Globular Cluster Systems in Brightest Cluster Galaxies. III: Beyond Bimodality
arXiv:1612.08089 · doi:10.3847/1538-4357/835/1/101
Abstract
We present new deep photometry of the rich globular cluster (GC) systems around the Brightest Cluster Galaxies UGC 9799 (Abell 2052) and UGC 10143 (Abell 2147), obtained with the HST ACS and WFC3 cameras. For comparison, we also present new reductions of similar HST/ACS data for the Coma supergiants NGC 4874 and 4889. All four of these galaxies have huge cluster populations (to the radial limits of our data, comprising from 12000 to 23000 clusters per galaxy). The metallicity distribution functions (MDFs) of the GCs can still be matched by a bimodal-Gaussian form where the metal-rich and metal-poor modes are separated by ~0.8 dex, but the internal dispersions of each mode are so large that the total MDF becomes very broad and nearly continuous from [Fe/H] = -2.4 to Solar. There are, however, significant differences between galaxies in the relative numbers of \emph{metal-rich} clusters, suggesting that they underwent significantly different histories of mergers with massive, gas-rich halos. Lastly, the proportion of metal-poor GCs rises especially rapidly outside projected radii R > 4 R_eff, suggesting the importance of accreted dwarf satellites in the outer halo. Comprehensive models for the formation of GCs as part of the hierarchical formation of their parent galaxies will be needed to trace the systematic change in structure of the MDF with galaxy mass, from the distinctly bimodal form in smaller galaxies up to the broad continuum that we see in the very largest systems.
In press for Astrophysical Journal
References in corpus (134)
- Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
- Embedded Clusters in Molecular Clouds
- Extragalactic Globular Clusters and Galaxy Formation
- The remnants of galaxy formation from a panoramic survey of the region around M31
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey IX: The Color Distributions of Globular Cluster Systems in Early-Type Galaxies
- Properties of Globular Cluster Systems in Nearby Early-type Galaxies
- On the Origin of Globular Cluster Systems in Elliptical and cD Galaxies
- The Formation of Giant Elliptical Galaxies and Their Globular Cluster Systems
- M31 Globular Clusters: Colors and Metallicities
- Modeling the Metallicity Distribution of Globular Clusters
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey. XII. The Luminosity Function of Globular Clusters in Early Type Galaxies
- Formation of globular clusters in hierarchical cosmology
- The Hubble Space Telescope UV Legacy Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. V. Constraints on Formation Scenarios
- New Insights from HST Studies of Globular Cluster Systems I: Colors, Distances and Specific Frequencies of 28 Elliptical Galaxies
- A Catalog of Globular Cluster Systems: What Determines the Size of a Galaxy's Globular Cluster Population?
- An optical spectroscopic survey of the 3CR sample of radio galaxies with z<0.3. II. Spectroscopic classes and accretion modes in radio-loud AGN
- Globular Cluster Systems I: V-I Color Distributions
- Globular Cluster Systems in Brightest Cluster Galaxies: Bimodal Metallicity Distributions and the Nature of the High-Luminosity Clusters
- The SAGES Legacy Unifying Globulars and GalaxieS Survey (SLUGGS): Sample definition, methods, and initial results
- The Kinematics and Metallicity of the M31 Globular Cluster System
- Wide-Field Precision Kinematics of the M87 Globular Cluster System
- The ages of young star clusters, massive blue stragglers and the upper mass limit of stars: analysing age dependent stellar mass functions
- Globular Clusters in Virgo Ellipticals: Unexpected Results for Giants, Dwarfs, and Nuclei from ACS Imaging
- The ACS Fornax Cluster Survey. VIII. The Luminosity Function of Globular Clusters in Virgo and Fornax Early-Type Galaxies and its Use as a Distance Indicator
- Explaining the Color Distributions of Globular Cluster Systems in Elliptical Galaxies
- Chandra Observation of the Cooling Flow Cluster Abell 2052
- Star Clusters in M31: II. Old Cluster Metallicities and Ages from Hectospec Data
- The Globular Cluster Systems of the Early-type Galaxies NGC3379, NGC4406, and NGC4594 and Implications for Galaxy Formation
- Intracluster light and the extended stellar envelopes of cD galaxies: An analytical description
- The Next Generation Virgo Cluster Survey. VIII. The Spatial Distribution of Globular Clusters in the Virgo Cluster
- The HST/ACS Coma Cluster Survey IV. Intergalactic Globular Clusters and the Massive Globular Cluster System at the Core of the Coma Galaxy Cluster
- Globular Cluster Systems in Giant Ellipticals: the Mass/Metallicity Relation
- The Mass Of The Coma Cluster From Weak Lensing In The Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- The SLUGGS Survey: Calcium Triplet-based Spectroscopic Metallicities for Over 900 Globular Clusters
- Large-scale study of the NGC 1399 globular cluster system in Fornax
- A Very Deep Chandra Observation of Abell 2052: Bubbles, Shocks, and Sloshing
- The Chandra view of the 3C/FRI sample of low luminosity radio-galaxies
- Evidence for the Hierarchical Formation of the Galactic Spheroid
- The metallicity bimodality of globular cluster systems: a test of galaxy assembly and of the evolution of the galaxy mass-metallicity relation
- Modeling the Formation of Globular Cluster Systems in the Virgo Cluster
- The Fossil Record of Two-phase Galaxy Assembly: Kinematics and Metallicities in the Nearest S0 Galaxy
- The GHOSTS survey. II. The diversity of Halo Color and Metallicity Profiles of Massive Disk Galaxies
- Evidence for Two Phases of Galaxy Formation from Radial Trends in the Globular Cluster System of NGC 1407
- The importance of major mergers in the build up of stellar mass in brightest cluster galaxies at z=1
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey. XIV. Analysis of Color-Magnitude Relations in Globular Cluster Systems
- Line Emission in the Brightest Cluster Galaxies of the NOAO Fundamental Plane and Sloan Digital Sky Surveys
- The Ages, Metallicities and Alpha Element Enhancements of Globular Clusters in the Elliptical NGC 5128: A Homogeneous Spectroscopic Study with Gemini/GMOS
- The Growth in Size and Mass of Cluster Galaxies since z=2
- Globular Cluster Systems in Brightest Cluster Galaxies: A Near-Universal Luminosity Function?
- The Globular Cluster System in M87: A Wide-Field Study with CFHT/Megacam
- Obscuration and Origin of Nuclear X-ray emission in FR I Radio Galaxies
- The low-mass Initial Mass Function in the 30 Doradus starburst cluster
- The Massive Star Content of NGC 3603
- Stochastic self-enrichment, pre-enrichment, and the formation of globular clusters
- The Color-Magnitude Relation for Metal-Poor Globular Clusters in M87: Confirmation From Deep HST/ACS Imaging
- Rapid Star Formation and Global Gravitational Collapse
- The Leo Elliptical NGC 3379: A Metal-Poor Halo Emerges
- The Globular Cluster System of NGC 5128 I. Survey and Catalogs
- Gemini/GMOS Imaging of Globular Cluster Systems in Five Early-type Galaxies
- The Next Generation Virgo Cluster Survey (NGVS). XIII. The Luminosity and Mass Function of Galaxies in the Core of the Virgo Cluster and the Contribution from Disrupted Satellites
- The SLUGGS Survey: NGC 3115, A Critical Test Case for Metallicity Bimodality in Globular Cluster Systems
- The SLUGGS Survey: The globular cluster systems of three early-type galaxies using wide-field imaging
- Mass distribution in nearby Abell clusters
- How old are the stars in the halo of NGC 5128 (Centaurus A)?
- Wide-field imaging of NGC 4365's globular cluster system: The third subpopulation revisited
- Mass profiles and galaxy orbits in nearby galaxy clusters from the analysis of the projected phase-space
- The Luminosity Profiles of Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- Infrared and Ultraviolet Star Formation in Brightest Cluster Galaxies in the ACCEPT Sample
- The High-Mass End of the Black Hole Mass Function: Mass Estimates in Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- Globular Cluster Formation Within The Aquarius Simulation
- The Rich Globular Cluster System of Abell 1689 and the Radial Dependence of the Globular Cluster Formation Efficiency
- Globular Clusters in Dense Clusters of Galaxies
- The Globular Cluster Systems in the Coma Ellipticals. IV: WFPC2 Photometry for Five Giant Ellipticals
- On the Metallicity-Color Relations and Bimodal Color Distributions in Extragalactic Globular Cluster Systems
- Globular Cluster Metallicity Subpopulations in NGC 4472
- Detecting Star Formation in Brightest Cluster Galaxies with GALEX
- Growth of brightest cluster galaxies via mergers since z = 1
- The ACS Fornax Cluster Survey. X. Color Gradients of Globular Cluster Systems in Early-Type Galaxies
- An optical/NIR survey of globular clusters in early-type galaxies III. On the colour bimodality of GC systems
- The ACS Fornax Cluster Survey. IX. The Color-Magnitude Relation of Globular Cluster Systems
- Diamonds on the Hat: Globular Clusters in The Sombrero Galaxy (M104)
- The Globular Cluster Systems around NGC 3311 and NGC 3309
- Star Clusters in M31: VII. Global Kinematics and Metallicity Subpopulations of the Globular Clusters
- Bimodal Infrared Colors of the M87 Globular Cluster System: Peaks in the Metallicity Distribution
- A Quantitative Link Between Globular Clusters and the Stellar Halos in Elliptical Galaxies
- Optical and IR Photometry of Globular Clusters in NGC1399: Evidence for Color-Metallicity Nonlinearity
- The SLUGGS Survey: Wide Field Imaging of the Globular Cluster System of NGC 4278
- Globular Cluster Systems in Brightest Cluster Galaxies. II: NGC 6166
- Kinematics of the Hercules Supercluster
- Simulating radiative feedback and star cluster formation in GMCs: I. Dependence on gravitational boundedness
- Washington CCD Photometry of the Globular Cluster System of the Giant Elliptical Galaxy M60 in Virgo
- Nonlinear Color-Metallicity Relations of Globular Clusters. III. On the Discrepancy in Metallicity between Globular Cluster Systems and their Parent Elliptical Galaxies
- Mass Function of Rich Galaxy Clusters and Its Constraint on sigma_8
- Tracing the outer halo in a giant elliptical to 25 Reff
- Spectra of globular clusters in the Sombrero galaxy: evidence for spectroscopic metallicity bimodality
- Extending the baseline: Spitzer Mid-Infrared Photometry of Globular Cluster Systems in the Centaurus A and Sombrero Galaxies
- A new method to measure the mass of galaxy clusters
- The SLUGGS survey: Globular cluster stellar population trends from weak absorption lines in stacked spectra
- Deep HST/ACS Photometry of the M81 Halo
- New g'r'i'z' Photometry of the NGC 5128 Globular Cluster System
- VLT photometry in the Antlia Cluster: the giant ellipticals NGC 3258 and NGC 3268 and their globular cluster systems
- The SLUGGS Survey: Globular cluster system kinematics and substructure in NGC 4365
- Full spectral fitting of Milky Way and M31 globular clusters: ages and metallicities
- Deriving Metallicities From the Integrated Spectra of Extragalactic Globular Clusters Using the Near-Infrared Calcium Triplet
- Nonlinear Color-Metallicity Relations of Globular Clusters. II. A Test on the Nonlinearity Scenario for Color Bimodality Using the u-band Colors: The Case of M87 (NGC 4486)
- The accretion histories of brightest cluster galaxies from their stellar population gradients
- The Globular Cluster System of the Coma cD Galaxy NGC 4874 from Hubble Space Telescope ACS and WFC3/IR Imaging
- Wide-Field Multiband Photometry of Globular Cluster Systems in the Fornax Galaxy Cluster
- Globular Clusters in NGC 4365: New K-band Imaging and a Reassessment of the Case for Intermediate-age Clusters
- The Globular Cluster Systems of Abell 1185
- Globular clusters of NGC 3115 in the near-infrared. Demonstrating the correctness of two opposing scenarios
- The Color Distributions of Globular Clusters in Virgo Elliptical Galaxies
- The SLUGGS Survey: HST/ACS Mosaic Imaging of the NGC 3115 Globular Cluster System
- The SLUGGS survey: Exploring the globular cluster systems of the Leo II group and their global relationships
- Globular Clusters, Ultracompact Dwarfs, and Dwarf Galaxies in Abell 2744 at the Redshift of 0.308
- The extremely populated globular cluster system of the lenticular galaxy NGC 6861
- Simulations of gas sloshing in galaxy cluster Abell 2052
- A Blue Tilt in the Globular Cluster System of the Milky Way-like Galaxy NGC 5170
- Globular cluster systems in elliptical galaxies of Coma
- Globular Clusters and Spur Clusters in NGC 4921, the Brightest Spiral Galaxy in the Coma Cluster
- A Two-Phase Chemical Enrichment Model for the Milky Way Globular Cluster System
- G2C2 II: Integrated colour-metallicity relations for Galactic Globular Clusters in SDSS passbands
- Testing stellar population synthesis models with Sloan Digital Sky Survey colors of M31's globular clusters
- Multicolour-metallicity Relations from Globular Clusters in NGC 4486 (M87)
- Mass and size growth of early-type galaxies by dry mergers in cluster environments
- The colour-magnitude relation of Globular Clusters in Centaurus and Hydra - Constraints on star cluster self-enrichment with a link to massive Milky Way GCs
- Further Definition of the Mass-Metallicity Relation in Globular Cluster Systems Around Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- Serendipitous discovery of a massive cD galaxy at z=1.096: Implications for the early formation and late evolution of cD galaxies
- The Integrated Calcium II Triplet as a Metallicity Indicator: Comparisons with High Resolution [Fe/H] in M31 Globular Clusters
- Nonlinear Color--Metallicity Relations of Globular Clusters. VI. On Calcium II Triplet Based Metallicities of Globular Clusters in Early-type Galaxies
- On the Formation of cD Galaxies and their Parent Clusters
- The old globular cluster system of NGC 4365: new VLT/FORS2 spectra
- The Correlations between the Intrinsic Colors and Spectroscopic Metallicities of M31 Globular Clusters
- Metal Abundance and Kinematical Properties of M81 Globular Cluster System
Cited by in corpus (52)
- The E-MOSAICS Project: simulating the formation and co-evolution of galaxies and their star cluster populations
- The formation and hierarchical assembly of globular cluster populations
- Formation of Globular Cluster Systems: From Dwarf Galaxies to Giants
- Star cluster formation in cosmological simulations. III. Dynamical and chemical evolution
- Origins of scaling relations of globular cluster systems
- VEGAS-SSS II: Comparing the globular cluster systems in NGC3115 and NGC1399 using VEGAS and FDS survey data
- How large are the globular cluster systems of early-type galaxies and do they scale with galaxy halo properties?
- Formation and evolution of young massive clusters in galaxy mergers: the SMUGGLE view
- The difference in metallicity distribution functions of halo stars and globular clusters as a function of galaxy type: A tracer of globular cluster formation and evolution
- The origin of the 'blue tilt' of globular cluster populations in the E-MOSAICS simulations
- Globular cluster systems and galaxy formation
- Where did the globular clusters of the Milky Way form? Insights from the E-MOSAICS simulations
- The Next Generation Virgo Cluster Survey (NGVS) XXXI. The kinematics of intra-cluster globular clusters in the core of the Virgo cluster
- Globular clusters as tracers of the dark matter halo: insights from the E-MOSAICS simulations
- Formation of Globular Cluster Systems II: Impact of the Cutoff of the Cluster Initial Mass Function
- A Photometric Survey of Globular Cluster Systems in Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- Globular cluster numbers in dark matter haloes in a dual formation scenario: an empirical model within EMERGE
- The Hydra I cluster core - II. Kinematic complexity in a rising velocity dispersion profile around the cD galaxy NGC 3311
- The PIPER Survey: I. An Initial Look at the Intergalactic Globular Cluster Population in the Perseus Cluster
- Characterization of the velocity anisotropy of accreted globular clusters
- Detection of Intracluster Globular Clusters in the First JWST Images of the Gravitational Lens Cluster SMACS J0723.3-7327 at z = 0.39
- A wide field map of intracluster globular clusters in Coma
- What Are Those Tiny Things? A First Study of Compact Star Clusters in the SMACS0723 Field with JWST
- New Constraints on Early-Type Galaxy Assembly from Spectroscopic Metallicities of Globular Clusters in M87
- A feather on the hat: Tracing the giant stellar stream around the Sombrero galaxy
- Dissolved Massive Metal-Rich Globular Clusters Can Cause the Range of UV Upturn Strengths Found among Early-type Galaxies
- Nonlinear Color-Metallicity Relations of Globular Clusters. VIII. Reproducing Color Distributions of Individual Globular Cluster Systems in the Virgo and Fornax Galaxy Clusters
- The SLUGGS Survey: The Inner Dark Matter Density Slope of the Massive Elliptical Galaxy NGC 1407
- Scaling relations for globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies. II. Is there an environmental dependence?
- Tracing the Assembly History of NGC 1395 through its Globular Cluster System
- Globular cluster metallicity distributions in the E-MOSAICS simulations
- The influence of globular cluster evolution on the specific frequency in dwarf galaxies
- Globular Cluster Systems of Massive Compact Elliptical Galaxies in the Local Universe: Evidence for Relic Red Nuggets?
- Globular Clusters in the Outer Halo of M31
- The globular cluster system of the nearest Seyfert II galaxy Circinus
- Early-type galaxies in low-density environments: NGC 6876 explored through its globular cluster system
- Wide-field study of the peculiar globular cluster system hosted by the field lenticular NGC 1172
- Supra-galactic Colour Patterns in Globular Cluster Systems
- Evaluating the feasibility of interpretable machine learning for globular cluster detection
- Star Clusters in the Elliptical Galaxy NGC 4589 Hosting a Calcium-rich SN Ib (SN 2005CZ)
- A Supra-galactic Conundrum: The Globular Clusters Colour Pattern in Virgo Galaxies
- Searching for globular clusters in the inner halo of the Circinus galaxy
- Globular Cluster Systems and X-Ray Atmospheres in Galaxies
- Possible Gravitational Microlensing Events in the Optical Lightcurve of Active Galaxy S5 0716+714
- Nonlinear Color-Metallicity Relations of Globular Clusters. IX. Different Radial Number Density Profiles between Blue and Red Clusters
- Total mass slopes and enclosed mass constrained by globular cluster system dynamics
- The Color Gradients of the Globular Cluster Systems in M87 and M49
- Nonlinear Color-Metallicity Relations of Globular Clusters. X. Subaru/FOCAS Multi-object Spectroscopy of M87 Globular Clusters
- Globular cluster population of the HST frontier fields galaxy J07173724+3744224
- Reconstructing the mass accretion histories of nearby Red Nuggets with their globular cluster systems
- Massive Star Clusters in the Semi-Analytical Galaxy Formation Model L-Galaxies 2020
- Evidence for Environmental Stripping in the Coma Cluster