Debris Disc Constraints on Planetesimal Formation

Abstract

Two basic routes for planetesimal formation have been proposed over the last few decades. One is a classical "slow-growth" scenario. Another one is particle concentration models, in which small pebbles are concentrated locally and then collapse gravitationally to form planetesimals. Both types of models make certain predictions for the size spectrum and internal structure of newly-born planetesimals. We use these predictions as input to simulate collisional evolution of debris discs left after the gas dispersal. The debris disc emission as a function of a system's age computed in these simulations is compared with several Spitzer and Herschel debris disc surveys around A-type stars. We confirm that the observed brightness evolution for the majority of discs can be reproduced by classical models. Further, we find that it is equally consistent with the size distribution of planetesimals predicted by particle concentration models - provided the objects are loosely bound "pebble piles" as these models also predict. Regardless of the assumed planetesimal formation mechanism, explaining the brightest debris discs in the samples uncovers a "disc mass problem." To reproduce such discs by collisional simulations, a total mass of planetesimals of up to ~1000 Earth masses is required, which exceeds the total mass of solids available in the protoplanetary progenitors of debris discs. This may indicate that stirring was delayed in some of the bright discs, that giant impacts occurred recently in some of them, that some systems may be younger than previously thought, or that non-collisional processes contribute significantly to the dust production.

This is a pre-copyedited, author-produced PDF of an article accepted for publication in MNRAS following peer review. The version of record (MNRAS Vol. 474, Issue 2, 21 February 2018, Pages 2564-2575) is available online at https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stx2932

References in corpus (68)

• Protoplanetary Disks and Their Evolution
• Rapid planetesimal formation in turbulent circumstellar discs
• Catastrophic disruptions revisited
• Origin of the Structure of the Kuiper Belt during a Dynamical Instability in the Orbits of Uranus and Neptune
• Rapid Coagulation of Porous Dust Aggregates Outside the Snow Line: A Pathway to Successful Icy Planetesimal Formation
• Collisions Between Gravity-Dominated Bodies: 1. Outcome Regimes and Scaling Laws
• Collisions between Gravity-Dominated Bodies: 2. The Diversity of Impact Outcomes during the End Stage of Planet Formation
• How Observations of Circumstellar Disk Asymmetries Can Reveal Hidden Planets: Pericenter Glow and its Application to the HR 4796 Disk
• Debris Disk Evolution Around A Stars
• Zonal Flows and Long-Lived Axisymmetric Pressure Bumps in Magnetorotational Turbulence
• Towards planetesimals: dense chondrule clumps in the protoplanetary nebula
• The Mass and Size Distribution of Planetesimals Formed by the Streaming Instability. I. The Role of Self-Gravity
• Transience of hot dust around sun-like stars
• Characterization of Dusty Debris Disks: the IRAS and Hipparcos Catalogs
• Collisional Processes in Extrasolar Planetsimal Disks - Dust Clumps in Fomalhaut's Debris Disk
• Steady-state evolution of debris disks around A stars
• Variations on Debris Disks: Icy Planet Formation at 30-150 AU for 1-3 Solar Mass Main Sequence Stars
• Nearby debris disk systems with high fractional luminosity reconsidered
• Planetesimal formation by sweep-up: How the bouncing barrier can be beneficial to growth
• Age dependence of the Vega Phenomenon: Theory
• Initial mass function of planetesimals formed by the streaming instability
• Evidence for the formation of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko through gravitational collapse of a bound clump of pebbles
• Long-Term Collisional Evolution of Debris Disks
• Debris Disks: Seeing Dust, Thinking of Planetesimals and Planets
• Steady-State Size Distributions for Collisional Populations: Analytical Solution with Size-Dependent Strength
• Debris disc stirring by secular perturbations from giant planets
• Towards Initial Mass Functions for Asteroids and Kuiper Belt Objects
• Collisional processes and size distribution in spatially extended debris discs
• Eclipsing binaries as standard candles: HD 23642 and the distance to the Pleiades
• Planetesimal formation by the streaming instability in a photoevaporating disk
• The Collisional Evolution of Debris Disks
• Debris disk size distributions: steady state collisional evolution with P-R drag and other loss processes
• Predictions for the secondary CO, C and O gas content of debris discs from the destruction of volatile-rich planetesimals
• Ice Lines, Planetesimal Composition and Solid Surface Density in the Solar Nebula
• Prospects for Detection of Catastrophic Collisions in Debris Disks
• Debris from giant impacts between planetary embryos at large orbital radii
• On Gas-Drag Induced Rapid Migration of Solids in a Non-Uniform Solar Nebula
• Evidence for universality in the initial planetesimal mass function
• An icy Kuiper-Belt around the young solar-type star HD 181327
• Dust Production from collisions in extrasolar planetary systems The inner Beta-Pictoris disc
• The History of the Solar System's Debris Disc: Observable Properties of the Kuiper Belt
• Disk Radii and Grain Sizes in Herschel-Resolved Debris Disks
• Modeling Collisional Cascades In Debris Disks: Steep Dust-Size Distributions
• Survival of icy grains in debris discs. The role of photosputtering
• The dust grain size - stellar luminosity trend in debris discs
• Planetary Growth with Collisional Fragmentation and Gas Drag
• Accretion in the Early Outer Solar System
• Are debris disks self-stirred?
• Warm Debris Disks Produced by Giant Impacts During Terrestrial Planet Formation
• Molecular gas in young debris disks
• An improved model of the Edgeworth-Kuiper debris disk
• Herschel's "Cold Debris Disks": Background Galaxies or Quiescent Rims of Planetary Systems?
• Collisional and Thermal Emission Models of Debris Disks: Towards Planetesimal Population Properties
• Modeling the HD32297 Debris Disk with Far-IR Herschel Data
• The cold origin of the warm dust around epsilon Eridani
• A Minimum-Mass Extrasolar Nebula
• The Debris Disk of Vega: A Steady-State Collisional Cascade, Naturally
• Collisional modelling of the AU Microscopii debris disc
• From Planetesimals to Planets in Turbulent Protoplanetary Disks I. Onset of Runaway Growth
• The role of pebble fragmentation in planetesimal formation I. Experimental study
• Effect of rotational disruption on the size-frequency distribution of the Main Belt asteroid population
• Signatures of massive collisions in debris discs
• Does warm debris dust stem from asteroid belts?
• Physical Properties of Asteroids in Comet-like Orbits in Infrared Asteroid Survey Catalogs
• Debris disc formation induced by planetary growth
• Collisions and drag in debris discs with eccentric parent belts
• Origin and evolution of two-component debris discs and an application to the q${}^1$ Eridani system
• Collisional modelling of the debris disc around HIP 17439

Cited by in corpus (30)

• Dust evolution in protoplanetary discs and the formation of planetesimals. What have we learned from laboratory experiments?
• Chemical Diversity in Protoplanetary Disks and Its Impact on the Formation History of Giant Planets
• A gap in the planetesimal disc around HD 107146 and asymmetric warm dust emission revealed by ALMA
• Solution to the debris disc mass problem: planetesimals are born small?
• Planet populations inferred from debris discs: insights from 178 debris systems in the ISPY, LEECH and LIStEN planet-hunting surveys
• ALMA observations of the narrow HR 4796A debris ring
• Population synthesis of exocometary gas around A stars
• Self-Stirring of Debris Discs by Planetesimals Formed by Pebble Concentration
• A $75\%$ Occurrence Rate of Debris Discs around F stars in the $\beta$ Pic Moving Group
• High resolution ALMA and HST images of q${}^1$ Eri: an asymmetric debris disc with an eccentric Jupiter
• The unexpected narrowness of eccentric debris rings: a sign of eccentricity during the protoplanetary disc phase
• Formation of Comets
• Is there more than meets the eye? Presence and role of submicron grains in debris discs
• Vertical gas accretion impacts the carbon-to-oxygen ratio of gas giant atmospheres
• Dust-to-gas ratio resurgence in circumstellar disks due to the formation of giant planets: the case of HD 163296
• The Age of the Carina Young Association and Potential Membership of HD 95086
• Survival of ALMA Rings in the Absence of Pressure Maxima
• The REASONS Survey: Resolved Millimeter Observations of a Large Debris Disk Around the Nearby F Star HD 170773
• Extrasolar Kuiper Belts
• Linking the formation and fate of exo-Kuiper belts within solar system analogues
• The GAPS program at TNG XLVII: The unusual formation history of V1298 Tau
• Multiwavelength Vertical Structure in the AU Mic Debris Disk: Characterizing the Collisional Cascade
• The tensile strength of compressed dust samples and the catastrophic disruption threshold of pre-planetary matter
• Inner edges of planetesimal belts: collisionally eroded or truncated?
• Relating grain size distributions in circumstellar discs to the spectral index at millimetre wavelengths
• The big sibling of AU Mic: a cold dust-rich debris disk around CP-72 2713 in the $\beta$ Pic moving group
• Debris Disks: Probing Planet Formation
• Twisted debris: how differential secular perturbations shape debris disks
• The influence of planetesimal fragmentation on planet formation
• Changes in a Dusty Ringlet in the Cassini Division after 2010