• The Evolution of Jupiter and Saturn as a function of the Parameter R${}_{\rho }$
• The Kadomtsev pinch revisited for sheared-flow-stabilized Z-pinch modeling
• The theoretical pulsation spectra of hot B subdwarfs. Static and evolutionary STELUM models
• Evolutionary models for the Very Massive Stars in the R136 cluster of 30 Doradus in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Magnetized oscillatory double-diffusive convection
• 3D Simulations of Convective Entrainment in Gas Giants: Rotation and Decreasing Luminosity as Barriers to Mixing