A Guide to Comparisons of Star Formation Simulations with Observations

Abstract

We review an approach to observation-theory comparisons we call "Taste-Testing." In this approach, synthetic observations are made of numerical simulations, and then both real and synthetic observations are "tasted" (compared) using a variety of statistical tests. We first lay out arguments for bringing theory to observational space rather than observations to theory space. Next, we explain that generating synthetic observations is only a step along the way to the quantitative, statistical, taste tests that offer the most insight. We offer a set of examples focused on polarimetry, scattering and emission by dust, and spectral-line mapping in starforming regions. We conclude with a discussion of the connection between statistical tests used to date and the physics we seek to understand. In particular, we suggest that the "lognormal" nature of molecular clouds can be created by the interaction of many random processes, as can the lognormal nature of the IMF, so that the fact that both the "Clump Mass Function" (CMF) and IMF appear lognormal does not necessarily imply a direct relationship between them.

arXiv commentastro-ph version added upon publication in proceedings of IAU270; 2011IAUS..270..511G

References in corpus (32)

• Density, Velocity, and Magnetic Field Structure in Turbulent Molecular Cloud Models
• Structural Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Dendrograms
• The mass function of dense molecular cores and the origin of the IMF
• Probing the evolution of molecular cloud structure: From quiescence to birth
• A Theory of the IMF for Star Formation in Molecular Clouds
• The "True" Column Density Distribution in Star-Forming Molecular Clouds
• Inverse temperature dependence of the dust submillimeter spectral index
• Physical vs. Observational Properties of Clouds in Turbulent Molecular Cloud Models
• Theoretical Models of Polarized Dust Emission from Protostellar Cores
• The Efficiency of Grain Alignment in Dense Interstellar Clouds: A Reassessment of Constraints from Near Infrared Polarization
• Turbulent Driving Scales in Molecular Clouds
• The Effect of Noise on the Dust Temperature - Spectral Index Correlation
• The Perils of Clumpfind: The Mass Spectrum of Sub-structures in Molecular Clouds
• Dynamical HII Region Evolution in Turbulent Molecular Clouds
• Direct evidence of dust growth in L183 from MIR light scattering
• On the efficiency of grain alignment in dark clouds
• The Virial Balance of Clumps and Cores in Molecular Clouds
• The Power Spectrum of Supersonic Turbulence in Perseus
• Obtaining Spectra of Turbulent Velocity from Observations
• Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Molecular Clouds II. The Depolarization Effect in the OMC-3 Filament of Orion A
• Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Molecular Clouds. V. Submillimeter Polarization of the Barnard 1 Dark Cloud
• Molecular Line Emission from Massive Protostellar Disks: Predictions for ALMA and the EVLA
• Cloudshine: New Light on Dark Clouds
• Super-Sonic Turbulence in the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• The structure of molecular clouds and the universality of the clump mass function
• The Kinematics of Molecular Cloud Cores in the Presence of Driven and Decaying Turbulence: Comparisons with Observations
• Molecular and Atomic Gas in the Large Magellanic Cloud - I. Conditions for CO Detection
• On the Evolution of the Dense Core Mass Function
• The Spectral Correlation Function of Molecular Clouds: A Statistical Test for Theoretical Models
• High Resolution Mapping of Interstellar Clouds by Near--IR Scattering
• On the relative motions of dense cores and envelopes in star-forming molecular clouds
• The Interplay of Turbulence & Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Regions: Simulations and Observations

Cited by in corpus (3)

• Quantifying Observational Projection Effects Using Molecular Cloud Simulations
• Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
• Topological signatures of interstellar magnetic fields - I. Betti numbers and persistence diagrams