The Effect of Noise on the Dust Temperature - Spectral Index Correlation

Abstract

We investigate how uncertainties in flux measurements affect the results from modified blackbody SED fits. We show that an inverse correlation between the dust temperature T and spectral index (beta) naturally arises from least squares fits due to the uncertainties, even for sources with a single T and beta. Fitting SEDs to noisy fluxes solely in the Rayleigh-Jeans regime produces unreliable T and beta estimates. Thus, for long wavelength observations (lambda >~ 200 micron), or for warm sources (T >~ 60 K), it becomes difficult to distinguish sources with different temperatures. We assess the role of noise in recent observational results that indicate an inverse and continuously varying T - beta relation. Though an inverse and continuous T - beta correlation may be a physical property of dust in the ISM, we find that the observed inverse correlation may be primarily due to noise.

14 pages, including 5 Figures; Accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (3)

• Some Aspects of Measurement Error in Linear Regression of Astronomical Data
• Submillimetre point sources from the Archeops experiment: Very Cold Clumps in the Galactic Plane
• The 1-1000 micron SEDs of far-infrared galaxies

Cited by in corpus (132)

• Planck 2013 results. XI. All-sky model of thermal dust emission
• Dusty Star-Forming Galaxies at High Redshift
• Andromeda's Dust
• The global dust SED: Tracing the nature and evolution of dust with DustEM
• The Interstellar dust properties of nearby galaxies
• Planck Early Results: Thermal dust in Nearby Molecular Clouds
• The dust scaling relations of the Herschel Reference Survey
• What Does a Submillimeter Galaxy Selection Actually Select? The Dependence of Submillimeter Flux Density on Star Formation Rate and Dust Mass
• Planck Early Results: The Galactic Cold Core Population revealed by the first all-sky survey
• Dust and Gas in the Magellanic Clouds from the HERITAGE Herschel Key Project. I. Dust Properties and Insights into the Origin of the Submm Excess Emission
• The earliest phases of star formation - A Herschel key project. The thermal structure of low-mass molecular cloud cores
• Galactic cold cores III. General cloud properties
• Revealing the cold dust in low-metallicity environments: I - Photometry analysis of the Dwarf Galaxy Survey with Herschel
• The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey IX: Data Release 2 and Outer Galaxy Extension
• Planck Early Results: Origin of the submm excess dust emission in the Magellanic Clouds
• The heating of dust by old stellar populations in the Bulge of M31
• DustPedia - A Definitive Study of Cosmic Dust in the Local Universe
• The Brightest Galaxies in the Dark Ages: Galaxies' Dust Continuum Emission During the Reionization Era
• The Herschel and JCMT Gould Belt Surveys: Constraining Dust Properties in the Perseus B1 Clump with PACS, SPIRE, and SCUBA-2
• Far-Infrared Dust Temperatures and Column Densities of the MALT90 Molecular Clump Sample
• How to distinguish starbursts and quiescently star-forming galaxies: The `bimodal' submillimetre galaxy population as a case study
• PACS photometry of the Herschel Reference Survey - Far-infrared/sub-millimeter colours as tracers of dust properties in nearby galaxies
• Should we believe the results of UV-mm galaxy SED modelling?
• The Dust Properties of Bubble HII Regions as seen by Herschel
• A Nearby Galaxy Perspective on Dust Evolution. Scaling relations and constraints on the dust build-up in galaxies with the DustPedia and DGS samples
• Dust continuum emission as a tracer of gas mass in galaxies
• Dust and star-formation properties of a complete sample of local galaxies drawn from the Planck Early Release Compact Source Catalogue
• Can dust emission be used to map the interstellar medium in high-redshift galaxies? Results from the Herschel Reference Survey
• FIR colours of nearby late-type galaxies in the Herschel Reference Survey
• Accuracy of core mass estimates in simulated observations of dust emission
• The Dust Emissivity Spectral Index in the Starless Core TMC-1C
• Planck intermediate results. XIV. Dust emission at millimetre wavelengths in the Galactic plane
• Galactic cold cores VI. Dust opacity spectral index
• The Submm and mm Excess of the SMC: Magnetic Dipole Emission from Magnetic Nanoparticles?
• Cool dust heating and temperature mixing in nearby star-forming galaxies
• The degeneracy between dust colour temperature and spectral index. Comparison of methods for estimating the beta(T) relation
• The Relationship Between Molecular Gas, HI, and Star Formation in the Low-Mass, Low-Metallicity Magellanic Clouds
• The physical properties of the dust in the RCW 120 HII region as seen by Herschel
• Herschel far-infrared observations of the Carina Nebula complex I: Introduction and global cloud structure
• Droplets I: Pressure-Dominated Sub-0.1 pc Coherent Structures in L1688 and B18
• QUIJOTE Scientific Results. II. Polarisation Measurements of the Microwave Emission in the Galactic molecular complexes W43 and W47 and supernova remnant W44
• FitSKIRT: genetic algorithms to automatically fit dusty galaxies with a Monte Carlo radiative transfer code
• Herschel-ATLAS: The Surprising Diversity of Dust-Selected Galaxies in the Local Submillimetre Universe
• Variation in the dust emissivity index across M33 with Herschel and Spitzer (HerM33es)
• Probing changes of dust properties along a chain of solar-type prestellar and protostellar cores in Taurus with NIKA
• The degeneracy between the dust colour temperature and the spectral index. The problem of multiple chi^2 minima
• A resolved analysis of cold dust and gas in the nearby edge-on spiral NGC 891
• Cloud Structure of Galactic OB Cluster Forming Regions from Combining Ground and Space Based Bolometric Observations
• Dust models post-Planck: constraining the far-infrared opacity of dust in the diffuse interstellar medium
• Herschel reveals the obscured star formation in HiZELS Hα emitters at z=1.47
• The Dust & Gas Properties of M83
• The effect of temperature mixing on the observable (T,beta)-relation of interstellar dust clouds
• The First Maps of ${\kappa }_d$ -- the Dust Mass Absorption Coefficient -- in Nearby Galaxies, with DustPedia
• An Empirical Determination of the Dust Mass Absorption Coefficient, ${\kappa }_d$, Using the Herschel Reference Survey
• Evidence for Large Grains in the Star-forming Filament OMC-2/3
• Isothermal dust models of Herschel-ATLAS galaxies
• Spitzer Analysis of HII Region Complexes in the Magellanic Clouds: Determining a Suitable Monochromatic Obscured Star Formation Indicator
• A Dust spectral energy distribution model with hierarchical Bayesian inference. I. Formalism & benchmarking
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Evidence for Dust Grain Evolution in Perseus Star-forming Clumps
• The Spatial Distribution of Dust and Stellar Emission of the Magellanic Clouds
• The Spatially Resolved Dust-to-Metals Ratio in M101
• Dust Emissivity in the Star-Forming Filament OMC 2/3
• The roles of star formation and AGN activity of IRS sources in the HerMES fields
• Herschel-ATLAS: Statistical Properties of Galactic Cirrus in the GAMA-9 Hour Science Demonstration Phase Field
• Dust opacity variations in the pre-stellar core L1544
• The SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey: demographics of the 450 μm-population
• The Quest for the Missing Dust: II -- Two Orders of Magnitude of Evolution in the Dust-to-Gas Ratio Resolved Within Local Group Galaxies
• C${}_{60}$ in Photodissociation Regions
• Herschel photometric observations of the low metallicity dwarf galaxy NGC 1705
• L1495 Revisited: A PPMAP View of a Star-Forming Filament
• Dust spectrum and polarisation at 850 um in the massive IRDC G035.39-00.33
• Multi-scale analysis of the Monoceros OB 1 star-forming region: II. Colliding filaments in the Monoceros OB1 molecular cloud
• The Herschel Virgo Cluster Survey. XX. Dust and gas in the foreground Galactic cirrus
• Herschel and SCUBA-2 observations of dust emission in a sample of Planck cold clumps
• Properties of massive star-forming clumps with infall motions
• A multi-wavelength exploration of the [CII]/IR ratio in H-ATLAS/GAMA galaxies out to z=0.2
• Stochastic grain heating and mid-infrared emission in protostellar cores
• The Herschel Virgo Cluster Survey. XVIII. Star-forming dwarf galaxies in a cluster environment
• Dust-correlated centimetre-wave radiation from the M 78 reflection nebula
• Exploring the Dust Content of Galactic Winds with Herschel. I. NGC 4631
• Physical properties of the Sh2-104 HII region as seen by Herschel
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: the effect of molecular contamination in SCUBA-2 observations of Orion A
• Star formation towards the southern Cometary HII region IRAS 17256-3631
• High-Resolution Mapping of Dust via Extinction in the M31 Bulge
• An analysis of the deuterium fractionation of star-forming cores in the Perseus molecular cloud
• The Herschel Virgo Cluster Survey XVI: a cluster inventory
• Full-sky Models of Galactic Microwave Emission and Polarization at Sub-arcminute Scales for the Python Sky Model
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Evidence for radiative heating and contamination in the W40 complex
• Determining thermal dust emission from Planck HFI data using a sparse, parametric technique
• Bayesian method for the analysis of the dust emission in the Far-Infrared and Submillimeter
• Uncertainties and biases of source masses derived from fits of integrated fluxes or image intensities
• Smoke in the Pipe Nebula: dust emission and grain growth in the starless core FeSt 1-457
• ALMA imaging of the cold molecular and dusty disk in the type 2 active nucleus of the Circinus galaxy
• RCW 120: A possible case of hit and run, elucidated by multi temperature dust mapping
• Search for grain growth towards the center of L1544
• A NIKA view of two star-forming infrared dark clouds: Dust emissivity variations and mass concentration
• Estimation of high-resolution dust column density maps. Comparison of modified black-body fits and radiative transfer modelling
• Probing the massive star forming environment - a multiwavelength investigation of the filamentary IRDC G333.73+0.37
• A Corona Australis cloud filament seen in NIR scattered light. III. Modelling and comparison with Herschel sub-millimetre data
• Dust Properties of 870 Micron Selected Galaxies in the GOODS-S
• Far-infrared/sub-millimetre properties of pre-stellar cores L1521E, L1521F and L1689B as revealed by the Herschel SPIRE instrument -- I. Central positions
• Star forming activity in the H II regions associated with IRAS 17160-3707 complex
• Evidence of dust grain evolution from extinction mapping in the IC 63 photodissociation region
• Planck Observations of M33
• The location, clustering, and propagation of massive star formation in giant molecular clouds
• Quantifying the cool ISM in radio AGNs: evidence for late-time re-triggering by galaxy mergers and interactions
• A PPMAP analysis of the filamentary structures in Ophiuchus L1688 and L1689
• An Orientation Bias in Observations of Submillimetre Galaxies
• Implications of Grain Size Distribution and Composition for the Correlation Between Dust Extinction and Emissivity
• Characterizing line-of-sight variability of polarized dust emission with future CMB experiments
• A CO survey on a sample of Herschel cold clumps
• Characterization of dense Planck clumps observed with Herschel and SCUBA-2
• Cold Dust in Hot Regions
• Constraining the Dust Opacity Law in Three Small and Isolated Molecular Clouds
• The HP2 Survey - IV. The Pipe nebula: Effective dust temperatures in dense cores
• ALMA resolves molecular clouds in the metal poor Magellanic Bridge A
• Alignment and Rotational Disruption of Dust Grains in the Galactic Centre Revealed by Polarized Dust Emission
• Simultaneously modelling far-infrared dust emission and its relation to CO emission in star forming galaxies
• A study of 90 GHz dust emissivity on molecular cloud and filament scales
• On the structure of galactic halos and the microwave temperature maps
• A Guide to Comparisons of Star Formation Simulations with Observations
• Dense cores in the Seahorse infrared dark cloud: physical properties from modified blackbody fits to the far-infrared-submillimetre spectral energy distributions
• A multiwavelength analysis of the clumpy FIR-bright sources in M33
• The Dust-Selected Molecular Clouds in the Northeast Region of the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Estimation of high-resolution dust column density maps: Empirical model fits
• Interpreting Millimeter Emission from IMEGIN galaxies NGC 2146 and NGC 2976
• Comparison of modified black-body fits for the estimation of dust optical depths in interstellar clouds
• Modelling of dust emission of a filament in the Taurus molecular cloud
• Limitations of the modified blackbody fit method for determining molecular cloud properties
• Comparison of Herschel and ArTéMiS observations of massive filaments
• On the role of dust in the microwave emission of galactic halos
• Galactic cold cores II. Herschel study of the extended dust emission around the first Planck detections