Quantum Error Mitigation

Abstract

For quantum computers to successfully solve real-world problems, it is necessary to tackle the challenge of noise: the errors which occur in elementary physical components due to unwanted or imperfect interactions. The theory of quantum fault tolerance can provide an answer in the long term, but in the coming era of `NISQ' machines we must seek to mitigate errors rather than completely remove them. This review surveys the diverse methods that have been proposed for quantum error mitigation, assesses their in-principle efficacy, and then describes the hardware demonstrations achieved to date. We identify the commonalities and limitations among the methods, noting how mitigation methods can be chosen according to the primary type of noise present, including algorithmic errors. Open problems in the field are identified and we discuss the prospects for realising mitigation-based devices that can deliver quantum advantage with an impact on science and business.

References in corpus (13)

• Supplementary information for "Quantum supremacy using a programmable superconducting processor"
• Surface codes: Towards practical large-scale quantum computation
• Strong quantum computational advantage using a superconducting quantum processor
• Detecting arbitrary quantum errors via stabilizer measurements on a sublattice of the surface code
• Restrictions on Transversal Encoded Quantum Gate Sets
• Experimental Quantum Computations on a Topologically Encoded Qubit
• N-representability is QMA-complete
• Purification-based quantum error mitigation of pair-correlated electron simulations
• Quantum-classical hybrid algorithm using an error-mitigating $N$-representability condition to compute the Mott metal-insulator transition
• Compilation by stochastic Hamiltonian sparsification
• Comparison of a quantum error correction threshold for exact and approximate errors
• Efficient Two-Electron Ansatz for Benchmarking Quantum Chemistry on a Quantum Computer
• Virtual quantum error detection

Cited by in corpus (277)

• Barren Plateaus in Variational Quantum Computing
• Quantum-centric Supercomputing for Materials Science: A Perspective on Challenges and Future Directions
• Benchmarking quantum computers
• Machine Learning for Practical Quantum Error Mitigation
• Decoding algorithms for surface codes
• Combining quantum processors with real-time classical communication
• Quasiprobabilities in quantum thermodynamics and many-body systems
• Towards large-scale quantum optimization solvers with few qubits
• Artificial Intelligence for Quantum Computing
• Quantum computing for chemistry and physics applications from a Monte Carlo perspective
• Quantifying the effect of gate errors on variational quantum eigensolvers for quantum chemistry
• Quantum-Enhanced Greedy Combinatorial Optimization Solver
• Learning quantum states and unitaries of bounded gate complexity
• Entanglement Structure and Information Protection in Noisy Hybrid Quantum Circuits
• Folded Spectrum VQE : A quantum computing method for the calculation of molecular excited states
• Many-Body Open Quantum Systems
• Benchmarking digital quantum simulations above hundreds of qubits using quantum critical dynamics
• Visualizing Dynamics of Charges and Strings in (2+1)D Lattice Gauge Theories
• An Empirical Comparison of Optimizers for Quantum Machine Learning with SPSA-based Gradients
• How quantum computing can enhance biomarker discovery
• Hybrid Oscillator-Qubit Quantum Processors: Instruction Set Architectures, Abstract Machine Models, and Applications
• Doubly optimal parallel wire cutting without ancilla qubits
• Exponentially tighter bounds on limitations of quantum error mitigation
• Group-theoretic error mitigation enabled by classical shadows and symmetries
• Lie-algebraic classical simulations for quantum computing
• Enabling Large-Scale and High-Precision Fluid Simulations on Near-Term Quantum Computers
• Accelerating Quantum Computations of Chemistry Through Regularized Compressed Double Factorization
• Uncovering Local Integrability in Quantum Many-Body Dynamics
• Robustness of quantum algorithms against coherent control errors
• Networked Quantum Services
• Variational quantum algorithm for ergotropy estimation in quantum many-body batteries
• Accelerated variational quantum eigensolver with joint Bell measurement
• Quantum algorithms for scientific computing
• Scalable Quantum Simulations of Scattering in Scalar Field Theory on 120 Qubits
• Suppressing Correlated Noise in Quantum Computers via Context-Aware Compiling
• Two-time weak measurement protocol for ergotropy protection in open quantum batteries
• Mitigating crosstalk errors by randomized compiling: Simulation of the BCS model on a superconducting quantum computer
• Quantum Latent Diffusion Models
• Quantum State Tomography with Locally Purified Density Operators and Local Measurements
• Development of Zero-Noise Extrapolated Projection Based Quantum Algorithm for Accurate Evaluation of Molecular Energetics in Noisy Quantum Devices
• Readout error mitigated quantum state tomography tested on superconducting qubits
• A Perspective on Quantum Computing Applications in Quantum Chemistry using 25--100 Logical Qubits
• Locally Purified Density Operators for Symmetry-Protected Topological Phases in Mixed States
• On-Premises Superconducting Quantum Computer for Education and Research
• Learning How to Dynamically Decouple
• Entanglement enhancement induced by noise in inhomogeneously monitored systems
• Ultrafast high-fidelity state readout of single neutral atom
• Algorithmic Shadow Spectroscopy
• Tensor network noise characterization for near-term quantum computers
• Quantum computing through the lens of control: A tutorial introduction
• Opportunities and challenges of quantum computing for climate modelling
• GHZ protocols enhance frequency metrology despite spontaneous decay
• Comparative study of quantum error correction strategies for the heavy-hexagonal lattice
• Modeling the unphysical pseudomode model with physical ensembles: simulation, mitigation, and restructuring of non-Markovian quantum noise
• Avoiding Barren Plateaus with Entanglement
• Dynamically Generated Decoherence-Free Subspaces and Subsystems on Superconducting Qubits
• Localized Virtual Purification
• Adaptive variational low-rank dynamics for open quantum systems
• Optimized noise-assisted simulation of the Lindblad equation with time-dependent coefficients on a noisy quantum processor
• Error suppression by a virtual two-qubit gate
• Solving an Industrially Relevant Quantum Chemistry Problem on Quantum Hardware
• Layering and subpool exploration for adaptive Variational Quantum Eigensolvers: Reducing circuit depth, runtime, and susceptibility to noise
• Quantum-machine-assisted Drug Discovery
• Guided-SPSA: Simultaneous Perturbation Stochastic Approximation assisted by the Parameter Shift Rule
• Reversing Unknown Quantum Processes via Virtual Combs for Channels with Limited Information
• Realizing string-net condensation: Fibonacci anyon braiding for universal gates and sampling chromatic polynomials
• Accurate and precise quantum computation of valence two-neutron systems
• Synergistic Dynamical Decoupling and Circuit Design for Enhanced Algorithm Performance on Near-Term Quantum Devices
• Efficient Quantum Circuit Compilation for Near-Term Quantum Advantage
• Mitigating Errors on Superconducting Quantum Processors through Fuzzy Clustering
• Empirical Sample Complexity of Neural Network Mixed State Reconstruction
• Gate Operations for Superconducting Qubits and Non-Markovianity
• An Accurate and Efficient Analytic Model of Fidelity Under Depolarizing Noise Oriented to Large Scale Quantum System Design
• Non-Markovian to Markovian decay in structured environments with correlated disorder
• Universal imaginary-time critical dynamics on a quantum computer
• Quantum State Reconstruction in a Noisy Environment via Deep Learning
• Quantum Kernel Learning for Small Dataset Modeling in Semiconductor Fabrication: Application to Ohmic Contact
• Solving Fractional Differential Equations on a Quantum Computer: A Variational Approach
• Gate-set evaluation metrics for closed-loop optimal control on nitrogen-vacancy center ensembles in diamond
• Benchmarking Quantum Optimization for the Maximum-Cut Problem on a Superconducting Quantum Computer
• Noise-Robust Detection of Quantum Phase Transitions
• Unveiling quantum phase transitions from traps in variational quantum algorithms
• FragQC: An Efficient Quantum Error Reduction Technique using Quantum Circuit Fragmentation
• Two-dimensional coherent spectrum of high-spin models via a quantum computing approach
• Measuring Trotter error and its application to precision-guaranteed Hamiltonian simulations
• Noise-Agnostic Quantum Error Mitigation with Data Augmented Neural Models
• Precision ground-state energy calculation for the water molecule on a superconducting quantum processor
• Quantum error cancellation in photonic systems -- undoing photon losses
• Unlocking early fault-tolerant quantum computing with mitigated magic dilution
• Symmetric Clifford twirling for cost-optimal quantum error mitigation in early FTQC regime
• Quantum smoothed particle hydrodynamics algorithm inspired by quantum walks
• Demonstrating quantum error mitigation on logical qubits
• Problem-tailored Simulation of Energy Transport on Noisy Quantum Computers
• Error mitigation, optimization, and extrapolation on a trapped ion testbed
• Efficient discrimination between real and complex quantum theories
• Direct pulse-level compilation of arbitrary quantum logic gates on superconducting qutrits
• TE-PAI: Exact Time Evolution by Sampling Random Circuits
• Improving Quantum Approximate Optimization by Noise-Directed Adaptive Remapping
• Quantum computing for genomics: conceptual challenges and practical perspectives
• Quantum error mitigation by layerwise Richardson extrapolation
• Quantum error mitigation in the regime of high noise using deep neural network: Trotterized dynamics
• QSlack: A slack-variable approach for variational quantum semi-definite programming
• Accelerating two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy simulations with a probe qubit protocol
• Efficient Lindblad synthesis for noise model construction
• Efficient self-consistent learning of gate set Pauli noise
• Statistics of topological defects across a phase transition in a digital superconducting quantum processor
• Mitigating Quantum Gate Errors for Variational Eigensolvers Using Hardware-Inspired Zero-Noise Extrapolation
• Comparison of encoding schemes for quantum computing of $S>1/2$ spin chains
• Virtual mitigation of coherent non-adiabatic transitions by echo verification
• Identifying Bottlenecks of NISQ-friendly HHL algorithms
• Adaptive variational quantum computing approaches for Green's functions and nonlinear susceptibilities
• Generating multipartite nonlocality to benchmark quantum computers
• Hermitian-preserving ansatz and variational open quantum eigensolver
• Rigorous noise reduction with quantum autoencoders
• Shadow Simulation of Quantum Processes
• Quantum-Enhanced Dark Matter Search Using Cat States
• Multireference error mitigation for quantum computation of chemistry
• Noise-adapted Quantum Error Correction for Non-Markovian Noise
• Encoded probabilistic imaginary-time evolution on a trapped-ion quantum computer for ground and excited states of spin qubits
• Error suppression in multicomponent cat codes with photon subtraction and teleamplification
• Probing entanglement dynamics and topological transitions on noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers
• Bringing Quantum Systems under Control: A Tutorial Invitation to Quantum Computing and Its Relation to Bilinear Control Systems
• Low-Rank Variational Quantum Algorithm for the Dynamics of Open Quantum Systems
• Quantum error mitigation for rotation symmetric bosonic codes with symmetry expansion
• Synergy between noisy quantum computers and scalable classical deep learning
• Certifying nonstabilizerness in quantum processors
• Experimental Virtual Quantum Broadcasting
• Quantum phase estimation based filtering: performance analysis and application to low-energy spectral calculation
• Error mitigation and circuit division for early fault-tolerant quantum phase estimation
• Virtual Z gates and symmetric gate compilation
• Noisy Probabilistic Error Cancellation and Generalized Physical Implementability
• More buck-per-shot: Why learning trumps mitigation in noisy quantum sensing
• Thresholds for post-selected quantum error correction from statistical mechanics
• A New Framework for Quantum Phases in Open Systems: Steady State of Imaginary-Time Lindbladian Evolution
• Universal framework for simultaneous tomography of quantum states and SPAM noise
• Sequency Hierarchy Truncation (SeqHT) for Adiabatic State Preparation and Time Evolution in Quantum Simulations
• Optimization via Quantum Preconditioning
• Performance of Uncoded Implementation of Grover's Algorithm on Today's Quantum Processors
• Limitations of Noisy Quantum Devices in Computational and Entangling Power
• Readout Error Mitigation for Mid-Circuit Measurements and Feedforward
• Exact Spin Correlators of Integrable Quantum Circuits from Algebraic Geometry
• Simulation of open quantum systems on universal quantum computers
• Optimal compression of constrained quantum time evolution
• Resource-efficient Generalized Quantum Subspace Expansion
• Echo-evolution data generation for quantum error mitigation via neural networks
• Symmetry verification for noisy quantum simulations of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories
• Quantum Tunneling: From Theory to Error-Mitigated Quantum Simulation
• Quantum correlations in general qubit-qudit axially symmetric states
• Linear decomposition of approximate multi-controlled single qubit gates
• Unifying non-Markovian characterisation with an efficient and self-consistent framework
• Resource-Efficient Quantum Circuits for Molecular Simulations: A Case Study of Umbrella Inversion in Ammonia
• Machine learning non-Markovian two-level quantum noise spectroscopy
• Spectral signatures of the Markovian to Non-Markovian transition in open quantum systems
• Variational post-selection for ground states and thermal states simulation
• Quantum enhanced stratification of Breast Cancer: exploring quantum expressivity for real omics data
• Measuring Correlation and Entanglement between Molecular Orbitals on a Trapped-Ion Quantum Computer
• Counter-intuitive yet efficient regimes for measurement based quantum computation on symmetry protected spin chains
• A circuit-differentiation framework for Green's functions on quantum computers
• A recipe for local simulation of strongly-correlated fermionic matter on quantum computers: the 2D Fermi-Hubbard model
• Space-time tradeoff in networked virtual distillation
• Maximum Likelihood Quantum Error Mitigation for Algorithms with a Single Correct Output
• Mutual information maximizing quantum generative adversarial networks
• Adaptive measurement strategy for quantum subspace methods
• Quantum null-hypothesis device-independent Schmidt rank witness
• Interplay between external driving, dissipation and collective effects in the Markovian and non-Markovian regimes
• Simulation-assisted learning of open quantum systems
• Quantum Computational Insurance and Actuarial Science
• Purity-Assisted Zero-Noise Extrapolation for Quantum Error Mitigation
• Error Mitigation Thresholds in Noisy Random Quantum Circuits
• Theory of quantum error mitigation for non-Clifford gates
• Robust projective measurements through measuring code-inspired observables
• Quantum Realization of the Finite Element Method
• Lindblad-like quantum tomography for non-Markovian quantum dynamical maps
• Mitigation of correlated readout errors without randomized measurements
• An Energy Estimation Benchmark for Quantum Computers
• Tomography-assisted noisy quantum circuit simulator using matrix product density operators
• Automated quantum error mitigation based on probabilistic error reduction
• Deep Neural Network-assisted improvement of quantum compressed sensing tomography
• A Quantum-Inspired Algorithm for Wave Simulation Using Tensor Networks
• Practical limitations of quantum data propagation on noisy quantum processors
• Pathfinding Quantum Simulations of Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay
• Error-Mitigated Quantum Routing on Noisy Devices
• Agnostic Process Tomography
• Density matrix representation of hybrid tensor networks for noisy quantum devices
• The role of higher-order terms in trapped-ion quantum computing with magnetic gradient induced coupling
• Q-gen: A Parameterized Quantum Circuit Generator
• Biased Estimator Channels for Classical Shadows
• Learning Density Functionals from Noisy Quantum Data
• Error analysis of quantum operators written as a linear combination of permutations
• Digital Zero-Noise Extrapolation with Quantum Circuit Unoptimization
• Superdiffusion resilience in Heisenberg Chains with 2D interactions on a quantum processor
• Refined Criteria for QRAM Error Suppression via Efficient Large-Scale QRAM Simulator
• Symmetric channel verification for purifying noisy quantum channels
• Implementing Finite Impulse Response Filters on Quantum Computers
• Efficient Online Quantum Circuit Learning with No Upfront Training
• Quantum computational advantage of noisy boson sampling with partially distinguishable photons
• Sparse Non-Markovian Noise Modeling of Transmon-Based Multi-Qubit Operations
• Distributing Quantum Computations, Shot-wise
• Efficient Eigenstate Preparation in an Integrable Model with Hilbert Space Fragmentation
• An Error Mitigated Non-Orthogonal Quantum Eigensolver via Shadow Tomography
• Low bit-flip rate probabilistic error cancellation
• Phase vs coin vs position disorder as a probe for the resilience and revival of single particle entanglement in cyclic quantum walks
• Mitigating Errors in Analog Quantum Simulation by Hamiltonian Reshaping or Hamiltonian Rescaling
• Optimal and robust error filtration for quantum information processing
• Bayesian mitigation of measurement errors in multiqubit experiments
• Protecting entanglement witnesses with randomized measurements
• Sublinear Classical-to-Quantum Data Encoding using $n$-Toffoli Gates
• Recovery of resources through sequential noisy measurements
• Error Crafting in Mixed Quantum Gate Synthesis
• Variational-toolbox-based separability detection of multiqubit states
• Integrals of motion as slow modes in dissipative many-body operator dynamics
• Efficient Berry Phase Calculation via Adaptive Variational Quantum Computing Approach
• Variational quantum algorithms with invariant probabilistic error cancellation on noisy quantum processors
• Describing Trotterized Time Evolutions on Noisy Quantum Computers via Static Effective Lindbladians
• Quantum Circuit Unoptimization
• Quantum Algorithm for Green's Functions Measurements in the Fermi-Hubbard Model
• Charge-Preserving Operations in Quantum Batteries
• Experimental Quantum Channel Purification
• Feasibility of performing quantum chemistry calculations on quantum computers
• Rovibrational energy levels of H${}_2$O by quantum computing
• Skyrmionic qubits stabilized by Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction as platforms for qubits and quantum gates
• Averaging gate approximation error and performance of Unitary Coupled Cluster ansatz in Pre-FTQC Era
• Information conservation relations for weak measurement and its reversal
• Noise-Agnostic Unbiased Quantum Error Mitigation for Logical Qubits
• Hardware-efficient quantum annealing with error mitigation via classical shadow
• Cyclicity of interaction frame transformations
• Error-Mitigated Quantum Random Access Memory
• Cross-platform certification of the qubit space with a minimal number of parameters
• Noise-resilient and resource-efficient hybrid algorithm for robust quantum gap estimation
• Power and limitations of distributed quantum state purification
• Feed-Forward Probabilistic Error Cancellation with Noisy Recovery Gates
• Efficient and operational quantifier of non-divisibility in terms of channel discrimination
• Data-Efficient Quantum Noise Modeling via Machine Learning
• Optimizing Circuit Reusing and its Application in Randomized Benchmarking
• The Efficiency Frontier: Classical Shadows versus Direct Quantum Measurement
• Disambiguating Pauli noise in quantum computers
• The abelian state hidden subgroup problem: Learning stabilizer groups and beyond
• A Time Optimization Framework for the Implementation of Robust and Low-latency Quantum Circuits
• Normal quantum channels and Markovian correlated two-qubit quantum errors
• Qubit-efficient quantum combinatorial optimization solver
• Shift of quantum critical point of discrete time crystal on a noisy quantum simulator
• Resilience-Runtime Tradeoff Relations for Quantum Algorithms
• Jet evolution in a quantum computer: quark and gluon dynamics
• Error bounds on the universal Lindblad equation in the thermodynamic limit
• Scaling of Computational Order Parameters in Rydberg Atom Graph States
• Optimal randomized measurements for a family of non-linear quantum properties
• Error-Mitigated Multi-Layer Quantum Routing
• Unbiased observable estimation with approximate channels in fault-tolerant quantum computation
• Linear-optical protocols for mitigating and suppressing noise in bosonic systems
• Molecular resonance identification in complex absorbing potentials via integrated quantum computing and high-throughput computing
• Zero-Noise Extrapolation via Cyclic Permutations of Quantum Circuit Layouts
• Reshaping quantum device noise via repetition code circuits
• Q-Cluster: Quantum Error Mitigation Through Noise-Aware Unsupervised Learning
• The Virtual Quantum Device (VQD): A tool for detailed emulation of quantum computers
• Unitary-transformed projective squeezing: applications for circuit-knitting and state-preparation of non-Gaussian states
• Measuring entanglement without local addressing in quantum many-body simulators via spiral quantum state tomography
• Calibration of syndrome measurements in a single experiment
• Moments of Quantum Channel Ensembles
• Noisy Monitored Quantum Circuits
• On sampling determinantal and Pfaffian point processes on a quantum computer
• Limitations for adaptive quantum state tomography in the presence of detector noise
• A Useful Metric for the NISQ Era: Qubit Error Probability and Its Role in Zero Noise Extrapolation
• Prime Number Identification Demonstrated with Quantum Processors Using a New Rescaling-Based Noise Mitigation Technique
• End-to-End Quantum Algorithms for the Jones Polynomial
• Near-Term Fermionic Simulation with Subspace Noise Tailored Quantum Error Mitigation
• Reduced Sampling Overhead for Probabilistic Error Cancellation by Pauli Error Propagation
• Hybrid quantum recurrent neural network for remaining useful life prediction of turbofan engines
• Error-mitigated inference of quantum network topology
• An occupation number quantum subspace expansion approach to compute the single-particle Green function: an opportunity for noise filtering
• Efficient Simulation of Open Quantum Systems on NISQ Trapped-Ion Hardware
• Learning mixed quantum states in large-scale experiments
• Sampling (noisy) quantum circuits through randomized rounding
• Constrained free energy minimization for the design of thermal states and stabilizer thermodynamic systems
• Simulating plasma wave propagation on a superconducting quantum chip
• Protocol for Purifying Noisy Preparation and Measurements of Qubits
• Imperfect Entangling Power of Quantum Gates
• Robust Error Accumulation Suppression for Quantum Circuits