The Perils of Clumpfind: The Mass Spectrum of Sub-structures in Molecular Clouds

Abstract

We study the mass spectrum of sub-structures in the Perseus Molecular Cloud Complex traced by 13CO (1-0), finding that $dN/dM\propto M^{-2.4}$ for the standard Clumpfind parameters. This result does not agree with the classical $dN/dM\propto M^{-1.6}$. To understand this discrepancy we study the robustness of the mass spectrum derived using the Clumpfind algorithm. Both 2D and 3D Clumpfind versions are tested, using 850 $\mu$m dust emission and 13CO spectral-line observations of Perseus, respectively. The effect of varying threshold is not important, but varying stepsize produces a different effect for 2D and 3D cases. In the 2D case, where emission is relatively isolated (associated with only the densest peaks in the cloud), the mass spectrum variability is negligible compared to the mass function fit uncertainties. In the 3D case, however, where the 13CO emission traces the bulk of the molecular cloud, the number of clumps and the derived mass spectrum are highly correlated with the stepsize used. The distinction between "2D" and "3D" here is more importantly also a distinction between "sparse" and "crowded" emission. In any "crowded" case, Clumpfind should not be used blindly to derive mass functions. Clumpfind's output in the "crowded" case can still offer a statistical description of emission useful in inter-comparisons, but the clump-list should not be treated as a robust region decomposition suitable to generate a physically-meaningful mass function. We conclude that the 13CO mass spectrum depends on the observations resolution, due to the hierarchical structure of MC.

arXiv comment5 pages, 3 figures. Accepted for publication in ApJ Letters

References in corpus (21)

• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• Structural Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Dendrograms
• The mass function of dense molecular cores and the origin of the IMF
• Bolocam Survey for 1.1 mm Dust Continuum Emission in the c2d Legacy Clouds. I. Perseus
• CO Isotopologues in the Perseus Molecular Cloud Complex: the X-Factor and Regional Variations
• The COMPLETE Survey of Star-Forming Regions: Phase I Data
• Bolocam Survey for 1.1 mm Dust Continuum Emission in the c2d Legacy Clouds. II. Ophiuchus
• 2MASS wide field extinction maps - I. The Pipe nebula
• The Large and Small Scale Structures of Dust in the Star-Forming Perseus Molecular Cloud
• The Mass Spectra of Giant Molecular Clouds in the Local Group
• An Extinction Threshold for Protostellar Cores in Ophiuchus
• Molecular clouds and clumps in the Boston University-Five College Radio Astronomy Observatory Galactic Ring Survey
• High Mass Star Formation I: The Mass Distribution of Submillimeter Clumps in NGC 7538
• Modeling the Near-Infrared Luminosity Functions of Young Stellar Clusters
• A Large Scale Survey of NGC1333
• The structure of molecular clouds and the universality of the clump mass function
• High Mass Star Formation. II. The Mass Function of Submillimeter Clumps in M17
• High Mass Star Formation. III. The Functional Form of the Submillimeter Clump Mass Function
• Massive Clumps in the NGC 6334 Star Forming Region
• Massive Quiescent Cores in Orion. -- II. Core Mass Function
• On the fidelity of the core mass functions derived from dust column density data

Cited by in corpus (91)

• The Structure of the Interstellar Medium of Star Forming Galaxies
• Cloud-Scale Molecular Gas Properties in 15 Nearby Galaxies
• A Uniform Catalog of Molecular Clouds in the Milky Way
• The Exciting Lives of Giant Molecular Clouds
• Giant Molecular Cloud Catalogues for PHANGS-ALMA: Methods and Initial Results
• FellWalker - a Clump Identification Algorithm
• G0.253+0.016: a molecular cloud progenitor of an Arches-like cluster
• First results from the Herschel Gould Belt Survey in Taurus
• Molecular Cloud Populations in the Context of Their Host Galaxy Environments: A Multiwavelength Perspective
• Quantifying Observational Projection Effects Using Molecular Cloud Simulations
• Graph-based interpretation of the Molecular Interstellar Medium Segmentation
• Dense core formation in supersonic turbulent converging flows
• An Excursion-Set Model for the Structure of GMCs and the ISM
• ALMA Resolves 30 Doradus: Sub-parsec Molecular Cloud Structure Near the Closest Super-Star Cluster
• Probing the evolution of molecular cloud structure II: From chaos to confinement
• Feedback Effects on Low-Mass Star Formation
• The Mass-Size Relation from Clouds to Cores. I. A new Probe of Structure in Molecular Clouds
• Accuracy of core mass estimates in simulated observations of dust emission
• Search for starless clumps in the ATLASGAL survey
• The Green Bank Ammonia Survey: Dense Cores Under Pressure in Orion A
• The integrated properties of the molecular clouds from the JCMT CO(3-2) High Resolution Survey
• Star formation in the Taurus filament L1495: From Dense Cores to Stars
• The Effect of Projection on Derived Mass-Size and Linewidth-Size Relationships
• The Angular Momentum of Magnetized Molecular Cloud Cores: A 2D-3D Comparison
• Filament Fragmentation in High-Mass Star Formation
• Dense core properties in the Infrared Dark cloud G14.225-0.506 revealed by ALMA
• MUSCLE W49 : A Multi-Scale Continuum and Line Exploration of the Most Luminous Star Formation Region in the Milky Way. I. Data and The Mass Structure of the Giant Molecular Cloud
• Two Populations of Molecular Clouds in the Antennae Galaxies
• The SILCC project - V. The impact of magnetic fields on the chemistry and the formation of molecular clouds
• A statistical study of the mass and density structure of Infrared Dark Clouds
• Investigating the structure and fragmentation of a highly filamentary IRDC
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: A Quantitative Comparison Between SCUBA-2 Data Reduction Methods
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: A First Look at Southern Orion A with SCUBA-2
• Cloud Structure of Galactic OB Cluster Forming Regions from Combining Ground and Space Based Bolometric Observations
• The Core Mass Function in the Massive Protocluster G286.21+0.17 revealed by ALMA
• Physical Properties of Dense Cores in the Rho Ophiuchi Main Cloud and A Significant Role of External Pressures in Clustered Star Formation
• The fractal dimension of star-forming regions at different spatial scales in M33
• The Dynamics of Dense Cores in the Perseus Molecular Cloud II: The Relationship Between Dense Cores and the Cloud
• Mapping the core mass function to the initial mass function
• The observable prestellar phase of the IMF
• Numerical and semi-analytic core mass distributions in supersonic isothermal turbulence
• ALMA Observations of Starless Core Substructure in Ophiuchus
• Observational constraints on star cluster formation theory - I. The mass-radius relation
• The fragmentation and stability of hierarchical structure in Serpens South
• The physical and dynamical structure of Serpens: Two very different sub-(proto)clusters
• 13CO Cores in Taurus Molecular Cloud
• Cloud-cloud Collision in the Galactic Center 50 km s${}^{-1}$ Molecular Cloud
• Magnetically-regulated fragmentation of a massive, dense and turbulent clump
• Catalog of dense cores in the Orion A giant molecular cloud
• Measuring the Clump Mass Function in the Age of SCUBA2, Herschel, and ALMA
• The Super-Alfvénic Model of Molecular Clouds: Predictions for Mass-to-Flux and Turbulent-to-Magnetic Energy Ratios
• The fragmentation properties of massive protocluster gas clumps: an ALMA study
• Young stellar clusters in the Rosette molecular cloud. Arguments against triggered star formation
• A C${}^{18}$O study of the origin of the power-law nature in the IMF
• Gravitationally unstable condensations revealed by ALMA in the TUKH122 prestellar core in the Orion A cloud
• The Green Bank Ammonia Survey: A Virial Analysis of Gould Belt Clouds in Data Release 1
• Assessing the Performance of Molecular Gas Clump Identification Algorithms
• The G305 star forming complex: Wide-Area molecular mapping of NH3 and H2O masers
• The G305 star-forming complex: radio continuum and molecular line observations
• LABOCA mapping of the infrared dark cloud MSXDC G304.74+01.32
• The molecular distribution of the IRDC G351.77-0.51
• Interstellar MHD Turbulence and Star Formation
• The Core Mass Function in the Orion Nebula Cluster Region: What Determines the Final Stellar Masses?
• Statistical Properties of Molecular Clumps in the Galactic Center 50 km s${}^{-1}$ Molecular Cloud
• Multicomponent kinematics in a massive filamentary IRDC
• Synthetic Observations of the Evolution of Starless Cores in a Molecular Cloud Simulation: Comparisons with JCMT Data and Predictions for ALMA
• Extended ammonia observations towards the 'Integral-Shaped Filament'
• The KOSMA-$\tau$ PDR Model -- I. Recent updates to the numerical model of photo-dissociated regions
• Atacama Compact Array Measurements of the Molecular Mass in the NGC 5044 Cooling Flow Group
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: SCUBA-2 Data-Reduction Methods and Gaussian Source Recovery Analysis
• The changing GMC population in galaxy interactions
• Kinematics of Arp 270: gas flows, nuclear activity and two regimes of star formation
• Mass distributions of stars and cores in young groups and clusters
• Similarity between the C18O (J=1-0) core mass function and the IMF in the S 140 region
• Probing the multi-scale interplay between gravity and turbulence - Power-law like gravitational energy spectra of the Orion Complex
• The location, clustering, and propagation of massive star formation in giant molecular clouds
• An Unbiased CO Survey Toward the Northern Region of the Small Magellanic Cloud with the Atacama Compact Array. II. CO Cloud Catalog
• Connecting the Dots: Analyzing Synthetic Observations of Star-Forming Clumps in Molecular Clouds
• Dependence of Molecular Cloud Samples on Angular Resolution, Sensitivity, and Algorithms
• Molecular environs and triggered star formation around the large Galactic infrared bubble N 24
• Identification of molecular clouds in emission maps: a comparison between methods in the \ce{^{13}CO}/\ce{C^{18}O} ($J=3-2$) Heterodyne Inner Milky Way Plane Survey
• Statistical analysis of the mass-to-flux ratio in turbulent cores: effects of magnetic field reversals and dynamo amplification
• The mass distribution of clumps within infrared dark clouds. A Large APEX Bolometer Camera study
• Distance determination of molecular clouds in the 1st quadrant of the Galactic plane using deep learning : I. Method and Results
• Extreme giant molecular clouds in the luminous infrared galaxy NGC 3256
• ALMA observations of two massive and dense MALT90 clumps
• Hot Molecular Core Candidates in the Galactic Center 50 km/s Molecular Cloud
• SABOCA 350-micron and LABOCA 870-micron dust continuum imaging of IRAS 05399-0121: mapping the dust properties of a pre- and protostellar core system
• The Correlation of Dust and Gas Emission in Star-Forming Environments
• A Guide to Comparisons of Star Formation Simulations with Observations
• A Core Mass Function Indistinguishable from the Salpeter Stellar Initial Mass Function Using 1000 au Resolution ALMA Observations