Lens Models Under the Microscope: Comparison of Hubble Frontier Field Cluster Magnification Maps

Abstract

Using the power of gravitational lensing magnification by massive galaxy clusters, the Hubble Frontier Fields provide deep views of six patches of the high redshift Universe. The combination of deep Hubble imaging and exceptional lensing strength has revealed the greatest numbers of multiply-imaged galaxies available to constrain models of cluster mass distributions. However, even with $\mathcal{O}(100)$ images per cluster, the uncertainties associated with the reconstructions are not negligible. The goal of this paper is to show the diversity of model magnification predictions. We examine 7 and 9 mass models of Abell 2744 and MACS J0416, respectively, submitted to the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes for public distribution in September 2015. The dispersion between model predictions increases from 30% at common low magnifications ($\mu \sim 2$) to 70% at rare high magnifications ($\mu \sim 40$). MACS J0416 exhibits smaller dispersions than Abell 2744 for $2<\mu <10$. We show that magnification maps based on different lens inversion techniques typically differ from each other by more than their quoted statistical errors. This suggests that some models underestimate the true uncertainties, which are primarily due to various lensing degeneracies. Though the exact mass sheet degeneracy is broken, its generalized counterpart is not broken at least in Abell 2744. Other, local degeneracies are also present in both clusters. Our comparison of models is complementary to the comparison of reconstructions of known synthetic mass distributions. By focusing on observed clusters, we can identify those that are best constrained, and therefore provide the clearest view of the distant Universe.

17 pages, 18 figures, MNRAS, in press

References in corpus (18)

• A Bayesian approach to strong lensing modelling of galaxy clusters
• Multiple Images of a Highly Magnified Supernova Formed by an Early-Type Cluster Galaxy Lens
• Mass and magnification maps for the Hubble Space Telescope Frontier Fields clusters: implications for high redshift studies
• Multi-scale cluster lens mass mapping I. Strong Lensing modelling
• Lens models and magnification maps of the six Hubble Frontier Fields clusters
• Rest-Frame Optical Spectra of Three Strongly Lensed Galaxies at z~2
• Hubble Frontier Fields First Complete Cluster Data: Faint Galaxies at $z\sim 5-10$ for UV Luminosity Functions and Cosmic Reionization
• New redshift z ~ 9 galaxies in the Hubble Frontier Fields: Implications for early evolution of the UV luminosity density
• Hubble Frontier Fields : A High Precision Strong Lensing Analysis of Galaxy Cluster MACSJ0416.1-2403 using ~200 Multiple Images
• Frontier Fields: High-Redshift Predictions and Early Results
• The sizes of $z\sim 6-8$ lensed galaxies from the Hubble Frontier Fields Abell 2744 data
• Resolved Spectroscopy of a Gravitationally Lensed L* Lyman-break Galaxy at z~5
• Hubble Frontier Fields: The Geometry and Dynamics of the Massive Galaxy Cluster Merger MACSJ0416.1-2403
• Free Form Lensing Implications for the Collision of Dark Matter and Gas in the Frontier Fields Cluster MACSJ0416.1-2403
• Non-parametric inversion of gravitational lensing systems with few images using a multi-objective genetic algorithm
• Young Galaxy Candidates in the Hubble Frontier Fields - III. MACSJ0717.5+3745
• A Rigorous Free-form Lens Model of Abell 2744 to Meet the Hubble Frontier Fields Challenge
• A generalisation of the mass-sheet degeneracy producing ring-like artefacts in the lens mass distribution

Cited by in corpus (60)

• The z~6 Luminosity Function Fainter than -15 mag from the Hubble Frontier Fields: The Impact of Magnification Uncertainties
• The Star Formation Main Sequence in the Hubble Space Telescope Frontier Fields
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST - I. UV luminosity functions at z = 4 - 10
• Strong lensing analysis of Abell 2744 with MUSE and Hubble Frontier Fields images
• Size--luminosity relations and UV luminosity functions at $z=6-9$ simultaneously derived from the complete Hubble Frontier Fields data
• High redshift JWST predictions from IllustrisTNG: Dust modelling and galaxy luminosity functions
• Intracluster light: a luminous tracer for dark matter in clusters of galaxies
• A refined mass distribution of the cluster MACS J0416.1$-$2403 from a new large set of spectroscopic multiply lensed sources
• Dark matter under the microscope: Constraining compact dark matter with caustic crossing events
• UNCOVERing the extended strong lensing structures of Abell 2744 with the deepest JWST imaging
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST -- IV. Implications for cosmic reionization and LyC escape fraction
• The ALMA Frontier Fields survey I: 1.1 mm continuum detections in Abell 2744, MACSJ0416.1-2403 and MACSJ1149.5+2223
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: Deep 1.2 mm continuum number counts
• Strong Lens Models for 37 Clusters of Galaxies from the SDSS Giant Arcs Survey
• Early Low-Mass Galaxies and Star-Cluster Candidates at z~6-9 Identified by the Gravitational Lensing Technique and Deep Optical/Near-Infrared Imaging
• The GLASS-JWST Early Release Science Program. III. Strong lensing model of Abell 2744 and its infalling regions
• Resolving Quiescent Galaxies at $z\gtrsim 2$: I. Search for Gravitationally Lensed Sources and Characterization of their Structure, Stellar Populations, and Line Emission
• Sizes of Lensed Lower-luminosity z=4-8 Galaxies from the Hubble Frontier Field Program
• A free-form lensing model of A370 revealing stellar mass dominated BCGs, in Hubble Frontier Fields images
• The Ionizing Photon Production Efficiency (${\xi }_{ion}$) Of Lensed Dwarf Galaxies At $z\sim 2$
• On the faint-end of the galaxy luminosity function in the Epoch of Reionization: updated constraints from the HST Frontier Fields
• Faint end of the $z\sim 3-7$ luminosity function of Lyman-alpha emitters behind lensing clusters observed with MUSE
• Very low-luminosity galaxies in the early universe have observed sizes similar to single star cluster complexes
• An Evaluation of 10 Lensing Models of the Frontier Fields Cluster MACSJ0416.1-2403
• The Cosmic Telescope that Lenses the Sunburst Arc, PSZ1 G311.65-18.48: Strong Gravitational Lensing model and Source Plane Analysis
• RELICS: Strong-lensing analysis of the massive clusters MACS J0308.9+2645 and PLCK G171.9-40.7
• The role of multiple images and model priors in measuring $H_0$ from supernova Refsdal in galaxy cluster MACS J1149.5+2223
• A versatile tool for cluster lensing source reconstruction. I. methodology and illustration on sources in the Hubble Frontier Field Cluster MACS J0717.5+3745
• Evidence for the line of sight structure in the largest Hubble Frontier Field cluster, MACSJ0717.5+3745
• The size-luminosity relation of lensed galaxies at $z=6-9$ in the Hubble Frontier Fields
• Systematic vs. Statistical Uncertainties in Masses and Magnifications of the Hubble Frontier Fields
• Blind millimeter line emitter search using ALMA data toward gravitational lensing clusters
• The ALMA Frontier Fields Survey - IV. Lensing-corrected 1.1 mm number counts in Abell 2744, MACSJ0416.1-2403 and MACSJ1149.5+2223
• Sparse Lens Inversion Technique (SLIT): lens and source separability from linear inversion of the source reconstruction problem
• Free-form Grale lens inversion of galaxy clusters with up to 1000 multiple images
• The 300 pc resolution imaging of a z = 8.31 galaxy: Turbulent ionized gas and potential stellar feedback 600 million years after the Big Bang
• Free-form Grale reconstruction of Abell 2744: robustness of uncertainties against changes in lensing data
• Mass Modeling of Frontier Fields Cluster MACS J1149.5+2223 Using Strong and Weak Lensing
• Exploring Effects on Magnifications due to Line-of-Sight Galaxies in the Hubble Frontier Fields
• Statistical Microlensing Toward Magnified High-Redshift Star Clusters
• Further support for a trio of mass-to-light deviations in Abell 370: free-form Grale lens inversion using BUFFALO strong lensing data
• CANUCS: Constraining the MACS J0416.1-2403 Strong Lensing Model with JWST NIRISS, NIRSpec and NIRCam
• Probing the faint end Luminosity Function of Lyman Alpha Emitters at 3<z<7 behind 17 MUSE lensing clusters
• New metrics to probe the dynamical state of galaxy clusters
• Improving parametric mass modelling of lensing clusters through a perturbative approach
• A Submillimeter Survey of Faint Galaxies Behind Ten Strong Lensing Clusters
• Efficient Mass Estimate at the Core of Strong Lensing Galaxy Clusters Using the Einstein Radius
• An excursion into the core of the cluster lens Abell 1689
• Core Mass Estimates in Strong Lensing Galaxy Clusters Using a Single-Halo Lens Model
• Gravity.jl: fast and accurate gravitational lens modeling in Julia
• relensing: Reconstructing the mass profile of galaxy clusters from gravitational lensing
• Flashlights: Prospects for constraining the Initial Mass Function around cosmic noon with caustic-crossing events
• Cluster Strong Lensing with Hierarchical Inference
• Exotic Image Formation in Strong Gravitational Lensing by Clusters of Galaxies. I: Cross-Section
• What Multiple Images Say About the Large-Scale Mass Maps of Galaxy Clusters
• Neutral hydrogen lensing simulations in the Hubble Frontier Fields
• Exotic Image Formation in Strong Gravitational Lensing by Clusters of Galaxies -- II: Uncertainties
• Exotic Image Formation in Strong Gravitational Lensing by Clusters of Galaxies -- III: Statistics with HUDF
• Core Mass Estimates in Strong Lensing Galaxy Clusters: a Comparison Between Masses Obtained from Detailed Lens Models, Single-Halo Lens Models, and Einstein Radii
• The BUFFALO HST Survey