Entangled massive mechanical oscillators
arXiv:1711.01640 · doi:10.1038/s41586-018-0038-x
Abstract
An entangled quantum state of two or more particles or objects exhibits some of the most peculiar features of quantum mechanics. Entangled systems cannot be described independently of each other even though they may have an arbitrarily large spatial separation. Reconciling this property with the inherent uncertainty in quantum states is at the heart of some of the most famous debates in the development of quantum theory. Nonetheless, entanglement nowadays has a solid theoretical and experimental foundation, and it is the crucial resource behind many emerging quantum technologies. Entanglement has been demonstrated for microscopic systems, such as with photons, ions, and electron spins, and more recently in microwave and electromechanical devices. For macroscopic objects, however, entanglement becomes exceedingly fragile towards environmental disturbances. A major outstanding goal has been to create and verify the entanglement between the motional states of slowly-moving massive objects. Here, we carry out such an experimental demonstration, with the moving bodies realized as two micromechanical oscillators coupled to a microwave-frequency electromagnetic cavity that is used to create and stabilise the entanglement of the centre-of-mass motion of the oscillators. We infer the existence of entanglement in the steady state by combining measurement of correlated mechanical fluctuations with an analysis of the microwaves emitted from the cavity. Our work qualitatively extends the range of entangled physical systems, with implications in quantum information processing, precision measurement, and tests of the limits of quantum mechanics.
arXiv commentsupplement included
References in corpus (22)
- Gaussian Quantum Information
- Experimental loophole-free violation of a Bell inequality using entangled electron spins separated by 1.3 km
- Sideband Cooling Micromechanical Motion to the Quantum Ground State
- Inseparability criterion for continuous variable systems
- Experimental long-lived entanglement of two macroscopic objects
- Quantum squeezing of motion in a mechanical resonator
- Entangling macroscopic oscillators exploiting radiation pressure
- Preparation and Measurement of Three-Qubit Entanglement in a Superconducting Circuit
- Reservoir-engineered entanglement in optomechanical systems
- Squeezing of quantum noise of motion in a micromechanical resonator
- Nonlocality of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen State in Wigner Representation
- Quantum nondemolition measurement of a nonclassical state of a massive object
- Two-mode squeezed states in cavity optomechanics via engineering of a single reservoir
- Entangling movable mirrors in a double cavity system
- Experimental demonstration of continuous variable polarization entanglement
- Dissipation-driven two-mode mechanical squeezed states in optomechanical systems
- Entangled Mechanical Oscillators
- Quantum back-action evading measurement of collective mechanical modes
- Two-mode back-action-evading measurements in cavity optomechanics
- Generation and detection of large and robust entanglement between two different mechanical resonators in cavity optomechanics
- Two-mode squeezing in an electromechanical resonator
- Dynamical two-mode squeezing of thermal fluctuations in a cavity opto-mechanical system
Cited by in corpus (295)
- Magnon-photon-phonon entanglement in cavity magnomechanics
- Quantum control of surface acoustic wave phonons
- Direct observation of deterministic macroscopic entanglement
- Creation and control of multi-phonon Fock states in a bulk acoustic wave resonator
- Squeezed states of magnons and phonons in cavity magnomechanics
- Nonreciprocal Optomechanical Entanglement against Backscattering Losses
- Microwave-to-optics conversion using a mechanical oscillator in its quantum groundstate
- Reconciliation of quantum local master equations with thermodynamics
- Quantum entanglement between two magnon modes via Kerr nonlinearity
- Entangling two magnon modes via magnetostrictive interaction
- Towards real-world quantum networks: a review
- Quantum-mechanics free subsystem with mechanical oscillators
- Magnetostrictively induced stationary entanglement between two microwave fields
- Tailoring Structure-borne Sound Through Bandgap Engineering in Phononic Crystals and Metamaterials: A Comprehensive Review
- An optomechanical Bell test
- Mesoscopic physics of nanomechanical systems
- Stationary Entangled Radiation from Micromechanical Motion
- Nonreciprocal ground-state cooling of multiple mechanical resonators
- A quantum memory at telecom wavelengths
- Quantum state preparation, tomography, and entanglement of mechanical oscillators
- Noise-Tolerant Optomechanical Entanglement via Synthetic Magnetism
- Entangling the vibrational modes of two massive ferromagnetic spheres using cavity magnomechanics
- Entanglement between Distant Macroscopic Mechanical and Spin Systems
- Simultaneous cooling of coupled mechanical resonators in cavity optomechanics
- Cryogenic electro-optic interconnect for superconducting devices
- Observation of quantum entanglement in top-quark pairs using the ATLAS detector
- Probing Macroscopic Quantum Superpositions with Nanorotors
- Feedback cooling of a room temperature mechanical oscillator close to its motional groundstate
- Quantum drives produce strong entanglement between YIG samples without using intrinsic nonlinearities
- Parity measurement in the strong dispersive regime of circuit quantum acoustodynamics
- Developing a platform for linear mechanical quantum computing
- Laser cooling of a nanomechanical oscillator to the zero-point energy
- Nonreciprocal enhancement of remote entanglement between nonidentical mechanical oscillators
- Nonreciprocal entanglement in cavity-magnon optomechanics
- A perspective on hybrid quantum opto- and electromechanical systems
- Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen entanglement and asymmetric steering between distant macroscopic mechanical and magnonic systems
- Entanglement enhancement in cavity magnomechanics by an optical parametric amplifier
- Optical Backaction-Evading Measurement of a Mechanical Oscillator
- Ground State Cooling of an Ultracoherent Electromechanical System
- Interaction of Mechanical Oscillators Mediated by the Exchange of Virtual Photon Pairs
- Massive quantum systems as interfaces of quantum mechanics and gravity
- Enhanced photon blockade in an optomechanical system with parametric amplification
- Enhancing Gravitational Interaction between Quantum Systems by a Massive Mediator
- Sideband cooling of nearly degenerate micromechanical oscillators in a multimode optomechanical system
- Contextual Wavefunction Collapse: An integrated theory of quantum measurement
- Coupling microwave photons to a mechanical resonator using quantum interference
- Phase-controlled asymmetric optomechanical entanglement against optical backscattering
- Selective optomechanically-induced amplification with driven oscillators
- Simultaneous cooling of all six degrees of freedom of an optically levitated nanoparticle by elliptic coherent scattering
- Coherent phonon dynamics in spatially separated graphene mechanical resonators
- Demonstration of displacement sensing of a mg-scale pendulum for mm- and mg- scale gravity measurements
- Multimode optomechanical cooling via general dark-mode control
- Force-Gradient Sensing and Entanglement via Feedback Cooling of Interacting Nanoparticles
- Generation and detection of non-Gaussian phonon-added coherent states in optomechanical systems
- Nonreciprocal transport based on cavity Floquet modes in optomechanics
- Topological lattices realized in superconducting circuit optomechanics
- Entangling ferrimagnetic magnons with an atomic ensemble via opto-magnomechanics
- Enhancement of few-photon optomechanical effects with cross-Kerr nonlinearity
- Giant Tunable Mechanical Nonlinearity in Graphene-Silicon Nitride Hybrid Resonator
- Quantum experiments with microscale particles
- Nanomechanical Dissipation and Strain Engineering
- Delayed sudden death of entanglement at exceptional points
- A squeezed mechanical oscillator with milli-second quantum decoherence
- Enhanced force sensitivity and entanglement in periodically driven optomechanics
- Cavity electromechanics with parametric mechanical driving
- Domino cooling of a coupled mechanical-resonator chain via cold-damping feedback
- Non-Abelian effects in dissipative photonic topological lattices
- Amplitude-modulation-based atom-mirror entanglement and mechanical squeezing in a hybrid optomechanical system
- Nonlocal magnon entanglement generation in coupled hybrid cavity systems
- Magnon squeezing by two-tone driving of a qubit in cavity-magnon-qubit systems
- Strong mechanical squeezing in a standard optomechanical system by pump modulation
- Observation and stabilization of photonic Fock states in a hot radio-frequency resonator
- Levitated cavity optomechanics in high vacuum
- A macroscopic object passively cooled into its quantum ground state of motion: beyond single-mode cooling
- Entangling levitated nanoparticles by coherent scattering
- Unconditional preparation of nonclassical states via linear-and-quadratic optomechanics
- Squeezing and multimode entanglement of surface acoustic wave phonons
- Non-classical mechanical states guided in a phononic waveguide
- Stationary optomechanical entanglement between a mechanical oscillator and its measurement apparatus
- Photon-Pressure Strong-Coupling between two Superconducting Circuits
- Proposal to Test Quantum Wave-Particle Superposition on Massive Mechanical Resonators
- Witnessing Opto-Mechanical Entanglement with Photon-Counting
- Cavity Optomechanics with Photonic Bound States in the Continuum
- Prospects for observing gravitational forces between nonclassical mechanical oscillators
- Thermal-noise-resistant optomechanical entanglement via general dark-mode control
- Two-Level System Damping in a Quasi-One-Dimensional Optomechanical Resonator
- Creation, storage and retrieval of an optomechanical cat state
- Quantum electromechanics with levitated nanoparticles
- Single-photon cooling in microwave magneto-mechanics
- On-chip thermometry for microwave optomechanics implemented in a nuclear demagnetization cryostat
- Optomechanical generation of a mechanical catlike state by phonon subtraction
- Measurement of motion beyond the quantum limit by transient amplification
- Generation of mechanical interference fringes by multi-photon counting
- Quantum correlations in optomechanical crystals
- Ground-state cooling of mechanical resonators by quantum reservoir engineering
- Optimal Control of Hybrid Optomechanical Systems for Generating Non-Classical States of Mechanical Motion
- Quantum Information meets High-Energy Physics: Input to the update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics
- State preparation and tomography of a nanomechanical resonator with fast light pulses
- Rare-earth-mediated opto-mechanical system in the reversed dissipation regime
- Revealing hidden quantum correlations in an electromechanical measurement
- Cavity optomechanics with feedback--controlled in--loop light
- Quantum squeezing induced quantum entanglement and EPR steering in coupled optomechanical system
- Generating quantum entanglement between macroscopic objects with continuous measurement and feedback control
- Soft-clamped phononic dimers for mechanical sensing and transduction
- Preparation and decay of a single quantum of vibration at ambient conditions
- Entangling mechanical vibrations of two massive ferrimagnets by fully exploiting the nonlinearity of magnetostriction
- Four-wave-cooling to the single phonon level in Kerr optomechanics
- Phonon Quantum Nondemolition Measurements in Nonlinearly Coupled Optomechanical Cavities
- Linear-and-quadratic reservoir engineering of non-Gaussian states
- Hybrid cavity-antenna architecture for strong and tunable sideband-selective molecular Raman scattering enhancement
- Generating mechanical and optomechanical entanglement via pulsed interaction and measurement
- Strong squeezing of microwave output fields via reservoir-engineered cavity magnomechanics
- Roadmap on Nanoscale Magnetic Resonance Imaging
- Unconditional steady-state entanglement in macroscopic hybrid systems by coherent noise cancellation
- Floquet control of optomechanical bistability in multimode systems
- Superconducting electro-mechanics to test Diósi-Penrose effects of general relativity in massive superpositions
- Perfect nonreciprocity by loss engineering
- Stationary Gaussian Entanglement between Levitated Nanoparticles
- "Mechano-optics": An optomechanical quantum simulator
- Quadratic optomechanical cooling of a cavity-levitated nanosphere
- Controllable generation of mechanical quadrature squeezing via dark-mode engineering in cavity optomechanics
- Macroscopicity of quantum mechanical superposition tests via hypothesis falsification
- Two-mode Schrödinger-cat states with nonlinear optomechanics: generation and verification of non-Gaussian mechanical entanglement
- Phononic entanglement concentration via optomechanical interactions
- Master-equation treatment of nonlinear optomechanical systems with optical loss
- Large flux-mediated coupling in hybrid electromechanical system with a transmon qubit
- Quantum correlation enhanced weak field detection in optomechanical system
- Chimera states in small disordered optomechanical arrays
- Enhanced optomechanical entanglement and cooling via dissipation engineering
- Enhancement of optomechanically induced sum sideband using parametric interactions
- Nonlinear Sideband Cooling to a Cat State of Motion
- Multi-phonon interactions between nitrogen-vacancy centers and nanomechanical resonators
- Beyond linear coupling in microwave optomechanics
- Quantum collective motion of macroscopic mechanical oscillators
- Sympathetic cooling of a radio-frequency LC circuit to its ground state in an optoelectromechanical system
- Quantum State Smoothing for Linear Gaussian Systems
- Analytic solutions to the Maxwell-London equations and levitation force for a superconducting sphere in a quadrupole field
- Entanglement and Bell nonlocality with bottom-quark pairs at hadron colliders
- Energy-level-attraction and heating-resistant-cooling of mechanical resonators with exceptional points
- Strong Mechanical Squeezing for a Levitated Particle by Coherent Scattering
- Emergence and enhancement of feedback control induced quantum entanglement
- Floquet dynamics in quantum measurement of mechanical motion
- Quantum master equations for entangled qubit environments
- Stochastic Path Integral Analysis of the Continuously Monitored Quantum Harmonic Oscillator
- Stroboscopic quantum optomechanics
- Propagation-induced entanglement revival
- Ground-state cooling of multiple near-degenerate mechanical modes
- Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt Bell inequality test in an optomechanical device
- Synthesizing multi-phonon quantum superposition states using flux-mediated three-body interactions with superconducting qubits
- Tripartite quantum entanglement with squeezed optomechanics
- Generation of coherence in an exactly solvable nonlinear nanomechanical system
- Left-handed superlattice metamaterials for circuit QED
- Dissipative Quantum Feedback in Measurements Using a Parametrically Coupled Microcavity
- Atomic Quantum Technologies for Quantum Matter and Fundamental Physics Applications
- Quantum backaction evading measurements of a silicon nitride membrane resonator
- Measurement of two-photon position-momentum EPR correlations through single-photon intensity measurements
- Number-phase entanglement and Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering
- Coherent mechanical noise cancellation and cooperativity competition in optomechanical arrays
- Stationary quantum entanglement between a massive mechanical membrane and a low frequency LC circuit
- Instabilities near ultrastrong coupling in microwave optomechanical cavity
- Stroboscopic high-order nonlinearity for quantum optomechanics
- Interference effects in hybrid cavity optomechanics
- Strong Thermo-mechanical Squeezing in a far detuned Membrane-in-the-middle System
- Magnomechanics in suspended magnetic beams
- Cooling photon-pressure circuits into the quantum regime
- Critical quantum fluctuations and photon antibunching in optomechanical systems with large single-photon cooperativity
- Switchable bipartite and genuine tripartite entanglement via an optoelectromechanical interface
- Millionfold improvement in multivibration-feedback optomechanical refrigeration via auxiliary mechanical coupling
- Generation of single entangled photon-phonon pairs via an atom-photon-phonon interaction
- Active-feedback quantum control of an integrated low-frequency mechanical resonator
- Vector optomechanical entanglement
- Enhanced Gaussian interferometric power, entanglement and Gaussian quantum steering in magnonics system with squeezed light
- Mesoscopic two-mode entangled and steerable states of 40,000 atoms in a Bose-Einstein condensate interferometer
- Continuous field tracking with machine learning and steady state spin squeezing
- Degeneracy-breaking and Long-lived Multimode Microwave Electromechanical Systems Enabled by Cubic Silicon-Carbide Membrane Crystals
- Dueling Dynamical Backaction in a Cryogenic Optomechanical Cavity
- Simulating indefinite causal order with Rindler observers
- Preparation and Verification of Two-Mode Mechanical Entanglement Through Pulsed Optomechanical Measurements
- Cascade and locally dissipative realizations of linear quantum systems for pure Gaussian state covariance assignment
- Deterministic multi-phonon entanglement between two mechanical resonators on separate substrates
- Simultaneous ground-state cooling of multiple degenerate mechanical modes through cross-Kerr effect
- Electric circuit model of microwave optomechanics
- Parametrically enhanced interactions and non-trivial bath dynamics in a photon-pressure Kerr amplifier
- Quantifying quantumness of correlations using Gaussian Rényi-2 entropy in optomechanical interfaces
- Quantum Magnetometer with Dual-Coupling Optomechanics
- Combining Floquet and Lyapunov techniques for time-dependent problems in optomechanics and electromechanics
- Creation of Two-Mode Squeezed States in Atomic Mechanical Oscillators
- Quantifying the mesoscopic nature of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen nonlocality
- Engineering asymmetric steady-state Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering in macroscopic hybrid systems
- Detecting quantumness in uniform precessions
- Entanglement Dynamics in Dispersive Optomechanics: Non-Classicality and Revival
- Solving quantum trajectories for systems with linear Heisenberg-picture dynamics and Gaussian measurement noise
- Multipartite Entanglement Swapping and Mechanical Cluster States
- Macroscopic quantum entanglement between an optomechanical cavity and a continuous field in presence of non-Markovian noise
- Optimal control of linear Gaussian quantum systems via quantum learning control
- Nonstationary force sensing under dissipative mechanical quantum squeezing
- Enhancing squeezing and nonclassicality of light in atom-optomechanical systems
- Complementarity-Entanglement Tradeoff in Quantum Gravity
- Continuous variable multipartite vibrational entanglement
- Detecting kHz gravitons from a neutron star merger with a multi-mode resonant mass detector
- Enhancing the quantum entanglement and EPR steering of a coupled optomechanical system with a squeezed vacuum field
- Fast feedback control of mechanical motion using circuit optomechanics
- Non-classical correlations between photons and phonons of center-of-mass motion of a mechanical oscillator
- Nonreciprocal transition between two nondegenerate energy levels
- Method of Higher-Order Operators for Quantum Optomechanics
- Multiphonon transitions in a quantum electromechanical system
- Entangling independent particles by path identity
- Macroscopic quantum mechanics in gravitational-wave observatories and beyond
- Manipulation of nanomechanical resonator via shaking optical frequency
- Nonclassical mechanical states in cavity optomechanics in the single-photon strong-coupling regime
- Proposal for a quantum traveling Brillouin resonator
- Optimizing mechanical entanglement using squeezing and parametric amplification
- Quantum correlations enhanced in hybrid optomechanical system via phase tuning
- Robust Macroscopic Matter-Wave Interferometry with Solids
- Nonclassical photon statistics in two-tone continuously driven optomechanics
- Nonclassical states of levitated macroscopic objects beyond the ground state
- Microwave single-tone optomechanics in the classical regime
- Reinforcement learning assisted non-reciprocal optomechanical gyroscope
- Hyperbolic ring based formulation for thermo field dynamics, quantum dissipation, entanglement, and holography
- An optomechanical platform with a 3-dimensional waveguide cavity
- Backaction-evading measurement of entanglement in optomechanics
- Electron-mediated entanglement of two distant macroscopic ferromagnets within a nonequilibrium spintronic device
- Design Evaluation of Serial and Parallel sub-mK Continuous Nuclear Demagnetization Refrigerators
- Mesoscopic and macroscopic quantum correlations in photonic, atomic and optomechanical systems
- Optomechanical compensatory cooling mechanism with exceptional points
- Amplitude and phase noise in Two-membrane cavity optomechanics
- Generation of multipartite entangled states based on double-longitudinal-mode cavity optomechanial system
- Can the displacemon device test objective collapse models?
- Normal-mode splitting in the optomechanical system with an optical parametric amplifier and coherent feedback
- Motional entanglement of remote optically levitated nanoparticles
- Enhancing optomechanical force sensing utilizing synthetic magnetism
- Generation of stable Gaussian cluster states in optomechanical systems with multifrequency drives
- Deterministic generation of nonclassical mechanical states in cavity optomechanics via reinforcement learning
- Large amplitude mechanical coherent states and detection of weak nonlinearities in cavity optomechanics
- Quantum Simulation of Tunable and Ultrastrong Mixed-Optomechanics
- Effect of internal resonance on the dynamics of MoS2 resonator
- Mesoscopic Quantum Thermo-mechanics: a new frontier of experimental physics
- Numerical detection of Gaussian entanglement and its application to the identification of bound entangled Gaussian states
- Simultaneous cooling of degenerate mechanical modes in unresolved sideband regime via optical and mechanical nonlinearities
- Nanomechanical damping via electron-assisted relaxation of two-level systems
- Fast quantum state transfer and entanglement preparation in strongly coupled bosonic systems
- Optomechanical cooling with simultaneous intracavity and extracavity squeezed light
- Macroscopic distant magnon-mode entanglement via a squeezed drive
- Three-particle quantum correlation interferometry
- A cavity optomechanical locking scheme based on the optical spring effect
- Preparation of conditionally-squeezed states in qubit-oscillator systems
- Quantum simulation of a three-mode optomechanical system based on the Fredkin-type interaction
- Far-Infrared frequency mode conversion using bulk acoustic phonon modes
- Acute entanglement and Photon/Phonons statistics in a balanced/unbalanced PT-symmetry systems
- Robustness of entanglement in a non-Hermitian cavity-optomechanical system even away from exceptional points
- Cavity Optomechanical Probe of Gravity Between Massive Mechanical Oscillators
- Proposal for a clumsiness-free test of macroscopic realism
- Full dynamics of two-membrane cavity optomechanics
- Steady-state entanglement of interacting masses in free space through optimal feedback control
- A Novel Architecture for room temperature microwave optomechanical experiments
- Phase-controlled robust tripartite quantum entanglement in cavity-magnon optomechanics
- Amplitude Noise Cancellation of Microwave Tones
- Hybrid optomechanical superconducting qubit system
- Phase-dependent controllable field generation in a ring cavity resonator
- Selective cooling and squeezing in a lossy optomechanical closed loop embodying an exceptional surface
- Kerr-enhanced optomechanical entanglement generation via reservoir design
- Dynamical Generation of Synthetic Electric Fields for Photons in the Quantum Regime
- Position- and momentum-squeezed quantum states in micro-scale mechanical resonators
- Quantum and thermal fluctuations of a thin elastic plate
- Demonstrating levitation within a microwave cavity
- Effective optoelectrical entanglement and strong mechanical squeezing in a multi-modulated optoelectromechanical system
- Synchronization of molecular electrochemical oscillators by photon-assisted entanglement
- Bayesian optimization of non-classical optomechanical correlations
- Theory of bifurcation amplifiers utilizing the nonlinear dynamical response of an optically damped mechanical oscillator
- Floquet phonon lasing in multimode optomechanical systems
- Quantum Zeno blockade in optomechanical systems
- Non-Gaussian macroscopic entanglement of motion in a hybrid electromechanical device
- Prospects of cooling a mechanical resonator with a transmon qubit in c-QED setup
- Microwave optomechanical measurement of non-metallized SiN strings at mK temperatures
- Generation of bipartite mechanical cat state by performing projective Bell state measurement
- Manipulating Topological Polaritons in Optomechanical Ladders
- Mechanical Squeezed-Fock Qubit: Towards Quantum Weak-Force Sensing
- Optomechanics for quantum technologies
- Steady motional entanglement between two distant levitated nanoparticles
- Coupling modifies the quantum fluctuations of entangled oscillators
- Measuring High-Order Phonon Correlations in an Optomechanical Resonator
- Strongly driven cavity quantum electrodynamical-optomechanical hybrid system
- Multimode Gaussian steady state engineering in optomechanical systems with a squeezed reservoir
- Continuous-Variable Quantum Teleportation Using Microwave Enabled Plasmonic Graphene Waveguide
- Beating the 3 dB Limit for Intracavity Squeezing and Its Application to Nondemolition Qubit Readout
- Dephasing versus collapse: Lessons from the tight-binding model with noise
- Devices in Superposition
- Routing entanglement through quantum networks
- Quantitative calibration of a TWPA applied to an optomechanical platform
- CDJ-Pontryagin Optimal Control for General Continuously Monitored Quantum Systems
- Decoherence of nonrelativistic bosonic quantum fields
- Optical entanglement facilitated by a hot mechanical oscillator
- On Schrödingerist Quantum Thermodynamics
- Nonreciprocal Coupling Induced Non-Hermitian Entanglement in Optomechanical Systems
- Significant enhancement in refrigeration and entanglement in auxiliary-cavity-assisted optomechanical systems