Evidence for (and Against) Progenitor Bias in the Size Growth of Compact Red Galaxies

Abstract

Most massive passive galaxies are compact at high redshifts, but similarly compact massive galaxies are rare in the local universe. The most common interpretation of this phenomenon is that massive galaxies have grown in size by a factor of about five since redshift z=2. An alternative explanation is that recently quenched massive galaxies are larger (a "progenitor bias"). In this paper we explore the importance of progenitor bias by looking for systematic differences in the stellar populations of compact early-type galaxies in the DEEP2 survey as a function of size. Our analysis is based on applying the statistical technique of bootstrap resampling to constrain differences in the median ages of our samples and to begin to characterize the distribution of stellar populations in our co-added spectra. The light-weighted ages of compact early-type galaxies at redshifts 0.5 < z < 1.4 are compared to those of a control sample of larger galaxies at similar redshifts. We find that massive compact early-type galaxies selected on the basis of red color and high bulge-to-total ratio are younger than similarly selected larger galaxies, suggesting that size growth in these objects is not driven mainly by progenitor bias, and that individual galaxies grow as their stellar populations age. However, compact early-type galaxies selected on the basis of image smoothness and high bulge-to-total ratio are older than a control sample of larger galaxies. Progenitor bias will play a significant role in defining the apparent size changes of early-type galaxies if they are selected on the basis of the smoothness of their light distributions.

arXiv comment39 pages, 10 figures. Astrophysical Journal (in press)

References in corpus (104)

• Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• The Host Galaxies of AGN
• The Origin of the Mass--Metallicity Relation: Insights from 53,000 Star-Forming Galaxies in the SDSS
• The physical properties of star forming galaxies in the low redshift universe
• 3D-HST+CANDELS: The Evolution of the Galaxy Size-Mass Distribution since $z=3$
• Passively Evolving Early-type Galaxies at 1.4<z<2.5 in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field
• The Growth of Massive Galaxies Since z=2
• The Two Phases of Galaxy Formation
• Confirmation of the remarkable compactness of massive quiescent galaxies at z~2.3: early-type galaxies did not form in a simple monolithic collapse
• The DEEP2 Galaxy Redshift Survey: Design, Observations, Data Reduction, and Redshifts
• The Mass Assembly History of Field Galaxies: Detection of an Evolving Mass Limit for Star Forming Galaxies
• The All-wavelength Extended Groth Strip International Survey (AEGIS) Data Sets
• How Do Disks Survive Mergers?
• The Relation Between Compact, Quiescent High Redshift Galaxies and Massive Nearby Elliptical Galaxies: Evidence for Hierarchical, Inside-Out Growth
• Strong size evolution of the most massive galaxies since z~2
• Science Objectives and Early Results of the DEEP2 Redshift Survey
• Can Minor Merging Account for the Size Growth of Quiescent Galaxies? New Results from the CANDELS Survey
• The DEEP Groth Strip Survey II. Hubble Space Telescope Structural Parameters of Galaxies in the Groth Strip
• Size evolution of the most massive galaxies at 1.7<z<3 from GOODS NICMOS survey imaging
• Formation of early-type galaxies from cosmological initial conditions
• The cosmological size and velocity dispersion evolution of massive early-type galaxies
• Red Nuggets at z~1.5: Compact passive galaxies and the formation of the Kormendy Relation
• Population Synthesis in the Blue IV: Accurate Model Predictions for Lick Indices and UBV Colors in Single Stellar Populations
• The K20 survey. VI. The Distribution of the Stellar Masses in Galaxies up to z~2
• The SAURON project XVI: On the Sources of Ionisation for the Gas in Elliptical and Lenticular Galaxies
• GMASS Ultradeep Spectroscopy of Galaxies at 1.4<z<2. II. Superdense passive galaxies: how did they form and evolve ?
• On the Origin of [OII] Emission in Red Sequence and Post-starburst Galaxies
• The stellar masses of 25000 galaxies at 0.2<z<1.0 estimated by the COMBO-17 survey
• Newly-quenched galaxies as the cause for the apparent evolution in average size of the population
• Recent Structural Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies: Size Growth from z=1 to z=0
• The Nature of LINER-like Emission in Red Galaxies
• The Assembly History of Field Spheroidals: Evolution of Mass-to-light Ratios and Signatures of Recent Star Formation
• A simple model for the size-evolution of elliptical galaxies
• Compact High-Redshift Galaxies Are the Cores of the Most Massive Present-Day Spheroids
• HST and Spitzer imaging of red and blue galaxies at z~2.5: A correlation between size and star formation activity from compact quiescent galaxies to extended star forming galaxies
• A Catalogue and Analysis of Local Galaxy Ages and Metallicities
• The Dependence of Quenching upon the Inner Structure of Galaxies at 0.5<z< 0.8 in the DEEP2/AEGIS Survey
• The dramatic size evolution of elliptical galaxies and the quasar feedback
• Mergers in Lambda-CDM: Uncertainties in Theoretical Predictions and Interpretations of the Merger Rate
• The Majority of Compact Massive Galaxies at z~2 are Disk Dominated
• A Large Population of Massive Compact Post-Starburst Galaxies at z>1: Implications for the Size Evolution and Quenching Mechanism of Quiescent Galaxies
• HST/WFC3 Confirmation of the Inside-Out Growth of Massive Galaxies at 0<z<2 and Identification of their Star Forming Progenitors at z~3
• The sizes, masses and specific star-formation rates of massive galaxies at 1.3<z<1.5: strong evidence in favour of evolution via minor mergers
• NICMOS Imaging of DRGs in the HDF-S: A Relation Between Star-Formation and Size at z ~ 2.5
• Superdense massive galaxies in the Nearby Universe
• Sizes and surface brightness profiles of quiescent galaxies at z ~ 2
• The DEEP3 Galaxy Redshift Survey: The Impact of Environment on the Size Evolution of Massive Early-type Galaxies at Intermediate Redshift
• Dissecting the size evolution of elliptical galaxies since z~1: puffing up vs minor merging scenarios
• Superdense galaxies and the mass-size relation at low redshift
• A census of metals and baryons in stars in the local Universe
• Superdense Massive Galaxies in Wings Local Clusters
• The Morphologies of Massive Galaxies at 1<z<3 in the CANDELS-UDS Field: Compact Bulges, and the Rise and Fall of Massive Disks
• Galaxy luminosities, stellar masses, sizes, velocity dispersions as a function of morphological type
• Red Nuggets at High Redshift: Structural Evolution of Quiescent Galaxies Over 10 Gyr of Cosmic History
• On the Size and Comoving Mass Density Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies
• CANDELS Observations of the Structural Properties and Evolution of Galaxies in a Cluster at z=1.62
• An HST/WFC3-IR Morphological Survey of Galaxies at z = 1.5-3.6: I. Survey Description and Morphological Properties of Star Forming Galaxies
• Reliable random error estimation in the measurement of line-strength indices
• On the Dearth of Compact, Massive, Red Sequence Galaxies in the Local Universe
• Quiescent Galaxies in the 3D-HST Survey: Spectroscopic Confirmation of a Large Number of Galaxies with Relatively Old Stellar Populations at z~2
• The dominant role of mergers in the size evolution of massive early-type galaxies since z ~ 1
• The Kormendy relation of massive elliptical galaxies at z~1.5. Evidence for size evolution ?
• Cosmic Evolution of Size and Velocity Dispersion for Early Type Galaxies
• Measuring Ages and Elemental Abundances from Unresolved Stellar Populations: Fe, Mg, C, N, and Ca
• The evolution of the mass-size relation for early type galaxies from z~1 to the present: dependence on environment, mass-range and detailed morphology
• The relative abundance of compact and normal massive early-type galaxies and its evolution from redshift z~2 to the present
• The Carnegie-Irvine Galaxy Survey. III. The Three-Component Structure of Nearby Elliptical Galaxies
• Galaxy stellar mass functions of different morphological types in clusters, and their evolution between z=0.8 and z=0
• Hubble Space Telescope Imaging of the CFRS and LDSS Redshift Surveys---III. Field elliptical galaxies at 0.2 < z < 1.0
• Formation epochs, star formation histories and sizes of massive early-type galaxies in cluster and field environments at z=1.2: insights from the rest-frame UV
• High-redshift elliptical galaxies: are they (all) really compact?
• The stellar population histories of early-type galaxies. III. The Coma Cluster
• Confirmation of the compactness of a z=1.91 quiescent galaxy with Hubble Space Telescope's Wide Field Camera 3
• Keck Spectroscopy of z>1 Field Spheroidals: Dynamical Constraints on the Growth Rate of Red "Nuggets"
• Average spectra of massive galaxies in the SDSS
• The fundamental plane of EDisCS galaxies - The effect of size evolution
• The environmental dependence of the stellar mass-size relation in STAGES galaxies
• Spot the difference. Impact of different selection criteria on observed properties of passive galaxies in zCOSMOS 20-k sample
• The Morphology of Passively Evolving Galaxies at z ~ 2 from HST/WFC3 Deep Imaging in the Hubble Ultradeep Field
• The evolution of the number density of compact galaxies
• Superdense massive galaxies in the ESO Distant Cluster Survey (EDisCS)
• Fossil Evidence for the Two-phase Formation of Elliptical Galaxies
• Morphological evolution of galaxies from ultradeep HST WFC3 imaging: the Hubble sequence at z~2
• Studying The Star Formation Histories of Galaxies in Clusters from Composite Spectra
• The DEEP2 Galaxy Redshift Survey: Mean Ages and Metallicities of Red Field Galaxies at z ~ 0.9 from Stacked Keck/DEIMOS Spectra
• Massive and Newly Dead: Discovery of a Significant Population of Galaxies with High Velocity Dispersions and Strong Balmer Lines at z~1.5 from Deep Keck Spectra and HST/WFC3 Imaging
• The Mass Assembly History of Spheroidal Galaxies: Did Newly-Formed Systems Arise Via Major Mergers?
• Probing recent star formation with absorption-line strengths in hierarchical models and observations
• The evolution of galaxy size and morphology at z~0.5-3.0 in the GOODS-N region with HST/WFC3 data
• The age dependence of the size-stellar mass relation and some implications
• The number density of superdense early-type galaxies at 1<z<2 and the local cluster galaxies
• Early-type galaxies at z~1.3. IV. Scaling relations in different environments
• Evolution of the Early-Type Galaxy Fraction in Clusters since z = 0.8
• Gemini K-band NIRI Adaptive Optics Observations of Massive Galaxies at 1 < z < 2
• Constraining the star formation and the assembly histories of normal and compact early-type galaxies at 1<z<2
• Sizes and ages of SDSS ellipticals: Comparison with hierarchical galaxy formation models
• The Size Evolution of Passive Galaxies: Observations from the Wide Field Camera 3 Early Release Science Program
• Shape Evolution of Massive Early-Type Galaxies: Confirmation of Increased Disk Prevalence at z>1
• Structure of Protocluster Galaxies: Accelerated Structural Evolution in Overdense Environments?
• On the Shapes and Structures of High-Redshift Compact Galaxies
• Ultra deep sub-kpc view of nearby massive compact galaxies
• Colour gradients in normal and compact early-type galaxies at 1<z<2
• Discovery of Nine Intermediate Redshift Compact Quiescent Galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey

Cited by in corpus (21)

• The diverse evolutionary paths of simulated high-z massive, compact galaxies to z=0
• Fast and slow paths to quiescence: ages and sizes of 400 quiescent galaxies from the LEGA-C survey
• Massive post-starburst galaxies at z > 1 are compact proto-spheroids
• Hiding in plain sight: An abundance of compact massive spheroids in the local Universe
• An analysis of the evolving comoving number density of galaxies in hydrodynamical simulations
• Avoiding progenitor bias: The structural and mass evolution of Brightest Group and Cluster Galaxies in Hierarchical models since z~1
• Minor Mergers or Progenitor Bias? The Stellar Ages of Small and Large Quenched Early-Type Galaxies
• The structure of post-starburst galaxies at $0.5<z<2$: evidence for two distinct quenching routes at different epochs
• Sizes, Colour gradients and Resolved Stellar Mass Distributions for the Massive Cluster Galaxies in XMMUJ2235-2557 at z = 1.39
• Morphology Dependence Of Stellar Age in Quenched Galaxies at Redshift ~ 1.2: Massive Compact Galaxies Are Older Than More Extended Ones
• A Detection of the Environmental Dependence of the Sizes and Stellar Haloes of Massive Central Galaxies
• The kinematics of massive quiescent galaxies at $1.4<z<2.1$: dark matter fractions, IMF variation, and the relation to local early-type galaxies
• Testing the presence of multiple photometric components in nearby early-type galaxies using SDSS
• HST/WFC3 grism observations of $z\sim 1$ clusters: evidence for evolution in the mass-size relation of quiescent galaxies from poststarburst galaxies
• Ultramassive dense early-type galaxies: velocity dispersions and number density evolution since z=1.6
• The role of quenching time in the evolution of the mass-size relation of passive galaxies from the WISP survey
• Implications of Increased Central Mass Surface Densities for the Quenching of Low-mass Galaxies
• The relationship between galaxy and halo sizes in the Illustris and IllustrisTNG simulations
• MOSEL and IllustrisTNG: Massive Extended Galaxies at z=2 Quench Later Than Normal-size Galaxies
• Gamma-rays from the binary system containing PSR J2032+4127 during its periastron passage
• The LEGA-C galaxy survey: multiple quenching channels for quiescent galaxies at $z\sim 1$