Overturning the Case for Gravitational Powering in the Prototypical Cooling Lyman-alpha Nebula
arXiv:1501.05312 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/802/1/32
Abstract
The Nilsson et al. (2006) Lyman-alpha nebula has often been cited as the most plausible example of a Lyman-alpha nebula powered by gravitational cooling. In this paper, we bring together new data from the Hubble Space Telescope and the Herschel Space Observatory as well as comparisons to recent theoretical simulations in order to revisit the questions of the local environment and most likely power source for the Lyman-alpha nebula. In contrast to previous results, we find that this Lyman-alpha nebula is associated with 6 nearby galaxies and an obscured AGN that is offset by 4"30 kpc from the Lyman-alpha peak. The local region is overdense relative to the field, by a factor of 10, and at low surface brightness levels the Lyman-alpha emission appears to encircle the position of the obscured AGN, highly suggestive of a physical association. At the same time, we confirm that there is no compact continuum source located within 2-3"15-23 kpc of the Lyman-alpha peak. Since the latest cold accretion simulations predict that the brightest Lyman-alpha emission will be coincident with a central growing galaxy, we conclude that this is actually a strong argument against, rather than for, the idea that the nebula is gravitationally-powered. While we may be seeing gas within cosmic filaments, this gas is primarily being lit up, not by gravitational energy, but due to illumination from a nearby buried AGN.
arXiv commentAccepted to ApJ; 21 pages in emulateapj format; 12 figures, 1 table
References in corpus (71)
- The Global Schmidt Law in Star Forming Galaxies
- How Do Galaxies Get Their Gas?
- EAZY: A Fast, Public Photometric Redshift Code
- Cold streams in early massive hot haloes as the main mode of galaxy formation
- The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey: Initial Results From Optical and Near-Infrared Imaging
- GOODS-Herschel: an infrared main sequence for star-forming galaxies
- An ultra-deep near-infrared spectrum of a compact quiescent galaxy at z=2.2
- 3D-HST WFC3-selected Photometric Catalogs in the Five CANDELS/3D-HST Fields: Photometry, Photometric Redshifts and Stellar Masses
- Mid-Infrared Selection of Active Galaxies
- Spectral Energy Distributions of Hard X-ray selected AGNs in the XMDS Survey
- Constraining the Low-Mass Slope of the Star Formation Sequence at 0.5<z<2.5
- The Herschel Multi-tiered Extragalactic Survey: HerMES
- 3D-HST: A wide-field grism spectroscopic survey with the Hubble Space Telescope
- Obscured and unobscured active galactic nuclei in the Spitzer Space Telescope First Look Survey
- Identifying Luminous AGN in Deep Surveys: Revised IRAC Selection Criteria
- The Chandra Deep Field-South Survey: 4 Ms Source Catalogs
- Structural Parameters of Galaxies in CANDELS
- Multi-Wavelength Constraints on the Cosmic Star Formation History from Spectroscopy: the Rest-Frame UV, H-alpha, and Infrared Luminosity Functions at Redshifts 1.9<z<3.4
- Diffuse Lyman Alpha Emitting Halos: A Generic Property of High Redshift Star Forming Galaxies
- A Critical Assessment of Photometric Redshift Methods: A CANDELS Investigation
- Lyman Alpha Radiation From Collapsing Protogalaxies I: Characteristics of the Emergent Spectrum
- The Hubble Space Telescope Wide Field Camera 3 Early Release Science data: Panchromatic Faint Object Counts for 0.2-2 microns wavelength
- Cooling Radiation and the Lyman-alpha Luminosity of Forming Galaxies
- The Chandra Deep Field-South Survey: 2 Ms Source Catalogs
- Lyman Alpha Cooling Radiation from High-Redshift Halos
- Lyman-alpha Cooling Emission from Galaxy Formation
- Color-selected galaxies at z~6 in the Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey
- Extended Lyman-alpha emission from cold accretion streams
- Fluorescent Ly-alpha emission from the high-redshift intergalactic medium
- Optical spectroscopy and X-ray detections of a sample of quasars and AGN selected in the mid-infrared from two Spitzer wide-area surveys
- Spitzer's Contribution to the AGN Population
- Spitzer Power-law AGN Candidates in the Chandra Deep Field-North
- The Herschel Multi-Tiered Extragalactic Survey: Source Extraction and Cross-Identifications in Confusion-Dominated SPIRE Images
- Gravity-driven Lyman-alpha blobs from cold streams into galaxies
- Lyman alpha Radiative Transfer with Dust: Escape Fractions from Simulated High-Redshift Galaxies
- Superwind model of extended Lyman alpha emitters at high redshift
- A Lyman-alpha blob in the GOODS South field: evidence for cold accretion onto a dark matter halo
- Lyman-alpha Emission From Cosmic Structure I: Fluorescence
- Lyman-alpha Emission from Structure Formation
- The Chandra Deep Protocluster Survey: Ly-alpha Blobs are powered by heating, not cooling
- Spitzer observations of MAMBO galaxies: weeding out active nuclei in starbursting proto-ellipticals
- Lyman alpha Resonant Scattering in Young Galaxies - Predictions from Cosmological Simulations
- A multi-wavelength study of z = 3.15 Lyman-alpha emitters in the GOODS South Field
- On the (non-)enhancement of the Lyman α equivalent width by a multiphase interstellar medium
- Central Powering of the Largest Lyman-alpha Nebula is Revealed by Polarized Radiation
- HST Images of a Galaxy Group at z=2.81, and the Sizes of Damped Lyman Alpha Galaxies
- Hot gas halos around disk galaxies: Confronting cosmological simulations with observations
- Extended Lyman-Alpha Emission around Star-forming Galaxies
- Strong Field-to-Field Variation of Lyman alpha Nebulae Populations at z~2.3
- The Nature of Lya Blobs: Supernova-Dominated Primordial Galaxies
- The Sudden Death of the Nearest Quasar
- The Lyman-alpha glow of gas falling into the dark matter halo of a z=3 galaxy
- The Discovery of a Large Lyman-alpha+HeII Nebula at z~1.67: A Candidate Low Metallicity Region?
- The extended Lyman-alpha emission surrounding the z=3.04 radio-quiet QSO1205-30: Primordial infalling gas illuminated by the quasar?
- Probing Galaxy Formation with He II Cooling Lines
- Filamentary Large Scale Structure Traced by Six Ly-alpha Blobs at z=2.3
- HerMES: SPIRE Science Demonstration Phase Maps
- Resolving the optical emission lines of Lya blob 'B1' at z=2.38: another hidden quasar
- Resolving the Galaxies within a Giant Lya Nebula: Witnessing the Formation of a Galaxy Group?
- On the Origin of Lyman Blobs at High Redshift: Submillimetric Evidence for a Hyperwind Galaxy at z=3.1
- Nature of Lyman Alpha Blobs: Powered by Extreme Starbursts
- Dissecting the Lyman Alpha Emission Halo of LAB1
- Infrared and millimetre-wavelength evidence for cold accretion within a z = 2.83 Lyman-alpha blob
- A Successful Broad-band Survey for Giant Lya Nebulae II: Spectroscopic Confirmation
- A Successful Broad-band Survey for Giant Lya Nebulae I: Survey Design and Candidate Selection
- Extended Lyman-alpha emission from interacting galaxies at high redshifts
- Continuum Emission by Cooling Clouds
- B2 0902+34: A Collapsing Protogiant Elliptical Galaxy at z=3.4
- Pinpointing the Molecular Gas within a Lyman Alpha Blob at z ~ 2.7
- Obscured star formation in Ly-alpha blobs at z = 3.1
- Stochastic backgrounds of gravitational waves from cosmological sources - The role of dark energy
Cited by in corpus (38)
- Ubiquitous giant Ly nebulae around the brightest quasars at revealed with MUSE
- Quasar Quartet Embedded in Giant Nebula Reveals Rare Massive Structure in Distant Universe
- QSO MUSEUM I: A sample of 61 extended Ly-emission nebulae surrounding quasars
- The MUSE-Wide Survey: Survey Description and First Data Release
- A young star-forming galaxy at z = 3.5 with an extended Ly\, halo seen with MUSE
- Deep HeII and CIV Spectroscopy of a Giant Lyman alpha Nebula: Dense Compact Gas Clumps in the Circumgalactic Medium of a z~2 Quasar
- MusE GAs FLOw and Wind (MEGAFLOW) VIII. Discovery of a MgII emission halo probed by a quasar sightline
- The Stacked Lyman-Alpha Emission Profile from the Circum-Galactic Medium of z~2 Quasars
- Figuring Out Gas & Galaxies in Enzo (FOGGIE). II. Emission from the z=3 Circumgalactic Medium
- Discovery of a Proto-cluster Associated with a Ly- Blob Pair at z=2.3
- Discovery of a faint, star-forming, multiply lensed, Lyman-alpha blob
- Chasing Lyman alpha-emitting galaxies at z = 8.8
- ALMA observations of Lyman-alpha Blob 1: halo sub-structure illuminated from within
- Deciphering Lyman blob 1 with deep MUSE observations
- Overdensity of submillimeter galaxies around the MAMMOTH-1 nebula
- Extended and broad Lyman alpha emission around a BAL quasar at z~5
- A Faint Flux-Limited Lyman Alpha Emitter Sample at
- Deep rest-frame far-UV spectroscopy of the giant Lyman-alpha emitter 'Himiko'
- About AGN ionization echoes, thermal echoes, and ionization deficits in low redshift Lyman-alpha blobs
- ODIN: Where Do Lyman-alpha Blobs Live? Contextualizing Blob Environments within the Large-Scale Structure
- ALMA observations of a z~3.1 Protocluster: Star Formation from Active Galactic Nuclei and Lyman-Alpha Blobs in an Overdense Environment
- Deep submillimeter and radio observations in the SSA22 field. I. Powering sources and Lyα escape fraction of Lyα blobs
- Probing the Inner Circumgalactic Medium and Quasar Illumination around the Reddest `Extremely Red Quasar' (ERQ)
- The Detection of Intergalactic Halpha Emission from the Slug Nebula at z~2.3
- The Ionised- and Cool-Gas Content of The BR1202-0725 System as seen by MUSE and ALMA
- CHORUS. III. Photometric and Spectroscopic Properties of Ly Blobs at
- Mapping the Morphology and Kinematics of a Lyman-alpha-selected Nebula at z=3.15 with MUSE
- Strongly Time-Variable Ultra-Violet Metal Line Emission from the Circum-Galactic Medium of High-Redshift Galaxies
- Spectro-polarimetry confirms central powering of a Ly nebula at z=3.09
- Observational Aspects of Galactic Accretion at Redshift 3.3
- The Origin and Evolution of Lyman-alpha Blobs in Cosmological Galaxy Formation Simulations
- The average submillimetre properties of Lyman-alpha Blobs at z=3
- NuSTAR hard X-ray data and Gemini 3D spectra reveal powerful AGN and outflow histories in two low-redshift Lyman- blobs
- C IV and He II Line Emission of Lyman Alpha Blobs: Powered by Shock Heated Gas
- Lyman- emission from a WISE-selected optically faint powerful radio galaxy M151304.72-252439.7 at = 3.132
- Understanding Lyman-alpha Nebulae at Low Redshift I: The Sizes, Powering, and Kinematics of "Green Bean" Galaxies
- Modelling the Evolution of Ly Blobs and Ly Emitters
- A Ly-alpha nebula at z~3.3