The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: A Quantitative Comparison Between SCUBA-2 Data Reduction Methods

Abstract

Performing ground-based submillimetre observations is a difficult task as the measurements are subject to absorption and emission from water vapour in the Earth's atmosphere and time variation in weather and instrument stability. Removing these features and other artifacts from the data is a vital process which affects the characteristics of the recovered astronomical structure we seek to study. In this paper, we explore two data reduction methods for data taken with the Submillimetre Common-User Bolometer Array-2 (SCUBA-2) at the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope (JCMT). The JCMT Legacy Reduction 1 (JCMT LR1) and The Gould Belt Legacy Survey Legacy Release 1 (GBS LR1) reduction both use the same software, Starlink, but differ in their choice of data reduction parameters. We find that the JCMT LR1 reduction is suitable for determining whether or not compact emission is present in a given region and the GBS LR1 reduction is tuned in a robust way to uncover more extended emission, which better serves more in-depth physical analyses of star-forming regions. Using the GBS LR1 method, we find that compact sources are recovered well, even at a peak brightness of only 3 times the noise, whereas the reconstruction of larger objects requires much care when drawing boundaries around the expected astronomical signal in the data reduction process. Incorrect boundaries can lead to false structure identification or it can cause structure to be missed. In the JCMT LR1 reduction, the extent of the true structure of objects larger than a point source is never fully recovered.

arXiv comment26 Pages, 16 Figures, Accepted for publication in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (MNRAS)

References in corpus (29)

• HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
• SCUBA: A common-user submillimetre camera operating on the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope
• SCUBA-2: The 10000 pixel bolometer camera on the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope
• Structural Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Dendrograms
• The Spitzer Space Telescope Survey of the Orion A & B Molecular Clouds - Part I: A Census of Dusty Young Stellar Objects and a Study of their Mid-IR Variability
• The Mass Distribution and Lifetime of Prestellar Cores in Perseus, Serpens, and Ophiuchus
• SCUBA-2: iterative map-making with the Sub-Millimetre User Reduction Facility
• The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey: Survey Description and Data Reduction
• SCUBA-2: on-sky calibration using submillimetre standard sources
• AzTEC Millimetre Survey of the COSMOS Field: I. Data Reduction and Source Catalogue
• A multi-scale, multi-wavelength source extraction method: getsources
• The James Clerk Maxwell Telescope Legacy Survey of Nearby Star-forming Regions in the Gould Belt
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: First results from the SCUBA-2 observations of the Ophiuchus molecular cloud and a virial analysis of its prestellar core population
• FellWalker - a Clump Identification Algorithm
• A Uniform CO Survey of the Molecular Clouds in Orion and Monoceros
• The Perils of Clumpfind: The Mass Spectrum of Sub-structures in Molecular Clouds
• The Herschel and JCMT Gould Belt Surveys: Constraining Dust Properties in the Perseus B1 Clump with PACS, SPIRE, and SCUBA-2
• The Mass Distributions of Starless and Protostellar Cores in Gould Belt Clouds
• The SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey: blank-field number counts of 450um-selected galaxies and their contribution to the cosmic infrared background
• Large Area Mapping at 850 Microns. V. Analysis of the Clump Distribution in the Orion A South Molecular Cloud
• SANEPIC: A Map-Making Method for Timestream Data From Large Arrays
• A census of molecular hydrogen outflows and their sources along the Orion A molecular ridge: characteristics and overall distribution
• Producing Mega-pixel CMB Maps from Differential Radiometer Data
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: SCUBA-2 observations of radiative feedback in NGC1333
• Submillimeter Continuum Emission in the Rho Ophiuchus Molecular Cloud: Filaments, Arcs, and an Unidentified Infrared Object
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Evidence for radiative heating in Serpens MWC 297 and its influence on local star formation
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: SCUBA-2 observations of circumstellar disks in L 1495
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: low-mass proto-planetary discs from a SCUBA-2 census of NGC1333
• Observatory/data centre partnerships and the VO-centric archive: The JCMT Science Archive experience

Cited by in corpus (44)

• Magnetic fields towards Ophiuchus-B derived from SCUBA-2 polarization measurements
• The TOP-SCOPE survey of Planck Galactic Cold Clumps: Survey overview and results of an exemplar source, PGCC G26.53+0.17
• A First Look at BISTRO Observations of The $\rho$ Oph-A core
• How do stars gain their mass? A JCMT/SCUBA-2 Transient Survey of Protostars in Nearby Star Forming Regions
• JCMT BISTRO survey: Magnetic Fields within the Hub-Filament Structure in IC 5146
• The JCMT BISTRO Survey: The Magnetic Field of the Barnard 1 Star-Forming Region
• The JCMT Plane Survey: First complete data release - emission maps and compact source catalogue
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: A First Look at Southern Orion A with SCUBA-2
• The JCMT Transient Survey: Stochastic and Secular Variability of Protostars and Disks In the Sub-Millimeter Observed Over Eighteen Months
• JCMT POL-2 and BISTRO Survey observations of magnetic fields in the L1689 molecular cloud
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: A First Look at Dense Cores in Orion B
• The JCMT Transient Survey: Detection of sub-mm variability in a Class I protostar EC 53 in Serpens Main
• The JCMT Transient Survey: Data Reduction and Calibration Methods
• Embedded Binaries and Their Dense Cores
• The JCMT BISTRO Survey: The Distribution of Magnetic Field Strengths towards the OMC-1 Region
• SCOPE: SCUBA-2 Continuum Observations of Pre-protostellar Evolution - Survey Description and Compact Source Catalogue
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Dense Core Clusters in Orion A
• Dust spectrum and polarisation at 850 um in the massive IRDC G035.39-00.33
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: First results from SCUBA-2 observations of the Cepheus Flare Region
• The JCMT Transient Survey: Identifying Submillimetre Continuum Variability over Several Year Timescales Using Archival JCMT Gould Belt Survey Observations
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: A First Look at IC 5146
• The properties of Planck Galactic cold clumps in the L1495 dark cloud
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Dense Core Clusters in Orion B
• The JCMT Transient Survey: An Extraordinary Submillimetre Flare in the T Tauri Binary System JW 566
• The JCMT BISTRO Survey: An 850/450$\mu$m Polarization Study of NGC 2071IR in OrionB
• The DR21(OH) Trident -- Resolving the Massive Ridge into Three Entangled Fibers As the Initial Condition of Cluster Formation
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Evidence for radiative heating and contamination in the W40 complex
• The Eruption of the Candidate Young Star ASASSN-15qi
• JINGLE, a JCMT legacy survey of dust and gas for galaxy evolution studies: II. SCUBA-2 850 μm data reduction and dust flux density catalogues
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: SCUBA-2 Data-Reduction Methods and Gaussian Source Recovery Analysis
• The JCMT BISTRO Survey: Studying the Complex Magnetic Field of L43
• First Sub-pc Sale Mapping of Magnetic Fields in the Vicinity of a Very Low Luminosity Object, L1521F-IRS
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: A First Look at the Auriga-California Molecular Cloud with SCUBA-2
• The JCMT BISTRO-2 Survey: The Magnetic Field in the Center of the Rosette Molecular Cloud
• Extreme star formation in the Milky Way: Luminosity distributions of young stellar objects in W49A and W51
• The CARMA-NRO Orion Survey: Core Emergence and Kinematics in the Orion A Cloud
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: radiative heating by OB stars
• On the Scarcity of Dense Cores ($n>10^5$ cm${}^{-3}$) in High Latitude Planck Galactic Cold Clumps
• Submillimeter continuum variability in Planck Galactic cold clumps
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey Complete Core Catalogue: Core mass function variations between nearby molecular clouds
• The HASHTAG project: The First Submillimeter Images of the Andromeda Galaxy from the Ground
• The JCMT Nearby Galaxies Legacy Survey: SCUBA-2 observations of nearby galaxies
• The JCMT Transient Survey: Four Year Summary of Monitoring the Submillimeter Variability of Protostars
• Time-domain deep learning filtering of structured atmospheric noise for ground-based millimeter astronomy