Crossing the Line: Active Galactic Nuclei in the Star-forming region of the BPT Diagram

Abstract

In this work, we investigate the reliability of the BPT diagram for excluding galaxies that host an AGN. We determine the prevalence of X-ray AGN in the star-forming region of the BPT diagram and discuss the reasons behind this apparent misclassification, focusing primarily on relatively massive ($\log (M_{\ast })\gtrsim 10$) galaxies. X-ray AGN are selected from deep XMM observations using a new method that results in greater samples with a wider range of X-ray luminosities, complete to $\log (L_X)>41$ for $z<0.3$. Taking X-ray detectability into account, we find the average fraction of X-ray AGN in the BPT star-forming branch is 2$\%$, suggesting the BPT diagram can provide a reasonably clean sample of star-forming galaxies. However, the X-ray selection is itself rather incomplete. At the tip of the AGN branch of the BPT diagram, the X-ray AGN fraction is only 14$\%$, which may have implications for studies that exclude AGN based only on X-ray observations. Interestingly, the X-ray AGN fractions are similar for Seyfert and LINER populations, consistent with LINERs being true AGN. We find that neither the star-formation dilution nor the hidden broad-line components can satisfactorily explain the apparent misclassification of X-ray AGN. On the other hand, $\sim 40\%$ of all X-ray AGN have weak emission lines such that they cannot be placed on the BPT diagram at all and often have low specific SFRs. Therefore, the most likely explanation for "misclassified" X-ray AGN is that they have intrinsically weak AGN lines, and are only placeable on the BPT diagram when they tend to have high specific SFRs.

arXiv comment16 pages, 16 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (70)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• Star Formation in Galaxies Along the Hubble Sequence
• The Seventh Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The Host Galaxies of AGN
• The Origin of the Mass--Metallicity Relation: Insights from 53,000 Star-Forming Galaxies in the SDSS
• Theoretical Modeling of Starburst Galaxies
• Advection-Dominated Accretion: A Self-Similar Solution
• The Host Galaxies and Classification of Active Galactic Nuclei
• UV Star Formation Rates in the Local Universe
• Nuclear Activity in Nearby Galaxies
• Mid-Infrared Selection of Active Galaxies
• Mid-Infrared Selection of AGN with the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer. I. Characterizing WISE-Selected AGN in COSMOS
• Obscured and unobscured active galactic nuclei in the Spitzer Space Telescope First Look Survey
• The 2-10 keV luminosity as a Star Formation Rate indicator
• X-ray emission from star-forming galaxies - I. High-mass X-ray binaries
• Host galaxies, clustering, Eddington ratios, and evolution of radio, X-ray, and infrared-selected AGNs
• The MOSFIRE Deep Evolution Field (MOSDEF) Survey: Rest-Frame Optical Spectroscopy for ~1500 H-Selected Galaxies at 1.37 < z < 3.8
• GALEX-SDSS-WISE Legacy Catalog (GSWLC): Star Formation Rates, Stellar Masses and Dust Attenuations of 700,000 Low-redshift Galaxies
• Gas metallicity diagnostics in star-forming galaxies
• SDSS IV MaNGA - Spatially resolved diagnostic diagrams: A proof that many galaxies are LIERs
• The XMM-Newton serendipitous survey. VII. The third XMM-Newton serendipitous source catalogue
• Using the Bright Ultra-Hard XMM-Newton Survey to define an IR selection of luminous AGN based on WISE colours
• The Difference between Radio-Loud and Radio-Quiet Active Galaxies
• A Chandra Perspective On Galaxy-Wide X-ray Binary Emission And Its Correlation With Star Formation Rate And Stellar Mass: New Results From Luminous Infrared Galaxies
• Semi-empirical analysis of Sloan Digital Sky Survey galaxies III. How to distinguish AGN hosts
• Can retired galaxies mimic active galaxies? Clues from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The Relationship of Hard X-ray and Optical Line Emission in Low Redshift Active Galactic Nuclei
• The Nature of LINER-like Emission in Red Galaxies
• GOODS-Herschel: The far-infrared view of star formation in AGN host galaxies since z~3
• Towards a Complete Census of AGNs in Nearby Galaxies: A Large Population of Optically Unidentified AGNs
• A New Diagnostic of Active Galactic Nuclei: Revealing Highly-Absorbed Systems at Redshift>0.3
• Growing supermassive black holes in the late stages of galaxy mergers are heavily obscured
• Galaxy Zoo: The fundamentally different co-evolution of supermassive black holes and their early- and late-type host galaxies
• AGN Emission Line Diagnostics and the Mass-Metallicity Relation up to Redshift z~2: the Impact of Selection Effects and Evolution
• "Hidden" Seyfert 2 Galaxies and the X-ray Background
• X-Rays from NGC 3256: High-Energy Emission in Starburst Galaxies and Their Contribution to the Cosmic X-Ray Background
• Theoretical Modeling of Star-Forming Galaxies I. Emission Line Diagnostic Grids for Local and Low-Metallicity Galaxies
• The MOSDEF Survey: Optical AGN Diagnostics at z~2.3
• Are Compton-Thick AGN the Missing Link Between Mergers and Black Hole Growth?
• The Biases of Optical Line-Ratio Selection for Active Galactic Nuclei, and the Intrinsic Relationship between Black Hole Accretion and Galaxy Star Formation
• The Nature of X-ray Bright Optically Normal Galaxies
• A New Population of Compton-Thick AGN Identified Using the Spectral Curvature Above 10 keV
• On The Nature of Low Luminosity Narrow Line AGN
• Low-Luminosity Accretion in Black Hole X-ray Binaries and Active Galactic Nuclei
• The $L-\sigma$ relation for massive bursts of star formation
• Imprints of galaxy evolution on H ii regions Memory of the past uncovered by the CALIFA survey
• AEGIS: Demographics of X-ray and Optically Selected AGNs
• Why X-ray--Selected AGN Appear Optically Dull
• Indicators of Intrinsic AGN Luminosity: a Multi-Wavelength Approach
• ROSAT and ASCA Observations of X-ray Luminous starburst Galaxies : NGC3310 and NGC3690
• The MOSDEF survey: AGN multi-wavelength identification, selection biases and host galaxy properties
• Exploring NLS1 through the physical properties of their hosts
• Compton Thick AGN in the XMM-COSMOS survey
• An XMM-Newton spectral survey of 12 micron selected galaxies. II. Implications for AGN selection and unification
• Galactic star-formation rates gauged by stellar end-products
• Mid-infrared luminous quasars in the GOODS-Herschel fields: a large population of heavily-obscured, Compton-thick quasars at z~2
• Buried AGNs in Advanced Mergers:Mid-infrared color selection as a dual AGN finder
• Are Most Low-Luminosity AGN Really Obscured?
• The Intrinsic Eddington Ratio Distribution of Active Galactic Nuclei in Star-forming Galaxies from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The Limitations of Optical Spectroscopic Diagnostics in Identifying AGNs in the Low Mass Regime
• The Nature of Optically Dull Active Galactic Nuclei in COSMOS
• Luminous WISE-selected Obscured, Unobscured, and Red Quasars in Stripe 82
• The OPTX Project IV: How Reliable is [OIII] as a Measure of AGN Activity?
• A new sample of X-ray selected narrow emission-line galaxies. I. The nature of optically elusive AGN
• Evolution of the X-ray Luminosity in Young HII Galaxies
• Mixing between Seyfert and HII-region excitation in local active galaxies
• Aperture Effects on Spectroscopic Galaxy Activity Classification
• A new sample of X-ray selected narrow emission-line galaxies. II. Looking for True Seyfert 2
• The X-ray luminous galaxies optically classified as star forming are mostly narrow line Seyfert 1s

Cited by in corpus (34)

• X-ray Detected AGN in SDSS Dwarf Galaxies
• AGN Selection and Demographics in GOODS-S/HUDF from X-ray to Radio
• The Diagnostic Potential of JWST in Characterizing Elusive AGNs
• The Incidence of X-ray selected AGN in Nearby Galaxies
• AGN All the Way Down? AGN-like Line Ratios are Common In the Lowest-Mass Isolated Quiescent Galaxies
• Dwarf AGNs from Optical Variability for the Origins of Seeds (DAVOS): Insights from the Dark Energy Survey Deep Fields
• AGN Selection Methods Have Profound Impacts on the Distributions of Host Galaxy Properties
• RESOLVE and ECO: Finding Low-Metallicity $z\sim 0$ Dwarf AGN Candidates Using Optimized Emission-Line Diagnostics
• Dwarf AGNs from Variability for the Origins of Seeds (DAVOS): Intermediate-mass black hole demographics from optical synoptic surveys
• A Systematic Analysis of Stellar Populations in the Host Galaxies of Changing-look AGNs
• A Catalog of 71 Coronal Line Galaxies in MaNGA: [NeV] is an Effective AGN Tracer
• A Large Population of Luminous Active Galactic Nuclei Lacking X-ray Detections: Evidence for Heavy Obscuration?
• The Nuclear Region of NGC1365: Star Formation, Negative Feedback, and Outflow Structure
• A complete spectroscopic catalogue of local galaxies in the Northern spring sky -- Gas properties and nuclear activity in different environments
• The eROSITA Final Equatorial-Depth Survey (eFEDS): Presenting The Demographics of X-ray Emission From Normal Galaxies
• Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA): A $\text{WISE}$ study of the activity of emission-line systems in G23
• Effect of richness on AGN and star formation activities in SDSS galaxy groups
• Circumnuclear regions of different BPT types in star-forming MaNGA galaxies: AGN detectability
• The Activation of Galactic Nuclei and Their Accretion Rates are Linked to the Star Formation Rates and Bulge-types of Their Host Galaxies
• A Multi-wavelength Study of the Dual Nuclei in Mrk 212
• AGN in the CALIFA survey: X-ray detection of nuclear sources
• A New Physical Picture for AGNs Lacking Optical Emission Lines
• ULISSE: A Tool for One-shot Sky Exploration and its Application to Active Galactic Nuclei Detection
• Dark Energy Survey Identification of A Low-Mass Active Galactic Nucleus at Redshift 0.823 from Optical Variability
• Connecting MeerKAT radio continuum properties to GAMA optical emission-line and WISE mid-infrared activity
• Multiple giant eruptions and X-ray emission in the recoiling AGN/LBV candidate SDSS1133
• VLT-MUSE spectroscopy of AGNs misclassified by BPT diagnostic or with weak emission lines
• X-ray Selected Narrow-Line Active Galactic Nuclei in the COSMOS Field: Nature of Optically Dull Active Galactic Nuclei
• X-ray Analysis of AGN from the GALEX Time Domain Survey
• Beyond diagnostic-diagrams: A critical exploration on the classification of ionization processes
• Mid-infrared Variability-based AGN Selection using the Multi-epoch Photometric Data from WISE
• On the relation of host properties and environment of AGN galaxies across the standard optical diagnostic diagram
• Physical Drivers of Emission Line Diversity of SDSS Seyfert 2s and LINERs After Removal of Contributions by Star Formation
• A catalogue of Type 2 active galactic nuclei in the 6dF Galaxy Survey