Comparison of modified black-body fits for the estimation of dust optical depths in interstellar clouds

Abstract

When dust far-infrared spectral energy distributions (SEDs) are fitted with a single modified black body (MBB), the optical depths tend to be underestimated. This is caused by temperature variations, and fits with several temperature components could lead to smaller errors. We want to quantify the performance of the standard model of a single MBB in comparison with some multi-component models. We are interested in both the accuracy and computational cost. We examine some cloud models relevant for interstellar medium studies. Synthetic spectra are fitted with a single MBB, a sum of several MBBs, and a sum of fixed spectral templates, but keeping the dust opacity spectral index fixed. When observations are used at their native resolution, the beam convolution becomes part of the fitting procedure. This increases the computational cost, but the analysis of large maps is still feasible with direct optimisation or even with Markov chain Monte Carlo methods. Compared to the single MBB fits, multi-component models can show significantly smaller systematic errors, at the cost of more statistical noise. The ${\chi }^2$ values of the fits are not a good indicator of the accuracy of the $\tau$ estimates, due to the potentially dominant role of the model errors. The single-MBB model also remains a valid alternative if combined with empirical corrections to reduce its bias. It is technically feasible to fit multi-component models to maps of millions of pixels. However, the SED model and the priors need to be selected carefully, and the model errors can only be estimated by comparing alternative models.

arXiv commentAccepted to A&A

References in corpus (35)

• Interstellar Dust Grains
• Planck 2013 results. XI. All-sky model of thermal dust emission
• High-Mass Star and Massive Cluster Formation in the Milky Way
• The global dust SED: Tracing the nature and evolution of dust with DustEM
• Observing the gas temperature drop in the high-density nucleus of L 1544
• Astrochemistry During the Formation of Stars
• Non-Standard Grain Properties, Dark Gas Reservoir, and Extended Submillimeter Excess, Probed by Herschel in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The Effect of Line of Sight Temperature Variation and Noise on Dust Continuum Observations
• Planck intermediate results. XVII. Emission of dust in the diffuse interstellar medium from the far-infrared to microwave frequencies
• Dust and Gas in the Magellanic Clouds from the HERITAGE Herschel Key Project. I. Dust Properties and Insights into the Origin of the Submm Excess Emission
• Reconstructing the density and temperature structure of prestellar cores from $Herschel$ data: A case study for B68 and L1689B
• Multi-temperature mapping of dust structures throughout the Galactic Plane using the PPMAP tool with Herschel Hi-GAL data
• Mapping the cold dust temperatures and masses of nearby Kingfish galaxies with Herschel
• The Effect of Noise on the Dust Temperature - Spectral Index Correlation
• Temperature as a third dimension in column-density mapping of dusty astrophysical structures associated with star formation
• Dust SEDs in the era of Herschel and Planck: a Hierarchical Bayesian fitting technique
• Variations of the spectral index of dust emissivity from Hi-GAL observations of the Galactic plane
• Accuracy of core mass estimates in simulated observations of dust emission
• The stellar IMF from Isothermal MHD Turbulence
• Galactic cold cores VI. Dust opacity spectral index
• The degeneracy between dust colour temperature and spectral index. Comparison of methods for estimating the beta(T) relation
• Galactic cold cores V. Dust opacity
• The degeneracy between the dust colour temperature and the spectral index. The problem of multiple chi^2 minima
• The effect of temperature mixing on the observable (T,beta)-relation of interstellar dust clouds
• Can we trace very cold dust from its emission alone ?
• A Dust spectral energy distribution model with hierarchical Bayesian inference. I. Formalism & benchmarking
• Detection and characterization of a 500 mic dust emissivity excess in the Galactic Plane using Herschel/Hi-GAL observations
• Detection of 6 K gas in Ophiuchus D
• L1495 Revisited: A PPMAP View of a Star-Forming Filament
• Benchmarking Dust Emission Models in M101
• Estimation of high-resolution dust column density maps. Comparison of modified black-body fits and radiative transfer modelling
• Insights from Synthetic Star-forming Regions: II. Verifying Dust Surface Density, Dust Temperature & Gas Mass Measurements with Modified Blackbody Fitting
• Filaments in the OMC-3 cloud and uncertainties in estimates of filament profiles
• The Interstellar Dust Emission Spectrum, Going beyond the single temperature greybody
• Synthetic ngVLA line observations of a massive star-forming cloud

Cited by in corpus (1)

• Modelling of dust emission of a filament in the Taurus molecular cloud