A comparison of chemical models of exoplanet atmospheres enabled by TauREx 3.1
arXiv:2110.01271 · doi:10.3847/1538-4357/ac6dcd
Abstract
Thermochemical equilibrium is one of the most commonly used assumptions in current exoplanet retrievals. As the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) and Ariel launch draw near, assessing the underlying biases and assumptions made when applying self-consistent chemistry into spectral retrievals is crucial. Here we use the flexibility of TauREx 3.1 to cross-compare three state of the art chemical equilibrium codes: ACE, FastChem and GGchem. We simulate JWST spectra for ACE, FastChem, GGchem and GGchem+condensation containing only C, H, O, N elements and spectra for FastChem, GGchem and GGchem+condensation with a more extensive range of elements giving seven simulated JWST spectra in total and then cross-retrieve giving a total of 49 retrievals. Our analysis demonstrates that like-for-like, all chemical codes retrieve the correct parameters to <1% of the truth. However, retrievals, where the contained elements do not match the truth, parameters such as metallicity deviate by 20% while maintaining extremely low uncertainties <1% giving false confidence. This point is of major importance for future analyses on JWST and Ariel, highlighting that self-consistent chemical scheme that do not employ the proper assumptions (missing species, fixed elemental ratios, condensation) are at risk of confidently biasing interpretations. Free chemistry retrievals employing parametric descriptions of the chemical profiles can provide alternative unbiased explorations.
arXiv comment31 pages, 15 figures
References in corpus (86)
- MultiNest: an efficient and robust Bayesian inference tool for cosmology and particle physics
- X-ray spectral modelling of the AGN obscuring region in the CDFS: Bayesian model selection and catalogue
- Detection of an Extrasolar Planet Atmosphere
- The Limiting Effects of Dust in Brown Dwarf Model Atmospheres
- A continuum from clear to cloudy hot-Jupiter exoplanets without primordial water depletion
- Clouds in the atmosphere of the super-Earth exoplanet GJ 1214b
- ExoMol molecular line lists XXX: a complete high-accuracy line list for water
- Atmospheric circulation of hot Jupiters: Coupled radiative-dynamical general circulation model simulations of HD 189733b and HD 209458b
- A Temperature and Abundance Retrieval Method for Exoplanet Atmospheres
- petitRADTRANS: a Python radiative transfer package for exoplanet characterization and retrieval
- The ExoMol database: molecular line lists for exoplanet and other hot atmospheres
- Infrared Transmission Spectroscopy of the Exoplanets HD209458b and XO-1b Using the Wide Field Camera-3 on the Hubble Space Telescope
- Chemical Equilibrium Abundances in Brown Dwarf and Extrasolar Giant Planet Atmospheres
- Disequilibrium Carbon, Oxygen, and Nitrogen Chemistry in the Atmospheres of HD 189733b and HD 209458b
- Accurate, Empirical Radii and Masses of Planets and their Host Stars with Gaia Parallaxes
- ExoMol: molecular line lists for exoplanet and other atmospheres
- ExoMol line lists IV: The rotation-vibration spectrum of methane up to 1500 K
- Characterizing transiting exoplanet atmospheres with JWST
- A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra I: A Comparison of Atmospheric Retrieval Techniques
- A variationally computed line list for hot NH3
- Thermal structure of an exoplanet atmosphere from phase-resolved emission spectroscopy
- A population study of gaseous exoplanets
- Strong Water Absorption in the Dayside Emission Spectrum of the Planet HD 189733b
- Water Vapor and Clouds on the Habitable-Zone Sub-Neptune Exoplanet K2-18b
- HD 209458b in New Light: Evidence of Nitrogen Chemistry, Patchy Clouds and Sub-Solar Water
- Water, Methane, and Carbon Dioxide Present in the Dayside Spectrum of the Exoplanet HD 209458b
- ExoMol Molecular linelists -- XXXIII. The spectrum of Titanium Oxide
- Water vapour in the atmosphere of the habitable-zone eight Earth-mass planet K2-18 b
- Equilibrium chemistry down to 100 K - Impact of silicates and phyllosilicates on carbon/oxygen ratio
- A chemical model for the atmosphere of hot Jupiters
- Atmospheric reconnaissance of the habitable-zone Earth-sized planets orbiting TRAPPIST-1
- Mass-Metallicity Trends in Transiting Exoplanets from Atmospheric Abundances of HO, Na, and K
- ExoMol line lists XVIII. The high temperature spectrum of VO
- Detection of an atmosphere around the super-Earth 55 Cancri e
- A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra II: A Uniform Analysis of Eight Planets and Their C to O Ratios
- A combined transmission spectrum of the Earth-sized exoplanets TRAPPIST-1 b and c
- HO abundances and cloud properties in ten hot giant exoplanets
- ExoMol molecular line lists - XIV: The rotation-vibration spectrum of hot SO
- TauREx III: A fast, dynamic and extendable framework for retrievals
- Optimal Estimation Retrievals of the Atmospheric Structure and Composition of HD 189733b from Secondary Eclipse Spectroscopy
- Spitzer Phase Curve Constraints for WASP-43b at 3.6 and 4.5 microns
- FastChem: A computer program for efficient complex chemical equilibrium calculations in the neutral/ionized gas phase with applications to stellar and planetary atmospheres
- An absolute sodium abundance for a cloud-free 'hot Saturn' exoplanet
- HELIOS-Retrieval: An Open-source, Nested Sampling Atmospheric Retrieval Code, Application to the HR 8799 Exoplanets and Inferred Constraints for Planet Formation
- Partition functions and equilibrium constants for diatomic molecules and atoms of astrophysical interest
- New study of the line profiles of sodium perturbed by H2
- ExoMol molecular line lists -- XXXVII: spectra of acetylene
- The interior and atmosphere of the habitable-zone exoplanet K2-18b
- Hydrogen dimers in giant-planet infrared spectra
- Forward modelling and retrievals with PLATON, a fast open source tool
- Temperature-dependent molecular absorption cross sections for exoplanets and other atmospheres
- Characterizing Earth Analogs in Reflected Light: Atmospheric Retrieval Studies for Future Space Telescopes
- The impact of atmospheric circulation on the chemistry of the hot Jupiter HD 209458b
- Retrieval of Exoplanet Emission Spectra with HyDRA
- Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of the Directly Imaged Exoplanet HR 8799b
- Chemical equilibrium in AGB atmospheres: Successes, failures, and prospects for small molecules, clusters, and condensates
- The ARCiS framework for Exoplanet Atmospheres: Modelling Philosophy and Retrieval
- Helios-r2 -- A new Bayesian, open-source retrieval model for brown dwarfs and exoplanet atmospheres
- An emission spectrum for WASP-121b measured across the 0.8-1.1 micron wavelength range using the Hubble Space Telescope
- Optical phase curve of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b
- The ARCiS framework for Exoplanet Atmospheres: The Cloud Transport Model
- Towards a more complex description of chemical profiles in exoplanets retrievals: A 2-layer parameterisation
- ARES I: WASP-76 b, A Tale of Two HST Spectra
- ARES II: Characterising the Hot Jupiters WASP-127 b, WASP-79 b and WASP-62 b with HST
- ACCESS & LRG-BEASTS: a precise new optical transmission spectrum of the ultrahot Jupiter WASP-103b
- Strict Upper Limits on the Carbon-to-Oxygen Ratios of Eight Hot Jupiters from Self-Consistent Atmospheric Retrieval
- Hubble WFC3 Spectroscopy of the Habitable-zone Super-Earth LHS 1140 b
- Detection of an Atmosphere on a Rocky Exoplanet
- Confirmation of water emission in the dayside spectrum of the ultrahot Jupiter WASP-121b
- A new chemical scheme for giant planet thermochemistry. Update of the methanol chemistry and new reduced chemical scheme
- ARES V: No Evidence For Molecular Absorption in the HST WFC3 Spectrum of GJ 1132 b
- Pressure-dependent water absorption cross sections for exoplanets and other atmospheres
- The Metal-Rich Atmosphere of the Neptune HAT-P-26b
- On The Compatibility of Ground-based and Space-based Data: WASP-96 b, An Example
- ARES III: Unveiling the Two Faces of KELT-7 b with HST WFC3
- The Hubble WFC3 Emission Spectrum of the Extremely-Hot Jupiter, KELT-9b
- ARES IV: Probing the atmospheres of the two warm small planets HD 106315 c and HD 3167 c with the HST/WFC3 camera
- Alfnoor: A Retrieval Simulation of the Ariel Target List
- KELT-11 b: Abundances of water and constraints on carbon-bearing molecules from the Hubble transmission spectrum
- An exploration of model degeneracies with a unified phase curve retrieval analysis: The light and dark sides of WASP-43 b
- H- and Dissociation in Ultra-hot Jupiters: A Retrieval Case Study of WASP-18b
- Numerical Convergence of Hot-Jupiter Atmospheric Flow Solutions
- Ariel: Enabling planetary science across light-years
- TauREx3 PhaseCurve: A 1.5D model for phase curve description
- WASP-117 b: an eccentric hot-Saturn as a future complex chemistry laboratory
- Characterising brown dwarf companions with IRDIS long-slit spectroscopy: HD 1160 B and HD 19467 B
Cited by in corpus (27)
- FastChem 2: An improved computer program to determine the gas-phase chemical equilibrium composition for arbitrary element distributions
- Sulphur dioxide in the mid-infrared transmission spectrum of WASP-39b
- The JWST Early Release Science Program for the Direct Imaging & Spectroscopy of Exoplanetary Systems
- Retrieval study of cool, directly imaged exoplanet 51 Eri b
- Is the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b variable?
- Near-infrared transmission spectrum of TRAPPIST-1 h using Hubble WFC3 G141 observations
- Data availability and requirements relevant for the Ariel space mission and other exoplanet atmosphere applications
- Measuring Tracers of Planet Formation in the Atmosphere of WASP-77A b: Sub-stellar O/H and C/H ratios, with a stellar C/O ratio and a potentially Super-stellar Ti/H ratio
- Spitzer thermal phase curve of WASP-121 b
- YunMa: Enabling Spectral Retrievals of Exoplanetary Clouds
- Hot exoplanetary atmospheres in 3D
- Knobs and dials of retrieving JWST transmission spectra. I. The importance of p-T profile complexity
- Cloud and Haze Parameterization in Atmospheric Retrievals: Insights from Titan's Cassini Data and JWST Observations of Hot Jupiters
- MIRI-LRS spectrum of a cold exoplanet around a white dwarf: water, ammonia, and methane measurements
- An extensively validated C/H/O/N chemical network for hot exoplanet disequilibrium chemistry
- A Population Analysis of 20 Exoplanets Observed from the Optical to the Near-infrared Wavelengths with HST: Evidence for Widespread Stellar Contamination
- New routes for PN destruction and formation in the ISM via neutral-neutral gas-phase reactions and an extended database for reactions involving phosphorus
- ARES VI: Viability of one-dimensional retrieval models for transmission spectroscopy characterization of exo-atmospheres in the era of JWST and Ariel
- GEMS JWST: Transmission spectroscopy of TOI-5205b reveals significant stellar contamination and a metal-poor atmosphere
- The effect of spectroscopic binning on atmospheric retrievals
- A re-analysis of equilibrium chemistry in five hot Jupiters
- HST/WFC3 Constraints on the Abundances of OH and FeH in the Atmosphere of the Ultra-Hot Neptune LTT-9779 b
- Radiative Flux from a High-Resolution Atmospheric Dynamics Simulation of a Hot-Jupiter for JWST and Ariel
- Knobs and dials of retrieving JWST transmission spectra. II. Impacts of pipeline-level differences on retrieval posteriors
- A new look into the atmospheric composition of WASP-39 b
- The GAPS programme at TNG LXXI. A sub-Neptune suitable for atmospheric characterization in a multiplanet and mutually inclined system orbiting the bright K dwarf TOI-5789 (HIP 99452)
- Possible favored Great Oxidation Event scenario on exoplanets around M-Stars with the example of TRAPPIST-1e