Solution to the debris disc mass problem: planetesimals are born small?

Abstract

Debris belts on the periphery of planetary systems, encompassing the region occupied by planetary orbits, are massive analogues of the Solar system's Kuiper belt. They are detected by thermal emission of dust released in collisions amongst directly unobservable larger bodies that carry most of the debris disc mass. We estimate the total mass of the discs by extrapolating up the mass of emitting dust with the help of collisional cascade models. The resulting mass of bright debris discs appears to be unrealistically large, exceeding the mass of solids available in the systems at the preceding protoplanetary stage. We discuss this "mass problem" in detail and investigate possible solutions to it. These include uncertainties in the dust opacity and planetesimal strength, variation of the bulk density with size, steepening of the size distribution by damping processes, the role of the unknown "collisional age" of the discs, and dust production in recent giant impacts. While we cannot rule out the possibility that a combination of these might help, we argue that the easiest solution would be to assume that planetesimals in systems with bright debris discs were "born small", with sizes in the kilometre range, especially at large distances from the stars. This conclusion would necessitate revisions to the existing planetesimal formation models, and may have a range of implications for planet formation. We also discuss potential tests to constrain the largest planetesimal sizes and debris disc masses.

This is a pre-copyedited, author-produced PDF of an article accepted for publication in MNRAS following peer review; 20 pages, 11 figures. The version of record is available online at https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa2385

References in corpus (109)

• Interstellar Dust Grains
• Protoplanetary Disks and Their Evolution
• Rapid planetesimal formation in turbulent circumstellar discs
• Protoplanetary Disk Structures in Ophiuchus
• Rosseland and Planck Mean Opacities for Protoplanetary Discs
• Asteroids Were Born Big
• THE ORIGIN OF PLUTO'S ORBIT: IMPLICATIONS FOR THE SOLAR SYSTEM BEYOND NEPTUNE
• On the Submillimeter Opacity of Protoplanetary Disks
• The Minimum-Mass Extrasolar Nebula: In-Situ Formation of Close-In Super-Earths
• A Steeper than Linear Disk Mass-Stellar Mass Scaling Relation
• Can giant planets form by direct gravitational instability?
• Protoplanetary Disk Structures in Ophiuchus II: Extension to Fainter Sources
• The Size Distribution of Trans-Neptunian Bodies
• Towards planetesimals: dense chondrule clumps in the protoplanetary nebula
• The Mass and Size Distribution of Planetesimals Formed by the Streaming Instability. I. The Role of Self-Gravity
• Transience of hot dust around sun-like stars
• Debris Disks: Structure, Composition, and Variability
• Structure and evolution of pre-main sequence circumstellar disks
• Collisional Processes in Extrasolar Planetsimal Disks - Dust Clumps in Fomalhaut's Debris Disk
• Variations on Debris Disks: Icy Planet Formation at 30-150 AU for 1-3 Solar Mass Main Sequence Stars
• Molecular Gas Clumps from the Destruction of Icy Bodies in the $\beta$ Pictoris Debris Disk
• The Absolute Magnitude Distribution of Kuiper Belt Objects
• Why do protoplanetary disks appear not massive enough to form the known exoplanet population?
• Nearby debris disk systems with high fractional luminosity reconsidered
• "TNOs are Cool": A survey of the trans-Neptunian region X. Analysis of classical Kuiper belt objects from Herschel and Spitzer observations
• An Increase in the Mass of Planetary Systems around Lower-Mass Stars
• Age dependence of the Vega Phenomenon: Theory
• DUst Around NEarby Stars. The survey observational results
• Resonant Trapping of Planetesimals by Planet Migration: Debris Disk Clumps and Vega's Similarity to the Solar System
• The Insignificance of P-R Drag in Detectable Extrasolar Planetesimal Belts
• One Solution to the Mass Budget Problem for Planet Formation: Optically Thick Disks with Dust Scattering
• Dust masses of young disks: constraining the initial solid reservoir for planet formation
• Incidence and survival of remnant disks around main-sequence stars
• Initial mass function of planetesimals formed by the streaming instability
• Evidence for the formation of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko through gravitational collapse of a bound clump of pebbles
• Long-Term Collisional Evolution of Debris Disks
• Debris Disks: Seeing Dust, Thinking of Planetesimals and Planets
• Steady-State Size Distributions for Collisional Populations: Analytical Solution with Size-Dependent Strength
• Initial results from the New Horizons exploration of 2014 MU69, a small Kuiper Belt Object
• Dusty Debris Around Solar-Type Stars: Temporal Disk Evolution
• Debris disc stirring by secular perturbations from giant planets
• Towards Initial Mass Functions for Asteroids and Kuiper Belt Objects
• Predictions for a planet just inside Fomalhaut's eccentric ring
• Collisional processes and size distribution in spatially extended debris discs
• Debris disks as signposts of terrestrial planet formation
• Planetesimal formation by the streaming instability in a photoevaporating disk
• Mie Scattering by Ensembles of Particles with Very Large Size Parameters
• The Collisional Evolution of Debris Disks
• The Compositions of Kuiper Belt Objects
• Debris disk size distributions: steady state collisional evolution with P-R drag and other loss processes
• Predictions for the secondary CO, C and O gas content of debris discs from the destruction of volatile-rich planetesimals
• Resonance Occupation in the Kuiper Belt: Case Examples of the 5:2 and Trojan Resonances
• Detection of exocometary CO within the 440 Myr-old Fomalhaut belt: a similar CO+CO${}_2$ ice abundance in exocomets and Solar System comets
• Debris from giant impacts between planetary embryos at large orbital radii
• On Gas-Drag Induced Rapid Migration of Solids in a Non-Uniform Solar Nebula
• Evidence for universality in the initial planetesimal mass function
• SONS: The JCMT legacy survey of debris discs in the submillimetre
• Analysis of the Herschel DEBRIS Sun-like star sample
• The Effects of a Stellar Encounter on a Planetesimal Disk
• Turbulence sets the length scale for planetesimal formation: Local 2D simulations of streaming instability and planetesimal formation
• The History of the Solar System's Debris Disc: Observable Properties of the Kuiper Belt
• Debris disks as signposts of terrestrial planet formation. II Dependence of exoplanet architectures on giant planet and disk properties
• Outer edges of debris discs: how sharp is sharp?
• The Mass and Size Distribution of Planetesimals Formed by the Streaming Instability. II. The Effect of the Radial Gas Pressure Gradient
• The Mass Budget of Planet Forming Discs: Isolating the Epoch of Planetesimal Formation
• The dust grain size - stellar luminosity trend in debris discs
• "TNOs are Cool": A survey of the trans-Neptunian region VI. Herschel/PACS observations and thermal modeling of 19 classical Kuiper belt objects
• Kuiper belt: formation and evolution
• Kuiper Belt-Like Hot and Cold Populations of Planetesimal Inclinations in the $\beta$ Pictoris Belt Revealed by ALMA
• Dynamical evolution of an eccentric planet and a less massive debris disc
• Collisional Cascades in Planetesimal Disks I. Stellar Flybys
• Incidence of debris discs around FGK stars in the solar neighbourhood
• Are debris disks self-stirred?
• A gap in the planetesimal disc around HD 107146 and asymmetric warm dust emission revealed by ALMA
• An Empirical Planetesimal Belt Radius - Stellar Luminosity Relation
• Self-consistent size and velocity distributions of collisional cascades
• An improved model of the Edgeworth-Kuiper debris disk
• Herschel's "Cold Debris Disks": Background Galaxies or Quiescent Rims of Planetary Systems?
• Stirring in massive, young debris discs from spatially resolved Herschel images
• Have proto-planetary discs formed planets?
• The cold origin of the warm dust around epsilon Eridani
• A Minimum-Mass Extrasolar Nebula
• Constraints on Planetesimal Collision Models in Debris Disks
• Binary Survival in the Outer Solar System
• A gap in HD 92945's broad planetesimal disc revealed by ALMA
• The Mass of Stirring Bodies in the AU Mic Debris Disk Inferred from Resolved Vertical Structure
• Planetary embryos and planetesimals residing in thin debris disks
• Collisional modelling of the AU Microscopii debris disc
• Copious Amounts of Hot and Cold Dust Orbiting the Main Sequence A-type Stars HD 131488 and HD 121191
• Observations, Modeling and Theory of Debris Disks
• Population synthesis of exocometary gas around A stars
• ALMA Detection of Extended Millimeter Halos in the HD 32297 and HD 61005 Debris Disks
• Self-Stirring of Debris Discs by Planetesimals Formed by Pebble Concentration
• From Planetesimals to Planets in Turbulent Protoplanetary Disks I. Onset of Runaway Growth
• Double-ringed debris discs could be the work of eccentric planets: explaining the strange morphology of HD 107146
• Debris Disc Constraints on Planetesimal Formation
• Porous dust grains in debris disks
• Massive discs around low-mass stars
• The surprisingly low carbon mass in the debris disk around HD 32297
• The Maximum Mass Solar Nebula and the early formation of planets
• Debris disc formation induced by planetary growth
• Origin and evolution of two-component debris discs and an application to the q${}^1$ Eridani system
• An ATCA survey of debris disks at 7 millimeters
• The evolution of planetesimal swarms in self-gravitating protoplanetary discs
• Astronomical Evidence for the Rapid Growth of Millimeter Sized Particles in Protoplanetary Disks
• Low temperature optical properties of interstellar and circumstellar icy silicate grain analogues in the mid-infrared spectral region
• Collisional modelling of the debris disc around HIP 17439
• Predicting the frequencies of diverse exo-planetary systems
• Absorption of crystalline water ice in the far infrared at different temperatures

Cited by in corpus (48)

• The New Generation Planetary Population Synthesis (NGPPS). I. Bern global model of planet formation and evolution, model tests, and emerging planetary systems
• The Ophiuchus DIsc Survey Employing ALMA (ODISEA)-III: the evolution of substructures in massive discs at 3-5 au resolution
• Planet populations inferred from debris discs: insights from 178 debris systems in the ISPY, LEECH and LIStEN planet-hunting surveys
• On the Origin and Thermal Stability of Arrokoths and Plutos Ices
• Understanding planet formation using microgravity experiments
• Formation of Gaps in Self-Gravitating Debris Disks by Secular Resonance in a Single-planet System I: A Simplified Model
• A $75\%$ Occurrence Rate of Debris Discs around F stars in the $\beta$ Pic Moving Group
• From Pebbles and Planetesimals to Planets and Dust: the Protoplanetary Disk--Debris Disk Connection
• High resolution ALMA and HST images of q${}^1$ Eri: an asymmetric debris disc with an eccentric Jupiter
• System-level fractionation of carbon from disk and planetesimal processing
• Disc population synthesis: Decrease in the solid mass reservoir through pebble drift
• Survival of ALMA Rings in the Absence of Pressure Maxima
• Deprojecting and constraining the vertical thickness of exoKuiper belts
• Fomalhaut b could be massive and sculpting the narrow, eccentric debris disc, if in mean-motion resonance with it
• Gap carving by a migrating planet embedded in a massive debris disc
• Stirred but not shaken: a multi-wavelength view of HD 16743's debris disc
• Rapid Formation of Exoplanetesimals Revealed by White Dwarfs
• Prevalence of short-lived radioactive isotopes across exoplanetary systems inferred from polluted white dwarfs
• Has the dust clump in the debris disk of Beta Pictoris moved?
• A molecular wind blows out of the Kuiper belt
• The case of HD 106906 debris disc: A binary's revenge
• Inner edges of planetesimal belts: collisionally eroded or truncated?
• Hot exozodis: cometary supply without trapping is unlikely to be the mechanism
• Morphology of the gas-rich debris disk around HD 121617 with SPHERE observations in polarized light
• The vertical structure of debris discs and the role of disc gravity: A primer using a simplified model
• Resolving the outer ring of HD 38206 using ALMA and constraining limits on planets in the system
• Can comets deliver prebiotic molecules to rocky exoplanets?
• Self-gravity of debris discs can strongly change the outcomes of interactions with inclined planets
• High resolution ALMA and HST imaging of $\kappa$CrB: a broad debris disc around a post-main sequence star with low-mass companions
• A Mixed Stirring Mechanism for Debris Discs with Giant and Dwarf Planetary Perturbations
• Water ice in the debris disk around HD 181327
• The ALMA survey to Resolve exoKuiper belt Substructures (ARKS) III: The vertical structure of debris disks
• Characterization of debris disks observed with SPHERE
• Millimeter Dust Emission and Planetary Dynamics in the HD 106906 System
• Stellar winds can affect gas dynamics in debris disks and create observable belt winds
• ALMA Reveals an Eccentricity Gradient in the Fomalhaut Debris Disk
• Irregular moons possibly injected from the outer solar system by a stellar flyby
• Understanding the trans-Neptunian Solar system: Reconciling the results of serendipitous stellar occultations and the inferences from the cratering record
• Takeout and Delivery: Erasing the Dusty Signature of Late-stage Terrestrial Planet Formation
• White dwarf constraints on geological processes at the population level
• A second planetesimal collision in the Fomalhaut system
• Discovery of carbon monoxide emission from five debris disks around young A-type stars
• A broken debris cascade as a possible source of hot dust emission in transitioning planet-forming disks
• Testing the Impact of Planet-stirring, Self-stirring, and Mixed-stirring on Debris Disc Architecture: A Case Study of HD 16743
• The Mass Budgets and Spatial Scales of Exoplanet Systems and Protoplanetary Disks
• The ALMA survey to Resolve exoKuiper belt Substructures (ARKS) XI: Gas-dust interactions and radial offsets between micron and millimetre-sized grains
• Resolving the large exoKuiper belt of the HD 126062 debris disc and extended gas emission in its vicinity
• Study of the migration of Earth-like planets in planetesimal disks and the formation of debris disks