The role of multiple images and model priors in measuring $H_0$ from supernova Refsdal in galaxy cluster MACS J1149.5+2223

Abstract

Multiple image gravitational lensing systems with measured time delays provide a promising one-step method for determining $H_0$. MACS J1149, which lenses SN Refsdal into a quad S1-S4, and two other widely separated images, SX and SY, is a perfect candidate. If time delays are pinned down, the remaining uncertainty arises from the mass distribution in the lens. In MACS J1149, the mass in the relevant lens plane region can be constrained by (i) many multiple images, (ii) the mass of the galaxy splitting S1-S4 (which, we show, is correlated with $H_0$), (iii) magnification of SX (also correlated with $H_0$), and (iv) prior assumptions on the mass distribution. Our goal is not to estimate $H_0$, but to understand its error budget, i.e., estimate uncertainties associated with each of these constraints. Using multiple image positions alone, yields very large uncertainty, despite the fact that the position of SX is recovered to within $\le 0.036$" (rms $\le 0.36$") by GRALE lens inversion. Fixing the mass of the galaxy that splits S1-S4 reduces $1\sigma$ uncertainties to $\sim 23\%$, while fixing the magnification of SX yields $1\sigma$ uncertainties of $32\%$. We conclude that smaller uncertainties, of order few percent, are a consequence of imposing prior assumptions on the shapes of the galaxy and cluster mass distributions, which may or may not apply in a highly non-equilibrium environment of a merging cluster. We propose that if a measurement of $H_0$ is to be considered reliable, it must be supported by a wide range of lens inversion methods.

14 pages, 11 figures, accepted to MNRAS

References in corpus (21)

• A Bayesian approach to strong lensing modelling of galaxy clusters
• Multiple Images of a Highly Magnified Supernova Formed by an Early-Type Cluster Galaxy Lens
• A complete sample of twelve very X-ray luminous galaxy clusters at z>0.5
• Hubble Space Telescope Combined Strong and Weak Lensing Analysis of the CLASH Sample: Mass and Magnification Models and Systematic Uncertainties
• COSMOGRAIL XVI: Time delays for the quadruply imaged quasar DES J0408-5354 with high-cadence photometric monitoring
• Measuring the value of the Hubble constant "à la Refsdal"
• The systematics of strong lens modeling quantified: the effects of constraint selection and redshift information on magnification, mass, and multiple image predictability
• Discovery of the largest known lensed images formed by a critically convergent lensing cluster
• The Grism Lens-Amplified Survey from Space (GLASS) X. Sub-kpc resolution gas-phase metallicity maps at cosmic noon behind the Hubble Frontier Fields cluster MACS1149.6+2223
• Isophotal Shapes of Elliptical/S0 Galaxies from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• COSMOGRAIL XVII: Time delays for the quadruply imaged quasar PG 1115+080
• Revised Lens Model for the Multiply-Imaged Lensed Supernova, "SN Refsdal", in MACS J1149+2223
• Non-parametric inversion of gravitational lensing systems with few images using a multi-objective genetic algorithm
• The Hubble constant from SN Refsdal
• Predicted properties of multiple images of the strongly lensed supernova SN Refsdal
• Ultra-deep Ks-band Imaging of the Hubble Frontier Fields
• Non-parametric strong lens inversion of Cl~0024+1654: illustrating the monopole degeneracy
• A generalisation of the mass-sheet degeneracy producing ring-like artefacts in the lens mass distribution
• MC${}^2$: Dynamical Analysis of the Merging Galaxy Cluster MACS J1149.5+2223
• Evidence for the line of sight structure in the largest Hubble Frontier Field cluster, MACSJ0717.5+3745
• Isophote Shapes of Early-Type Galaxies in Massive Clusters at $z\sim 1$ and 0

Cited by in corpus (20)

• Strong gravitational lensing of explosive transients
• Constraints on the Hubble constant from Supernova Refsdal's reappearance
• On the accuracy of time-delay cosmography in the Frontier Fields Cluster MACS J1149.5+2223 with supernova Refsdal
• Strongly Lensed Transient Sources: A Review
• Free-form Grale lens inversion of galaxy clusters with up to 1000 multiple images
• Generalised model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lenses VI: the origin of the formalism intrinsic degeneracies and their influence on $H_0$
• A model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lensing by observables
• Galaxy-lens determination of $H_0$: constraining density slope in the context of the mass sheet degeneracy
• Free-form Grale reconstruction of Abell 2744: robustness of uncertainties against changes in lensing data
• Generalised model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lenses V: reconstructing the lensing distance ratio by supernovae for a general Friedmann universe
• Further support for a trio of mass-to-light deviations in Abell 370: free-form Grale lens inversion using BUFFALO strong lensing data
• Extended lens reconstructions with Grale: exploiting time domain, substructural and weak-lensing information
• Model-Independent Mass Reconstruction of the Hubble Frontier Field Clusters with MARS Based on Self-Consistent Strong Lensing Data
• Lessons from the first multiply imaged supernova II: A parametric strong-lensing model for the galaxy cluster MACS J1149.5+2223
• Model-independent and model-based local lensing properties of B0128+437 from resolved quasar images
• An excursion into the core of the cluster lens Abell 1689
• The Observable Supernova Rate in Galaxy-Galaxy Lensing Systems with the TESS Satellite
• BUFFALO Wild Wings: A High Precision Free-Form Lens Model of MACSJ0416 with Constraints on Dark Matter from Substructure and Highly Magnified Arcs
• MrMARTIAN: A Multi-resolution Mass Reconstruction Algorithm Combining Free-form and Analytic Components
• The BUFFALO HST Survey