Quantifying Observational Projection Effects Using Molecular Cloud Simulations
arXiv:1310.1929 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/777/2/173
Abstract
The physical properties of molecular clouds are often measured using spectral-line observations, which provide the only probes of the clouds' velocity structure. It is hard, though, to assess whether and to what extent intensity features in position-position-velocity (PPV) space correspond to "real" density structures in position-position-position (PPP) space. In this paper, we create synthetic molecular cloud spectral-line maps of simulated molecular clouds, and present a new technique for measuring the reality of individual PPV structures. Our procedure projects density structures identified in PPP space into corresponding intensity structures in PPV space and then measures the geometric overlap of the projected structures with structures identified from the synthetic observation. The fractional overlap between a PPP and PPV structure quantifies how well the synthetic observation recovers information about the 3D structure. Applying this machinery to a set of synthetic observations of CO isotopes, we measure how well spectral-line measurements recover mass, size, velocity dispersion, and virial parameter for a simulated star-forming region. By disabling various steps of our analysis, we investigate how much opacity, chemistry, and gravity affect measurements of physical properties extracted from PPV cubes. For the simulations used here, our results suggest that superposition induces a ~40% uncertainty in masses, sizes, and velocity dispersions derived from 13CO. The virial parameter is most affected by superposition, such that estimates of the virial parameter derived from PPV and PPP information typically disagree by a factor of ~2. This uncertainty makes it particularly difficult to judge whether gravitational or kinetic energy dominate a given region, since the majority of virial parameter measurements fall within a factor of 2 of the equipartition level alpha ~ 2.
arXiv comment25 pages, 22 figures, ApJ in press
References in corpus (38)
- Theory of Star Formation
- Density, Velocity, and Magnetic Field Structure in Turbulent Molecular Cloud Models
- Structural Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Dendrograms
- The Resolved Properties of Extragalactic Giant Molecular Clouds
- Probing the evolution of molecular cloud structure: From quiescence to birth
- Velocity Modification of HI Power Spectrum
- Simulating Radiating and Magnetized Flows in Multi-Dimensions with ZEUS-MP
- CO Isotopologues in the Perseus Molecular Cloud Complex: the X-Factor and Regional Variations
- The COMPLETE Survey of Star-Forming Regions: Phase I Data
- What determines the density structure of molecular clouds ? A case study of Orion B with Herschel
- Embedding Lagrangian Sink Particles in Eulerian Grids
- The "True" Column Density Distribution in Star-Forming Molecular Clouds
- Modeling CO Emission: I. CO as a Column Density Tracer and the X-Factor in Molecular Clouds
- Physical vs. Observational Properties of Clouds in Turbulent Molecular Cloud Models
- Modelling CO formation in the turbulent interstellar medium
- Modeling CO Emission: II. The Physical Characteristics that Determine the X factor in Galactic Molecular Clouds
- Velocity Modification of Power Spectrum from Absorbing Medium
- NICEST, a near-infrared color excess method tailored for small-scale structures
- The Perils of Clumpfind: The Mass Spectrum of Sub-structures in Molecular Clouds
- Molecular line intensities as measures of cloud masses - I. Sensitivity of CO emissions to physical parameter variations
- Six Myths on the Virial Theorem for Interstellar Clouds
- Analysis of Clumps in Molecular Cloud Models: Mass Spectrum, Shapes, Alignment and Rotation
- Studying Turbulence using Doppler-broadened lines: Velocity Coordinate Spectrum
- Dust SEDs in the era of Herschel and Planck: a Hierarchical Bayesian fitting technique
- A Bubbling Nearby Molecular Cloud: COMPLETE Shells in Perseus
- The Virial Balance of Clumps and Cores in Molecular Clouds
- Spectral Properties of Compressible Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence from Numerical Simulations
- Driven and Decaying Turbulence Simulations of Low-Mass Star Formation: From Clumps to Cores to Protostars
- Approximations for modelling CO chemistry in GMCs: a comparison of approaches
- The Effect of Projection on Derived Mass-Size and Linewidth-Size Relationships
- Hierarchical Structure of Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence In Position-Position-Velocity Space
- The Intrinsic Shapes of Molecular Cloud Fragments over a Range of Length Scales
- On the Effects of Projection on Morphology
- Modeling the Atomic-to-Molecular Transition and Chemical Distributions of Turbulent Star-Forming Clouds
- Principal Component Analysis of Spectral Line Data: Analytic Formulation
- The Shapes of Molecular Cloud Cores in Simulations and Observations
- The JCMT Legacy Survey of the Gould Belt: a first look at Taurus with HARP
- A Guide to Comparisons of Star Formation Simulations with Observations
Cited by in corpus (75)
- An ALMA study of the Orion Integral Filament: I. Evidence for narrow fibers in a massive cloud
- Molecular gas kinematics within the central 250 pc of the Milky Way
- A Uniform Catalog of Molecular Clouds in the Milky Way
- Mapping Distances Across the Perseus Molecular Cloud Using CO Observations, Stellar Photometry, and Gaia DR2 Parallax Measurements
- 'The Brick' is not a brick: A comprehensive study of the structure and dynamics of the Central Molecular Zone cloud G0.253+0.016
- Resolving the fragmentation of high line-mass filaments with ALMA: the integral shaped filament in Orion A
- Gravitational contraction versus Supernova driving and the origin of the velocity dispersion-size relation in molecular clouds
- On the Three-Dimensional Structure of Local Molecular Clouds
- Opacity broadening and interpretation of suprathermal CO linewidths: Macroscopic Turbulence and Tangled Molecular Clouds
- The Green Bank Ammonia Survey: Dense Cores Under Pressure in Orion A
- An Alternative Accurate Tracer of Molecular Clouds: The "-Factor"
- The CO/CO ratio in turbulent molecular clouds
- What can simulated molecular clouds tell us about real molecular clouds?
- The Physical Nature of Neutral Hydrogen Intensity Structure
- Investigating the structure and fragmentation of a highly filamentary IRDC
- Droplets I: Pressure-Dominated Sub-0.1 pc Coherent Structures in L1688 and B18
- Filaments in the Taurus Molecular Cloud
- Zooming in on Individual Star Formation: Low- and High-mass Stars
- Larson's scaling laws, and the gravitational instability of clumpy discs at high redshift
- Velocity-coherent Filaments in NGC 1333: Evidence for Accretion Flow?
- Histogram of oriented gradients: a technique for the study of molecular cloud formation
- The Onset of Massive Star Formation: The Evolution of Temperature and Density Structure in an Infrared Dark Cloud
- The Anatomy of the Column Density Probability Distribution Function (N-PDF)
- The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor across the Perseus Molecular Cloud
- The dense gas mass fraction in the W51 cloud and its protoclusters
- Does the CO-to-H2 conversion factor depend on the star formation rate?
- Impact of Winds from Intermediate-Mass Stars on Molecular Cloud Structure and Turbulence
- CARMA Large Area Star Formation Survey: Project Overview with Analysis of Dense Gas Structure and Kinematics in Barnard 1
- How well does CO emission measure the H mass of MCs?
- Interpreting the sub-linear Kennicutt-Schmidt relationship: The case for diffuse molecular gas
- Turbulence, Coherence and Collapse: Three Phases for Core Evolution
- Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
- The history of dynamics and stellar feedback revealed by the HI filamentary structure in the disk of the Milky Way
- TurbuStat: Turbulence Statistics in Python
- Multi-scale dynamics in star-forming regions: the interplay between gravity and turbulence
- Relations Between Molecular Cloud Structure Sizes and Line Widths in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- Filaments and striations: anisotropies in observed, supersonic, highly-magnetised turbulent clouds
- Simulations of the star-forming molecular gas in an interacting M51-like galaxy: cloud population statistics
- Recovering interstellar gas properties with HI spectral lines: A comparison between synthetic spectra and 21-SPONGE
- The effect of photoionising feedback on star formation in isolated and colliding clouds
- What is a GMC? Are Observers and Simulators Discussing the Same Star-forming Clouds?
- A new approach to determine optically thick H2 cooling and its effect on primordial star formation
- Are massive dense clumps truly sub-virial? A new analysis using Gould Belt ammonia data
- Maps of the number of HI clouds along the line of sight at high galactic latitude
- The Core Mass Function in the Orion Nebula Cluster Region: What Determines the Final Stellar Masses?
- The highly variable time evolution of star-forming cores identified with dendrograms
- The relation between the true and observed fractal dimensions of turbulent clouds
- Relative Alignment between Dense Molecular Cores and Ambient Magnetic Field: The Synergy of Numerical Models and Observations
- An Exploration of the Statistical Signatures of Stellar Feedback
- Molecular gas and star formation in nearby starburst galaxy mergers
- A Parsec-Scale Catalog of Molecular Clouds in the Solar Neighborhood Based on 3D Dust Mapping: Implications for the Mass-Size Relation
- Probing the multi-scale interplay between gravity and turbulence - Power-law like gravitational energy spectra of the Orion Complex
- G-virial: Gravity-based structure analysis of molecular clouds
- Spatially associated clump populations in Rosette from CO and dust maps
- Kinetic tomography of the Galactic plane within 1.25 kiloparsecs from the Sun. The interstellar flows revealed by HI and CO line emission and 3D dust
- Effects of Galactic Disc Inclination and Resolution on Observed GMC Properties and Larson's Scaling Relations
- The filamentary structures in the CO emission toward the Milky Way disk
- Collision between Molecular Clouds I. The effect of the cloud virial ratio in head-on collisions
- Connecting the Cosmic Star Formation Rate with the Local Star Formation
- Assessing the Impact of Astrochemistry on Molecular Cloud Turbulence Statistics
- The Kinematic Structure of Magnetically Aligned HI Filaments
- Effects of stellar feedback on cores in STARFORGE
- Neutral hydrogen filaments in interstellar media: Are they physical?
- The CO core mass function toward Orion A: Single-dish observations
- Predictions for Observing Protostellar Outflows with ALMA
- Dynamical Properties of Molecular-forming Gas Clumps in Galaxies at the Epoch of Reionization
- Cold molecular gas in the hot nuclear wind of the Milky Way
- A deep-learning approach to the 3D reconstruction of dust density and temperature in star-forming regions
- Northern Galactic Molecular Cloud Clumps in Hi-GAL: Clump and Star Formation within Clouds
- The Hierarchical Dynamical State of Molecular Gas from 3 to 300 pc in NGC 253
- Investigations of MWISP Filaments. I. Filament Identification and Analysis Algorithms, and Source Catalogue
- Which Molecular Cloud Structures Are Bound?
- Diagnosing Turbulence in the Neutral and Molecular Interstellar Medium of Galaxies
- The Dynamical State of Massive Clumps
- Modeling turbulent and self-gravitating fluids with Fourier neural operators