Is Thermohaline Mixing the Full Story? Evidence for Separate Mixing Events near the Red Giant Branch Bump

Abstract

The abundances of mixing--sensitive elements including lithium, [C/N], and 12C/13C are known to change near the red giant branch bump. The explanation most often offered for these alterations is double diffusive thermohaline mixing in the stellar interior. In this analysis, we investigate the ability of thermohaline mixing to explain the observed timing of these chemical depletion events. Recent observational measurements of lithium and [C/N] show that the abundance of lithium decreases before the abundance of [C/N], whereas numerical simulations of the propagation of the thermohaline mixing region computed with MESA show that the synthetic abundances drop simultaneously. We therefore conclude that thermohaline mixing alone cannot explain the distinct events of lithium depletion and [C/N] depletion, as the simultaneity predicted by simulations is not consistent with the observation of separate drops. We thus invite more sophisticated theoretical explanations for the observed temporal separation of these chemical depletion episodes as well as more extensive observational explorations across a range of masses and metallicities.

arXiv commentIn revision at AAS Journals. 9 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (64)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions
• The 2.5 m Telescope of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions
• The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV: Mapping the Milky Way, Nearby Galaxies, and the Distant Universe
• Low Temperature Opacities
• ASPCAP: The Apogee Stellar Parameter and Chemical Abundances Pipeline
• Shell-model calculations of stellar weak interaction rates: II. Weak rates for nuclei in the mass range A=45-65 in supernovae environment
• The Fourteenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Spectroscopic Data from the extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey and from the second phase of the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
• Updated Electron-Conduction Opacities: The Impact on Low-Mass Stellar Models
• The Data Reduction Pipeline for the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
• Abundances, Stellar Parameters, and Spectra From the SDSS-III/APOGEE Survey
• Turbulent Convection in Stellar Interiors. I. Hydrodynamic Simulation
• Thermohaline mixing: A physical mechanism governing the photospheric composition of low-mass giants
• The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE) Spectrographs
• Target Selection for the SDSS-IV APOGEE-2 Survey
• Thermohaline instability and rotation-induced mixing. III - Grid of stellar models and asymptotic asteroseismic quantities from the pre-main sequence up to the AGB for low- and intermediate-mass stars at various metallicities
• APOGEE Data Releases 13 and 14: Data and Analysis
• Thermohaline instability and rotation-induced mixing. I - Low- and intermediate-mass solar metallicity stars up to the end of the AGB
• Red giant masses and ages derived from carbon and nitrogen abundances
• Thermodynamic functions of dense plasmas: analytic approximations for astrophysical applications
• Deep Mixing of He-3: Reconciling Big Bang and Stellar Nucleosynthesis
• Spectroscopic determination of masses (and implied ages) for red giants
• Rotational mixing in low-mass stars II. Self-consistent models of Pop II RGB stars
• Coulomb tunneling for fusion reactions in dense matter: Path integral Monte Carlo versus mean field
• Carbon, nitrogen and $\alpha$-element abundances determine the formation sequence of the Galactic thick and thin disks
• Internal mixing of rotating stars inferred from dipole gravity modes
• Numerically determined transport laws for fingering ("thermohaline") convection in astrophysics
• New H-band Stellar Spectral Libraries for the SDSS-III/APOGEE survey
• Chemical Transport and Spontaneous Layer Formation in Fingering Convection in Astrophysics
• Numerical Simulations of Thermohaline Convection: Implications for Extra-Mixing in Low-Mass RGB Stars
• Thermohaline mixing in evolved low-mass stars
• Not All Stars Are the Sun: Empirical Calibration of the Mixing Length for Metal-Poor Stars Using One-dimensional Stellar Evolution Models
• Red Giant Branch Bump Brightness and Number Counts in 72 Galactic Globular Clusters Observed with the Hubble Space Telescope
• The dependence of convective core overshooting on stellar mass: reality check, and additional evidence
• Thermohaline Mixing: Does It Really Govern the Atmospheric Chemical Composition of Low-Mass Red Giants?
• Constraining Metallicity-dependent Mixing and Extra Mixing using [C/N] in Alpha-Rich Field Giants
• On the Numerical Treatment and Dependence of Thermohaline Mixing in Red Giants
• Lithium-Rich Giants in Globular Clusters
• The depletion of carbon by extra mixing in metal-poor giants
• Abundance Anomalies and Rotational Evolution of Low Mass Red Giants: A Maximal Mixing Approach
• The Gaia-ESO survey: impact of extra-mixing on C- and N-abundances of giant stars
• A New Method for the Asteroseismic Determination of the Evolutionary State of Red-Giant Stars
• Inhibition of thermohaline mixing by a magnetic field in Ap star descendants: Implications for the Galactic evolution of 3He
• The thermohaline, Richardson, Rayleigh-Taylor, Solberg-Hoiland, and GSF criteria in rotating stars
• Population synthesis to constrain Galactic and Stellar Physics- I- Determining age and mass of thin-disc red-giant stars
• Lithium in red giant stars: Constraining non-standard mixing with large surveys in the Gaia era
• The Gaia-ESO survey: Mixing processes in low-mass stars traced by lithium abundance in cluster and field stars
• Thermohaline instability and rotation-induced mixing II- Yields of 3He for low- and intermediate-mass stars
• The Red-Giant Branch Bump Revisited: Constraints on Envelope Overshooting in a Wide Range of Masses and Metallicities
• Stellar convective penetration: parameterized theory and dynamical simulations
• Convective overshooting and penetration in a Boussinesq spherical shell
• Insights from the APOKASC Determination of the Evolutionary State of Red-Giant Stars by consolidation of different methods
• Diagnostics of Stellar Modelling from Spectroscopy and Photometry of Globular Clusters
• A phenomenological modification of thermohaline mixing in globular cluster red giants
• Schwarzschild and Ledoux are equivalent on evolutionary timescales
• The effect of rotation on fingering convection in stellar interiors
• Investigating the Consistency of Stellar Evolution Models with Globular Cluster Observations via the Red Giant Branch Bump
• The interaction between shear and fingering (thermohaline) convection
• Multidimensional low-Mach number time-implicit hydrodynamic simulations of convective helium shell burning in a massive star
• Thermohaline mixing in extremely metal-poor stars

Cited by in corpus (9)

• At least one in a dozen stars exhibits evidence of planetary ingestion
• Nature vs. Nurture: Distinguishing Effects from Stellar Processing and Chemical Evolution on Carbon and Nitrogen in Red Giant Stars
• Evidence of extra-mixing in field giants as traced by lithium and carbon isotope ratio
• Characterizing Observed Extra Mixing Trends in Red Giants using the Reduced Density Ratio from Thermohaline Models
• An Investigation of Non-Canonical Mixing in Red Giant Stars Using APOGEE 12C/13C Ratios Observed in Open Cluster Stars
• Are Lithium-Rich Giants Binaries? A Radial Velocity Variability Analysis of 1,400 Giants
• Convective Mixing: The Formation Channel of Li-rich Giants
• Beyond MESA Defaults: The Impact of Structural Resolution Uncertainty in p-mode Asteroseismology
• Toward a Comprehensive Grid of Cepheid Models with MESA II. Impact of Physical and Numerical Assumptions on Elemental Abundances